is night creature empathy really a great idea? seeing as currently... we're the last one
Okay, so the goblin and elvish empires let the vampires and werecreatures and boogeymen and such slide.Not to my best recollection. They should kick any vamps they find out of their city. I'm just thinking that if we can blend in, we can go anywhere. Towns are hilariously disorganized.
Okay, so the goblin and elvish empires let the vampires and werecreatures and boogeymen and such slide.Not to my best recollection. They should kick any vamps they find out of their city. I'm just thinking that if we can blend in, we can go anywhere. Towns are hilariously disorganized.
Well, that's kinda hard, declaring war on a species and all. Man can't just declare war on all turtles, can they?Okay, so the goblin and elvish empires let the vampires and werecreatures and boogeymen and such slide.Not to my best recollection. They should kick any vamps they find out of their city. I'm just thinking that if we can blend in, we can go anywhere. Towns are hilariously disorganized.
Not exactly what i meant, i just meant that they didn't declare an open and intensive war against *all* Night Creatures.
Sure he can. I seem to remember china declaring war on not one, not two, but 3 species! One of which was sparrows, which came back to screw them over later on.Well, yes, you can. But is it effective?
Sparrows and other birds were shot down from the sky, resulting in the near-extinction of the birds in China.
Apparently it was four species actually. Relevant link (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign)Still didn't work.QuoteSparrows and other birds were shot down from the sky, resulting in the near-extinction of the birds in China.
Pretty effective I'd say.
Well, Klingons declared war on tribbles, then what happened? No more tribbles.But... I can't argue with you there. Mainly because I don't know what a tribble really is.
Or develop hermaphrodite body characteristics and repopulate that wayDF universe. Does not exist.
As noted, not an option, and much slower than capturing a half-dozen or more mortal women, transforming them, and keeping them impregnated.Do you hear that? That's your sanity slipping.
It just occurred to me what I'm typing.
As noted, not an option, and much slower than capturing a half-dozen or more mortal women, transforming them, and keeping them impregnated.In a way that also creates more night creatures, because the women are night creatures too.
It just occurred to me what I'm typing.
Aargh, no tatooed arms? In any case can you turn him into a night troll? If not then knock him over the head to ensure unconsciousness while you gag and bind him. Make sure he can't wiggle his fingers. Use dark manipulation and hypnosis to put him into a submissive emotional state.Can night trolls turn people of the same gender into night trolls?
Don't explore tower first, you may set off wards.Agreed.
Can we use Eon Manipulation to freeze him, or possibly the entire tower in time so that we can search unhindered by him/wards? If so do that.
Aargh, no tatooed arms? In any case can you turn him into a night troll? If not then knock him over the head to ensure unconsciousness while you gag and bind him. Make sure he can't wiggle his fingers. Use dark manipulation and hypnosis to put him into a submissive emotional state.Can night trolls turn people of the same gender into night trolls?QuoteDon't explore tower first, you may set off wards.Agreed.
I'll count the votes to see if bladed arms really won, my analysis suggested otherwise.
Aargh, no tatooed arms? In any case can you turn him into a night troll? If not then knock him over the head to ensure unconsciousness while you gag and bind him. Make sure he can't wiggle his fingers. Use dark manipulation and hypnosis to put him into a submissive emotional state.Can night trolls turn people of the same gender into night trolls?
1 | Eon manipulation | Eon manipulation | Earth Manipulation | Night Creature Empathy | Stealth |
2 | Eon manipulation | Dark Manipulation | Unarmed | Communication | Stealth |
3 | Plant Empathy | Dark Manipulation | Necromancy | Communication | Stealth |
4 | Earth Crafting | Armed | Unarmed | Stealth | Stealth |
No.Aargh, no tatooed arms? In any case can you turn him into a night troll? If not then knock him over the head to ensure unconsciousness while you gag and bind him. Make sure he can't wiggle his fingers. Use dark manipulation and hypnosis to put him into a submissive emotional state.Can night trolls turn people of the same gender into night trolls?
I really think we should just kill the wizard and be done with it, snap his neck.Sounds like something we'd do.
Nah, wizard minion is best solution, otherwise what are our hypnotism for?I don't think that's quite how it works.
Nah, wizard minion is best solution, otherwise what are our hypnotism for?I don't think that's quite how it works.
Hypnotic: You can suspend a mortals self preservation instinct, often causing them to submit or attack recklessly
Yeah, according to my tally it's:
Tattooed arms: 3/2.5
Bladed Arms: 2/2.5Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Everything else seems correct though.
EDIT: Wait, how did night creature empathy get on there? only one person voted for it. Communication would seem the better choice since 2 people voted for it and probably has the same votepower as darkmanip, but I'm unsure how you tallied skills, but earth manipulation should have exactly the same voted value as dark creature empathy and I'd prefer earth manip myself(I prefer darkmanip over commun ofc, but commun over darkcreat empath, Darkmanip>earth manip>comm>darkemp). Also comm probably has more voting power than unarmed? Ignore this if it means we only get 4 skills.
1 Eon manipulation Eon manipulation Earth Manipulation Night Creature Empathy Stealth 2 Eon manipulation Dark Manipulation Unarmed Communication Stealth 3 Plant Empathy Dark Manipulation Necromancy Communication Stealth 4 Earth Crafting Armed Unarmed Stealth Stealth
EDIT2: How did i miss that fire manip allows us to control magma and makes us start next to a sea of magma? Aargh.
Can we use Eon Manipulation to freeze him, or possibly the entire tower in time so that we can search unhindered by him/wards? If so do that.
Good idea. If possible freeze him in place with eon manipulation then bind him, them hyptonize him and manipulate his emotions with dark manipulation.
Search for any tomes, scrolls, napkins, etc, with anything relating to arcane lore. Read them.Also, eat some meat.
Search for any tomes, scrolls, napkins, etc, with anything relating to arcane lore. Read them.Also, eat some meat.
I added up the total rankings (1-4) for each skill, using a 5 when somebody didn't include it in their list of four. The four (or five) lowest totals were included. Here is my math. Please tell me if I made a mistake, again it was late and I was tired when I did it.
My Tally:Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Search for some rope and chains to tie the wizard up with. Also a piece of cloth to use as a gag.
That locked box, is likely to have something of value, but may also have magical protection on it. Maybe we should examine it, and if we think it is safe... toss it down the stairs just in case. See what happens, if nothing bad happens and it remains unopened attempt to smash it open or look for key and open it.
Esmerlda sounds like a female name. We should eat the two male mages and take her as our troll-wife.Hey, that we should! Can we hide with camouflage and hypnotize the woman so we can convert her. Then undo the time loop on the mage while the man is distracted by something, and our wife and we can each eat one?
Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.The woman is going to be the easiest of the three to deal with, I'm thinking.
You're assuming it's two men and a woman by hearing one name?Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.The woman is going to be the easiest of the three to deal with, I'm thinking.
I don't know very many men with the name Esmerelda. Or many women who are fathers. And we've seen the mage.You're assuming it's two men and a woman by hearing one name?Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.The woman is going to be the easiest of the three to deal with, I'm thinking.
I don't think that's a healthy assumption anyway, these could be mages, or Night creatures for all we know, which is next to nothing.Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.The woman is going to be the easiest of the three to deal with, I'm thinking.
I meant the bedding. That should be simple, since we're going to transform her into aI don't think that's a healthy assumption anyway, these could be mages, or Night creatures for all we know, which is next to nothing.Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.The woman is going to be the easiest of the three to deal with, I'm thinking.
Sneak quietly out, look at the people. Then plan how to slay the men and bed the women.
"Help. My people are dying, maybe dead, and only you can help them."
((Really glad we got Communication...)
Use hypnotic gaze on her as well, to help persuade her. Do it subtly though."Help. My people are dying, maybe dead, and only you can help them."
((Really glad we got Communication...)
Oh, yeah, do this too.Use hypnotic gaze on her as well, to help persuade her. Do it subtly though."Help. My people are dying, maybe dead, and only you can help them."
((Really glad we got Communication...)
Oh, yeah, do this too.Use hypnotic gaze on her as well, to help persuade her. Do it subtly though."Help. My people are dying, maybe dead, and only you can help them."
((Really glad we got Communication...)
Tell her the truth. No, we don't have a name.
Tell her the truth. No, we don't have a name.
Supporting this to break the tie.
Yeah, it'd be stupid to lie to her about our name.Tell her the truth. No, we don't have a name.
Supporting this to break the tie.
Supporting this to prevent a new tie.
Follow quietly, but remain on gaurd. If the older wizard makes a hostile action then put him in a "Slow Bubble" and run circles around him, avoiding anything he can throw.
Tell him that we used our magic to escape into the future. Its mostly true.
1+Tell him that we used our magic to escape into the future. Its mostly true.
+w
Follow quietly, but remain on gaurd. If the older wizard makes a hostile action then put him in a "Slow Bubble" and run circles around him, avoiding anything he can throw.
What we want is to ensure our race's survival.
Now, it could be in Leghorn's best interest that we survive. We are fairly powerful, he has to admit. And we would be the patriarch of an entire race. All he needs to do is help us find a mate.
Then, he'll have a powerful and ancient race to help him, and then we'll have
A. A guide.
B. A wife
C. A teacher
Just to clarify, the wife doesn't have to Esmeralda. I doubt he would allow us to do so anyway.
Might be best not to bring... conversion up in casual conversation. He might take it as a threat.What we want is to ensure our race's survival.
Now, it could be in Leghorn's best interest that we survive. We are fairly powerful, he has to admit. And we would be the patriarch of an entire race. All he needs to do is help us find a mate.
Then, he'll have a powerful and ancient race to help him, and then we'll have
A. A guide.
B. A wife
C. A teacher
Just to clarify, the wife doesn't have to Esmeralda. I doubt he would allow us to do so anyway.
Offer to help Foghorn with what he is doing if he helps us recreate the species. Do mention Esmeralda would be safe.
Might be best not to bring... conversion up in casual conversation. He might take it as a threat.What we want is to ensure our race's survival.
Now, it could be in Leghorn's best interest that we survive. We are fairly powerful, he has to admit. And we would be the patriarch of an entire race. All he needs to do is help us find a mate.
Then, he'll have a powerful and ancient race to help him, and then we'll have
A. A guide.
B. A wife
C. A teacher
Just to clarify, the wife doesn't have to Esmeralda. I doubt he would allow us to do so anyway.
Offer to help Foghorn with what he is doing if he helps us recreate the species. Do mention Esmeralda would be safe.
Offer to help Foghorn with what he is doing if he helps us recreate the species. Do mention Esmeralda would be safe.He shouldn't. If we wanted to convert her, we could have done so already.
Agreed.
Ask about these "new toys."
Agreed.
Ask about these "new toys."
We can prowl about the forest, and leave some mutilated animals and animalmen so that hunters would find them. That's one way to make them fear the night. It could also distract them. We murder a few hunters, make the men come out in force to stop us. We then head to town, and have our pick of converts.Ok,i believe i've a simple solution for this,practice our magic,while upgrading the towers defences,also do we have any knives or bladed weapons Weirdsound?
Or, we could practice our magic. It is still fairly weak, and magic is one of our specializations. It's our most powerful asset, really. But so far, we've only used it to tie up a sleeping old man. We can definitely improve on that, so that it becomes a viable combat tactic. The old caster might be able and willing to help us.
We could go straight out for the town, to scout it out and pick a wife so that we may be assured our line continues, but that is risky, as we are still pretty weak. Biggest advantage of this plan is that they will have no idea we exist until then. Downside is that we will be woefully unprepared to face a siege against our tower.
I think we're going about this the wrong way.Yeah, why the hell not.
Instead of immediately fortifying the tower and making it obvious that something is up, we should cast an illusion with our dark magic that makes us look like Pyrost and pretend to be Pyrost until we're settled in.
We should definitely take an inventory of our tower and gather together all the weapons and spellbooks. We should practice our spells. Later on, we can take over an animalman tribe.
I think we're going about this the wrong way.Yeah, why the hell not.
Instead of immediately fortifying the tower and making it obvious that something is up, we should cast an illusion with our dark magic that makes us look like Pyrost and pretend to be Pyrost until we're settled in.
We should definitely take an inventory of our tower and gather together all the weapons and spellbooks. We should practice our spells. Later on, we can take over an animalman tribe.
But put a lot more emphasis on magic than on regular weapons. We're not very good with them, and there's no real point in learning them.
Magic that involves throwing fireballs can't save you from a soldier with a sword at point blank(without roasting yourself). It's always helpful to have a melee weapon on hand.To be fair, we aren't learning fireballs. We're learning how to slow down that soldier to the point where he completely freezes, walking behind him, and taking his belt off and strangling him with it. That kind of magic.
I think we should be focusing on non-combat methods of dealing with people. Practice hypnosis, use diplomacy, etc.Oh yeah, we have hypnosis! We can practice on rats or animalmen or something!
Oh, and find a bag.This is necessary, and quite obvious. I don't know how I forgot about it.
Practicing and studying magic sounds good. Maybe ask Foghorn if we could borrow a tome.Yeah, I think he said he'll bring us whatever it is we need next month or something.
I think we're going about this the wrong way.+1
Instead of immediately fortifying the tower and making it obvious that something is up, we should cast an illusion with our dark magic that makes us look like Pyrost and pretend to be Pyrost until we're settled in.
We should definitely take an inventory of our tower and gather together all the weapons and spellbooks. We should practice our spells. Later on, we can take over an animalman tribe.
Oh, and find a bag.
We should definitely take an inventory of our tower and gather together all the weapons and spellbooks.
find an oak chair or something, bring it into a bare room so that nothing else is damaged, and collect our fistful of oak ash. then brew the potion.
find an oak chair or something, bring it into a bare room so that nothing else is damaged, and collect our fistful of oak ash. then brew the potion.
Spend time chatting with the girl, we need more communication skills and learn about behavior of human females.Let's not get carried away now...
(doing funny stuff is always an option for a troll teanager, but I think we should develop the character in a seducer direction)
Be very polite during any and all interactions with the mage and his family, ask her to accompany you to the woods to cut a bit of wood from a tree for alchemy. Then set up a fireproof practice room for fire magic, asking Foghorn to give you a few pointers.This. Also, if there is time, learn plant and animal empathy from Alice.
Indeed. If she decides she likes us, all the better, but aside from chivalrousness (chivalry? That sounds righter) and maybe subtly showing the benefits of being a night troll, she'll succumb to Twilight Syndrome.Be very polite during any and all interactions with the mage and his family, ask her to accompany you to the woods to cut a bit of wood from a tree for alchemy. Then set up a fireproof practice room for fire magic, asking Foghorn to give you a few pointers.This. Also, if there is time, learn plant and animal empathy from Alice.
Please do not seduce Foghorn's daughter after specifically being asked not to do so by Foghorn.
Be very polite during any and all interactions with the mage and his family, ask her to accompany you to the woods to cut a bit of wood from a tree for alchemy. Then set up a fireproof practice room for fire magic, asking Foghorn to give you a few pointers.
Try to fry it with fire magic! It's the best kind of practiceNo! What, do you want to burn down the entire forest?
It's a long shot, but i think we should try to soothe the deer.Better than a forest fire.
It's a long shot, but i think we should try to soothe the deer.
Cowards.... Lost a chance to practice fire magic.
I think we should ask Alice to teach us more mundane things than magic, How to find something edible\otherwise useful in the forest. It's quite possible that we'll have to survive in the wilderness
No, it's not polite, treating a teen like a kid and asking her "how do you feel?" is a sure way to annoy her. It's disrespect+1 from the 15yr old. now to mention she is the daughter of a warlock.
Ask, then ask if she wants to investigate the elf.Agreed
Emphasize that you're asking out of concern for her well-being and because you're not used to humans' sleep patterns.
once again, she is the one who asked us do it. If she didn't want him dead, she wouldn't have come up with the idea.Ask, then ask if she wants to investigate the elf.Agreed
Emphasize that you're asking out of concern for her well-being and because you're not used to humans' sleep patterns.
Go and talk to the elf, make a decision after that.
Night trolls were genocided for exactly that kind of behavior. Our task is to save our kind even if this means to go against our own nature. We didn't fell to temptation to mate with young and sweet Alice, should be able to resisit temptation to kill the elf. At least right nowAgreed. Also, why does everyone want to start a fire that might burn the entire forest?
Try to soothe the wolf, if not successful put the animal in a time loop. Then we'll decide how to communicate with the elf
Agreed, and bear in mind that we're the same community that uses magma for everything.Night trolls were genocided for exactly that kind of behavior. Our task is to save our kind even if this means to go against our own nature. We didn't fell to temptation to mate with young and sweet Alice, should be able to resisit temptation to kill the elf. At least right nowAgreed. Also, why does everyone want to start a fire that might burn the entire forest?
Try to soothe the wolf, if not successful put the animal in a time loop. Then we'll decide how to communicate with the elf
Night trolls were genocided for exactly that kind of behavior. Our task is to save our kind even if this means to go against our own nature. We didn't fell to temptation to mate with young and sweet Alice, should be able to resisit temptation to kill the elf. At least right now
Try to soothe the wolf, if not successful put the animal in a time loop. Then we'll decide how to communicate with the elf
"Who is Vindel?"+1
Exit the trees.
Can we at least drop silently from the trees and whisper in a gutteral voice, "Vindel isn't here. Only me."? Please?Yeah...
Can we at least drop silently from the trees and whisper in a gutteral voice, "Vindel isn't here. Only me."? Please?
Time to practice fire magic and produce some oak ash in process. Also, should cook something tasty from elf's meat(Lucky Bastard. Nobody else posted in time :))
Also, prepare for an expedition and ponder where to go.Agreed, try not to step on any toes though. Also, bring something of value to trade for preserved meat, lots of it. Mostly as a backup for when hunting goes south.
I suggest heading to Dawnmadien in a disguise.
-3 Slices of Goblin Jerkey (In pocket)
Find out what he needs for the artifact.
Also, prepare for an expedition and ponder where to go.
I suggest heading to Dawnmadien in a disguise.
Should agree to go with her, we need a stomach(s) with digestive juicesThis. Also, since we need to hunt and we need to do fire magic, I propose that we try hunting with fire magic.
Besides if something bad happens to her and she doesn't return her father may think that we did something to her
Just go hunting with hunting,+1. Animal and plant empathy are invaluable for doing things in woods, and since elves live in woods...
Send the mother bear a few hours into the future with Eon magic, the cubs should be easy enough to deal with on their own.Actually, this.
But wouldn't having combat war bears to do our bidding be awesome?
Are we some kind of damned elven ranger to care about those cubs? Betray them and have a nice meal!
Converting Alice is a tempting idea, but I doubt that her father would allow that even of she ask
Impregnating on the other hand... Her father wouldn't know if she doesn't tell, right? Let's eat the cubs and than take Alice to some river\lake to allow the girl to wash herself. We may wash, too.
Then we'll consider having a funny time if she doesn't change her mind
It is not about kindness, it is about having too few allies in a strange and mostly hostile world.It's not about evilnesses, it about usefulness. And hunger
Also, to impregnate her we would need to turn her, it is the Night Troll way.
Be kind to her, and assure her we will not force her to do something she does not want to do.Definitely, that's why I wrote - if she doesn't change her mind. Also it's a roleplay, we have a virgin troll and an alluring female, aren't we far too cool headed?
Definitely, that's why I wrote - if she doesn't change her mind. Also it's a roleplay, we have a virgin troll and an alluring female, aren't we far too cool headed?
Definitely, that's why I wrote - if she doesn't change her mind. Also it's a roleplay, we have a virgin troll and an alluring female, aren't we far too cool headed?
I said the same thing about wanting to set the elf on fire. Apparently we were selected to be sent into the future because we have exceptional willpower for a troll.
Are we really can impregnate only another night troll? Or any mating will change the mate even if we don't want to? I haven't seen anything in the thread about it
yes, keep the bears.And if she's still interested, tell her to talk it over with Foghorn. Worst-case scenario, we can honestly say we tried to talk her out of it.
Also, with Alice, I agree that we shouldn't use our "gift" on her. Go fishing/ washing, and remind her of the many reasons why that is a bad idea. If nothing else, remind her that
a)she will become hideous by human standards
b)this is infinitely more binding than marriage
c) we have known each other for two days.
If we were a human, with those points taken into consideration, would this be a good idea?
Regarding Alice, why not have her take the cubs back to the tower? That way you can still get some hunting in, and she can talk things over with her father if she truly wishes to become a night troll.
I really think we should play the gentleman on the score of Alice, it's a pretty powerful position to be in in this case.Indeed.
oh, and somthing else. How do you think Alice will react if we take another mate? We probably will, we have an elven hemigoddess princess available for when we can endure the reaction from the elves. Night creature or not, Alice is would still be outraged.We'll burn that bridge when we come to it.
so yes, play gentleman
If you desire to turn me into something... like yourself and make me your own, I will demand to my father that you be allowed to do so."Note the words your own She is ready to be treated in a non-respectable way
a)she will become hideous by human standardsand if she's still interested, have her okay it with Foghorn before we even think about starting preparations.
b)this is infinitely more binding than marriage
c) we have known each other for two days.
we can honestly say that we tried to dissuade her without hurting her feelingsWhat if Foghorn doesn't believe our words?
And nix to impregnating Alice without Foghorn's consent,I think risk\reward ratio is better in secret impregnation then in let's try to get consent
regardless of it's even possible (it isn't).I'd wait for GM's words. Description of gifts, don't imply that
I imagine her dad would still be pretty upset two months down the line when she gets a visible bump and saysI hope that in two months time we will not care about his mood, because we will be far stronger than him.
Then we'd be screwed no matter what we do. Unless you want to alienate Alice?Quotewe can honestly say that we tried to dissuade her without hurting her feelingsWhat if Foghorn doesn't believe our words?
Well, if we MUST impregnate someone...QuoteAnd nix to impregnating Alice without Foghorn's consent,I think risk\reward ratio is better in secret impregnation then in let's try to get consent
Oh, and hiding from father is a cooler story :)
Also, I afraid that as we accumulate gifts, our mating urge will rise to the point when it will be impossible to control
It's true in DF, and you seem to be the only person here who thinks otherwise.Quoteregardless of it's even possible (it isn't).I'd wait for GM's words. Description of gifts, don't imply that
Don't bet your life on your chickens before they've hatched. Ten bucks says Foghorn's had longer than two months to gather his strength...QuoteI imagine her dad would still be pretty upset two months down the line when she gets a visible bump and saysI hope that in two months time we will not care about his mood, because we will be far stronger than him.
Well, if we MUST impregnate someone...Oh, yes, let's impregnate a random peasant girl. It's safer, nothing else matter
DON'T IMPREGNATE THE DAUGHTER OF A POWERFUL WIZARD!
It's true in DFDo we have eon manipulation skill in DF? :) DF doesn't have interspecies breeding not because it's world doesn't have it, but because it's unimplemented. Anyway, only GM can answer that.
Don't bet your life on your chickens before they've hatched. Ten bucks says Foghorn's had longer than two months to gather his strength...He is a mere human. We should get stonger. Another possibility - we will be far away
So, you'd rather anger a powerful wizard who is our only ally than risk having a subpar child?QuoteWell, if we MUST impregnate someone...Oh, yes, let's impregnate a random peasant girl. It's safer, nothing else matter
DON'T IMPREGNATE THE DAUGHTER OF A POWERFUL WIZARD!
Pretty sure it was implied. Still, what kind of non-stupid plan do you have that relies on that detail?QuoteIt's true in DFDo we have eon manipulation skill in DF? :) DF doesn't have interspecies breeding not because it's world doesn't have it, but because it's unimplemented. Anyway, only GM can answer that.
He's got years of a head start and knows more about the world as it is. And you want to abandon all we have just so you can do the nasty with Foghorn's daughter?QuoteDon't bet your life on your chickens before they've hatched. Ten bucks says Foghorn's had longer than two months to gather his strength...He is a mere human. We should get stonger. Another possibility - we will be far away
And third - Alice will leave her father for some excuse, because she is not a moron, and know that she will be punished for that pregnancyYes, because Foghorn will not go looking for her and definitely hasn't been taking every precaution he can to be able to find her again, especially since she's gallivanting about with a night troll.
So, you'd rather anger a powerful wizard who is our only ally than risk having a subpar child?Well, yes. I am not risk averse. Besides I think it's a funnier story and more roleplayish
He's got years of a head start and knows more about the world as it is. And you want to abandon all we have just so you can do the nasty with Foghorn's daughter?1) Years of head start mean little, when we advance skills fast. Also in two month time he may need to fight with more than one night troll
Yes, because Foghorn will not go looking for her and definitely hasn't been taking every precaution he can to be able to find her again, especially since she's gallivanting about with a night troll.He has many daughters and is a pretty busy person to look out after his ranger daughter constantly.
If I had my LIFE at stake, and that of my species, no way I'd risk angering Foghorn for no good reason. Just have Alice chat with him. Possible anger vs. certain rage...QuoteSo, you'd rather anger a powerful wizard who is our only ally than risk having a subpar child?Well, yes. I am not risk averse. Besides I think it's a funnier story and more roleplayish
1. You're making assumptions, such as "Night trolls learn dozens of times as fast as humans," "We'll be able to learn as well as Foghorn did despite not having a regular teacher," and "We'll be able to find/grow new night creatures quickly in those two months, and no one will hunt us, and they will risk their lives for us."QuoteHe's got years of a head start and knows more about the world as it is. And you want to abandon all we have just so you can do the nasty with Foghorn's daughter?1) Years of head start mean little, when we advance skills fast. Also in two month time he may need to fight with more than one night troll
2) If(when) we start hunting elves, we will need to change our base anyway.
He doesn't have to look out for her constantly, just have a spell that lets him scry on her easily or something. If I was a wizardly father, I'd develop such a spell by the time my first child was 3. If I hadn't, I'd figure it out later, by the time my kids were hunting in dangerous woods or hanging out with more dangerous beings.QuoteYes, because Foghorn will not go looking for her and definitely hasn't been taking every precaution he can to be able to find her again, especially since she's gallivanting about with a night troll.He has many daughters and is a pretty busy person to look out after his ranger daughter constantly.
It's getting old... Not that any of us will change his mind, and we overflood the topic
Compromise position: Turn the mother bear, train the babies to use pyromancy and then eat Alice.aaaaaaand sigged
Compromise position: Turn the mother bear, train the babies to use pyromancy and then eat Alice....
And all I'm going to say is reproduction without conversion is not possible.Oh, well. I hoped for another situation :) So no sex for a while, unless we want to run away
first chat a bit with the girl and explain her few things:Agreed. Sounds good.
a) That we like her like she is. And would be like to have her as a friend and an ally (and I mean feel this, don't lie)
b) That you are attracted to her beauty and sure that she would be a great mate, but:
c) That even if that happens we can't be loyal, because we must convert and impregnate as many females as you can
d) That we have concerns that Foghorn can ban any contacts between us if he will think that we both want conversion
e) Repeat that we find her beautiful and while you sure that she'll be a very alluring night troll, we aren't sure that we want to destroy the beauty that exists.
f) DO NOT tell her "it's a big step, think better, you can't change back, we know each other 2 days" and another bullshit like that (translation to teens' language - you are stupid kid and can't make decisions on your own)
QuoteAnd all I'm going to say is reproduction without conversion is not possible.Oh, well. I hoped for another situation :) So no sex for a while, unless we want to run away
______________________________________
I support sending Alice back to the tower with cubs and continue hunting alone, but that can wait till the next update. first chat a bit with the girl and explain her few things:
a) That we like her like she is. And would be like to have her as a friend and an ally (and I mean feel this, don't lie)
b) That you are attracted to her beauty and sure that she would be a great mate, but:
c) That even if that happens we can't be loyal, because we must convert and impregnate as many females as you can
d) That we have concerns that Foghorn can ban any contacts between us if he will think that we both want conversion
e) Repeat that we find her beautiful and while you sure that she'll be a very alluring night troll, we aren't sure that we want to destroy the beauty that exists.
f) DO NOT tell her "it's a big step, think better, you can't change back, we know each other 2 days" and another bullshit like that (translation to teens' language - you are stupid kid and can't make decisions on your own)
Hmmmm,
I have a plan
Leap, catch Vindel, send us both in a future for several hours
But I am not sure about it myself, because many things can go wrong
After he leaves, use Eon manipulation on the bracelet to send it into the future for a few hours. It's hardly guaranteed to work, but it's worth a shot.Sure. Maybe fabricate a fake first?
How flimsy does that bracelet look? It's cursed to prevent removal, not necessarily a good smashing. That might be option one as soon as his back is turned. Depends on whether the spell considers it 'his' belonging any more.probably not a good idea.
How? this is the middle of the forest.After he leaves, use Eon manipulation on the bracelet to send it into the future for a few hours. It's hardly guaranteed to work, but it's worth a shot.Sure. Maybe fabricate a fake first?
If he asks us how we got here perhaps we can intimidate him with knowledge of our alliance with our wizardly benefactor.
Well, that sucks, i thought that plan was pretty risky, but something of the like was bound to happen eventually. Better a thrall then dead.
I suggest we cooperate for the moment, telling him the abilities we've *fully* learned and glossing over the details of the skills we've been attempting to develop.
If he asks us how we got here perhaps we can intimidate him with knowledge of our alliance with our wizardly benefactor.
a) Find a female to convert her and make her kill the mage or remove the bracelet (we are ordered to not kill inhabitants, no one banned some sex)Disagreed. Creating a new night troll will only tip our hand and result in the first new generation of night trolls being born as slaves. We have considerable liberty still and should use it more productively. Rather than trying to create another troll, we should do as GreatWyrmGold says. Search the local area, get a new magical weapon, and otherwise formulate a plan to escape.
b) Try to find an animal(s) (flying bug or bird) and ask it to find Alice and tell what happened with youAgreed. Contacting Alice would be a good start.
Disagreed. Creating a new night troll will only tip our hand and result in the first new generation of night trolls being born as slavesWhy do you think that they will be slaves?
Try sending the bracelet a few hours into the future using Eon Magic.We already tried that.
Because...the elf isn't an idiot?QuoteDisagreed. Creating a new night troll will only tip our hand and result in the first new generation of night trolls being born as slavesWhy do you think that they will be slaves?
Weirdsound, looks like you forgot to count jumping forward in time as a successful eon magic action
I know. So what? Why do you assume that he will catch the second troll and put another bracelet?Because...the elf isn't an idiot?QuoteDisagreed. Creating a new night troll will only tip our hand and result in the first new generation of night trolls being born as slavesWhy do you think that they will be slaves?
He caught us, and we're trained in magic and know how to be a night troll.I know. So what? Why do you assume that he will catch the second troll and put another bracelet?Because...the elf isn't an idiot?QuoteDisagreed. Creating a new night troll will only tip our hand and result in the first new generation of night trolls being born as slavesWhy do you think that they will be slaves?
Anyway, I have a new idea:Last resort.
We can cut\bite the arm away (Yes, arms are useful. But I am sure that it's temporary and we can find a magical way to regrow\reattach it later. Or get artificial arm from Illuem)
He caught us, and we're trained in magic and know how to be a night troll.Oh, if he was successful once (and veeery lucky) He will be autosuccessful again, I see. Logical
Last resortBetter sooner then late. Who knows what will he force us to do? For example he may ask what we plan to do to run away and then ban all our ideas.
No, if he was successful at a difficult task he has a good chance of succeeding at an easier and pretty much identical one, especially now that he knows what works.QuoteHe caught us, and we're trained in magic and know how to be a night troll.Oh, if he was successful once (and veeery lucky) He will be autosuccessful again, I see. Logical
Better to not bet the use of one arm on the fact that A. we can regrow it and B. we can escape to full safety before the elf notices that we are gone, despite blood loss.QuoteLast resortBetter sooner then late. Who knows what will he force us to do? For example he may ask what we plan to do to run away and then ban all our ideas.
BTW, aren't troll regenerative? Cut the arm, remove the bracelet, tie the arm back and hope that it will reatachSome trolls, maybe not us. Want to bet?
Anyway, losing the arm is not a mega problem, I think any semi-copmpetent healer can regrow it back. And elven city should have a healer or two
No, if he was successful at a difficult task he has a good chance of succeeding at an easier and pretty much identical one, especially now that he knows what works.He is a squashy human with no combat skills, if we choose mate with combat skills then...
B. we can escape to full safety before the elf notices that we are gone, despite blood loss.Escape? I'd rather wait for him and make him pay for an attempt to enslave us. As for bloodloss... I don't believe that night trolls are that fragile that can't survive after some bandaging
Want to bet?Yes, Yes, Yes! I want to bet. As I said before, even long term armlessness is not a huge problem for a mage. In the worst case we'll get a small penalty for casting spells
And how do you know what any healer can do?Setting is highly magical, so it's logical to assume that such kind of magic exist and pretty common
Total and absolute risk averseness again....Yeah, yeah, I want to avoid dying. So sue me, figurative money ain't good for a corpse.
If we can find a woman with combat skills. Hm, not like this is a pseudo-medieval society, making women with combat skills sufficient to overcome a mage one in a million, on top of the low odds of them being locateable...QuoteNo, if he was successful at a difficult task he has a good chance of succeeding at an easier and pretty much identical one, especially now that he knows what works.He is a squashy human with no combat skills, if we choose mate with combat skills then...
Besides, using new ally for a direct attack is a last resort. We may use it to assist us in breaking the bracelet, helping to get some equipment, sending her as a messenger and so on.And what makes you think we have to attack the elf for him to notice her?
Oh, yes, attack him with one arm while woozy from blood-loss when he defeated us when we had surprise, two arms, and were at our best. Maybe he threw away his magic dagger?QuoteB. we can escape to full safety before the elf notices that we are gone, despite blood loss.Escape? I'd rather wait for him and make him pay for an attempt to enslave us. As for bloodloss... I don't believe that night trolls are that fragile that can't survive after some bandaging
Yup, arms aren't important, not like we'll be heavily restricted by only having one arm.QuoteWant to bet?Yes, Yes, Yes! I want to bet. As I said before, even long term armlessness is not a huge problem for a mage. In the worst case we'll get a small penalty for casting spells
We've been around a few wizards and the daughter of a wizard since we arrived; we haven't seen the larger society. Someone who spent time in the king's court might assume that the whole society was rich, but that isn't necessarily so.QuoteAnd how do you know what any healer can do?Setting is highly magical, so it's logical to assume that such kind of magic exist and pretty common
Yeah, yeah, I want to avoid dying. So sue me, figurative money ain't good for a corpse.Oh, you think you can die as a result of forum game? Believe me you'll not.
If we can find a woman with combat skills. Hm, not like this is a pseudo-medieval society, making women with combat skills sufficient to overcome a mage one in a million, on top of the low odds of them being locateable...Yep, let's not even try. It's better
And what makes you think we have to attack the elf for him to notice her?The fact that he will not actively look for another night troll. Yep, there are some risk that he do notice her, I know. All complex ideas have a chance of failure. Only ones like - "look around" don't
Oh, yes, attack him with one arm while woozy from blood-loss when he defeated us when we had surprise, two arms, and were at our best. Maybe he threw away his magic dagger?He defeated us only because he got lucky, combination of his natural 20 and our low result had chance like 2% (Yep I know that it's metagamey but still ) Had we fight with him using our normal methods (fire magic, eon manipulation, darkness) It would be an easy victory.
Yup, arms aren't important, not like we'll be heavily restricted by only having one arm.You can be sarcastic, but being a slave is a far more restricting
Hint, I'm being sarcastic.
But let's say we found a healer of sufficient power. We're still a Night Troll. Do you think s/he would heal us out of the goodness of their heart?Night trolls have methods to force someone to do something. And there are different kinds of healers
We've been around a few wizards and the daughter of a wizard since we arrived; we haven't seen the larger society.IIRC, Foghorn told us that there are many weak wizards around
I think that cutting our arm of is a terrible idea which should not be considered at this time.Sure, one more risk averse person.
I won't, but I try to put myself in the mind of the character, who is at risk and doesn't realise that he's the protagonist. Also, this elf strikes me as the type to kill us if we end up doing more harm than good, and it sure sounds lime we're doing that.QuoteYeah, yeah, I want to avoid dying. So sue me, figurative money ain't good for a corpse.Oh, you think you can die as a result of forum game? Believe me you'll not.
As for character, we are far, far away from dying. Vendel will not kill such a valuable tool, he will just treat us worse. And even if our little troll will die, so what? (BTW, how many forum suggestion games ended with the death of main character? Name me few)
More skills than we had.QuoteIf we can find a woman with combat skills. Hm, not like this is a pseudo-medieval society, making women with combat skills sufficient to overcome a mage one in a million, on top of the low odds of them being locateable...Yep, let's not even try. It's better
And what exceptional skills are needed to overcome Vendel? He is not a combat mage
How dumb does he have to be not to have enough magical surveillance on us to be able to tell if we're regularly meeting somewhere, and how do we know this hypothetical warrior woman who we turn into a night troll will keep a low profile?QuoteAnd what makes you think we have to attack the elf for him to notice her?The fact that he will not actively look for another night troll. Yep, there are some risk that he do notice her, I know. All complex ideas have a chance of failure. Only ones like - "look around" don't
Luck was on his side, but now he knows us better. Let's not throw him a bone.QuoteOh, yes, attack him with one arm while woozy from blood-loss when he defeated us when we had surprise, two arms, and were at our best. Maybe he threw away his magic dagger?He defeated us only because he got lucky, combination of his natural 20 and our low result had chance like 2% (Yep I know that it's metagamey but still ) Had we fight with him using our normal methods (fire magic, eon manipulation, darkness) It would be an easy victory.
And that's exactly what we should do if we get a chance for revenge
We're not a slave, we have too much freedom. Anyways, you know what's more restricting? Being a corpse.QuoteYup, arms aren't important, not like we'll be heavily restricted by only having one arm.You can be sarcastic, but being a slave is a far more restricting
Hint, I'm being sarcastic.
We've met...no healers. You seem to know a lot about them.QuoteBut let's say we found a healer of sufficient power. We're still a Night Troll. Do you think s/he would heal us out of the goodness of their heart?Night trolls have methods to force someone to do something. And there are different kinds of healers
Weak. Wizards. Not strong healers. Besides, weak could mean "a decade less experience than me" or "burns down the house while boiling water."QuoteWe've been around a few wizards and the daughter of a wizard since we arrived; we haven't seen the larger society.IIRC, Foghorn told us that there are many weak wizards around
Sure.QuoteI think that cutting our arm of is a terrible idea which should not be considered at this time.Sure, one more risk averse person.
Can you offer some non-terrible ideas?
I think no, while putting him in the loop doesn't harm him, we know that miscast can harm it and we can't risk his healthWe could, however, try. When we're not being closely watched. It would help us understand the limits of our bindings, too.
but I try to put myself in the mind of the character, who is at risk and doesn't realise that he's the protagonistOh, so you want to roleplay a coward, OK. Then your suggestions are perfectly logical. I'd like to see another kind of character
Also, this elf strikes me as the type to kill us if we end up doing more harm than goodWhy kill us if he can order anything?
We're not a slave, we have too much freedom.As long as we get no worse orders.
Sure.So, in short: "Do nothing and hope for the best?" Let him use us? Let him create enemies for ourself? Let him send us on any suicide mission he wants?
Work within his rules and use every ambiguity and loophole against him.
-Send a bird to Alice. She owes us one and can come help break us out.Terrible, the bird could work on Vindel, elves are known to employ animals.
-Survey the area at night for good escape routes once we do break free.Terrible. What if someone sees us? That will create so many problems. Let's sit entire night in the basement. It's safe. Besides what can Alice do? We decided that Vindel is unbeatable ubermage
Examine the enchanting workshop during the night and look for a book on enchantment so we can disenchant the bracelet.Oh, Vindel will be mad when he finds that attempt, besides we can hurt ourself by trying enchantments
If all else fails, send Vindel as far into the future as we can and just wait it out in Vindel's workshop.Terrible. Doubt that we can do that, besides if we fail he will be mad at us and much more cautious (this time I am serious)
I vote that we ignore Ukrainian Ranger on the grounds that he is enormously butthurt about us not listening to his suggestion.LOL. I just like discussion, even if they are a bit rough. Just posting a suggestion or +1 isn't really fun
I have a suggestion that is feasible, although it may have backlash that we cannot necessarily predict. We could incriminate our intrepid master in the crimes that we know he has committed.So, you want to make enemies for our master. How do you think who will fight against that enemies?
Something to think about, he doesn't seem to know... that we know, his other companions may also crack if the rumor breaks out.
For now, search the area we're allowed in.
Let's have the elf help us make a new magical weapon. Maybe a sword or knife that absorbs life force or something?
b) Look for loopholes, find allies, weaken the magic and so on. ( Minus: It's damn hard to intrigue if you must answer questions like "What are you trying to do to get out? What did you do last night? " And if Vindel is not an idiot he'll ask that. While half-truth may help, most likely it will not. IMO it's a worst route
If he asks, just say we were planning on cutting off our arm or somethingGods, no... Then you'll take away option to get rid of hand if we get a suicidal order. I really can't understand why everyone is so opposed to this solution with temporal injury but at least do not take it as last rersort
If I am correct, we have fire magic. And the bracelet is steel. It may be impossibly painful, but would it be possible to melt the bracelet off with enough fire?If we can't send it in the future, then we can't melt it away. Besides arm damage would be so severe that it's no better than chopping it off
This is a good idea. We can also remind ourselves that this is not an escape plan, because we will still be here. Finally, if he asks "what did you plan to do to escape", we can honestly say that we though of cutting our arm off, so that huge argument everyone just had was actually very productive.b) Look for loopholes, find allies, weaken the magic and so on. ( Minus: It's damn hard to intrigue if you must answer questions like "What are you trying to do to get out? What did you do last night? " And if Vindel is not an idiot he'll ask that. While half-truth may help, most likely it will not. IMO it's a worst route
This sort of twisty logic requires even twistier logic to counteract: We must precommit ourselves to preemptively abandoning all escape plans that are in danger of being discovered within the immediate future due to us being forced to answer questions about them. That way, when asked "What do you plan to do to escape?" we are forced to honestly answer that we've given up on all of our plans to escape because we know he'll figure them out.
E: Also, we should come up with some unworkable and stupid plans to escape so that we have something to tell him when he asks "Well, what DID you plan to do to escape?"
I have a trope (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HonorBeforeReason) for you. It's not cowardice, it's wanting to live longer and better.Quotebut I try to put myself in the mind of the character, who is at risk and doesn't realise that he's the protagonistOh, so you want to roleplay a coward, OK. Then your suggestions are perfectly logical. I'd like to see another kind of character
Because we're doing more harm than good?QuoteAlso, this elf strikes me as the type to kill us if we end up doing more harm than goodWhy kill us if he can order anything?
And we WILL get worse orders if we go about our rebellion all obvious-like.QuoteWe're not a slave, we have too much freedom.As long as we get no worse orders.
Um...Thanks for strawmanning me! No, take his orders literally. If he has us bring him water, flood the house because he didn't tell us to stop. Ignore his orders that would require us to be outside during daylight hours, because he told us not to. Stuff like that.QuoteSure.So, in short: "Do nothing and hope for the best?" Let him use us? Let him create enemies for ourself? Let him send us on any suicide mission he wants?
Work within his rules and use every ambiguity and loophole against him.
Oh... And just a little "let's find what can go wrong" from meTrue enough, so we wander a ways away before choosing the bird, and we bribe it with food. That way, the bird flies fast to Alice and Vindel won't know until Alice has been contacted. Unless he questions every animal leaving his neck of the woods, which seems rather paranoid and impractical.Quote-Send a bird to Alice. She owes us one and can come help break us out.Terrible, the bird could work on Vindel, elves are known to employ animals.
When did we decide that Vindel was unbeatable? I was talking about him repeating his exact, same victory, only with more knowledge and a weaker night troll.Quote-Survey the area at night for good escape routes once we do break free.Terrible. What if someone sees us? That will create so many problems. Let's sit entire night in the basement. It's safe. Besides what can Alice do? We decided that Vindel is unbeatable ubermage
Examine the enchanting workshop during the night and look for a book on enchantment so we can disenchant the bracelet.Oh, Vindel will be mad when he finds that attempt, besides we can hurt ourself by trying enchantments
This, I agree with. I think the GM said that temporal manipulation would be beyond our leash to do to him.QuoteIf all else fails, send Vindel as far into the future as we can and just wait it out in Vindel's workshop.Terrible. Doubt that we can do that, besides if we fail he will be mad at us and much more cautious (this time I am serious)
I vote that we ignore Ukrainian Ranger on the grounds that he is enormously butthurt about us not listening to his suggestion.And he's making strawmen.
You know what else isn't fun? Being strawmanned.I vote that we ignore Ukrainian Ranger on the grounds that he is enormously butthurt about us not listening to his suggestion.LOL. I just like discussion, even if they are a bit rough. Just posting a suggestion or +1 isn't really fun
Vindel will fight against the enemies and hopefully weaken himself. Or ruin his public image.I have a suggestion that is feasible, although it may have backlash that we cannot necessarily predict. We could incriminate our intrepid master in the crimes that we know he has committed.So, you want to make enemies for our master. How do you think who will fight against that enemies?
Something to think about, he doesn't seem to know... that we know, his other companions may also crack if the rumor breaks out.
Basically we have only three basic ways to deal with the situationI think b has the least chance of immediate punishment. And we can claim that we were only following his orders like the bracelet ordered us to.
a) Do nothing, cooperate with Vindel and hope that something good happens ( minus: Eventually he will use us for something that we really don't want to do)
b) Look for loopholes, find allies, weaken the magic and so on. ( Minus: It's damn hard to intrigue if you must answer questions like "What are you trying to do to get out? What did you do last night? " And if Vindel is not an idiot he'll ask that. While half-truth may help, most likely it will not. IMO it's a worst route
c) Find a way to get rid of the bracelet NOW (Minus: It's not easy to do)
Wrong, I consider it a last resort.QuoteIf he asks, just say we were planning on cutting off our arm or somethingGods, no... Then you'll take away option to get rid of hand if we get a suicidal order. I really can't understand why everyone is so opposed to this solution with temporal injury but at least do not take it as last rersort
Slightly better--there's a higher chance we can get healed and a lower chance of exsanguination. We'll consider it if we need to.QuoteIf I am correct, we have fire magic. And the bracelet is steel. It may be impossibly painful, but would it be possible to melt the bracelet off with enough fire?If we can't send it in the future, then we can't melt it away. Besides arm damage would be so severe that it's no better than chopping it off
Can we at least search Vindel shop for healing magic? As enchanter he may have that.I'd advise putting that stuff off a day, and spend the first night investigating our surroundings.
and\or Look for healer in the town
EUREKA! I have the solution. If we hear Vindel give us a command, we have to obey it, but if we can't hear anything, he can't command us. Plug our ears with wax or something, and use our eon magic to distort time around our head so that everything we do hear is unintelligible. Then we can just tie Vindel to his bed/ barricade him in the basement and not have to worry about his orders. We can even reinforce the rope/door with eon magic to protect our possessions if is looks like he's going to escape.We should, however, make these preparations at night, outside the house, and whatever room we trap him in should have no enchanting supplies whatsoever.Good idea. Best wait to spring our plan into action when we're acting on it, ideally shortly after he's given us permission to leave before dark, so we can run to the tower and escape to safety.
This is a good idea. We can also remind ourselves that this is not an escape plan, because we will still be here. Finally, if he asks "what did you plan to do to escape", we can honestly say that we though of cutting our arm off, so that huge argument everyone just had was actually very productive.b) Look for loopholes, find allies, weaken the magic and so on. ( Minus: It's damn hard to intrigue if you must answer questions like "What are you trying to do to get out? What did you do last night? " And if Vindel is not an idiot he'll ask that. While half-truth may help, most likely it will not. IMO it's a worst routeThis sort of twisty logic requires even twistier logic to counteract: We must precommit ourselves to preemptively abandoning all escape plans that are in danger of being discovered within the immediate future due to us being forced to answer questions about them. That way, when asked "What do you plan to do to escape?" we are forced to honestly answer that we've given up on all of our plans to escape because we know he'll figure them out.
E: Also, we should come up with some unworkable and stupid plans to escape so that we have something to tell him when he asks "Well, what DID you plan to do to escape?"
Because we're doing more harm than good?What stops him from stopping us to to do harm?
Um...Thanks for strawmanning me! No, take his orders literally. If he has us bring him water, flood the house because he didn't tell us to stop. Ignore his orders that would require us to be outside during daylight hours, because he told us not to. Stuff like that.Yep, it's exactly hoping for the best. ( Or hoping that our kind GM that will gift an opportunity like that) Also, I doubt that ignoring order because it's going against older order works. (GM decision in fact, can be either way)
Slightly better--there's a higher chance we can get healed and a lower chance of exsanguination. We'll consider it if we need to.What? Higher chance? If you cleanly cut an arm and bring it to modern surgeons in time, they can reattach it and the arm will be close to normal, but badly burned hand will stay injured forever.
Good idea. Best wait to spring our plan into action when we're acting on it, ideally shortly after he's given us permission to leave before dark, so we can run to the tower and escape to safety.Now, I am really confused... Looks like it's not a risk averseness after all.... You are sure that Vindel can easily defeat onearmed troll that can do whatever he wants. You are sure that he will easily defeat a freshly born night troll. And you think it's a good idea to try to tie him up when we have limitations much more severe than onearmlessnes. Can't understand the logic. We can't even scratch him in struggle.
racnorYour idea is quite creative and original one, but there are several problemsa. His plan doesn't need combat like yours.
a) It's damn hard to tie up someone with enchanted dagger when you have no unarmed combat skills, can't hurt the victim and inside his magical basement
b) He may give orders with gestures that are hard to not understand
c) There are no guarantee that our body will not obey orders that we don't understand
I dislike the idea to delay escape attempts because it's highly likely that escape will become harder in future and\or we'll get a bad job, even this set of rules is hard to circumvent, and he'll add more and more. Simple orders like - "don't injury yourself" "don't use magic unless commanded to" "don't touch my stuff" "Don't tell anyone about your bond" will enslave us until either he is dead (not by our efforts, we'll have no options) or our magic resistance kick in. This elf underestimated our intelligence, but I'd not count that this will continue foreverHopefully, the elf would be complacent, but that's a dumb bet to make.
Nothing, but we will either find new ways to bother by the book. Or bother him enough that he kills us...let's hope the first.QuoteBecause we're doing more harm than good?What stops him from stopping us to to do harm?
I was giving examples that popped into my head; any further orders will be followed by me coming up with ways to twist them to our advantage.QuoteUm...Thanks for strawmanning me! No, take his orders literally. If he has us bring him water, flood the house because he didn't tell us to stop. Ignore his orders that would require us to be outside during daylight hours, because he told us not to. Stuff like that.Yep, it's exactly hoping for the best. ( Or hoping that our kind GM that will gift an opportunity like that) Also, I doubt that ignoring order because it's going against older order works. (GM decision in fact, can be either way)
Being evil genie may be fun when you are very mighty and can't get killed by the master, else that works badly.
Chances are that we'll get orders that will bring us in trouble, not Vindel
With modern tech and no magic.QuoteSlightly better--there's a higher chance we can get healed and a lower chance of exsanguination. We'll consider it if we need to.What? Higher chance? If you cleanly cut an arm and bring it to modern surgeons in time, they can reattach it and the arm will be close to normal, but badly burned hand will stay injured forever.
How is deafness worse than being one-armed and exsanguinated? If he can't give orders, we don't need to follow them..QuoteGood idea. Best wait to spring our plan into action when we're acting on it, ideally shortly after he's given us permission to leave before dark, so we can run to the tower and escape to safety.Now, I am really confused... Looks like it's not a risk averseness after all.... You are sure that Vindel can easily defeat onearmed troll that can do whatever he wants. You are sure that he will easily defeat a freshly born night troll. And you think it's a good idea to try to tie him up when we have limitations much more severe than onearmlessnes. Can't understand the logic. We can't even scratch him in struggle.
OK, enough discussions time for an action
How about that?
a) Wander around, learn surroundings.
b) Find flying animal ( bird, bat or swarm of flying insects ) and send message to Alice. Don't do it to close to the basement
c) Try to locate night creatures nearby
and
d) Don't touch Vindel stuff. It's highly likely that he has traps\alarms. In fact it's an almost certainty, he is a master in exactly that kind of magic
OK, enough discussions time for an actionIf the turn hadn't already been posted, I would agree with you.
How about that?
a) Wander around, learn surroundings.
b) Find flying animal ( bird, bat or swarm of flying insects ) and send message to Alice. Don't do it to close to the basement
c) Try to locate night creatures nearby
and
d) Don't touch Vindel stuff. It's highly likely that he has traps\alarms. In fact it's an almost certainty, he is a master in exactly that kind of magic
+1, lets put night creature empathy to work.OK, enough discussions time for an actionIf the turn hadn't already been posted, I would agree with you.
How about that?
a) Wander around, learn surroundings.
b) Find flying animal ( bird, bat or swarm of flying insects ) and send message to Alice. Don't do it to close to the basement
c) Try to locate night creatures nearby
and
d) Don't touch Vindel stuff. It's highly likely that he has traps\alarms. In fact it's an almost certainty, he is a master in exactly that kind of magic
I agree, jump away and chat with the Sasquatch. They're clever, right?
Few last turns our luck is ****
On other hand now Vindel will have to heal us, and that will be useful
As for what to do: Leap away to safe distance and try to communicate with Sasquatch
Run towards town! Two birds, one stone.
we can't. It would be causing a commotion in the town.
we can't. It would be causing a commotion in the town.We're not causing the commotion, the sasquatch is.
Run towards town! Two birds, one stone.
Throw something at the sasquatch to anger it!
Then run.
Throw something at the sasquatch to anger it!
Then run.
Throw something at the sasquatch to anger it!
Then run.
Go the opposite direction as the Sasquatch, seek a bird again.+1 to bird
Alternatively, hold down in the basement and rest that wound.
Go the opposite direction as the Sasquatch, seek a bird again.find insects instead. if asked what we were doing, say that we tried to fight the Sasquatch early in it's rampage.
Alternatively, hold down in the basement and rest that wound.
Go the opposite direction as the Sasquatch, seek a bird again.
Alternatively, hold down in the basement and rest that wound.
Hm, injury benefits us in factSounds like a plan. Spend the time before Vindel returns studying Intro to the Inferno.
That empath is our chance to do the arm cutting trick :P
If we will be allowed to keep the healing items, it may help, too
Agree to use elven items AND ask about empath.
Ask something like
" Are there are really idiots around that like to interact with night creatures without precautions like your masterwork bracelet? I am curios who is this moron who doesn't understand that he'll get eaten sooner or later"
In short make it look like a simple curiosity. And that we despise that empath. And flattery is our weapon, make him believe that we think that he is a genius
Well, if the enchantment allows vindel to control us, would he still be vinde?Yes, he will.
Lawl on my part forminor derail
New tack. What can we do to cause hurt to his lady love? Is there any way we can frame her for something unpleasant? Can we get others to hurt her in some way? Can we convince her that he killed his rival?
Can we break into her house and hypnotise her?
We might as well make this guy's life a living hell by as indirect a method as we can. He might snap and do something stupid that way, and even if he doesn't... well, it's vengeance.
New tack. What can we do to cause hurt to his lady love? Is there any way we can frame her for something unpleasant? Can we get others to hurt her in some way? Can we convince her that he killed his rival?I like this idea. Maybe once the chaos dies down from the sasquatch, we could disguise ourselves as an elf disguised as a bogeyman and tell her that we saw Vindel kill...the other elf...
We should scout out the area if you are going to bust into someones house specially someone who has the queen's favor.Agreed.
New tack. What can we do to cause hurt to his lady love? Is there any way we can frame her for something unpleasant? Can we get others to hurt her in some way? Can we convince her that he killed his rival?I like this idea. Maybe once the chaos dies down from the sasquatch, we could disguise ourselves as an elf disguised as a bogeyman and tell her that we saw Vindel kill...the other elf...
No hypnotism. That will be short-lived, and so will we.We should scout out the area if you are going to bust into someones house specially someone who has the queen's favor.Agreed.
New tack. What can we do to cause hurt to his lady love? Is there any way we can frame her for something unpleasant? Can we get others to hurt her in some way? Can we convince her that he killed his rival?I like this idea. Maybe once the chaos dies down from the sasquatch, we could disguise ourselves as an elf disguised as a bogeyman and tell her that we saw Vindel kill...the other elf...
No hypnotism. That will be short-lived, and so will we.We should scout out the area if you are going to bust into someones house specially someone who has the queen's favor.Agreed.
i agree
Hm, injury benefits us in factSounds like a plan. Spend the time before Vindel returns studying Intro to the Inferno.
That empath is our chance to do the arm cutting trick :P
If we will be allowed to keep the healing items, it may help, too
Agree to use elven items AND ask about empath.
Ask something like
" Are there are really idiots around that like to interact with night creatures without precautions like your masterwork bracelet? I am curios who is this moron who doesn't understand that he'll get eaten sooner or later"
In short make it look like a simple curiosity. And that we despise that empath. And flattery is our weapon, make him believe that we think that he is a genius
Just to comment: Why are we always rolling horribly? What are you using to do the dice rolls anyway?
Totally freedom.I disagree.
Totally freedom.I disagree.
The enchanted items would be excellent, and possibly let us get our own freedom, AND possibly not be gettable otherwise.
Instead, ask, "What kind of enchanted item, and how much closer to freedom?"
Yeah, item. I kinda get the feeling he's going to kill us once he has the princess.
You are not to travel more than an hour outside the settlement's bordersAs a time mage we should exploit that "hour" somehow. It's much easier then if he said something like - don't get further away
Wow, Vindel isn't smart enough... I never expected that amount of freedomYup. Time to get all that stuff in that we've been wanting to do that we've not had time to. Locate a bird to contact Alice, brew some elf avoidance potions, get our fire magic up to snuff, etc. Let's do this.
Oh, missed the last paragraph...disregard the previous action.
Reconnaissance.
Ask the plants and animals about a nearby cave and anything we might find out about the retreat's defences.
Drop down beside him. "Few have the bravery to deal with such as me with such a cool head, i admit i am impressed. You speak of flesh, what do you mean by that?"
Guys, this is another either-or choice. We can have his wife OR the gold, not both.Thats... not half bad! As long as he doesn't somehow see through our plan or has a weapon at the ranch.
I say we grab the gold, but ask if he knows any enchanters.
E: Unless we want to kill him, that is. We could get him to show us to the gold, kill him, eat him and convert his wife. Then send said wife to Foghorn to rescue us.
Guys, this is another either-or choice. We can have his wife OR the gold, not both.Thats... not half bad! As long as he doesn't somehow see through our plan or has a weapon at the ranch.
I say we grab the gold, but ask if he knows any enchanters.
E: Unless we want to kill him, that is. We could get him to show us to the gold, kill him, eat him and convert his wife. Then send said wife to Foghorn to rescue us.
+1 to this, but how will we convince the wife to help us once we've converted her?Guys, this is another either-or choice. We can have his wife OR the gold, not both.Thats... not half bad! As long as he doesn't somehow see through our plan or has a weapon at the ranch.
I say we grab the gold, but ask if he knows any enchanters.
E: Unless we want to kill him, that is. We could get him to show us to the gold, kill him, eat him and convert his wife. Then send said wife to Foghorn to rescue us.
Let's go with that.
+1 to this, but how will we convince the wife to help us once we've converted her?Guys, this is another either-or choice. We can have his wife OR the gold, not both.Thats... not half bad! As long as he doesn't somehow see through our plan or has a weapon at the ranch.
I say we grab the gold, but ask if he knows any enchanters.
E: Unless we want to kill him, that is. We could get him to show us to the gold, kill him, eat him and convert his wife. Then send said wife to Foghorn to rescue us.
Let's go with that.
Yeah, no need to randomly convert people.Wait until we have someone we know we want to convert. Random elf rancher's current wife? Who knows what problems she has.
then at least learn about her. we don't want an inept cripple or something, and we have an entire settlement to choose from.Exactly. The elf woman should be at least above-average and/or very notable in some quality before we use our precious Gift on her.
Also, ust to clarify, we're using the gift of displacement, right?We had best...
Even if she's a cripple (which she probably isn't!), I think trading our Displacement Gift for our freedom is a good deal.
Well, we can ask her husband, something like
" Why do you think that your wife worth more than you or your gold?"
Guys, seriously. We have a workable plan here. Convert the wife, make her disenchant the bracelet and let the man-elf go. Let's not complicate this by letting our new minion keep her free will or having qualms about converting people. For goodness sakes, she has skill at enchantment, sword fighting, dark manipulation, animal empathy and a bunch of other useful stuff. We aren't going to find someone better!
Guys, seriously. We have a workable plan here. Convert the wife, make her disenchant the bracelet and let the man-elf go. Let's not complicate this by letting our new minion keep her free will or having qualms about converting people. For goodness sakes, she has skill at enchantment, sword fighting, dark manipulation, animal empathy and a bunch of other useful stuff. We aren't going to find someone better!^ This
As spake the reasonably ancient sages of Amanereli: thiiiiiiiiisGuys, seriously. We have a workable plan here. Convert the wife, make her disenchant the bracelet and let the man-elf go. Let's not complicate this by letting our new minion keep her free will or having qualms about converting people. For goodness sakes, she has skill at enchantment, sword fighting, dark manipulation, animal empathy and a bunch of other useful stuff. We aren't going to find someone better!^ This
Well we are at ranch, time to go out and have a snack, then return and use the displacement gift...Yep, get to it.
We should waste no time, sooner or later Vindel will visit us if we don't return with souls
Well we are at ranch, time to go out and have a snack, then return and use the displacement gift...
We should waste no time, sooner or later Vindel will visit us if we don't return with souls
Once we've created our mate i think we should treat her with genuine kindness, being the Last Night Troll in the world seems lonely business.Agreed.
Once we've created our mate i think we should treat her with genuine kindness, being the Last Night Troll in the world seems lonely business.
So hunting it is. We must stay careful, serious injure or killing more than 3 elves may ruin our plans...Heheh - yup some burning trees should attract some attention from those treehuggers. Two smaller fires would be better than one large one, to spread the responders out more - making them easier to pick off.
I think luring a guard or two from the settlement is our best bet, but how?
Imitating call for help is one option, starting a forest fire and hunting in the resulting chaos is another and mix of dark manipulation and hypnosis is the third
I'm mostly suggesting that we use Vindel's soul on the bracelet because it's ironic and cruel, not because there's any practical reason to do so. We're a night troll. Ironic and cruel is what we do.I'd rather use Vindel on some other ironic thing, especially if we discover that the enchantment on the bracelet vanishes after he dies.
We would at least need the ability to carve through the earth, if not a team of miners, and *that* is assuming that we can use the very limited magical resources and skills at our disposal to eventually master the ability to pull up vast quantities of molten earth from the ground before it cools to the consistency of... well... half melted rock.Yeah, I'm not sure how serious he was...
That's why we got tatoos right, even though I would make the bonus a +2 instead of +1The +1 bonus is more than fair because of the simple fact it is an all encompassing skill, it provides a bonus to pretty much *all* magical and quasi-magical skills we have engaged in, that's not something to laugh at.
I do think we should stalk the edges of the town, looking for vulnerable folks, and if finding none i suggest we attempt to subtly lure people into our deadly (and figurative) embrace.
Send his head several minutes ahead in time, severing it from his neckI vote for that plan
Send his head several minutes ahead in time, severing it from his neckI vote for that plan
Send his head several minutes ahead in time, severing it from his neckI vote for that plan
Also, since we are the only remaining entity that remembers night troll culture, we could take this as an opportunity to redefine enchanting as a sacrifice by the soul collector, instead of a dark art. Don't lie about anything, just take a different perspective.We're the last night troll, but between books and immortal elves there's still the probability that people know about our culture. And they'll probably see through our ruse.
We shall not forget Alice, she is our friend... (and a nice potential mate)
We should chat with the tigerwoman and carefully find out if she is ready to go against Foghorn to save Alice.
I suggest to spend a night sparring with the wife (use sticks for swords) That may let us learn a trick or two and Gwen needs to get used for her body
If she is skilled in unarmed combat, we should practice that, too
As for bracelet, I think boost to animal empathy is a nice thing to have
I think alice might be one who could actually prove a more powerful and adaptable ally with her free will, if we do free her.Our former-elf consort is relatively free-willed - its instinctive loyalty, not the kind of full mind bind that cripples autonomy and creativity. I assume it would be the same with Alice - particularly since this would be the second time we've saved her.
I'm not saying we should lie to her, just don't flip out about enchanting.Also, since we are the only remaining entity that remembers night troll culture, we could take this as an opportunity to redefine enchanting as a sacrifice by the soul collector, instead of a dark art. Don't lie about anything, just take a different perspective.We're the last night troll, but between books and immortal elves there's still the probability that people know about our culture. And they'll probably see through our ruse.
I agree that switching the enchantment to plant empathy makes sense, and that we should talk to Rox about Alice and the "wonderland" she may want Alice to escape.
I'd also suggest inquiring as to why Alice is not present. I doubt that Foghorn told Rox to tell us about what he had done to her...This is a really good point. seconded.
Foghorn is a potential problem that we need to figure out how to solve. Asking about Alice would probably help in that regard.
Didn't he already tell us about Alice, its in the black text
"Wakey-wakey!"Hm, actually, we can ask HOW she was punished. We did, after all, "cause" her punishment and don't want to worry that we accidentally caused her lots of harm.
"I'm soooooo sorry about my daughter's behavior. I thank you for rejecting her, and assure you she has been punished for trying to turn you against me. Speaking of which I got a note from Vindel ordering you to obey his orders no longer, but it looks like you don't need it!"
"This is a nice ranch. The lovebirds are a great resource. Are you going to want to stay here or return to the tower? I can have Rox or Edgar babysit the site you aren't using until you have enough mates to keep them all occupied."
"If you leave now, Rox can show you back by around midnight."
To figure out how Foghorn feels about us knowing. If he tells the truth, he trusts us or doesn't care; if he says nothing or changes the subject, he's probably nervous about it and therefore likely wasn't doing it willingly; if he just lies, we've got almost nothing but at least we tried.
Her punishment is being sold to Vindel and being disowned, which we already knowWell, the tigerwoman said that Foghorn intended to use Alice as a peace offering. We can still avoid that.
Anything further on that is to be determined by Vindel
What we should ask is why Foghorn was speaking to Vindel, which wont arouse suspicion
This guy seems really eager to help us, I'm kinda wondering just how motivated he is by taking credit, what exactly would that do for him?He's a dark wizard - it's in his best interest for the night trolls to spread and envelop the nights in fear again. Endangered species protection at its evilest, lol.
On that vein, perhaps ask what he has to gain by taking credit for us? I'm not seeing the return on investment here considering how much he has done and what he is offering. He isn't exactly getting stingy on us either, as if he would be happy to burn some more time/resources for us.
e: To be clear, we finally got our ass handed back to us from some random enchanter, you'd think he would at least be having second thoughts with respect to our badassery.
What I want to determine is how confortable Foghorn is about telling us where Alice is.To figure out how Foghorn feels about us knowing. If he tells the truth, he trusts us or doesn't care; if he says nothing or changes the subject, he's probably nervous about it and therefore likely wasn't doing it willingly; if he just lies, we've got almost nothing but at least we tried.
I am sure that we should open our cards and tell about Vindel's plan to marry his way to the capital. If Foghorn will know that Vindel will leave as soon as he can he will value such an ally way less. And if he will know that Vindel doesn't truly need Alice as a wife, because he desires another oman he may change his mind.
Tell Foghorn that we don't agree with what he's decided to do, that we think Vindel is scum that should be killed and eaten, but that we're not going to interfere with his peace offering to VindelIn short, we should let Foghorn know that we don't like the plan to keep the guy who enslaved us alive but won't interfere with it; tell Foghorn everything we know about Vindel; and let Vindel know we'd be willing to barter for Alice.because we owe Foghorn for the tower.
Once Foghorn has left, send word to Vindel that we desire Alice (don't specify why) and are willing to forgive him for his treatment of us if he will agree to sell her to us.
I am sure that we should open our cards and tell about Vindel's plan to marry his way to the capital. If Foghorn will know that Vindel will leave as soon as he can he will value such an ally way less. And if he will know that Vindel doesn't truly need Alice as a wife, because he desires another oman he may change his mind.
Nah, I think having a human agent would be more useful to us. We may have camouflage, but she's actually normal. That makes her incredibly useful for recon.Best idea. We don't have to cling to the old ways; we'll make our own.
She's useful to us as a human for other reasons too. Imagine, she establishes her own bloodline. She trains her children to work with ours, basically forming a cult around us. Wouldn't that be useful?
We also don't have to worry about her being swayed by her husband, because... well... you know. That also makes it awkward to convert her, I imagine. She clearly wouldn't enjoy it.
I was referring to the bit about Alice. It's probably sarcasm, but I wanted to make sure I wasn't seeing thinngs.I think he's pretty pissed at him. We did roll a 20 in persuasion. It's a bit meta-gamey to tell that way, but I'm assuming we could tell better if he was being sarcastic in RL.
Nah, I think having a human agent would be more useful to us. We may have camouflage, but she's actually normal. That makes her incredibly useful for recon.Well with a new elf target set out for us to convert, I agree that we should have Alice remain a human agent for us. However, we should keep that option on the table for the future imo. As for the problem you mentioned, it's possible conversion will fix that...
She's useful to us as a human for other reasons too. Imagine, she establishes her own bloodline. She trains her children to work with ours, basically forming a cult around us. Wouldn't that be useful?
We also don't have to worry about her being swayed by her husband, because... well... you know. That also makes it awkward to convert her, I imagine. She clearly wouldn't enjoy it.
Foghorn is pissed at the PC, right?I was referring to the bit about Alice. It's probably sarcasm, but I wanted to make sure I wasn't seeing thinngs.I think he's pretty pissed at him. We did roll a 20 in persuasion. It's a bit meta-gamey to tell that way, but I'm assuming we could tell better if he was being sarcastic in RL.
Nah, I think having a human agent would be more useful to us. We may have camouflage, but she's actually normal. That makes her incredibly useful for recon.She is not normal human, she is a quite strange girl used to live in forest and talk with animals. Not a good spy at all. Now imagine boosting her with our megagift (stealth, bonus in magic, jumping) or some other future gift that we may get
She's useful to us as a human for other reasons too. Imagine, she establishes her own bloodline.Quite unlikely unless forced
She clearly wouldn't enjoy it.Conversion isn't a pleasant thing for everyone. And as we know sex is not required
She can, however, interact with humans and other races normally.QuoteNah, I think having a human agent would be more useful to us. We may have camouflage, but she's actually normal. That makes her incredibly useful for recon.She is not normal human, she is a quite strange girl used to live in forest and talk with animals. Not a good spy at all. Now imagine boosting her with our megagift (stealth, bonus in magic, jumping) or some other future gift that we may get
That's hardly the biggest bonus to having her remain human.QuoteShe's useful to us as a human for other reasons too. Imagine, she establishes her own bloodline.Quite unlikely unless forced
You're agreeing with him...QuoteShe clearly wouldn't enjoy it.Conversion isn't a pleasant thing for everyone. And as we know sex is not required
Huh? I am saying that her orientation is unimportant, as well as her feelings during the conversion because every mate will not liker it at firstQuoteYou're agreeing with him...QuoteShe clearly wouldn't enjoy it.Conversion isn't a pleasant thing for everyone. And as we know sex is not required
Oh.Huh? I am saying that her orientation is unimportant, as well as her feelings during the conversion because every mate will not liker it at firstQuoteYou're agreeing with him...QuoteShe clearly wouldn't enjoy it.Conversion isn't a pleasant thing for everyone. And as we know sex is not required
Again it's a long term stuff, but don't you see that we can't touch Vindel without pissing Foghorn? He is his enchanterI'm not saying we should do any permanent damage to him - besides, Foghorn's pissed at him right now, he won't care if we rough him up a bit. And he pretty much offered Alice to us on a silver platter, so he should be fine with us just releasing her from the torture.
I am not sure that asking about Alice is a good idea, we shouldn't look too interested in her, I say just inform him that we are planing to go to the tower to prepare for the abduction of Ciara, as this is not an easy task to do.
Gwen goes to the ranch with instructions to bring the birds to the tower.
We go release Alice.
We bring Alice back to our wizard tower
Introduce Alice to Gwen.
Make whatever preparations we need to abduct the princess.
Abduct the princess.
Little problem... To release Alice we need to learn where we can find Alice
Also if we do bring birds with us to the tower, why not do it know? I'd rather not destroy food supply in that way
So, here's the plan: Get Foghorn to tell us where Alice is. Invite Alice to stay with us at our ranch while she recovers. Then, once Alice is safe and settled, we go on a day trip to the tower to get the dwarf whatever he needs for his artifact. Artifact in hand, we abduct Clairia.The first step is the most important and least certain.
You guys seem to forget that unconverted Alice can do whatever she want and I suspect that it's quite possible that she will run away\plot a revenge against her father. Especially if left aloneWe're saving the girl who already owes her life to us, a possible consideration but if we rush and screw up we'll lose more time, we don't know where Alice is, he kinda enslaved us...hm, you gave me an idea. Could we use that enslaving gift on Caira?
Also, I'd not spend too much time in preparations, or Vindel may marry Caira
Also I don't understand why to not go to the tower now.
Also, I see no real reason to revenge Vindel, he treated us quite nicely after we attempted to kill him. Besides doing something bad to his love is a much better revenge
You're implying that there are circumstances people would not want to be rescued from torture machines...Little problem... To release Alice we need to learn where we can find AliceGwen is going for the birds while we ask Foghorn about Alice. He just said that we can have her, so he shouldn't object to us letter her out of the torture machine.
Also if we do bring birds with us to the tower, why not do it know? I'd rather not destroy food supply in that way
Could we use that enslaving gift on Caira?
Alright, revision to the plan:
Gwen goes to the ranch with instructions to bring the birds to the tower.
We go release Alice.
We bring Alice back to our wizard tower
Introduce Alice to Gwen.
Make whatever preparations we need to abduct the princess.
Abduct the princess.
Let them undig the box first however, that way we will be saved work and can set upon them while they are already tired.+1
+1Let them undig the box first however, that way we will be saved work and can set upon them while they are already tired.+1
Also, you're right that Alice is probably going to be a little pissed at Leghorn for giving her to an enchanter as punishment. But, she does owe us her life twice over now, and is our best friend (I'm not counting our wife as a friend, in a way she's more than a friend, but in some ways she's less). We should be able to convince her to not kill Leghorn. Yet, at least.Alice is also our friend willingly.
Let them undig the box first however, that way we will be saved work and can set upon them while they are already tired.
Why are we even killing them?
It's not stupid evil. Doing horrible things to people and overcoming dangerous gives us Gifts and seems to make us a more powerful Night Troll in general. We're not killing them for the evulz, we're doing it because doing so gives us benefits that outweigh the risks.Um...
"Gift" perks can be gained by rolling very high, learning new skills, or through other supernatural means.Not mentioned is major plot events. Killing some kids is not learning a new skill, a supernatural means, or a major plot development. I see no other reason, aside from the claim that we should glut ourselves. Both reasons for your side have been refuted, yet you haven't even mentioned the dangers from angering the children's parents and communities. We're trying to NOT be the monsters that were genocided all those years ago, we're trying to turn over a new leaf. Killing kids for no good reason doesn't help that.
Ooh! i had an idea i'm fond of, we could convince them that they awoke a curse that is now centered on them, scare the living crap out of them. Let's make the night something to be feared again. We could use a combination of dark manipulation and the terror of our presence to accomplish this.
I actually think the curse thing might throw people off the scent for at least a time, because it has them on entirely the wrong train of thought.
I think we should eat the dead human (after looting him), with the elf still alive to hear every sickening crunch. Let the fear season the meat, then ask her what she knows about the chest and it's contents. Tell her that we won't kill her if she cooperates. If she cooperates then maybe gag and bind her with cloth from shredded clothes, sling her over our shoulder and bring her to our mate as a present. If she resists then (EDIT) eat her hand or something, and cauterize the wound with fire magic. Then repeat the request.
Then bring our mate to help us loot the chest?
Edit edit: don't forget to loot their stuff for anything of interest or value
Edit edit edit: Bloody... while we're grilling her (literally or figuratively), we may as well ask if she knows anything about Claira. Sorry, there's a lot to remember guys XD.
Guys. We are a night troll. We can't do our thing without pissing some people off. Doesn't really come off as a reason to me.Doesn't mean we need to go out of our way to do so. You may need to break a few eggs to make an omelette, but do you smash the rest of the dozen against the ceiling?
Also, should we capture her soul?I suggest no. We've scared her enough, and don't have a use for souls ATM. What if they figure out how to rebel or otherwise go "bad" after a while? Besides, it's a child. Child souls are probably less potent than adult souls for anything we want to do.
What? You never heard of Powered by a Forsaken Child (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoweredByAForsakenChild)?Ooh, it's like someone hitting you with your own sword! Ouch! That's gotta hurt, man!
Exactly my point... although we are compassionate for a night troll, we are a perversion of the night and thus should strike fear into the hearts of our enemies..Compassionate? We're evil. We're just not stupid.
Instead of killing the young girl, use dark manipulation to give her frightening visions, the long and repeating kind that causes insanity
Also for our new gift I propose we use it on the girl Vindel wantedOh, that's awesome. We should definitely do that. Something like set up a mock-wedding, and when he lifts the veil, BLAMMO! SHE'S HIDEOUS!
Its ironic because her loved her beauty
Also for our new gift I propose we use it on the girl Vindel wantedOh, that's awesome. We should definitely do that. Something like set up a mock-wedding, and when he lifts the veil, BLAMMO! SHE'S HIDEOUS!
Its ironic because her loved her beauty
He is, after all, a homicidal dickwad.
Let's get back to the tower. We really really want that artifact, so we should feed Gwen and then see if she'll have a look at the chest.
Yeah, not really sure why we would want to have a young, insane elven child as our servant. That doesn't sound helpful at all.Depends on the madness. But yeah, she's pretty far gone. And Gwen is probably going to be hungry...
And on a side note... TAKE THAT Greatwyrm, from the combo of great rolls and being scary to children, we got gift of HideousnessIt was due to luck, which we would have had no matter what we chose, and hideousness is the worst gift I've seen so far.
Not really. He can quote tropes all he likes, but without any sort of evidence it's meaningless. I haven't seen anything to suggest that child souls would be anything but younger, less mature souls.What? You never heard of Powered by a Forsaken Child (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoweredByAForsakenChild)?Ooh, it's like someone hitting you with your own sword! Ouch! That's gotta hurt, man!
Joke aside, I'm pretty sure we are here to be a typical night troll. That includes the typical DF mythology, but there are other myths with night trolls in them. I can't think of any of them being "nice." It's just not who we are, and we can't run from it. Doesn't mean we're an idiot, nor does it mean we should senselessly slaughter. We're a thinking evil, the worst kind you can ever fight. We're going to stack the deck, and our greatest asset really is fear. We don't feel it, but all the civs, immortal or not, do. And fear makes people do very stupid things.Yes, because we've taken every opportunity to slaughter innocents and be generally an ass.
Simply, a thinking enemy is the hardest to fight. That will be us. The small child pissing their beds at night will be the Elves. I don't imagine they would put up much of a fight.They can think, too. And they outnumber us, have more magic and weapons than us, and include some of the only people to have ever seen a night troll before. Don't piss the elves off without a good reason.
Since we've already attacked them, I'd advise either killing her or letting her go free, able to tell them about the horrible creature we are.Exactly my point... although we are compassionate for a night troll, we are a perversion of the night and thus should strike fear into the hearts of our enemies..Compassionate? We're evil. We're just not stupid.
Instead of killing the young girl, use dark manipulation to give her frightening visions, the long and repeating kind that causes insanity
But I do like your plan. Perhaps a mixture of dark manipulation and hypnosis could drive her mad.
We could use a mad elf in many ways:
Making her a subtle kind of mad, and really only break her deep down inside. Basically creating a fear-thrall.
Have her then either overthrow the government or the religion. They are capable of calming the populace and forming hunts after us. Of course, if Elves are a theocracy (I think I remember druids appointing queens, or vice-versa, but times have changed) then we could kill two birds with one stone.
We could use her as just a traveling spy, and get us some intel every once in a while.
We could use her to spread tales of fear. Have her claim to her "friends" that the being who cursed them cursed her with some kind of foresight. Maybe we could give her some kind of distinctive mark that way. We can have her pretend to predict the future, and throw them off and make them fear an enemy, just the wrong one. We can make her predictions come true from time to time using our magic, and using Leghorn's. He'll help us with this plan because he has something to gain as well: infamy. It's the reason he agreed to help us, so it makes sense he would go for it again. We'll just have her tell listeners about a great sorcerer. Hell, we can paint him as the good guy of this situation, and ourselves as the bad guy. Then the Elves will side with Leghorn, and through him, us. (This plan is actually my favorite.)
We could also break her completely, and make her completely mad. Then have her wander a bit and cause fear that way. It's kinda mindless evil though, I don't think it would do that much.
Or we could give her to our dear wife.
What do y'all think? Any of these good?
Not truly compassionate, just compassionate for a night troll,Meh. We're more compassionate than some people. Look at the contrasting treatments of Alice between us and Foghorn.
I'm more concerned about the enslaving for some reason. Maybe it's because death frees the soul or some philosophical BS like that.Also for our new gift I propose we use it on the girl Vindel wantedOh, that's awesome. We should definitely do that. Something like set up a mock-wedding, and when he lifts the veil, BLAMMO! SHE'S HIDEOUS!
Its ironic because her loved her beauty
He is, after all, a homicidal dickwad.
Despite my disagreement with him earlier, in large part i *do* agree with GreatWyrmGold about needless evil. We are the very last breeding member of our kind, and we still aren't heavily prepared for the machinations of a skilled enemy or civilization that fully discovers and declares war against us. We need to play smart. However we also need to stay strong and healthy, and i believe it's likely that the terror and flesh of sentient beings goes along way towards that. Think of it this way; the reason certain things are so tasty to humans is because at a fundamental level the tasty things we eat are some of the things that organisms require the most, even if those things become bad for us simply because of how god damn complicated our bodies are. Thinking about it this way, maybe there is a biological/magical reason that we enjoy fear and the flesh of sentient beings so much, if it's hard wired into us there could well be a reason for it. So while i espouse caution and *yes* even compassion at times, i do think we should get our recommended daily intake of pain and suffering.Thanks. I'm glad to know others sometimes think of me as the voice of reason.
My vote summed up: Bring Gwendolyn to look at the chest quickly, don't steal the soul of our prisoner or otherwise turn her into a psychotic liability, drop off useless crap, give the elf as a temporary plaything and meal to Gwendolyn if she gets the chest open.+1
Is the captured elf chick over 18? If so I think we should consider converting her, we have a few gifts. Can never have enough loyal consorts.18 is, like, 5 in elf years. Yes, she's over 18. No, she's probably not over elf!18.
Even if she wasn't, overall she isn't particularly special, we should still save our gifts for those who are.+1. Unless we somehow get a gift surplus.
Not really. He can quote tropes all he likes, but without any sort of evidence it's meaningless. I haven't seen anything to suggest that child souls would be anything but younger, less mature souls.What? You never heard of Powered by a Forsaken Child (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoweredByAForsakenChild)?Ooh, it's like someone hitting you with your own sword! Ouch! That's gotta hurt, man!
Well, it's all speculation. Let's assume child souls are exactly like adult souls until we hear from the GM, okay?It's my belief that the use of a child soul would greatly increase the potency of dark manipulation magic because of fear. Also There may or may not be a time limit on how long souls last. Child souls may well last longer.Not really. He can quote tropes all he likes, but without any sort of evidence it's meaningless. I haven't seen anything to suggest that child souls would be anything but younger, less mature souls.What? You never heard of Powered by a Forsaken Child (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PoweredByAForsakenChild)?Ooh, it's like someone hitting you with your own sword! Ouch! That's gotta hurt, man!
Women would be married of at the age of 11 in medieval times, usually to an older man
and i think most of us can agree that was creepy...Besides, that wasn't average behavior at the time. And elves would be like 50-60 before they're 11 in elf years. Probably. Of course, this math suggests that elven gestation period is four years, so take with a grain of salt.
For God's sake, do you guys not understand the concept of moving on? It involves not talking about gestation, in case you need a refresher. Now, what are we going to do next?Women would be married of at the age of 11 in medieval times, usually to an older manand i think most of us can agree that was creepy...Besides, that wasn't average behavior at the time. And elves would be like 50-60 before they're 11 in elf years. Probably. Of course, this math suggests that elven gestation period is four years, so take with a grain of salt.
...Want to preserve a decent post that got ninja'd.For God's sake, do you guys not understand the concept of moving on? It involves not talking about gestation, in case you need a refresher. Now, what are we going to do next?Women would be married of at the age of 11 in medieval times, usually to an older manand i think most of us can agree that was creepy...Besides, that wasn't average behavior at the time. And elves would be like 50-60 before they're 11 in elf years. Probably. Of course, this math suggests that elven gestation period is four years, so take with a grain of salt.
My vote summed up: Bring Gwendolyn to look at the chest quickly, don't steal the soul of our prisoner or otherwise turn her into a psychotic liability, drop off useless crap, give the elf as a temporary plaything and meal to Gwendolyn if she gets the chest open.
If we attack him i suggest we sneak up on him using our camouflage and darkness, telling Gwendolyn to attack from the opposite direction if he spots us or we attack.
If we we screw with him maybe we can use dark manipulation to summon terrifying visions of shadowy creatures. Then watch the little dwarf cry wee wee wee all the way home.
Not really much to be said about slinking off, it would just be... slinking off.
Hmm. Perhaps we could use eon manipulation on his crossbow, then leave the rest to Gwen so she can get some hunting experience?Like that. But I'd rather use fire magic on his crossbow, we need to train it after all
You spit in the girls face. "Nah. That is a good enough answer. Now onto question two. You are from Oakworshiped correct? What can you tell me about the noble Claira?"So she is old enough
The scared elf falls silent for a few seconds as she processes your question. "Umm... her? She is about my age,
Hmm. Perhaps we could use eon manipulation on his crossbow, then leave the rest to Gwen so she can get some hunting experience?Like that. But I'd rather use fire magic on his crossbow, we need to train it after all
______________
Edit: BTW, IMO we should convert the captured girl, even if she is not a special mate one more wife is good enough... and hideous gift isn't good enough to spent it on someone worthy. As for her age:QuoteYou spit in the girls face. "Nah. That is a good enough answer. Now onto question two. You are from Oakworshiped correct? What can you tell me about the noble Claira?"So she is old enough
The scared elf falls silent for a few seconds as she processes your question. "Umm... her? She is about my age,
Replace "sadistic" with "vengeful" and I agree.Nah, we should save the hideous gift for the more sadistic princess conversion. That girl doesn't have any useful skills, she's better as a snack.Hmm. Perhaps we could use eon manipulation on his crossbow, then leave the rest to Gwen so she can get some hunting experience?Like that. But I'd rather use fire magic on his crossbow, we need to train it after all
______________
Edit: BTW, IMO we should convert the captured girl, even if she is not a special mate one more wife is good enough... and hideous gift isn't good enough to spent it on someone worthy. As for her age:QuoteYou spit in the girls face. "Nah. That is a good enough answer. Now onto question two. You are from Oakworshiped correct? What can you tell me about the noble Claira?"So she is old enough
The scared elf falls silent for a few seconds as she processes your question. "Umm... her? She is about my age,
And yeah, let's do some weird time shit to his crossbow.
vengfully sadistic/sadistically vengfulReplace "sadistic" with "vengeful" and I agree.Nah, we should save the hideous gift for the more sadistic princess conversion. That girl doesn't have any useful skills, she's better as a snack.Hmm. Perhaps we could use eon manipulation on his crossbow, then leave the rest to Gwen so she can get some hunting experience?Like that. But I'd rather use fire magic on his crossbow, we need to train it after all
______________
Edit: BTW, IMO we should convert the captured girl, even if she is not a special mate one more wife is good enough... and hideous gift isn't good enough to spent it on someone worthy. As for her age:QuoteYou spit in the girls face. "Nah. That is a good enough answer. Now onto question two. You are from Oakworshiped correct? What can you tell me about the noble Claira?"So she is old enough
The scared elf falls silent for a few seconds as she processes your question. "Umm... her? She is about my age,
And yeah, let's do some weird time shit to his crossbow.
IMO, having a noble as a puppet is much more important than revengeHow could we make the elf a puppet? Ideas abound for more mischief we could do if we didn't convert her, but enchanted her somehow...
How could we make the elf a puppet? Ideas abound for more mischief we could do if we didn't convert her, but enchanted her somehow...One of our other Gifts is one that mind controls the person we give it to. So instead of making the princess hideous, we do that to her.
Wait, isn't that what we hate Vindel for doing to us?Vindel, an elf, enslaving us, a Night Troll, is unacceptable because it reverses the natural order of Night Trolls being superior to elves.
Don't all Gifts have a certain element of physical change involved with them?How could we make the elf a puppet? Ideas abound for more mischief we could do if we didn't convert her, but enchanted her somehow...One of our other Gifts is one that mind controls the person we give it to. So instead of making the princess hideous, we do that to her.
That's Nazi logic there. Let's not go Magneto and plunge straight into the territory of what our enemies did...QuoteWait, isn't that what we hate Vindel for doing to us?Vindel, an elf, enslaving us, a Night Troll, is unacceptable because it reverses the natural order of Night Trolls being superior to elves.
Clairia is (in addition to someone with a name that people constantly misspell) is an excellent choice to become a troll wife. She's the High Queen's neice on one side and a demigoddess on the other.Agreed, unless we can mind-control her in some way that let's her keep her appearance.
I was kinda hoping that we could eventually figure out a potion or a spell or something that would let her disguise herself as her pre-transformation self.Let's do that before converting her, m'kay?
If we practice messing with peoples' mindsLet's not bet on it...
We could mind control the princess fairly easily
Agreed. What shall we enchant with his soul? A waste disposal unit, maybe?Yes. Let's make a magical shitter with his soul.
Hmm. Perhaps we could use eon manipulation on his crossbow, then leave the rest to Gwen so she can get some hunting experience?
That... that sucks. First thing we should do is express regret and concern, tell her that her kidney may be hurt and offer her the chance to go back to the tower and rest.+1
If she still leaves it up to us... what do we do? Go on?
That... that sucks. First thing we should do is express regret and concern, tell her that her kidney may be hurt and offer her the chance to go back to the tower and rest.
If she still leaves it up to us... what do we do? Go on?
Go off--not too far--and find something nice for Gwen.
To be more specific, let's try to learn the power of our new bracelet and have a friendly chat with trees, maybe ask for advice or two from a wife if that will not distract her too much from the chest.This.
Sure, I guess.To be more specific, let's try to learn the power of our new bracelet and have a friendly chat with trees, maybe ask for advice or two from a wife if that will not distract her too much from the chest.This.
To be more specific, let's try to learn the power of our new bracelet and have a friendly chat with trees, maybe ask for advice or two from a wife if that will not distract her too much from the chestYeah we should do that. Also, ask if she could teach us some sort of navigational skill when she's done?
The ancient elf, Goldtubers Timelesssmile ditched his wife Gwendo-something and has taken up lodging at the Inn at Oakworshipped. He is preaching that a night beast, called Pastforsaken, will soon rise to punish Oakworshipped for abandoning the old ways.-Did... someone give us a name?
This is pretty sketchy guys, i get the feeling unicorns are pretty tough.Well, yeah. We all know what regular horses can do. Slap a horn on those bitches and you're in trouble.
Drop anything we can and isn't the shield, then eon manipulate the male's legs away like lituem suggested.
This is pretty sketchy guys, i get the feeling unicorns are pretty tough.Well, yeah. We all know what regular horses can do. Slap a horn on those bitches and you're in trouble.
Tell gwen to displace as far forward as possible, drop the maces if we can do that quickly, and jump up into a tree. THEN attempt to hack horses apart with eon magic.
Problem: Most of the weight is those ingots. They could weigh us down...Tell gwen to displace as far forward as possible, drop the maces if we can do that quickly, and jump up into a tree. THEN attempt to hack horses apart with eon magic.Best option considering the limited time.
Yeah, we'd have to strip to get rid of that weight. And stripping is hard to do when your pockets are loaded with platinum.Problem: Most of the weight is those ingots. They could weigh us down...Tell gwen to displace as far forward as possible, drop the maces if we can do that quickly, and jump up into a tree. THEN attempt to hack horses apart with eon magic.Best option considering the limited time.
Yeah, overburdening ourself was a bad idea, it destroyed our stealth, mobility, and probably our ability to fight in physical combat.Could we send our clothes forward into the future?
Could we send our clothes forward into the future?...
She might not be overburdened but we sure are, and we're arguably the more powerful one, i don't believe Gwendolyn can survive on her own. If we could somehow unburden ourself enough to enable jumping i would suggest retreat.Key word being if.
I do not believe our gm is going to apply the more stupidly unrealistic portions of DF."Stupidly unrealistic"?
I think the same thing may apply to using it as a flail.
Anyways as was pointed out displacing the dirt as time-mines to entomb the unicorns legs seems like the safer option to attempt to circumvent any magical protection, however it seems like they could just evade the holes in the dirt?
I'm not really clear on what would work at this point. Can we get a post from the OP on all of this?
I think the same thing may apply to using it as a flail.
Anyways as was pointed out displacing the dirt as time-mines to entomb the unicorns legs seems like the safer option to attempt to circumvent any magical protection, however it seems like they could just evade the holes in the dirt?
I'm not really clear on what would work at this point. Can we get a post from the OP on all of this?
Any ONE of those rolls can still kill us though. So yes, it still leads to a higher chance of us ending up dead.What rolls are that dangerous? even failed dodge roll shouldn't be as bad as no dodging at all due to time displacement. I am sure that it's hard to get us killed by one bad combat roll
Also, any combat related rolls that arn't magic that we make are subject to some penalties. One from being over encumbered, another for being unskilled.I know. That's why that situation is bad. But we have an ally, an artifact spear and magic.
While flinging ourselves forward in time would have a whole bunch of bonus's, including our Eon manipulation (one of our two greatest skills) our tattoos and our greater skill at using magic to fling things forward in time.I know, +6 to the roll... even if get no penalties then we still need 5 or better to get result above ten... that's 20% chance of almost certain death... even 5(11) and 6(12) may be not enough
Have you ever heard of "getting enormous stab wounds in your torso tends to be lethal, you video-game-expecting fool?" Internal bleeding, organ damage, external bleeding...unicorn horns are think and long. It's not gonna be pretty.QuoteAny ONE of those rolls can still kill us though. So yes, it still leads to a higher chance of us ending up dead.What rolls are that dangerous? even failed dodge roll shouldn't be as bad as no dodging at all due to time displacement. I am sure that it's hard to get us killed by one bad combat roll
We have only an ally with a freaking wooden sword, an artifact spear we don't know what it does (and it's made of gem--not exactly cutting-edge weapons tech), and magic which doesn't include any defensive magic.QuoteAlso, any combat related rolls that arn't magic that we make are subject to some penalties. One from being over encumbered, another for being unskilled.I know. That's why that situation is bad. But we have an ally, an artifact spear and magic.
I still don't understand why at character generation players chose night creature empathy to some combat skill, it was an awful decision
You're assuming failure means death. Heck, you're assuming a low success equals death! I'm guessing failure will either mean we don't displace ourself or we don't displace ourself as much as we intend, not that we die or go all frozen.QuoteWhile flinging ourselves forward in time would have a whole bunch of bonus's, including our Eon manipulation (one of our two greatest skills) our tattoos and our greater skill at using magic to fling things forward in time.I know, +6 to the roll... even if get no penalties then we still need 5 or better to get result above ten... that's 20% chance of almost certain death... even 5(11) and 6(12) may be not enough
Have you ever heard of "getting enormous stab wounds in your torso tends to be lethal, you video-game-expecting fool?"Pfff. That's why I don't want to stay defenseless while hoping that time jump will work
You're assuming failure means death. Heck, you're assuming a low success equals death! I'm guessing failure will either mean we don't displace ourself or we don't displace ourself as much as we intend, not that we die or go all frozen.Yes, I assume that standing still and doing nothing will get us killed, of cause we may dodge and so on, but that means multitasking penalty
I vote displace ourself and run.What? Running from a spearheaded charging horse that is 100ft away isn't a good idea... It's worse than meeting it with spear, it's worse then jumping aside in the last moment, it's worse than falling to the ground and letting it to trample, hell it's worse than trying to jump on it's back or using animal empathy to calm down\scare it away. Running by foot is a plain suicide
having a bloody massive amount of loot on us negatively affects our already low bonuses in that field.We are somewhat encumbered not bloody encumbered
what exactly do you think will go wrong again?You want a list? We may get stunned by our own magic, we may damage ourself, we may jump to close and still be a target without a chance to dodge, we may jump tgether with charging unicorn, we may jump into some bad future, we may lose Gwen permanently and many other bad ways how GM can interpret bad rolls
and the one time our eon magic has failed us so far was when we were trying to displace a crossbownope, we had one more failure when we tried to preserve parts of elven corpse and made all his corpse to rot immediately. Also we had huge trouble after one successful jump.
When it comes to displacing the dirt I think it is in fact a good concern that the unicorns would just be able to jump over the displaced dirt and possibly disrupt the magic with their own power to protect themselves.It's quite possible. We may roll bad or they may roll good, or both. But in that case we'll still have chances... If they'll, jump that will disrupt their attack anywayThat we'll get lucky with the spear, that Gwen get lucky with her rolls, that unicorns get unlucky with their attack rolls. But failed jumping attempt may not leave us such chances, because we'll become a siting duck
t's quite possible. We may roll bad or they may roll good, or both. But in that case we'll still have chances... If they'll, jump that will disrupt their attack anywayThat we'll get lucky with the spear, that Gwen get lucky with her rolls, that unicorns get unlucky with their attack rolls. But failed jumping attempt may not leave us such chances, because we'll become a siting duck
the voting was a little messy, but that's ancient history right now, no use crying over spilled milk.Nah, I'm not crying yet.
the voting was a little messy, but that's ancient history right now, no use crying over spilled milk.Nah, I'm not crying yet.
I'm waiting to get mauled by the pony first.
If we get wounded here, it's basically game over. Any wound will make something that's already very difficult even harder for us.Disagree, only bad wound is close to game over. If we survive the first attack we may have more time to act further -1 or -2 penalty is not death
if we get hurt by charging unicorns and/or they dispatch Gwen our chances of success go from not very good to absolutely awful.I never proposed to fight with arms, of cause we use magic
If we fight we *need* Gwen to roll good, we *need* to roll good and then we need to hope that all of the unicorns roll worse than we do. If one thing goes wrong, we are at an even greater disadvantage than we already are.1) We don't need all rolls to be good to win the fight. All good rolls = win without injuries, It's indeed unlikely
Right now, us sitting here being able to do little more than walk around, we already are a sitting duck.bullshit, somewhat encumbered is not equal to immobile
Allow me to demonstrate with a simple dodge roll, something that would become inevitable in a confrontation.Again on one said that we'll fight with weapons only
1d20 -3 (untrained in combat) -2 (somewhat encumbered) vs 1d20 + (maybe four? let's be realistic guys, there's gonna be a bonus here)
With our plus 6 bonus the lowest we can roll except for insta-fail is an 8.1) When we rolled 10 on sending head in future it was microseconds
We have bonuses to magic, and no bonuses to combat.Communication is a nice skill and helped us few times... Darkness manipulation and night creature empathy not so.
Remember who wanted to get those combat bonuses?
Me. What did we get? A nice voice. I had a feeling this would happen.
No. A failed magic roll is not going to result in insta-death. Not even a 1. Neither will a bad combat roll. That would be incredibly stupid.Realistically speaking pierced heart or brain = death. So it's not stupid at all. Also, note that all combats we had were very short.
So yes, running is the safest thing we could do.And still I disagree. It may be safest on average, because majority of time we will be in safety, but I am sure that it has the highest chance of death
But would it be as beneficial? Honestly, no. We could gain some experience fighting these things, so we'll be better off next time we fight one, and maybe next time we wouldn't have Gwen with us. We're also going to gain some 'corn parts, which we can probably use for something, and if not then Leghorn and Alice can. We aren't injured, and Gwen isn't too hurt. And maybe Gwen knows of some weakness of theirs?
a few things: an offensive spell that kills 2 unicorns will probably need a better roll than a tree-jump.
gwen has her gift of displacement, she can escape easily.
unicorns are both territorial and probably semi-intelligent. if we both jump forward we may have a scenario like this http://xkcd.com/989/ (http://xkcd.com/989/), except with an angry herd of unicorns.
I would stop the back and forth &p let the GM sort out the votes....
Let's play the game of Derail: where you must try to change the subject, and make it as awkward as possible.
We REALLY need a navigational skill. Even if its as simple as using the sun and stars. Also, what have we dropped?
Just because you can jump/are magic doesn't mean you can pull your feet/hooves out of 3-4 ft of solid EARTHRequires good timing--displace the dirt far enough that the unicorn falls in, not far enough that it can hop out before the dirt comes back.
Also give Gwen saber? and allow her to displace/blink on top of charging unicorn and kill it!What? "Here, honey, catch! Hopefully it's not too different than all the swords you've ever practiced with!"
We've jumped through time before, Ranger. We can do it again. We know we can do it.QuoteHave you ever heard of "getting enormous stab wounds in your torso tends to be lethal, you video-game-expecting fool?"Pfff. That's why I don't want to stay defenseless while hoping that time jump will work
We can jump forward in time without existing, and fail without being frozen, and you know what? Success means we'd be catapulted into the future, not that we'd get frozen.QuoteYou're assuming failure means death. Heck, you're assuming a low success equals death! I'm guessing failure will either mean we don't displace ourself or we don't displace ourself as much as we intend, not that we die or go all frozen.Yes, I assume that standing still and doing nothing will get us killed, of cause we may dodge and so on, but that means multitasking penalty
Minor success should be better than death but will not save us from danger1. Why not? The unicorns would probably move on after we aren't around, threatening their foal and all.
Those unicorns needs seconds to get to us. We can't attempt spell and then do something else. Also. we are casting powerful spell at ourself, failure may have other consequences expect nothing
Run after we displace...why did I type "and run"? I meant something like "displace TO run," I think.QuoteI vote displace ourself and run.What? Running from a spearheaded charging horse that is 100ft away isn't a good idea... It's worse than meeting it with spear, it's worse then jumping aside in the last moment, it's worse than falling to the ground and letting it to trample, hell it's worse than trying to jump on it's back or using animal empathy to calm down\scare it away. Running by foot is a plain suicide
____________________Well, what can we gain by fighting? Unicorn horns on the off chance that we beat two superior opponents, honor no matter what. On the other hand, severe injuries are all but certain if we fight and death is probable. On the other hand, running has a MUCH lower chance of death, and while we might lose "honor," we'd gain points from anyone looking at how we avoid getting ourself killed.
Edit: if we jump away and Gwen will not... she may either get killed or severely injured and pissed at us. In fact she may view as a coward even if she escapes too.
All that this jump may do - reduce loses, we can't gain anything (expect gift of cowardice :D ) Even rolling 20 will likely do nothing exceptionally good.
javierpwnHuge? That's like a huge failure, and we have about a +6 to eon manipulation. On a d20. When success is at least a 10. Yes, the 15% chance of any kind of failure gives us a huge chance of dying.
They are charging at us NOW, there are no time for giving saber, chatting and doing anything else, we are limited to few actions... I'd prefer to stay with spear and do dirt displacement, but that "jump away with huge risk of death and gain nothing in the best case scenario" is winning
We have bonuses to magic, and no bonuses to combat.Yeah, yeah. Why do you think we're not trying to fight?
Remember who wanted to get those combat bonuses?
Me. What did we get? A nice voice. I had a feeling this would happen.
Why the hell would we displace it?Because it's cooler. No other possible reason.
Whatever we leave behind (I suggest most of the maces), we should hide under some soil or rock or log or something, and figure out some way to mark it recognizeably.
Support to double hidden.
We do sort of have a navigation ability as long as we have access to trees, just for some reason we havn't been using it.
Mature: You are physically and mentally capable of converting and impregnating mates. To do so you must spend a "Gift" perk. "Gift" perks can be gained by rolling very high, learning new skills, or through other supernatural means. If you create a child it may be born with some traits of it's mother in addition to whatever gift you use to conceive it.
First Gift: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will have your four physical features. Gifts that grant more than two traits are rare, so this may be worth saving for somebody special.
Gift of Puppetry: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will be bound to follow your commands for as long as you both live. You will be made aware of any major changes to your puppet's health or location.
Gift of Hideousness: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will appear so unatural and ugly that it will almost always elicit a powerful emotional response (typically fear, disgust, or anger) in any mortal who lays eyes on it.
Improving Eon Mage: Your Eon magic skill will increase if you succeed in 2 successful Eon Manipulation actionsin the stats... I am quite sure that it was 2 right from the update when we killed an elf
Converting Alice serves what purpose? None.trained mage boosted by a suitable gift = useless, really?
Guys, do you see any difference in talking about converting and converting? We don't even have a suitable gift for her ATM. But learning about the options is important. As well as removing Alice's fearYeah, but a diplomat is much more useful. We got insanely lucky running into a sympathetic human when we first got here. We are not going to get so lucky again.
As for the whole spy\trader thing. It may be useful some times but I really prefer a strong trained mage to that as well as mother with wizard genes. Humans are way too fragile and prone to accidental deaths from consorts\sons\other night creature allies and enemiesQuoteConverting Alice serves what purpose? None.trained mage boosted by a suitable gift = useless, really?
Ah...why is that?QuoteMature: You are physically and mentally capable of converting and impregnating mates. To do so you must spend a "Gift" perk. "Gift" perks can be gained by rolling very high, learning new skills, or through other supernatural means. If you create a child it may be born with some traits of it's mother in addition to whatever gift you use to conceive it.
First Gift: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will have your four physical features. Gifts that grant more than two traits are rare, so this may be worth saving for somebody special.
Gift of Puppetry: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will be bound to follow your commands for as long as you both live. You will be made aware of any major changes to your puppet's health or location.
Gift of Hideousness: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will appear so unatural and ugly that it will almost always elicit a powerful emotional response (typically fear, disgust, or anger) in any mortal who lays eyes on it.
Guys, do you see any difference in talking about converting and converting? We don't even have a suitable gift for her ATM. But learning about the options is important. As well as removing Alice's fearI think that Alice won't get any "training" in wizardry from being a night consort, we're not a lot tougher, and how do you suggest we get anything safely that we can't get from the forest if we don't have a human who trusts us? We will need weapons and such eventually. Besides, A. it also gives us a better rep if we don't convert every woman we run across and B. converting Alice means one less kid. Night troll wizard<Wizard+Night Troll, potential wizard.
As for the whole spy\trader thing. It may be useful some times but I really prefer a strong trained mage to that as well as mother with wizard genes. Humans are way too fragile and prone to accidental deaths from consorts\sons\other night creature allies and enemies
We already have one of those. What we don't have is someone to chat with humans and such. While the gifts could enhance her, see how we're mostly having Gwen use her pre-conversion talents? The Gifts mostly don't help much.QuoteConverting Alice serves what purpose? None.trained mage boosted by a suitable gift = useless, really?
we're not a lot tougher,We are quite tough comparing to regular human. And that's highly depends on gift
and how do you suggest we get anything safely that we can't get from the forest if we don't have a human who trusts us?Well, I don't like the whole safely part, I prefer combat and building an army to negotiating\trading with prey
While the gifts could enhance her, see how we're mostly having Gwen use her pre-conversion talents?Gift was quite minor and not compatible with her skills
If we bleed, we can be killed. Our biggest advantage over puny mortals is that we don't feel pain.Quotewe're not a lot tougher,We are quite tough comparing to regular human. And that's highly depends on gift
And how do we feed and equip that army? Or get nice things like not eviscerated when we decide we want one of the myriad things we would need or want from town?Quoteand how do you suggest we get anything safely that we can't get from the forest if we don't have a human who trusts us?Well, I don't like the whole safely part, I prefer combat and building an army to negotiating\trading with prey
and counter question - what do you need in town that Alice can help us right now? What do we need in towns that we can't get otherwise?Um, nice healing potion or something?
Um, couldn't we give the gift to someone who isn't so useful without conversion? Say, an elf?QuoteWhile the gifts could enhance her, see how we're mostly having Gwen use her pre-conversion talents?Gift was quite minor and not compatible with her skills
Now imagine boosting Alice with something like animal empathy gift. Hello animal army.
I repeat right now we have no gift that will make Alice better ally, but that may changeAgain, Alice has much utility that would be lost if we converted her.
And how do we feed and equip that army?1) Looting
Um, couldn't we give the gift to someone who isn't so useful without conversion? Say, an elf?It was an example.
Almost any elf? Well, almost any elf without Y chromosomes, of course.
Again, Alice has much utility that would be lost if we converted her.
Dude, never underestimate diplomacy.I do not underestimate diplomacy, but I prefer to not negotiate with prey. It's disgusting
1) Could work, but nowhere near reliable, and impossible if we are besieging a fortification.QuoteAnd how do we feed and equip that army?1) Looting
2) there are many ways to trade outside towns, from black markets to night creature traders
3) don't freeing one ghost and force it to make weapons
Um, couldn't we give the gift to someone who isn't so useful without conversion? Say, an elf?
Almost any elf? Well, almost any elf without Y chromosomes, of course.
It was an example.Her magic is not going to be automatically boosted, and it's good enough as it is.
And you really think that daughter of a wizard = almost any elf?
Whoah, no biased phrases here. Seriously though, that's pretty rude. I don't patronize you. Not on purpose, at least. If I have, I'm honestly very sorry.QuoteAgain, Alice has much utility that would be lost if we converted her.
Pfff...
Just a short list:
Advantages of Alice staying human ( as you call that - utility)
1) We may send her in towns for trading ( forest girl is surely a magnificent trader)
2) She may spy ( We have no other options, like a guy with camouflaged body and stealth skill and or a girl that can send animal spies )
Advantages of Alice becoming a night troll1) I don't think there are very many lesbian chicks just wandering around. And she is loyal to us, she is willing to be converted. And conversion won't actually make her any more loyal. And I don't think she will find a lover, because again, I'm assuming lesbian love is not permitted in this realm.
1) She will be more loyal ( I don't want to see her falling deeply in love with some chick and leaving us)
2) She will be stronger
3) She will be tougher
4) Foghorn will lose chance to take her back and marry to someone else (except he finds a husband for a night troll)
5) She will piss Gwen way way less
6) We'll get a powerful father in law
Will you keep saying that converting Alice achieves nothing?
-Healing Magic (example, potions)There are other sources of that and we have unusual biology I'd not risk drinking potions designed for humans
-Even the most mundane information and gossip (which we do not have access to otherwise)Animal spies
-More specifically, information about potential allies and enemies
-A stable, regular, and safe food source as an alternative to eggs. These eggs might not always be enough to feed us and our servants.We need fear, not only regular food, so safe food isn't really an option... And isn't Alice know how to hunt for meat?
-Mundane goods and services, everything from labor if we want to build something to leather for straps if we want to be able to more efficiently strap stuff to ourself.Something that we can survive without
1. Good luck. They're an army, we're not.QuoteAnd how do we feed and equip that army?1) Looting
2) there are many ways to trade outside towns, from black markets to night creature traders
3) don't freeing one ghost and force it to make weapons
For what purpose? For natural magic, probably. However, Alice+Elf>Alice. Simple math.QuoteUm, couldn't we give the gift to someone who isn't so useful without conversion? Say, an elf?It was an example.
Almost any elf? Well, almost any elf without Y chromosomes, of course.
And you really think that daughter of a wizard = almost any elf?
Well, let's look over those purported advantages...QuoteAgain, Alice has much utility that would be lost if we converted her.
Pfff...
Just a short list:
Advantages of Alice staying human ( as you call that - utility)
1) We may send her in towns for trading ( forest girl is surely a magnificent trader)
2) She may spy ( We have no other options, like a guy with camouflaged body and stealth skill and or a girl that can send animal spies )
Advantages of Alice becoming a night troll
1) She will be more loyal ( I don't want to see her falling deeply in love with some chick and leaving us)
2) She will be stronger
3) She will be tougher
4) Foghorn will lose chance to take her back and marry to someone else (except he finds a husband for a night troll)
5) She will piss Gwen way way less
6) We'll get a powerful fat]
her in law
Will you keep saying that converting Alice achieves nothing?I have never said that.
They're not prey, and even if they were, it's better to negotiate with them than to not have everything we need, neh?QuoteDude, never underestimate diplomacy.I do not underestimate diplomacy, but I prefer to not negotiate with prey. It's disgusting
Vote to not convert Alice now, and to ask Illuem what he needs for his artifact.+1, more magic is always good. Maybe ask what his smithing specialty was in life.
Well yelling at them probably isn't the best way to do anything more than temporarily get things moving.It does, however, make sure that we can delay things getting worse until we get better. Besides, they both laughed, which will reduce tension in the short term at least.
Its not like screaming "FOOLISH FOOLS DO MY WILL" will be a profound turning point in how they view eachother.
Lets just test out what bonus the spear gives to earth manipulation eh?What tests do you suggest?
Spend some time with Alice chatting and sharing magical knowledge. She tells us about empathies and we give hints about darkness manipulation and eon magic.
What people wanted to do in the first place, displace some dirt or something similar. Nothing too big though, don't want to try to move one stone in the tower and accidentally collapse the entire thing on top of us.
Had pretty much already guessed that.True. She's a furry then? That's what you call it when it's anthropomorphic animals, right?
Also, i don't think it counts as bestiality, that would imply a lack of intelligent thought.
I think we should take our continued need for rest as an oppurtunity to train some of our skills.
I don't doubt that even 9-3=6 may end badly for our health. I suspect that GM has some hidden tables with nasty stuff
Edited my suggestion, BTW. Chat with lovebirds may bring even more problems
Uk, you can't live your virtual life in fear of a one.I am not afraid of risks (Damn, I always said that you guys are too risk averse) , but there are no need to risk when benefits are minor but if other players insist
I prefer URAlright, I'll do my best to call you UR. I dunno why I keep thinking you're UK. The syllables or something.
I don't doubt that even 9-3=6 may end badly for our health. I suspect that GM has some hidden tables with nasty stuffWell, GM just said he has no tables, and 4-3 ended well enough...
I think that if we wanted to send even messages through time that far we might have to get our virgin sacrifice on.Well, let's go find us a gaggle of virgins.
Let's stick to sending a message five minutes or so back in time.Well yeah, start small. I just think sending messages back would be very useful.
Say, have Alice hide something (a stick, a book, herself) somewhere in the tower, listen, follow our directions, and send a message back in time about how we found the item hidden.
If this works, we can figure out how to cheat time afterwards.
Probably.Let's stick to sending a message five minutes or so back in time.Well yeah, start small. I just think sending messages back would be very useful.
Say, have Alice hide something (a stick, a book, herself) somewhere in the tower, listen, follow our directions, and send a message back in time about how we found the item hidden.
If this works, we can figure out how to cheat time afterwards.
Or turn a part of our body in something nasty... Let's not play with powerful artifact that we know nothing about, we have been warned. I support droping rubies\platinium and sand in furnace as likely artifact ingredientsI suggest to visit lovebirds and start a pack animal (pack bird? ) lovebird training.
Nope, if make them mad due to failed roll that's awful while we can't defend ourself
Plant empathy, then? Are there are any old tree near the tower? We may talk with it and try learn secrets of the tower
If gwen has a child, she will lose her compulsive loyalty to us, so lets wait until we convert someone else. Also, the lock-box. What happened to it? as far as I can tell It's still on the roof, but I probably missed something.What? Why would this be the case?
If gwen has a child, she will lose her compulsive loyalty to us, so lets wait until we convert someone else. Also, the lock-box. What happened to it? as far as I can tell It's still on the roof, but I probably missed something.That's a reason why we should be friendly and nice with Gwen. Besides it will not happen immediately after the birth
What? Why would this be the case?You guys miss too much important info... Because GM said so. We'll lose that instinctive loyalty after her first child will be old enough
Drifting back you recall your fathers brief lesson on the ins and outs of conversion he gave you before sending you to the present.
"Get her in a position where she can't fight back, make contact with her, and let your instincts take over. It could take awhile; so do it somewhere secluded and bring a few meals. Once you are done she will be instinctively loyal to you and your family until her first son is weaned. If you wish her to stay longer than that make them feel important like I make your aunts feel, or dependent on you like your useless mother."
Thanks.QuoteDrifting back you recall your fathers brief lesson on the ins and outs of conversion he gave you before sending you to the present.
"Get her in a position where she can't fight back, make contact with her, and let your instincts take over. It could take awhile; so do it somewhere secluded and bring a few meals. Once you are done she will be instinctively loyal to you and your family until her first son is weaned. If you wish her to stay longer than that make them feel important like I make your aunts feel, or dependent on you like your useless mother."
And we should do something to gain animal empathy, training lovebird as a pet is still a viable idea... It's a pity that we lost cubs... or did we?
We should ask Alice about them
Well, we may tell Alice about the Gift of Puppetry and it's effects.
I think we can use a puppet consort to impregnate her with utility, not very useful gifts, some of the resulted sons may be puppets too.
Intentional double post to bump it with a suggestion
________________
Shouldn't we check the information about the flowers? If we find flowers, then ambush (together with Alice) is required. It's not like we can't cast due to broken. May read the alchemy book and\or fire book while waiting for ambush. Luckily we can read at night
Yes. Our first child should really have that first gift, after all, and we can depend on Gwen to nuture it until it is weaned.Third time I've +1'd this
It will but I don't like that storywise, I want to see our night troll more noble than thatA noble night creature? You do realize we're basically rapists?
And having an army is only one of the possible story direction, making babies and sending wifes with their sons all over the world is another
Prisoner... is interesting should interrogate first, then we may decide what to do
Healing. I'd enchant the steel buckler, because wearing it is useful. And no to enchanting our body... 1) we barely tolerate usage of souls on items and one time usage is even worse than making useful items 2) failed roll on item may destroy that item, failed roll on our body....
But let's return to the more urgent situation. We have our beloved wife that showed herself as a competent hunter (should congratulate her) , she is in a right mood and our instincts kicking in... I am sure that it's time to spend a gift. The first gift to be precise. Probably we may find a better target for the first gift but our mutual feelings with Gwen is more important... We should gift her the GIFT
Maybe we should attempt to enchant something that does not require us to constantly keep one hand occupied? A necklace perhaps?Maybe something hard to notice, like a piercing?
Necklace sounds good.
"He's dead; you wanted him dead. Why bother killing Foghorn's family and angering the fell creatures allied with them?" Crack knuckles or something to subtley indicate that we are such a creature.
"He's dead; you wanted him dead. Why bother killing Foghorn's family and angering the fell creatures allied with them?" Crack knuckles or something to subtley indicate that we are such a creature.Perhaps tell her we killed Phyros? But otherwise, +1.
"He's dead; you wanted him dead. Why bother killing Foghorn's family and angering the fell creatures allied with them?" Crack knuckles or something to subtley indicate that we are such a creature.
I see one little problem. Can we be sure that we can trust the mermaid? What if she'll force us to say some prayer that is bad for us?
Yay, Amazon Brigade...This.
Anyways, I suggest we say something like, "I'm sorry, but I do not know the prayer. My father was not religious, so I had no way of learning any of the rituals of Nocteclaw. I would, however, very much like to learn. Could you teach me?"
Agreed.Yay, Amazon Brigade...This.
Anyways, I suggest we say something like, "I'm sorry, but I do not know the prayer. My father was not religious, so I had no way of learning any of the rituals of Nocteclaw. I would, however, very much like to learn. Could you teach me?"
Her family will be trying to kill Foghorn and his family.I see one little problem. Can we be sure that we can trust the mermaid? What if she'll force us to say some prayer that is bad for us?I'll go one further.
Can we trust anything she just said is true?
DO NOT RELEASE HER.
Ask our good old friend if he wants to "question" a mermaid that told us her family will be trying to kill his.
Isn't that reason to convert Alice? She would be harder to kill and they should be more reluctant to kill a night trollOn the other hand, they would want to kill US. And it's debatable how much being a night troll really helps in combat. No pain, sure, but that's as much a curse as a boon...
Or we could ally the mermaid and, with her help, convince the other merfolk to not kill Foghorn.Mermaid said that this is impossible. If you hope that our communication skill is that good. Good luck
It might still be a good idea to send Alice to warn him later, though.Alice have magic mirror to contact with her father any moment she want. And likely she will do no matter if we ask her or not. We may try to force her not too, but that's a way to ruin our friendship
Your communication skill went up! I'm in a rush and will figure out what that means for your perks and skills when I get back home![/b]
Well, with out communication skills not ideal, I'd advise more...unsubtle methods of persuasion. Make sure they understand that Foghorn has powerful allies, imply that we're terrified of some of them, use the same logic as we did on our captured mermaid, and flee if it turns bad. What do we have to lose? Worst-case scenario, we timeshift out before they hurt us too much. Maybe listen to ourselves if we send a note to ourselves warning against talking with them and send a note back if it turns nasty...QuoteOr we could ally the mermaid and, with her help, convince the other merfolk to not kill Foghorn.Mermaid said that this is impossible. If you hope that our communication skill is that good. Good luck
So remind her to contact him.QuoteIt might still be a good idea to send Alice to warn him later, though.Alice have magic mirror to contact with her father any moment she want. And likely she will do no matter if we ask her or not. We may try to force her not too, but that's a way to ruin our friendship
Eh... not really much of a choice. I'd much rather have foghorn and alice behind me than some random mermaids. Besides, we don't know if we can convince the other merfolk to help us.I'd rather try for both.
Quote from: Weirdsound link=topic=118808.msg3861839#msg3861839 [bYour communication skill went up! I'm in a rush and will figure out what that means for your perks and skills when I get back home![/b]
And GM... let me remind that :)
I would not be against starting an underwater Night Troll race by converting the mermaid and impregnating her, then shipping her and the kid off to the water eventually.+1
I just don't know the logistics of it... Maybe a swimming pool in the tower to keep the water-borne Night Troll and consort that result from that wet until we can be sure they'll survive in the oceans?
Yay, Amazon Brigade...
Anyways, I suggest we say something like, "I'm sorry, but I do not know the prayer. My father was not religious, so I had no way of learning any of the rituals of Nocteclaw. I would, however, very much like to learn. Could you teach me?"
Voting that we continue working on Animal Empathy, Plant Empathy and Fire Manipulation while we rest. We should also learn some more about Nocteclaw.Agree with all, should also learn A NAVIGATIONAL SKILL!
But before we time-skip we should go get the lockbox.talking about lockboxes -
Dang. I'm not sure if we want to turn the mermaid into a fully female night troll, to start up the underwater race properly, or change Alice into one, since it's basically the best practical gift we have....Mermaid deserves it more. Also, we don't really want to convert Alice against her will, she'd resent us for it.
Gift of the Left Stone: Can be spent to convert a female or impregnate a mate. Instead of producing a son or a consort, this gift creates a fully functional female night troll. The traits gained depends on the female converted or consort impregnated.
She doesn't like men and would not have Night Troll babies.As I said, not liking man doesn't mean that she can't clench her teeth and let one to impregnate her. Also she is very young and may change her mind later. Also, IIRC she said that she prefers females not that sex with males is very disgusting for her
Converting the merfolk under water who already like night trolls will give the race a fall-back option in case we're ever hunted down.She don't like night trolls, she is not loyal tyo us. She likes her Goddess and loyal to her. She will enforce her ways... Like not allowing us to be friendly with humans or enforcing any other idiotic religious rule
Thecard, Read updatesFTFY.
Nocteclaw was eventually caught by Sol, the wrathful sun god, and his manhood was removed as punishment. His right stone fell to earth and became the first male night troll, His left stone fell to earth and became the first female night troll, and his rod fell to earth to become the first Glumprong tree. The once noble god became a vengeful goddess, intent on vicariously living out her lost masculinity through the actions of night trollkind and taking satisfaction in making mortals fear the night, her greatest creation.
Thecard, Read updates betterQuoteGift of the Left Stone: Can be spent to convert a female or impregnate a mate. Instead of producing a son or a consort, this gift creates a fully functional female night troll. The traits gained depends on the female converted or consort impregnated.QuoteShe doesn't like men and would not have Night Troll babies.As I said, not liking man doesn't mean that she can't clench her teeth and let one to impregnate her. Also she is very young and may change her mind later. Also, IIRC she said that she prefers females not that sex with males is very disgusting for herQuoteConverting the merfolk under water who already like night trolls will give the race a fall-back option in case we're ever hunted down.She don't like night trolls, she is not loyal tyo us. She likes her Goddess and loyal to her. She will enforce her ways... Like not allowing us to be friendly with humans or enforcing any other idiotic religious rule
We don't want unloyal night troll with at least equal strength to ours. Survival is important and stuff but personal power is also a goal
This is a worse idea than making her our consort. If we're going to make someone a fully fledged night troll then we will want someone who's actually going to *want* to propagate the species, someone who is going to actively attempt to spread our kind through the world again, without our constant babysitting.One word: instincts
I have a strong feeling that I will be the only one who thinks that we should convert Alice :)
Any attempt to spend a gift meets huge resistance.
As for hunting, I'd prefer to continue milking the forest retreat by patrolling around the fence and snatching the guards..., but I am afraid that we'll lose opportunity to raid the necromancer or get the noble elven... Still son is more important
Any attempt to spend a gift meets huge resistance.Not true. At all. Only in the case of Alice.
WE ARE NUTS!!!!Must...resist...urge...to...sig...
1) She is not weak, nor incompetent, she is capable and useful as is.Useful puppet, I see. What will we do when it will become obvious that we don't convert her not because we have no suitable gifts but because we don't want to?
2) While i think that we should keep him as an ally, i do not believe that we should do things just because he wants us to.OK, let's not do it, we will just anger him, he'll take his daughter away and use her in other useful way.
3) She's not the only potential ally out there.Key word is trust. We may find someone later or we may not
1) Those skills can just as easily be turned to help us get other mates, and would not improve through turning.I don't think so . Reread the description of the gift. Night troll will get some traits based on female converted. I think traits would be based on skills, genetics and character
2) Her family has disowned her, and i think that if we make the gesture of allowing her to maintain her humanity, we will have earned her undying loyalty, and perhaps the loyalty of the tigerwoman. On the other hand, if we turn her, the tigerwoman may come to hate us.We'll either have to fight with her angry father or convert her sooner or later. Don't you see that? And mortal inside a big family of night trolls... is a bad idea. If not we, one of our sons will convert her or one of our consorts will kill her. We may let her run away of cause, but that equals to losing an ally, too
3) she can do this as a humanShe can do that better as a night troll
5) We've gone through the game well enough without this, and even before we had our consort Weirdsound assured us he had a method of continuing the game.Surely he does. But let's think about better restarting conditions
Hey, I'll go right out and say it. We don't want to. Unless we get some kind of gift that changes sexual orientation (Honestly, I wouldn't hold my breath for this. That would be a morally gray area, at best) she will not be useful with the stone, and I don't think she would be more useful as a consort in general. Different colors make up the world, man. You want to have as big a variety as possible, just in case.Quote1) She is not weak, nor incompetent, she is capable and useful as is.Useful puppet, I see. What will we do when it will become obvious that we don't convert her not because we have no suitable gifts but because we don't want to?
We'll either have to fight with her angry father or convert her sooner or later. Don't you see that? And mortal inside a big family of night trolls... is a bad idea. If not we, one of our sons will convert her or one of our consorts will kill her. We may let her run away of cause, but that equals to losing an ally, tooNot necessarily. We are the most powerful of the night trolls, barring some catastrophe or anomaly we will always be. It's exponential, y'know. We can always protect her, it's not unheard of. We are sentient, and so are our children.
Some things. Remember, Gwen actually got a negative modifier from conversion.Quote3) she can do this as a humanShe can do that better as a night troll
Please, don't make all of your decisions just because you want to rp a lesbian chick. That's cool and all, but remember that the main guy is supposed to stay here. The backup is just in case of really bad luck/tactical decisions.
Hey, I'll go right out and say it. We don't want to.Then say that to her and close it forever
Not necessarily. We are the most powerful of the night trolls, barring some catastrophe or anomaly we will always be. It's exponential, y'know. We can always protect her, it's not unheard of. We are sentient, and so are our children.Accidents happen. and hat do you propose to do with Foghorn? I wouldn't even risk to leave her alone with hungry pregnant Gwen
Some things. Remember, Gwen actually got a negative modifier from conversion.She got a crappy gift, not the one that strong. Also there are should be some reason why she got so tall. I suspects that's because her plant empathy skill - she became treelike
Firstly, this is doubtful.
Also, who knows maybe Alice will get a trait that will make her able to mate\convert with both genders? Or only female ones. It's suitable for her background... Then we may share our consorts
I think we should use it on someone with plenty of skillsAnd I know one candidate :))) Hint - she has animal empathy, plant empathy, bow, stealth, knife fighting and likely some other skills
Maybe the hemigodess?Do you want to rape someone, then make her as strong as yourself? No thanks
Just... ew, i would rather our character not be the type to pressure others into sexual encounters they wouldn't enjoy just for some fap material.No a fact that we'll need to force. Not a fact that we'd want to force. But we'll have some consorts that we'll don't respect and treat like tools. It's no worse than necromancy.
If this is you trying to use reverse psychology... I don't... what? Why do you think you need to tell me that?QuoteHey, I'll go right out and say it. We don't want to.Then say that to her and close it forever
I do think we should store our loot in the tower, we have lost a lot of valuables last trip.
We should probably prioritize recovering our hidden loot stashes as well. First things first guys, we shouldn't forget about our little bits of useful stuff spread here and there.
I'd like to have a heart-to-analgous-organ talk with Alice before we make a final decision on not converting Alice...like, at least a turn apart.If this is you trying to use reverse psychology... I don't... what? Why do you think you need to tell me that?QuoteHey, I'll go right out and say it. We don't want to.Then say that to her and close it forever
Well... I'm going to assume you meant that seriously, because... I don't imagine why else you would mention that. I want to close it forever. I suggested doing that already. You wanna stop arguing and let us tell her we've decided to drop it then?
Tell Alice we've decided we are not going to convert her, we will let her live her own life. She is a faithful ally and now is a friend of the family. Ask her to stay on, as your friend. If she mentions wishing to go on and do other things with her life, remind her she owes that life to us.
Pretty sure she basically already said something to the effect of "men ew" ages and ages agoCan you provide a quote? I only remember that
"And... allow me to offer just a bit of practical advice seeing as you must be new to dealing with humans. When a woman keeps her hair and clothes as man would, as I do, there is a fair chance that she prefers to keep female company. You don't have to worry about me taking any sort of initiative toward you."
Tell Alice we've decided we are not going to convert her, we will let her live her own life. She is a faithful ally and now is a friend of the family. Ask her to stay on, as your friend. If she mentions wishing to go on and do other things with her life, remind her she owes that life to us.It's bad to lie to friends :)
QuotePretty sure she basically already said something to the effect of "men ew" ages and ages agoCan you provide a quote? I only remember thatQuote"And... allow me to offer just a bit of practical advice seeing as you must be new to dealing with humans. When a woman keeps her hair and clothes as man would, as I do, there is a fair chance that she prefers to keep female company. You don't have to worry about me taking any sort of initiative toward you."
"Prefers to keep female company" is far from "men ew"QuoteTell Alice we've decided we are not going to convert her, we will let her live her own life. She is a faithful ally and now is a friend of the family. Ask her to stay on, as your friend. If she mentions wishing to go on and do other things with her life, remind her she owes that life to us.It's bad to lie to friends :)
We should tell Alice "We don't consider you good enough to spend good gifts on you, and we are sure that spending mediocre gifts on you will do more harm than good because you are more useful as human. Besides you are lesbian and thus bad at babymaking" That's truth
And, no, I don't want to say that to Alice.... As well as anything else that assumes no converting ever. At least we'll win some time before we'll get problems with her father
:( So much potential of the left stone are gonna get wasted. It's doubtful that we'll find a suitable female for that anytime soon, most likely we'll need to spend it to make a baby girl or keep it in storage foreverOddly enough, I feel like a suitable female for the left stone would be one that... I dunno, isn't lesbian?
Anyway, Weirdsound will right a cool story. That's what matters
:( So much potential of the left stone are gonna get wasted. It's doubtful that we'll find a suitable female for that anytime soon, most likely we'll need to spend it to make a baby girl or keep it in storage foreverNot soon =/= Never
Yep, Yep. I know, lesbians can't have babies no matter what.They sure won't have as many as heterosexuals. Not like we're the last of our kind and need to repopulate our race...huh, what's that in the title?
We just need to wait for a female thatOr at least be willing to have kids, ideally eager; have skills which would make good traits to pass on; and be able to be captured or convinced. No doubt that Alice fails the most important of those.
a) Have enough useful skills
b) Have connections that will not care that she became a night troll
c) But have no very serious attachments to former life
d) Likes us enough to be a likely ally and not a competing night troll
e) Convertble
It's easier, more practical and probably faster to impregnate some consort and raise a girl troll....
Waiting for that megafemale without flaws
Not soon =/= NeverNot used gift = no benefit
OH GUYS! I'M PRETTY SURE I KNOW WHAT'S IN THAT BOX.So... like Pandora's Box, but Phyros'?
When Foghorn's other daughter first saw us she thought we might be a bogeyman, why would she make that assumption?
We were talking with Foghorn some time ago, and as he dozed off he said that the local bogeyman havn't been seen in decades, that Phyrost claimed to have sealed them away in something.
We know Foghorn desperately want's the lockbox that we have, and it's clearly magical, not to mention extraordinarily heavy.
Theory: inside is contained an extra-dimensional space, with all of the Local Bogeymen inside.
You are saying that homosexuality comes on a fine spectrum. It does not. There is Gay, Bi, Straight, and Asexual.Yes, strictly gay would find sex with opposite gender disgusting.
You are saying we should send her off to be raped for usWe are having a very different understanding of the word "rape". Rape = "forced sex", not "unpleasant sex". By your logic every prostitute is raped. She will do that on her own free will. She will choose partners, time, place, pose, duration. If she thinks that joy of having a children outweighs short disgust from sex she will do it, else - we shouldn't convert her. That's why we need to tell her about this gift and then decide
*yawns*On the other hand, keeping it in your pockets lets you invest it in something better later...and Alice plus the gifts we have now isn't a good investment.QuoteNot soon =/= NeverNot used gift = no benefit
used gift = benefits NOW
It's like cash, you need to invest it to make it useful... having it in your pockets will give you nothing good
Night trolls aren't humans, impregnation is not random. It's conscious act. I don't get all that buzz about homosexuality. Amount of children isn't dependent from pleasure... Nor from sex frequency. It's dependent on desire to have children. And we know nothing about Alice's views on childbirth.So? If Alice views intercourse with males the way a heterosexual male would, give or take a bit, that's a lot less baby trolls. Heterosexual night troll means more children. Maybe not a lot more, but we aren't in a position to gamble on the lives of future night trolls...nor are we desperate enough that we need to convert whoever happens to be in our tower right now.
I never proposed to convert Alice without getting agreement first and explaining what her life is going to be. If she say - I don't want to have any children or It's so disgusting to be with man that I'll not do it even for childbirth or I don't care about your race... Fine. We unlucky and lost an opportunity. And should deal with problem how to not convert and not piss her fatherWell, I still say that we should stick to our "No gift is appropriate" line until we, you know, have a gift that compliments Alice's ability instead of a cool gift that will probably be partly wasted on Alice.
But you all want to pass an opportunity without even trying to... because she may be too lesbian to make babies.
I made a small list why Alice may accept that kind of life, no one cared to commentMind repeating it? Only list I remember had an extensive counter-analysis posted before I could.
It's remind me Gwen, when you, Wyrm, said something like "who needs random rancher's wife. Let's spend our valuable gift on some queen"Indeed.
Sweet Azura, are we really still talking about this? This has been in debate for like 30 pages minimum, and nothing has changed, let's move on to something more constructive.One change: The debate is now using a unique gift of exceptional power on Alice, who won't be able to use it to its full potential.
Yeah, not like we weren't trying before we had a guess...OH GUYS! I'M PRETTY SURE I KNOW WHAT'S IN THAT BOX.So... like Pandora's Box, but Phyros'?
When Foghorn's other daughter first saw us she thought we might be a bogeyman, why would she make that assumption?
We were talking with Foghorn some time ago, and as he dozed off he said that the local bogeyman havn't been seen in decades, that Phyrost claimed to have sealed them away in something.
We know Foghorn desperately want's the lockbox that we have, and it's clearly magical, not to mention extraordinarily heavy.
Theory: inside is contained an extra-dimensional space, with all of the Local Bogeymen inside.
Sweet. Let's open that sucker up.
Irrelevant, Alice is lesbian. Unless you suggest we lock her in a room with a man and a couple gifts after converting her?QuoteYou are saying that homosexuality comes on a fine spectrum. It does not. There is Gay, Bi, Straight, and Asexual.Yes, strictly gay would find sex with opposite gender disgusting.
But do you really think that all Bisexuals have equal preference for both genders? Then in short: lol
I tell you little secret, many males that found homosexual sex disgusting often switch to males, when no females available (say prison) and then switch back when females become available
See below.QuoteYou are saying we should send her off to be raped for usWe are having a very different understanding of the word "rape". Rape = "forced sex", not "unpleasant sex". By your logic every prostitute is raped. She will do that on her own free will. She will choose partners, time, place, pose, duration. If she thinks that joy of having a children outweighs short disgust from sex she will do it, else - we shouldn't convert her. That's why we need to tell her about this gift and then decide
We need an update :)+1
All bisexuals? She's lesbian, for crying out loud. A lesbian is not a bisexual. A bisexual is a lesbo as well as a hetero, but it doesn't work the other way around. They're different.QuoteYou are saying that homosexuality comes on a fine spectrum. It does not. There is Gay, Bi, Straight, and Asexual.Yes, strictly gay would find sex with opposite gender disgusting.
But do you really think that all Bisexuals have equal preference for both genders? Then in short: lol
I tell you little secret, many males that found homosexual sex disgusting often switch to males, when no females available (say prison) and then switch back when females become availableUR, let me fill you in on a little secret: In prison, when those guys to homosexuality from heterosexuality, that's different. You know why? Because it's rape, and they never actually turned away from heterosexuality. Because the one who initiates it is still in the man's position. The other guy, unless he is consenting, is being raped.
Rape is unwanted sex. It is as black and white as that. Alice does not want to have sex with men. That makes it rape.QuoteYou are saying we should send her off to be raped for usWe are having a very different understanding of the word "rape". Rape = "forced sex", not "unpleasant sex". By your logic every prostitute is raped.
I tell you little secret, many males that found homosexual sex disgusting often switch to males, when no females available (say prison) and then switch back when females become availableIf you did the research i have you would know this is part of gang culture, not just prison culture. In this instance it is *not* because of the sex, it is because of the power, the domination, historically victors in battle would also rape their defeated opponents, and that's entirely different. Now, i am going to ask you to stop talking about rape, if you do not i will not take anything you say seriously from this point forward, i will ignore your ideas, good or no. This is not an appropriate line of conversation i find to be enjoyable discourse, it has reached the point of gratuitousness, so please stop.
Pfff... That's tiring. No more min\maxing and real world ethics discussion from me. Only ideas that would really come from a head of the character (As I see him, of cause) story deserves thatOur character isn't amoral.
I recommend that Ukrainian Ranger be barred from voting due to an excessive requirement for KY jelly, an inability to stop talking about converting Alice and generally being disruptive. All in favour say 'Aye'.Aye.
Now, any Ideas about tower defenses we might use in the future? we can't really do anything big if we can't endure the resulting retribution. I am in favor of using animal/plant empathy to make the surrounding life more loyal to us. we could have it be part of a routine: wake up, brush teeth, assert dominion over all we survey.Magic.
If Alice is so confident in her ability to distract the guards, and Gwen is so confident in her ability to snatch up prisoners, then both of them can do that. We'll hit one tree, Gwen hits another on the other side of the retreat and Alice distracts the guards.Yeah, I was thinking this too!
Pride?If Alice is so confident in her ability to distract the guards, and Gwen is so confident in her ability to snatch up prisoners, then both of them can do that. We'll hit one tree, Gwen hits another on the other side of the retreat and Alice distracts the guards.Yeah, I was thinking this too!
To be honest, I'm not sure what Alice's plan was. She pretty much wanted to do this, but have Gwen sit out. Dunno why.
When we attack, maybe we should just do some eon + dark manipulation? Have 'em shoot at each other, then freeze the survivors?Something magicky, probably involving eon manipulation. I prefer not to plan too far ahead. Sending some of the leaders or best combatants into the future could help; demoralization, if nothing else.
I think we have a little was to go until we're at fighting strength.
True, we could summon images of shadowy beasts that arn't real to run around and case panic, maybe using eon manipulation to occassionally catapult a body (or body part) into the future to make it seem like the "monsters" are doing stuff.Yeup.
Sounds frightening.True, we could summon images of shadowy beasts that arn't real to run around and case panic, maybe using eon manipulation to occassionally catapult a body (or body part) into the future to make it seem like the "monsters" are doing stuff.Yeup.
You misspelled "delightful."Sounds frightening.True, we could summon images of shadowy beasts that arn't real to run around and case panic, maybe using eon manipulation to occassionally catapult a body (or body part) into the future to make it seem like the "monsters" are doing stuff.Yeup.
Frightening to the victims, possibly delightful to the PC.You misspelled "delightful."Sounds frightening.True, we could summon images of shadowy beasts that arn't real to run around and case panic, maybe using eon manipulation to occassionally catapult a body (or body part) into the future to make it seem like the "monsters" are doing stuff.Yeup.
i say we declare ourselves the prophet of noctclaw, leftball the mermaid, and send her back to her homesea as high priestess to reform and revitalize the old religion, now with more focus on worshipping night creatures. the mermaids may care little for the old religion but at least they don't condemn it.I like the way you think, but think that for the time being we should keep a hold of that priestess, at least long enough to learn from her.
she should also take with her a magic mirror to communicate with us and our wizard ally, and they should coordinate their efforts to organize a proper duel between her family and the wizard, gaming the odds in his favour, possibly with some divine intervention. a victory through the proper channels would strengthen our cause
i don't know why you guys haven't thought of taking the locked chest to our less-than-corporeal blacksmith servant, i'm sure he'd make short work of the lock.
as for alice, i think we should disclose with her that the "waiting for the proper gift" gimmick is just a ruse to keep us in favour with her father, that we're far too thankful to her and trust her enough to betray her like that; that we have no interest in a mate with no interest in mating; and that she should do her best to get together with her furry friend and bring her to our cause too. the cult of the trangender goddess is probably the most appropriate faction for a homosexual couple. the wizard is useful to us and we're tankful to him, but he holds too much authority over us, we must take some cards off of his hand
as for the short term plans, i agree with jumping out of the way, obfuscating our retreat with camuflage and darkness manipulation at the first chance
Personally i would like to grab an elf that seems to be proficient with magic, divine or otherwise. Though at the same time... i find myself curious about the one tied up.I agree. Wonder if we could try and see what skills she may have?
(So your all agree to not being the strongest night troll just to ensure survival of our race? Not going to argue. Got bored)Yeah, exactly. We're not so arrogant that we would risk the survival of our species on ourself and an unborn child.
Yeah, exactly. We're not so arrogant that we would risk the survival of our species on ourself and an unborn child.Oh I see, totally different view on character's motivation. Happens
It's not like we're sacrificing ourself to give a random night troll time to escape.Yeah, exactly. We're not so arrogant that we would risk the survival of our species on ourself and an unborn child.Oh I see, totally different view on character's motivation. Happens
Ask the tree for coldbreath. If it doesn't give her to us, set something on fire and ask again, less politely(unless that wouldn't work with plants).we don't need to ask the tree, coldbreath isn't tied up in vines. if you want to restrain her, we're more skilled in time magic than treetalking, and it would be safer to trap her in a timeloop and then carry her away
Would we be able to carry someone if they're slowed down? Might that slow us down, or something? She wouldn't be able to move very fast, and would keep looping, so she wouldn't be able to go anywhere, even in our arms.Ask the tree for coldbreath. If it doesn't give her to us, set something on fire and ask again, less politely(unless that wouldn't work with plants).we don't need to ask the tree, coldbreath isn't tied up in vines. if you want to restrain her, we're more skilled in time magic than treetalking, and it would be safer to trap her in a timeloop and then carry her away
but i vote against going for one of the others when we got a bride secured already. just leave.
eating a sentient who was killed in their sleep is the same as eating giant lovebird eggs. their meat wouldn't be seasoned with the recommended daily dose of terror. we should go after little children for food and torture them before feeding. these are potential consorts, not preyExactly. We feed on fear too. We need to keep her alive. Well, we have one elf in a cocoon, and we can probably carry another if we bind her. We'll take two, and give Gwen one.
the left teste was a gift from the goddess, not one we earned ourselves, we shouldn't hoard it greedily. it is only fitting that we bestow it upon someone devout to her and dedicated to restoring the old faith. besides, a lineage of sea-bound trolls wouldn't compete with our progeny. if we succeed in establishing a cult to the night trolls we're effectively creating the foundation for a platform of collaboration between night trolls regardless of lineage. instead of reviving the isolationist culture of our fathers, we'd be creating a faction that could not only survive, but could reasonably aspire to dominate the worldAlso, we'd be spreading out the night trolls some.
as for the current action, most elves sound like good brides, and i'm really curious about the one bound in vines, but i suspect we can only take one of them. i'm confident whatever we pick will have an interesting result, but we shouldn't be greedy. we should just pick one and get outI still vote adventurer.
I do not think we should set the building we are currently in on fire.And sigging.
Ask the tree for coldbreath. If it doesn't give her to us, set something on fire and ask again, less politely(unless that wouldn't work with plants).
Whoever we choose, we should take some combination of the older elf's axe and possibly armor, the rogue's lockpicks and dagger, the adventurer's stuff. Yay, loot!
do we get plant empathy from that success?
Let us interview our prisoners, tell them that if they convince us of their worth they may live, if they resist than use dark manipulation to torture their minds.
I suggest we quickly interrogate the elves. Assuming they're all female, we'll make our choice(s) of mates afterwards.Guard is female, I think.
If the guard's male, give him to Gwen and interrogate the others.
...Double-ninja'd.
Dang.I suggest we quickly interrogate the elves. Assuming they're all female, we'll make our choice(s) of mates afterwards.Guard is female, I think.
If the guard's male, give him to Gwen and interrogate the others.
...Double-ninja'd.
Reverting to my old style of suggestions, new doesn't work and I like lists :)1. Use time productively.
I propose:
1) Stay here, wait for the attack
2) Let Gwen do have fun with prisoners, tell she should eat two, and choose one that she should like to see as a sister-wife, then leave her alone (I don't think that she'll became much more pregnant as a result, so should be combat-fine)
3) Spend that time night talking with Alice, tell her about all our current gifts (not only the ones that we consider giving to her due to minmaxing) , ask her about her life plans, her views on chilbirth and option how to avoid wraith of her father if we choose (Be we I mean the troll and Alice) to not do any kind of conversion
4) setup some kind of ambush, all members of our party are stealthy
Reverting to my old style of suggestions, new doesn't work and I like lists :)i agree with this except or the first point. i don't think we should linger, and we're encumbered with the prisioners, it'll be hard to fight or flee later, and we got all we wanted, so we should get a headstart. have alice split from the group and covering our retreat, by covering our tracks and spreading misleading gossip among the trees to confuse our pursuers
I propose:
1) Stay here, wait for the attack
2) Let Gwen do have fun with prisoners, tell she should eat two, and choose one that she should like to see as a sister-wife, then leave her alone (I don't think that she'll became much more pregnant as a result, so should be combat-fine)
3) Spend that time night talking with Alice, tell her about all our current gifts (not only the ones that we consider giving to her due to minmaxing) , ask her about her life plans and goals, her views on the childbirth and option how to avoid wraith of her father if we choose (By we I mean the troll and Alice) to not do any kind of conversion
4) setup some kind of ambush, all members of our party are stealthy
1. I mean not go to tower1. Ah. Agreed.
2.As a former elf and member of that society Gwen knows better. Besides we trust our wife, besides we want her to be happy with sister wife... And letting her doing the job may let us prepare better ambush Oh, let me guess min-maxing says that she may choose a suboptimal mate.
3. So what? Let Alice decide if she consider gift good or not. Let's learn what she really thinks about the conversion Or let's not pretend that we respect her as a friend. Or you are afraid that Alice will show interest in the left stone gift? Why is so? It's not like that we'll be forced to convert her
Interrogate all of them and the one we hate the most or isn't worthy to live feed it to Gwen. Then use the others for your pawns/slaves and they will have to follow your orders or die.Or, you know, convert them. Just a thought.
Stay here and prepare an ambush sounds like the best option.Of course, at the moment it's unanimous.
Interrogate all three prisoners, then let Gwen eat the two of them we want least as a consort.
I thought we agreed to stop discussing converting Alice until someone other than Ukrainian Ranger brings it up.
i agree with discussing it with alice herself. it would probably settle the matterWait for safety, and ideally a better gift.
Why does no one want two new consorts? Is there a time limit between conversions I forgot, or do people just not want to spend the time right now to convert two? I can agree with that, but if a night troll, two consorts, and Alice can't figure out how to bind an elf and then transport her to the tower I'll eat my avatar. Also bear in mind that eating a couple of screaming elven women will probably add the equivilant of a few months to Gwen's pregnancy...
Yay, someone agreed with me!QuoteWhy does no one want two new consorts? Is there a time limit between conversions I forgot, or do people just not want to spend the time right now to convert two? I can agree with that, but if a night troll, two consorts, and Alice can't figure out how to bind an elf and then transport her to the tower I'll eat my avatar. Also bear in mind that eating a couple of screaming elven women will probably add the equivilant of a few months to Gwen's pregnancy...
That's why i said to let Gwen eat one and convert the other 2. Also if we are going to interrogate them do we get to know their skills,traits,names,Etc?
Yah, I agree with you too.Yay, someone agreed with me!QuoteWhy does no one want two new consorts? Is there a time limit between conversions I forgot, or do people just not want to spend the time right now to convert two? I can agree with that, but if a night troll, two consorts, and Alice can't figure out how to bind an elf and then transport her to the tower I'll eat my avatar. Also bear in mind that eating a couple of screaming elven women will probably add the equivilant of a few months to Gwen's pregnancy...
That's why i said to let Gwen eat one and convert the other 2. Also if we are going to interrogate them do we get to know their skills,traits,names,Etc?
Anyways...names, skills, history, rumors heard, family, property, faith...anything they'll tell us, focusing on skills and such and what they've heard.
The reverse would be better, as Gwen likely is better at plantlife manipulation, and information would be better first hand, gwen may also get overzealous and go too far, she's already proven occassionally lacking in self control.Yeah, Gwen is better at ranger-shits, since she was an elf. We're also much better at dark manipulation.
While i like the idea of more servants i think we can only convert one at a time, and even if we do that we will be tired, if we plan an ambush this is a concern. If we turn one of them and keep another tied up that one may escape her bondage and fight against us along with her rescuers.
I'm okay with the idea of ambush, i just feel we need to be smart about this.
The reverse would be better, as Gwen likely is better at plantlife manipulation, and information would be better first hand, gwen may also get overzealous and go too far, she's already proven occassionally lacking in self control.Hmmmm.... how about temporal cheese wire? Decapitations are fun.
While i like the idea of more servants i think we can only convert one at a time, and even if we do that we will be tired, if we plan an ambush this is a concern. If we turn one of them and keep another tied up that one may escape her bondage and fight against us along with her rescuers.
I'm okay with the idea of ambush, i just feel we need to be smart about this.
A similiar suggestion to one i suggested earlier, is it possible to create a long thin sort of wall of frozen or slowed time? If we could get our opponents to bungle into it than we could deal with enemies in a more leisurely manner, at the very worst it would make navigation more difficult for our opponents.
Why does no one want two new consorts? Is there a time limit between conversions I forgot, or do people just not want to spend the time right now to convert two? I can agree with that, but if a night troll, two consorts, and Alice can't figure out how to bind an elf and then transport her to the tower I'll eat my avatar. Also bear in mind that eating a couple of screaming elven women will probably add the equivilant of a few months to Gwen's pregnancy...
1. Don't convert both at once, one now and one saved for later.Why does no one want two new consorts? Is there a time limit between conversions I forgot, or do people just not want to spend the time right now to convert two? I can agree with that, but if a night troll, two consorts, and Alice can't figure out how to bind an elf and then transport her to the tower I'll eat my avatar. Also bear in mind that eating a couple of screaming elven women will probably add the equivilant of a few months to Gwen's pregnancy...Right now, we have the time to convert one consort and even that means maybe being caught with our figurative pants down. Also, the ostensible purpose of this raid was to get Gwen food. So if we end up converting all of our victims instead of letting Gwen eat them, that's really a waste of a trip.
That said, if we are going to convert one of the elves, we should give them the Gift of Inferno's Embrace. Invincibility, Fire Magic and teleportation is too good of an asset to pass up.
Let us interview our prisoners, tell them that if they convince us of their worth they may live, if they resist than use dark manipulation to torture their minds.
Reverting to my old style of suggestions, new doesn't work and I like lists :)
I propose:
1) Stay here, wait for the attack
2) Let Gwen do have fun with prisoners, tell she should eat two, and choose one that she should like to see as a sister-wife, then leave her alone (I don't think that she'll became much more pregnant as a result, so should be combat-fine)
3) Spend that time night talking with Alice, tell her about all our current gifts (not only the ones that we consider giving to her due to minmaxing) , ask her about her life plans and goals, her views on the childbirth and option how to avoid wraith of her father if we choose (By we I mean the troll and Alice) to not do any kind of conversion
Don't light the tree on fire, it could catch the barn.
Phoenix sounds fine, except that flaming wings would ruin woodcraft.Yeah, I mean it doesn't go very well, but it would help us against Elves, and would let her fly.
Maybe Inferno's Embrace? Geez, we really do have crappy gifts for Alice. We ought to take 20 on Plant Empathy or something...
If we convert her now, she will be starving at best and dissolved at worst when the elves arrive. This is really the worst possible time for this sort of thing.Yeah, I'm thinking for afterwards. It takes time to convert, if I remember right.
If we convert her now, she will be starving at best and dissolved at worst when the elves arrive. This is really the worst possible time for this sort of thing.Yeah, I'm thinking for afterwards. It takes time to convert, if I remember right.
But we probably will be fighting Elves after this, still. This is just an ambush, right?
That's the word I was looking for, thanks. I couldn't remember it, and was torn between ambush and lynch mob.Less than a ambush. Just a posse.If we convert her now, she will be starving at best and dissolved at worst when the elves arrive. This is really the worst possible time for this sort of thing.Yeah, I'm thinking for afterwards. It takes time to convert, if I remember right.
But we probably will be fighting Elves after this, still. This is just an ambush, right?
Divide and conquer. Let's trap the invaders somehow (in the barn, in the trees, in a ring of fire, it doesn't matter), make sure they can't escape quickly, and use our dark manipulation, face, and other tricks to terrify and drive them into attacking each other.Daytime is coming, our dark manipulation won't be useful.
Isn't she sweet? I love Alice... Well I love the whole story and all NPCes but Alice is my favorite . Sad that we learn nothing about her desire (or lack off) to have childrenAgreed, great job by the Dm on the story thus far ^^
Conversion before the battle is a bad idea, way to risky and exhausting for both parties
I support making traps, both magical and mundane. I think we should consider delayed firespells
Left Stone Gift is not useful for combat. We need a combat-useful gift. Even if we decide Alice deserves to be the first female Night Troll, now is not the time to use the Left Stone.
Left Stone Gift is not useful for combat. We need a combat-useful gift. Even if we decide Alice deserves to be the first female Night Troll, now is not the time to use the Left Stone.
while converting now is a bad idea... the Left Stone is most likely will boost combat abilities of many females. It gives traits on based some unknown properties of female. Probably it includes skills
The night troll created may have more then one traits, I think something like 3 to 5.
It's a strong immediately ally and if supplied by nice skills may be stronger then we currently are.
_____________________________-
I should explain my view on the left stone gift, once again, when I am in a better mood (I was pissed me all that real world ethics discussion into a game and got a little inadequate, sorry. Strategy discussions are good, but I dislike when RPGs played like pure strategy)
I am putting all role-play and my hopes for story development aside and will talk about it like it a strategy game. Strategy that based on quality not quantity
1) I prefer to not base our survival on numbers. Numbers are good, but that didn't help night trolls before, we know that
2) another way is to become a powerful wizard with some nice allies who is capable to defend his small, but advanced and united family-race. (loyal consorts, few children that get proper education from the patriarch(us), allies from other races. I think only elves are our true enemies, any other race may become an ally. That's what our diplomacy skill for)
3) It would be great to learn to extract fear and feed without the need to kill\draw insane and making enemies
It might be possible with a small group, but it will not if we create a huge subrace, especially if it will follow Nocteclaw zealously
(BTW Gift of Amnesia gives a fun way to feed - scare, erase memory, scare, erase memory, scary, erase memory. We get alive, sane pray and well fed troll)
4) The faster we multiply, the faster we'll get attention, the more night trolls exist, the more food we need
5) I'd like to have full control over every birth\conversion as we have now. It's like vampiric laws in many settings - create vampire without a permission of council\Prince and you'll get killed. Sentient predators MUST limit their own numbers. That's why I prefer to not spent the left stone gift at all to giving it to any female (especially not loyal enough) and sending her away. I'd rather see female night troll as picky in making babies as we are. And Alice (yep, I bring that, again) is ideal in that role, because she'll not lie under every male she meet. If she choose to have a baby it will be a well thought decision. Even if she'll have no babies at all, that's not a tragedy for our race, we are still making sons
6) For me, the left stone gift is not a way to get a baby making machine , but a way to get a strong ally with several good traits, now. Infants are more liability than asset in our situation
Still doesn't cover practical issues, like burning a forest she's sneaking through. Plant empathy other than intimidation would be impossible too.Phoenix sounds fine, except that flaming wings would ruin woodcraft.Yeah, I mean it doesn't go very well, but it would help us against Elves, and would let her fly.
Maybe Inferno's Embrace? Geez, we really do have crappy gifts for Alice. We ought to take 20 on Plant Empathy or something...
I mean, we could gifts that would better suit her, but she's human, and less likely to object burning trees down than those Elves.
It'll probably be darker inside, but let's not base a dawntime plan on darkness.Divide and conquer. Let's trap the invaders somehow (in the barn, in the trees, in a ring of fire, it doesn't matter), make sure they can't escape quickly, and use our dark manipulation, face, and other tricks to terrify and drive them into attacking each other.Daytime is coming, our dark manipulation won't be useful.
Biggest benefit is the female night troll bit. If Alice isn't willing to have plenty of kids, we shouldn't give it to her.Left Stone Gift is not useful for combat. We need a combat-useful gift. Even if we decide Alice deserves to be the first female Night Troll, now is not the time to use the Left Stone.while converting now is a bad idea... the Left Stone is most likely will boost combat abilities of many females. It gives traits on based some unknown properties of female. Probably it includes skills
The night troll created may have more then one traits, I think something like 3 to 5.
It's a strong immediately ally and if supplied by nice skills may be stronger then we currently are.
I should explain my view on the left stone gift, once again, when I am in a better mood (I was pissed me all that real world ethics discussion into a game and got a little inadequate, sorry. Strategy discussions are good, but I dislike when RPGs played like pure strategy)Quantity has a quality all its own.
I am putting all role-play and my hopes for story development aside and will talk about it like it a strategy game. Strategy that based on quality not quantity
1) I prefer to not base our survival on numbers. Numbers are good, but that didn't help night trolls before, we know thatNeither did their power...just sayin'.
2) another way is to become a powerful wizard with some nice allies who is capable to defend his small, but advanced and united family-race. (loyal consorts, few children that get proper education from the patriarch(us), allies from other races. I think only elves are our true enemies, any other race may become an ally. That's what our diplomacy skill for)Potentially, but it'd be an uphill battle. We're still night trolls.
3) It would be great to learn to extract fear and feed without the need to kill\draw insane and making enemies'Twould be nice. Maybe we could become therapists. "Don't worry, it's okay. Just let me draw away your fear..."
It might be possible with a small group, but it will not if we create a huge subrace, especially if it will follow Nocteclaw zealously
(BTW Gift of Amnesia gives a fun way to feed - scare, erase memory, scare, erase memory, scary, erase memory. We get alive, sane pray and well fed troll)If it's possible to get fear without eating physical flesh, yes.
4) The faster we multiply, the faster we'll get attention, the more night trolls exist, the more food we needThink of it, again, like a strategy game. Say Civilization.
5) I'd like to have full control over every birth\conversion as we have now. It's like vampiric laws in many settings - create vampire without a permission of council\Prince and you'll get killed. Sentient predators MUST limit their own numbers. That's why I prefer to not spent the left stone gift at all to giving it to any female (especially not loyal enough) and sending her away. I'd rather see female night troll as picky in making babies as we are. And Alice (yep, I bring that, again) is ideal in that role, because she'll not lie under every male she meet. If she choose to have a baby it will be a well thought decision. Even if she'll have no babies at all, that's not a tragedy for our race, we are still making sonsDiscuss this with our son and whoever we give the Left Stone to, and what we'll do when we die, but good idea. Although the idea that a night troll without babies isn't a tragedy...it is. That's an almost completely wasted gift. The biggest point of that gift was that there would be more fruitful and abundant night troops, and female night trolls. If whoever we give it to doesn't even have one kid, it's wasted...
6) For me, the left stone gift is not a way to get a baby making machine , but a way to get a strong ally with several good traits, now. Infants are more liability than asset in our situationDisagree. Short-term, but thinking strictly short-term is dumb. Infants are going to be a boon to our race sooner than you think, especially if child growth follows the same rules postnatal as pre.
while discussing alice's conversion sounds a fair bit more sensible now, i still think it would be more interesting storywise to have her remain human and eventually reunite her with the tigress of her heart, even if it meant her leaving our party. i also still thing that lefstoning the mermaid would be a better idea than to leftstone alice, thoughSensible overall.
Biggest benefit is the female night troll bit. If Alice isn't willing to have plenty of kids, we shouldn't give it to her.Why are you so sure that we need plenty of kids? There are other ways to ensure our survival without behaving like rabbits
The biggest point of that gift was that there would be more fruitful and abundant night troops,That' what Nocteclaw wants, sure. I just don't think that we need to be her slave.
Also bear in mind that we're supposed to repopulate our race.Said who? We are free to do whatever we want.
Although the idea that a night troll without babies isn't a tragedy...it is. That's an almost completely wasted gift.Powerful, loyal, immortal ally that will become a better and better isn't a wasted gift at all. Besides I am sure that we can talk her into making at least one baby, and then her daughter may be the basis of creating all other female night trolls if you need a rabbit night troll
Efficiency. It's the only Left Stone gift we're ever getting.QuoteBiggest benefit is the female night troll bit. If Alice isn't willing to have plenty of kids, we shouldn't give it to her.Why are you so sure that we need plenty of kids? There are other ways to ensure our survival without behaving like rabbits
And let's assume that Alice isn't a lesbian, that she is ready to fuck constantly, do we really need constantly pregnant and hungry night troll? Do we need dozens of hungry kids? Prey is not unlimited, and infants\kids\constantly pregnant females add nothing to our ability to get more prey. Even more, they need constant protection and thus reducing our hunting abilitiesCan we have "dozens" of kids?
Not slave, just not antagonising her. Besides, s/he does kinda have a right to us, and as a god/dess has the ability to royally screw us over if we anger her.QuoteThe biggest point of that gift was that there would be more fruitful and abundant night troops,That' what Nocteclaw wants, sure. I just don't think that we need to be her slave.
Last wish of our father. Also a consideration most of us have.QuoteAlso bear in mind that we're supposed to repopulate our race.Said who? We are free to do whatever we want.
We are playing a character, not a night troll race
We aren't playing forces of evil vs forces of good, either
Almost. Sure, one ally is nice, but a family of equally powerful allies is better. Much better. Also loads better for our race.QuoteAlthough the idea that a night troll without babies isn't a tragedy...it is. That's an almost completely wasted gift.Powerful, loyal, immortal ally that will become a better and better isn't a wasted gift at all. Besides I am sure that we can talk her into making at least one baby, and then her daughter may be the basis of creating all other female night trolls if you need a rabbit night troll
And don't you think that may be in our interest to make future trolls (or majority of them) same as us and not create a potential gender vs gender war situation?No. I fail to see your point. There can be conflicts within a gender, too, and with family members it can be worse between brothers. I'm willing to bet that I would get along a lot better with a little sister than with my little brother.
Let's say about as many kids as we intend to have, over the course of our respective lifetimes.Our lifetimes are looong. Why can't you let daughter(s) of Alice to reproduce if you really want competitors to our sons? Besides what is bad in having only male trolls, again?
Last wish of our father. Also a consideration most of us have.It's not like we loved him much... And I suspect that he disliked female night trolls, that fits his character. And he was an atheist
Not slave, just not antagonising her. Besides, s/he does kinda have a right to us, and as a god/dess has the ability to royally screw us over if we anger her.Doing anything to not anger = slave
Female and male trolls arePretty much all of that is true for humans, too, and you don't need millions of people to reproduce. We work together anyway. Besides, if we are even halfway decent at choosing a recipient for the gift, we'll choose someone that works well with us.
1) Different
2) Have no need in each other too reproduce
3) Compete for same resources
Don't you see a huge potential for conflicts? Especially if we go underwater troll route. Female night trolls and male night trolls are very very close to being different races
I am not sure that they can mate with each other. And even if they can... humans and elves can mate, too. That doesn't make them one race
1. Not competitors, associates. And why not both?QuoteLet's say about as many kids as we intend to have, over the course of our respective lifetimes.Our lifetimes are looong. Why can't you let daughter(s) of Alice to reproduce if you really want competitors to our sons? Besides what is bad in having only male trolls, again?
So? He sent us forward in time.QuoteLast wish of our father. Also a consideration most of us have.It's not like we loved him much... And I suspect that he disliked female night trolls, that fits his character
Besides there are another way to recreate night troll race. Make a nation, not solitary families scattered around the world like it was before.
Not "doing anything not to anger her." Besides, it's always good to get on gods' good sides. Gods help their servants.QuoteNot slave, just not antagonising her. Besides, s/he does kinda have a right to us, and as a god/dess has the ability to royally screw us over if we anger her.Doing anything to not anger = slave
Keep it civil guys. If I update tonight, it will be right before I go to sleep. I have two Pokemon Tabletop Games to prep for. You can expect this to slow down on weekends a bit from now on.Pokemon tabletop? Huh.
Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?He mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.
Hm.Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?He mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.
Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?Don't automatically conclude that everybody thinks like you.
One occasion. Here (http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=118808.msg3868545#msg3868545)Hm.Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?He mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.
Maybe his ulterior motive is playing a lesbian night troll?
...Probably not.
Pretty much all of that is true for humans, too, and you don't need millions of people to reproduce. We work together anyway. Besides, if we are even halfway decent at choosing a recipient for the gift, we'll choose someone that works well with us.Imagine a simple situation, men or women or both find a way to reproduce without opposite gender (that's close tech-wise actually. Modern genetics aren't far away from making woman+woman = baby. With males it's harder, but probably possible) Don't you think that this will change humanity forever? That may bring female vs male war easily
Not "doing anything not to anger her." Besides, it's always good to get on gods' good sides. Gods help their servantsAlso gods have a habit to punish servants of other gods. Serving Nocteclaw = fighting with Sol and probably many other gods. Who are stronger then Nocteclaw
1. Not competitors, associates. And why not both?That's not how predators behave. Only pack mentality can keep them close. But then there are wars between packs
He mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.I mentioned that after you decided to spend the left stone gift to convert the mermaid. I dislike it for many, many reasons and still prefer character death to that. My current preference for the left stone gift usage. Convert Alice> keep it to impregnate a right consort > don't spend it at all > spend it on random housewife > die with it > spend it on the zealot
We have returned to one of our bases. If only one elf escapes they will attack the base in even greater numbers. I advise a scorched earth strategy. Literally. Freeze a powerful fireball in time - in one of the side rooms. Close all windows. Release it once you see the elves enter the Building. Also: wear the soul catcher amulet while doing so. After that hunt down any survivors as good as possible.I support this, including soul catching, but instead of one big fireball, many smaller frozen fire spells, we don't want to fry ourself
Arguments posed suggest that the majority is on his side.Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?Don't automatically conclude that everybody thinks like you.
Repopulate: yes, but slowly.How slowly do you mean, why not, duh, and why.
Worship: no
eat people: NOT ALL OF THEM.
(convert alice: yes-gift of the left stone ... or try to get the gift of the right stone.)
Doesn't really explain motives.One occasion. Here (http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=118808.msg3868545#msg3868545)Hm.Ukrainian Ranger: This is another issue where nobody agrees with you. People want to repopulate our race, worship Nocteclaw and eat people. You, for reasons unknown to me, do not. Why?He mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.
Maybe his ulterior motive is playing a lesbian night troll?
...Probably not.
You've read too much bad science fiction. Humans and night trolls alike will have ties which bind them without needing reproduction. Do you work with your coworkers at work? Either you work with people you never intend to mate with or your employment situation is rather shaky.QuotePretty much all of that is true for humans, too, and you don't need millions of people to reproduce. We work together anyway. Besides, if we are even halfway decent at choosing a recipient for the gift, we'll choose someone that works well with us.Imagine a simple situation, men or women or both find a way to reproduce without opposite gender (that's close tech-wise actually. Modern genetics aren't far away from making woman+woman = baby. With males it's harder, but probably possible) Don't you think that this will change humanity forever? That may bring female vs male war easily
Sol probably doesn't like night creatures in general. There are also a lot more Nocteclawean servants around who might like us than Solian servants who are around. Also, we owe Nocteclaw, and his/her decision that we pray to him/her about isn't binding.QuoteNot "doing anything not to anger her." Besides, it's always good to get on gods' good sides. Gods help their servantsAlso gods have a habit to punish servants of other gods. Serving Nocteclaw = fighting with Sol and probably many other gods. Who are stronger then Nocteclaw
We're not wolves, and in fact wolves work together better than you assume we would. We're people, we can work together.Quote1. Not competitors, associates. And why not both?That's not how predators behave. Only pack mentality can keep them close. But then there are wars between packs
And if you want many female trolls: Do the math. There are almost no long term difference in Alice and all her daughters(granddaughters, grand granddaughters....) have as many daughters as needed and Alice's only daughter and here descendants make as many babies as needed
You'd rather not spend it or DIE than spend it on the mermaid? Fool. Seriously, it's good to have allies with the merfolk and a night troll line which can't be so easily slain. If the elves drive us out of their forest, we will have the endless seas.QuoteHe mentioned, earlier on a few occassions that he was hoping our character died, this was after the huge clusterfuck argument.I mentioned that after you decided to spend the left stone gift to convert the mermaid. I dislike it for many, many reasons and still prefer character death to that. My current preference for the left stone gift usage. Convert Alice> keep it to impregnate a right consort > don't spend it at all > spend it on random housewife > die with it > spend it on the zealot
And still my main motivation in converting Alice is roleplayish one. We can treat Alice in only 3 ways - keep her weak and dependent on her father(human) , make her somewhat stronger and bound to us (consorting) and make her much stronger and free (convert her into female night troll)Consorts aren't bound forever. Anyways, Alice has already said we could consortify her.
While normal human ethics may suggest that not converting at all is the best thing we can do for a friend, we are playing a night troll, who surely thinks that his only friend deserves something much better then being a weak human (prey) even if she thinks otherwiseWe also need to keep other things in mind. While I'm not against turning Alice into a female night troll on principal, I'd rather make sure she's willing to have kids before using our most valuable gift on someone who can't fully utilize it.
I'm not sure about burning down our own house...QuoteWe have returned to one of our bases. If only one elf escapes they will attack the base in even greater numbers. I advise a scorched earth strategy. Literally. Freeze a powerful fireball in time - in one of the side rooms. Close all windows. Release it once you see the elves enter the Building. Also: wear the soul catcher amulet while doing so. After that hunt down any survivors as good as possible.I support this, including soul catching, but instead of one big fireball, many smaller frozen fire spells, we don't want to fry ourself
Do we really need to lock ourselves down? Our characters are stealthy and can hide outside pretty wellThe posse slightly put numbers us.
We're not wolves, and in fact wolves work together better than you assume we would. We're people, we can work together.Night trolls aren't humans. Different morals, different life span, different instincts, different food and no dark god to rule. And humans had many, many wars with nations far less different than different branches of night trolls
By your logic, all human societies should have collapsed long ago.
You'd rather not spend it or DIE than spend it on the mermaid? Fool. Seriously, it's good to have allies with the merfolk and a night troll line which can't be so easily slain. If the elves drive us out of their forest, we will have the endless seas.Yes, genius. I don't want to create a totally independent powerful subrace of zealots that most likely will be either enemies or masters for our sons
Consorts aren't bound forever. Anyways, Alice has already said we could consortify her.They are. They can't reproduce without night trolls (or maybe troll that converted consort) , that's quite binding. Female night troll can choose their mate freely
Yes, genius. I don't want to create a totally independent powerful subrace of zealots that most likely will be either enemies or masters for our sonssharks don't compete with wolves. the mermaid is equipped with a number of magical trinkets that allows her to leave the water; the fact that mermaids aren't a land conquering power hints that these trinkets aren't that common. if you want to minimize the competition for our children, creating a night creature that hunts in a completely different ecosystem, and is even unable to naturally enter our children' domain, would be the perfect choice
Do you know what happens when fanatically religious group meets atheistic, less religious or wrong religion group?
Do you know what happens when fanatically religious group meets atheistic, less religious or wrong religion group?if it was up to me we'd be fanatically religious too. religion makes a lot more sense and is an even better world domination tool in a world where gods actually exist. besides, since we're the ones choosing who to get the leftstone, that'd give us a status second only to noctclaw itself among the newly created race. do you think religious fanatics would go after us, noctlaw's chosen, the reviver of the night troll race?
sharks don't compete with wolves. the mermaid is equipped with a number of magical trinkets that allows her to leave the water; the fact that mermaids aren't a land conquering power hints that these trinkets aren't that common. if you want to minimize the competition for our children, creating a night creature that hunts in a completely different ecosystem, and is even unable to naturally enter our children' domain, would be the perfect choice1) Night trolls need to hunt, suitable prey is present only on shores. Ecosystem is same
if it was up to me we'd be fanatically religious too. religion makes a lot more sense and is an even better world domination tool in a world where gods actually existWell that's exactly why I'd rather see character dead. I don't like religious pure evil fanatics way, not the kind of story I like and not the way I'd like to see character developed. All the story before, like nice relationships with Gwen, or friendship with Alice are much more fun for me. Not evil force that strives to conquer the world, no matter what but race with it's own moral code that want to survive.
besides, since we're the ones choosing who to get the leftstone, that'd give us a status second only to noctclaw itself among the newly created race.Well, I agree. If we'll be totally obedient to Noctclaw, fanatics will like us and may be not masters but slaves. But then we are slaves of Noctclaw, no much better fate
1) Night trolls need to hunt, suitable prey is present only on shores. Ecosystem is samewhat? no. mermaids are suitable prey too
2) They will be amphibious not marine.mermaids are marine, not amphibious. why would a night troll race based on an exclusively marine race be amphibious?
3) They may evolve in many other different kind of night trollstrue
4) Do you see any seas around? Those merfolks are surely river\lake basedi don't see any river either, and merpeople inhabit oceans (http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/Mermaid) in df universe
Well that's exactly why I'd rather see character dead.that's where we'll have to agree to disagree. it is only natural that some of us want to see the story go a different direction than you do, though i at least find it a bit ungraceful of you to prefer to see our fun ruined just because you didn't have it your way
what? no. mermaids are suitable prey tooMerfolk are very fear resistant. So no, they aren't suitable prey
mermaids are marine, not amphibious. why would a night troll race based on an exclusively marine race be amphibious?Because they obviously can live on land, like mermaid in our tower shows. Besides we should get night troll with mermaid influenced traits not mermaid\night troll hybrid or as you say - troll based on mermaid
i don't see any river either, and merpeople inhabit oceans in df universeMy bad, haven't play DF for a long time. (Still my bad, story included mention that they are from see, forgot about it) But what do you want to do with the problem that we are far from sea? Just spend her away and hope that sometimes, years later we'll get an ally from see? Isn't that a waste of gift?
though i at least find it a bit ungraceful of you to prefer to see our fun ruined just because you didn't have it your wayYour fun will be ruined if we switch a playing character? Really? Ouch...
Because they obviously can live on land, like mermaid in our tower shows.the mermaid on our tower is wearing enchanted jewellery to be able to survive on land
Do we really need to lock ourselves down? Our characters are stealthy and can hide outside pretty wellWe're stealthy, but a posse of elves, most presumably with plant empathy and on their guard, will be very difficult to hide from.
the mermaid on our tower is wearing enchanted jewellery to be able to survive on landSo, why not mass produce such jewelry? Despite I highly doubt that night troll created will be that merfolklike
If we barricade, we badly need a reserve escape route.Do we really need to lock ourselves down? Our characters are stealthy and can hide outside pretty wellWe're stealthy, but a posse of elves, most presumably with plant empathy and on their guard, will be very difficult to hide from.
The boarding up of the windows idea could work, but we need traps and barricades as well.
Your fun will be ruined if we switch a playing character? Really? Ouch...
Quotethe mermaid on our tower is wearing enchanted jewellery to be able to survive on landSo, why not mass produce such jewelry? Despite I highly doubt that night troll created will be that merfolklikeIf we barricade, we badly need a reserve escape route.Do we really need to lock ourselves down? Our characters are stealthy and can hide outside pretty wellWe're stealthy, but a posse of elves, most presumably with plant empathy and on their guard, will be very difficult to hide from.
The boarding up of the windows idea could work, but we need traps and barricades as well.
I'll not sabotage character ever. I'll never make suicidal suggestions or the like. I always make suggestions that make sense roleplaywise. I know how to separate IC and OOC. But I have a full right to hope for the rolls I like. As well as promoting suggestions that I like and that make sense to my vision of the character.Your fun will be ruined if we switch a playing character? Really? Ouch...
What's being pointed out here is that the rest of us who have sticked with this charachter coming up on seventy five pages feel some affection for and like the character we have crafted, and that we will be displeased if you sabotage him to switch characters.
Great thread and great DM, just finished reading everything. Anyway maybe it would be better to use the left stone to impregnate a consort rather than transforming anyone. The child would likely be more loyal and dependent on us than some random female. This would also make us the literal father of the entire species further cementing night troll unity beneath us. Also would it be possible to set up an illusion of our group inside the house so everyone from the posse rushes in. Then shut he door behind them so they are trapped and set the place on fire.
Great thread and great DM, just finished reading everything. Anyway maybe it would be better to use the left stone to impregnate a consort rather than transforming anyone. The child would likely be more loyal and dependent on us than some random female. This would also make us the literal father of the entire species further cementing night troll unity beneath us. Also would it be possible to set up an illusion of our group inside the house so everyone from the posse rushes in. Then shut he door behind them so they are trapped and set the place on fire.Well, male night trolls are literally incapable of having daughters but of course, the GM has final say.
Night trolls are still capable of working together, as shown by the fact that we're working together with Gwen and the fact that we're not total dunces.QuoteWe're not wolves, and in fact wolves work together better than you assume we would. We're people, we can work together.Night trolls aren't humans. Different morals, different life span, different instincts, different food and no dark god to rule. And humans had many, many wars with nations far less different than different branches of night trolls
By your logic, all human societies should have collapsed long ago.
And by my logic, many human societies had collapsed long time ago.
Depends. If they have a god and goals in common and no reason to hate each other, but one owes another something (a night troll gift would be a great gift indeed), the religious one would probably be willing to work with the other.QuoteYou'd rather not spend it or DIE than spend it on the mermaid? Fool. Seriously, it's good to have allies with the merfolk and a night troll line which can't be so easily slain. If the elves drive us out of their forest, we will have the endless seas.Yes, genius. I don't want to create a totally independent powerful subrace of zealots that most likely will be either enemies or masters for our sons
Do you know what happens when fanatically religious group meets atheistic, less religious or wrong religion group?
Reproduction isn't everything. Just like real life, not everyone wants kids, or wants a a lot of them.QuoteConsorts aren't bound forever. Anyways, Alice has already said we could consortify her.They are. They can't reproduce without night trolls (or maybe troll that converted consort) , that's quite binding. Female night troll can choose their mate freely
So Nocteclaw made a race of underwater creatures without anyone else? She was so desperate for worshippers that she put them in an environment without any sacrifices outside their own kind? And anyways, Nocteclaw isn't nice. I can so see merfolk feeding the night trolls convicts and sacrifices, which if they're our enemies like you claim can only help us.Quotesharks don't compete with wolves. the mermaid is equipped with a number of magical trinkets that allows her to leave the water; the fact that mermaids aren't a land conquering power hints that these trinkets aren't that common. if you want to minimize the competition for our children, creating a night creature that hunts in a completely different ecosystem, and is even unable to naturally enter our children' domain, would be the perfect choice1) Night trolls need to hunt, suitable prey is present only on shores. Ecosystem is same
2) They will be amphibious not marine.
3) They may evolve in many other different kind of night trolls
4) Do you see any seas around? Those merfolks are surely river\lake based
What part of "worships the god/dess of the night" implies "pure evil"? Anyways, I can see in-story reasons for worshipping Nocteclaw, from fear to faith to Nocteclaw's meddling.Quoteif it was up to me we'd be fanatically religious too. religion makes a lot more sense and is an even better world domination tool in a world where gods actually existWell that's exactly why I'd rather see character dead. I don't like religious pure evil fanatics way, not the kind of story I like and not the way I'd like to see character developed. All the story before, like nice relationships with Gwen, or friendship with Alice are much more fun for me. Not evil force that strives to conquer the world, no matter what but race with it's own moral code that want to survive.
As for an even better world domination tool: munchkin detected.What, a night troll can't determine what pragmatic choices are?
Geez. Why do you assume that worshipping Nocteclaw and showing some devotion means that we're slaves to him/her? It's like real religions, except that the god is real. How many Christians would consider themselves or act like slaves to God?Quotebesides, since we're the ones choosing who to get the leftstone, that'd give us a status second only to noctclaw itself among the newly created race.Well, I agree. If we'll be totally obedient to Noctclaw, fanatics will like us and may be not masters but slaves. But then we are slaves of Noctclaw, no much better fate
Says who?Quotewhat? no. mermaids are suitable prey tooMerfolk are very fear resistant. So no, they aren't suitable prey
They need magic to live on land.Quotemermaids are marine, not amphibious. why would a night troll race based on an exclusively marine race be amphibious?Because they obviously can live on land, like mermaid in our tower shows. Besides we should get night troll with mermaid influenced traits not mermaid\night troll hybrid or as you say - troll based on mermaid
No. We get in the good graces of a race and a god/dess. Besides, we can either move closer to shore or ask about this magic they have.Quotei don't see any river either, and merpeople inhabit oceans in df universeMy bad, haven't play DF for a long time. (Still my bad, story included mention that they are from see, forgot about it) But what do you want to do with the problem that we are far from sea? Just spend her away and hope that sometimes, years later we'll get an ally from see? Isn't that a waste of gift?
Where did he say that?Quotethough i at least find it a bit ungraceful of you to prefer to see our fun ruined just because you didn't have it your wayYour fun will be ruined if we switch a playing character? Really? Ouch...
Several possible reasons, but we don't know enough about magic to tell. Most likely, mass producing magical anything isn't economical.Quotethe mermaid on our tower is wearing enchanted jewellery to be able to survive on landSo, why not mass produce such jewelry?
Despite I highly doubt that night troll created will be that merfolklikeWhy? And why does it matter?
Agreed. Let's say...jump and run through the forest?If we barricade, we badly need a reserve escape route.Do we really need to lock ourselves down? Our characters are stealthy and can hide outside pretty wellWe're stealthy, but a posse of elves, most presumably with plant empathy and on their guard, will be very difficult to hide from.
The boarding up of the windows idea could work, but we need traps and barricades as well.
Unless there's a more emotional sentient race in the ocean, the merfolk wouldn't make very good food. Remember, when we first met this one, she was not afraid. And she only got a little twinge of fear later on.She's from a society worshipping a dark god/dess. She's probably familiar with night creatures and hardened. We don't know how they're affected by magical fear...
I must say, I do agree with UR on not converting kelpmier, at least until we understand her better. If she really is serious about the whole, eternal servitude oath thing, THEN convert her.Agreed.
Great thread and great DM, just finished reading everything. Anyway maybe it would be better to use the left stone to impregnate a consort rather than transforming anyone. The child would likely be more loyal and dependent on us than some random female. This would also make us the literal father of the entire species further cementing night troll unity beneath us. Also would it be possible to set up an illusion of our group inside the house so everyone from the posse rushes in. Then shut he door behind them so they are trapped and set the place on fire.I'm not sure, maybe if we can't find anyone who would be a good Left Stoner.
Uh... Wyrm... I do just want to say that I happily think of myself as a slave/servant of God....Oops.
But yeah, I don't think there's anything wrong with not ticking off Nocteclaw. I mean, you guys wouldn't be atheists if you knew God existed. I am fairly certain no one would knowingly piss off a god.Agnostic. But yeah.
What, a night troll can't determine what pragmatic choices are?What is more pragmatic, getting an ally to ensure own survival, now or making long term world conquering plans?
Says who?Story says so. Find an update when we learned that kelpmier is a mermaid
Geez. Why do you assume that worshipping Nocteclaw and showing some devotion means that we're slaves to him/her? It's like real religions, except that the god is real. How many Christians would consider themselves or act like slaves to God?L.O.L. Many Christians (most?) do call themselves slave of God. It's not common in Western Christianity (servant of god is used, instead) , but it is very common in Orthodox Christianity and included in many prayers. Muslims call themselves in the same way.
But yeah, I don't think there's anything wrong with not ticking off Nocteclaw. I mean, you guys wouldn't be atheists if you knew God existed. I am fairly certain no one would knowingly piss off a god.But we have many gods here, while some will not accept us like worshiper, some will do. Nocteclaw admitted that he\she is weak.
Great thread and great DM, just finished reading everything. Anyway maybe it would be better to use the left stone to impregnate a consort rather than transforming anyone. The child would likely be more loyal and dependent on us than some random female. This would also make us the literal father of the entire species further cementing night troll unity beneath us. Also would it be possible to set up an illusion of our group inside the house so everyone from the posse rushes in. Then shut he door behind them so they are trapped and set the place on fire.Well, male night trolls are literally incapable of having daughters but of course, the GM has final say.
Though, the night troll we create will still be of our line, in a way, no matter what. Not by blood, but we did transform her. It'd be an unprecedented thing, really.
I'm not entirely sure how I feel about setting our house on fire. You guys?
Varies on situation and goals, and they're not mutually exclusive.QuoteWhat, a night troll can't determine what pragmatic choices are?What is more pragmatic, getting an ally to ensure own survival, now or making long term world conquering plans?
...Could you at least provide a page?QuoteSays who?Story says so. Find an update when we learned that kelpmier is a mermaid
A. Not all, though. Many just consider themselves children of God. I know, I listened to the sermons and read the Bible. Long story. Point is, not everyone is a slave.QuoteGeez. Why do you assume that worshipping Nocteclaw and showing some devotion means that we're slaves to him/her? It's like real religions, except that the god is real. How many Christians would consider themselves or act like slaves to God?L.O.L. Many Christians (most?) do call themselves slave of God. It's not common in Western Christianity (servant of god is used, instead) , but it is very common in Orthodox Christianity and included in many prayers. Muslims call themselves in the same way.
And Nocteclaw is surely much more tyrannic than Christian God (ninja'd)
What other gods want us? And how many gods would shun us for worshipping Nocteclaw, but not for being a night troll (literally BORN from Nocteclaw's dangly bits?)QuoteBut yeah, I don't think there's anything wrong with not ticking off Nocteclaw. I mean, you guys wouldn't be atheists if you knew God existed. I am fairly certain no one would knowingly piss off a god.But we have many gods here, while some will not accept us like worshiper, some will do. Nocteclaw admitted that he\she is weak.
In reply to the GreatWyrmGold, well I'm pretty new to this whole thing but I thought you could use the dark/shadow magic stuff to create illusions. Granted only when it's dark, so we might have to board up windows and all the other exits besides the main door to keep the inside dark but I think some people were suggesting that course of action regardless. Our group could hide in nearby trees, the less stealthy members further away with the most stealthy close to the house to set it on fire and pick off survivors. We could also dig a pit, possibly with our artifact spear within the house. Said pit could be covered up with an illusion as well so that they walk right into it. The bottom of the pit could have wooden spikes, or maybe a dangerous animal (yeti lol). On another note, I am against using the left stone on the lesbian (whose name I forget). I do feel that she should be turned at some point preferably soon but the left stone simply fails to play to any of her strengths and it could be used better.You can use dark manipulation more or less that way, but dawn is breaking and I'm not sure how exact the illusions are. Why would we put our artifact spear in the pit? I'm also against using the Left Stone on Alice, unless maybe she's willing to have lots of kids despite her nature.
The artifact spear can use earth magic right? Good chance to practice using it by creating a pit?Oh, I thought you meant to put it in the pit as a spike.
Also its dark outside but with boarded windows the inside of the house should be dark so illusions should still be applicable. At least that's my take on it.It's dark, but dawning.
Anyway even without the illusions, pits with spikes and covered up with foliage/leaves/sticks could be used as a trap and is something that can be done well enough in real life for hunting animals so why not people/elves.Elves are intelligent enough to have heard of this kind of trap, old enough to learn how to recognise it, and magical enough to chat with trees about its presence. Still a good idea.
You blink. A mermaid follower of Nocteclaw, the goddess of darkness. Your father was an Atheist, and raised you as such, but you know Nocteclaw is the god of choice for pious Night Trolls. You recall one of your much older brothers visiting the cave and talking about Merfolk. They come from a land so far beneath the waves it is always night, and the pious among their ranks view Night Trolls as divine beings who punish the land dwelling mortals for harvesting Merfolk Bones.
They have a reputation for being a stoic people, hard to scare and thus being poor prey, so many coastal Night Trolls would choose instead to use them as allies. You recall that they can be converted, but doing so in a way to allow them to survive on land is tricky.
What other gods want us? And how many gods would shun us for worshipping Nocteclaw, but not for being a night trollWho knows? Maybe even Sol will accept us under certain conditions. We know almost nothing about the Pantheon.
QuoteYou blink. A mermaid follower of Nocteclaw, the goddess of darkness. Your father was an Atheist, and raised you as such, but you know Nocteclaw is the god of choice for pious Night Trolls. You recall one of your much older brothers visiting the cave and talking about Merfolk. They come from a land so far beneath the waves it is always night, and the pious among their ranks view Night Trolls as divine beings who punish the land dwelling mortals for harvesting Merfolk Bones.
They have a reputation for being a stoic people, hard to scare and thus being poor prey, so many coastal Night Trolls would choose instead to use them as allies. You recall that they can be converted, but doing so in a way to allow them to survive on land is tricky.QuoteWhat other gods want us? And how many gods would shun us for worshipping Nocteclaw, but not for being a night trollWho knows? Maybe even Sol will accept us under certain conditions. We know almost nothing about the Pantheon.
Does the dark manipulation only work at night or does it only work in the dark. If it only works at night than too bad, but if it can work during the day so long as it is dark, then we could make the inside of the house dark by blocking the windows (and hence the light) and thereby allowing us to place an illusion within the house covering up the traps or creating distractions. And if distractions and spike pit traps are out of the question than burning them in the house could still be a possibility. BTW I think it would be nice to use the gift of the inferno to create a son relatively soon. Sounds really powerful especially in a forested area such as this. He could really prove to be a valuable asset, possibly more powerful than our main character even. Also if we assume our offspring get the first gift that we had for breeding, it would mean he could also create another inferno baby with time. Last thought, maybe from now on we should always have one of those birds nearby when we travel or hunt, just as a last ditch escape plan we could ride them away to safety (they are big enough to ride right?).In the OP it says that dark manipulation works in a "low light environment"
I absolutely love how you put that. "Literally BORN from Nocteclaw's dangly bits." Conjures a nice little mental image, don't it? :-\
But yeah. We shouldn't look at this like Christianity, we should look at it like pagan religion. Christian, Jewish, and Islamic faiths don't include a pantheon. Polytheism is much different than monotheism. What about famous guys, like Odysseus? He angered some gods, and was buddies with others, right? The cow-chick (Starts with 'h' right? Heria?) and the sea-penis (Starts with a 'p' anyway, has a trident, posy-somethin'. Was he a flower?) tried to kill him, right? So we could be friends with some deities, and enemies with others?
Or, we could just piss them all of and try to make our own way, but that ends with a lot of smiting at the end of the day.
Because, remember, these are undoubtedly, ball-droppingly real gods. There will be divine interference.
On that note, is Noctalon still androgynous? It doesn't have any balls left, unless it has a hernia.
Yeah, remember? She told his men to not eat the cows on her Isle, and they didn't when Odysseus was there to command them, but a'fore he could even fluff his pillow they had that shit on Bar-B-Q.I absolutely love how you put that. "Literally BORN from Nocteclaw's dangly bits." Conjures a nice little mental image, don't it? :-\
But yeah. We shouldn't look at this like Christianity, we should look at it like pagan religion. Christian, Jewish, and Islamic faiths don't include a pantheon. Polytheism is much different than monotheism. What about famous guys, like Odysseus? He angered some gods, and was buddies with others, right? The cow-chick (Starts with 'h' right? Heria?) and the sea-penis (Starts with a 'p' anyway, has a trident, posy-somethin'. Was he a flower?) tried to kill him, right? So we could be friends with some deities, and enemies with others?
Or, we could just piss them all of and try to make our own way, but that ends with a lot of smiting at the end of the day.
Because, remember, these are undoubtedly, ball-droppingly real gods. There will be divine interference.
On that note, is Noctalon still androgynous? It doesn't have any balls left, unless it has a hernia.
I think you're getting your Greek gods mixed up with other pantheons. The first one (I'm guessing) is Hera, though I don't think she had anything to do with cows, and the 'sea-penis' is Poseidon.
Yeah, remember? She told his men to not eat the cows on her Isle, and they didn't when Odysseus was there to command them, but a'fore he could even fluff his pillow they had that shit on Bar-B-Q.
I coulda sworn... Yes. It was Helios. My bad.Yeah, remember? She told his men to not eat the cows on her Isle, and they didn't when Odysseus was there to command them, but a'fore he could even fluff his pillow they had that shit on Bar-B-Q.
You're thinking of Helios, the Sun God. Hera was the one that hated Hercules.
derails aside, can we have some consensus on elf-murder techniques for the immediate future?Stabbing with sharp things tends to work well. So does any form of fire, really.
I coulda sworn... Yes. It was Helios. My bad.Yeah, remember? She told his men to not eat the cows on her Isle, and they didn't when Odysseus was there to command them, but a'fore he could even fluff his pillow they had that shit on Bar-B-Q.
You're thinking of Helios, the Sun God. Hera was the one that hated Hercules.
But Hera was a cow-goddess, right?
derails aside, can we have some consensus on elf-murder techniques for the immediate future?
Actually, Hera is a goddess of cows, among other things.Yeah, see?
Actually, Hera is a goddess of cows, among other things.Yeah, see?
Each pantheon had their own deities for their own stuff. All the gods have a sphere, there's not a 'housewife' sphere. (Actually, is there?)
I mean come on, why can't you accept the fact that she's a strong cow god that don't need no man?
We could, but honestly it's just easier to catapult their heads forward into the future.
Because she was basically goddess of the 'housewife' sphere.Really?
Well, we do know that Sol hates Nocteclaw and presumably hates all servants of Nocteclaw. We also know that night trolls were created from Nocteclaw. Therefore, it's a fair guess that followers of Sol who don't run from us will have a kill-on-sight mentality.QuoteWhat other gods want us? And how many gods would shun us for worshipping Nocteclaw, but not for being a night trollWho knows? Maybe even Sol will accept us under certain conditions. We know almost nothing about the Pantheon.
derails aside, can we have some consensus on elf-murder techniques for the immediate future?Stab them with the spear?
Not mutually exclusive with the cow thing.Because she was basically goddess of the 'housewife' sphere.Actually, Hera is a goddess of cows, among other things.Yeah, see?
Each pantheon had their own deities for their own stuff. All the gods have a sphere, there's not a 'housewife' sphere. (Actually, is there?)
I mean come on, why can't you accept the fact that she's a strong cow god that don't need no man?
Well, we do know that Sol hates Nocteclaw and presumably hates all servants of NocteclawThat's why I'd rather not serve Nocteclaw
We also know that night trolls were created from Nocteclaw.Created is not a right word, it wasn't a conscious act from anyone. Night trolls appeared accidentally
Therefore, it's a fair guess that followers of Sol who don't run from us will have a kill-on-sight mentality.True. But I said under certain conditions
So am I right in assuming that no one feels particularly strong about what course of action to take thus far? I'd also appreciate hearing what some of you think regarding my previously stated plan about the trap with illusions/pit/possible last resort fire.I love the plan.
So am I right in assuming that no one feels particularly strong about what course of action to take thus far? I'd also appreciate hearing what some of you think regarding my previously stated plan about the trap with illusions/pit/possible last resort fire.Take out the fire and it could work pretty well. I just don't want to burn our only house down.
We're of Nocteclaw's flesh and blood, we're going to be treated as Nocteclaw's servants by all but the most tolerant of Sol's servants.QuoteWell, we do know that Sol hates Nocteclaw and presumably hates all servants of NocteclawThat's why I'd rather not serve Nocteclaw
Whatever, Sol's worshippers still won't be fond of us. Because we were made from Nocteclaw.QuoteWe also know that night trolls were created from Nocteclaw.Created is not a right word, it wasn't a conscious act from anyone. Night trolls appeared accidentally
Sigh. You're alienating people who might help us to try and get in the good graces of people who probably would kill us first?QuoteTherefore, it's a fair guess that followers of Sol who don't run from us will have a kill-on-sight mentality.True. But I said under certain conditions
We also have the tower, but I agree.So am I right in assuming that no one feels particularly strong about what course of action to take thus far? I'd also appreciate hearing what some of you think regarding my previously stated plan about the trap with illusions/pit/possible last resort fire.Take out the fire and it could work pretty well. I just don't want to burn our only house down.
Also, should we hide the lockbox outside in case they somehow win and find it?What lockbox? Didn't we leave that behind? Why would we bring it with?
I'm standing behind my eon manipulation walls because it seems like it could be used to greater effect then a pit trap, it also stands more chance of being successful roll-wise.Agreed.
Don't get me wrong, i'm all for learning new techniques, but *not* when failure could result in significant losses of life and limb.
The last resort scorched earth policy is also a good idea.
Didn't we leave it at the tower?...
Which is not the barn?
Well, look at that, they delivered a new consort right to our door! How convenient. If we capture the mage, what gift should we use? Maybe Withering Touch? Seriously, you can't have enough wizards.
Short-term, Corruptor's idea is a good one, if it works. As for the mage, put her in a time-loop like we did with Phyros--saves her for conversion if we so choose, and takes her out of the fight quickly using one of our best skills.
Lol, GWG, good suggestion. Just one little problem - Mage is male
I am against any attempts to catch the warrior. If we lucky get her alive = nice. If not - too many consorts isn't in our best interests anyway. Our goal is to win the battle
I have been lurking the forum for a while, and one the reason why I decided to make an account is because of this game. I have followed it since the beginning, and would like to thank Weirdsound for this terrific story. Keep up the good work.
As for a suggestion, I think that the elf capitive should tied up in the barn to use as a hostage. When the warband gets here, it should be top priority to take the wizard down as he is probably the only ranged attacker.
Lol, GWG, good suggestion. Just one little problem - Mage is male
If we time-loop her, we can extract her at our leisure. Why would eon manipulation give away our position? Presence, sure, but they knew that...Well, look at that, they delivered a new consort right to our door! How convenient. If we capture the mage, what gift should we use? Maybe Withering Touch? Seriously, you can't have enough wizards.Agreed but still only capture her if convenient. Our primary objective needs to remain survival especially with our unborn child nearby. Eon manipulation sounds great so long as it does not give away our position any earlier than necessary.
Short-term, Corruptor's idea is a good one, if it works. As for the mage, put her in a time-loop like we did with Phyros--saves her for conversion if we so choose, and takes her out of the fight quickly using one of our best skills.
Side note: why do we still have beach sand in our pocket? Also if the spear can turn items into sand maybe later we could turn sand into items. Or people into sand?Because the GM never removed it despite us asking him to?
Lol, GWG, good suggestion. Just one little problem - Mage is male...Somehow I mixed the female warrior with the mage.
I am against any attempts to catch the warrior. If we lucky get her alive = nice. If not - too many consorts isn't in our best interests anyway. Our goal is to win the battleOkay. Fair enough. Warrior consort isn't as good as warrior/mage consort anyhow.
We can always hire mercanaries and thugs as muscle, spellcasters are in shorter supply.Creating a hole in the ceiling is a possibility. Another thing that can be done is having our character transport our companions at least an hour into the future. This might be hard to do in the thick of battle though. Also this could just lead us into a worst predicament, if they call reinforcement. Maybe it would be better to just send Alice, Gwen, and us into the future before the posse even gets here and hopefully evade them.
Now about the barn, is there more than one exit? And if not... escape plan for if it goes bad?
Nah, we made our bed; let's lie in it.We can always hire mercanaries and thugs as muscle, spellcasters are in shorter supply.Creating a hole in the ceiling is a possibility. Another thing that can be done is having our character transport our companions at least an hour into the future. This might be hard to do in the thick of battle though. Also this could just lead us into a worst predicament, if they call reinforcement. Maybe it would be better to just send Alice, Gwen, and us into the future before the posse even gets here and hopefully evade them.
Now about the barn, is there more than one exit? And if not... escape plan for if it goes bad?
Side note: why do we still have beach sand in our pocket?Pocket Sand?
Mage is a complicating factor, i just realised that our plan is basically hoping he doesn't screw us over. So, i'm wondering, what kind of mage might he be? What might that mean? and what do we do depending on the form of magic?Use the trees' affiliation with the elves to our advantage - go outside and converse loudly about our plans to lure the mage into the magic-nullifying zone our artifact creates inside the barn. If the trees rat on us, and the elven mage believes it, hopefully that should lead him to be overly cautious - giving us the chance to eliminate his allies.
We aren't very strong fire mage and infuriating the trees is not the best ideaAlso, we'd risk setting fire to the barn and possibly everything else in the forest's area.
If Weird decides to go with the flanking plan, I think the flanker should be Alice because she is probaly better at hiding than Gwen.Well, Gwen's kinda trolly too...
Edit: Our main guy should stay in the barn to attract the attackers as the attackers would want to bum rush the night troll.
If Weird decides to go with the flanking plan, I think the flanker should be Alice because she is probaly better at hiding than Gwen.
Edit: Our main guy should stay in the barn to attract the attackers as the attackers would want to bum rush the night troll.
Can't she only shift forward or backwards in time?
Mage is a complicating factor, i just realised that our plan is basically hoping he doesn't screw us over. So, i'm wondering, what kind of mage might he be? What might that mean? and what do we do depending on the form of magic?Use the trees' affiliation with the elves to our advantage - go outside and converse loudly about our plans to lure the mage into the magic-nullifying zone our artifact creates inside the barn. If the trees rat on us, and the elven mage believes it, hopefully that should lead him to be overly cautious - giving us the chance to eliminate his allies.
Creating a hole in the ceiling is a possibility.
Oh, and we should really make a point of securely restraining the elf rogue before the battle. Rogues tend to take opportunities like huge chaotic battles to make escapes and/or stabby stabby their captors.
Big no on casting anything on Alice, we have no time to waste and casting spell on someone wounded midcombat isn't the best idea because of possible miscasts( BTW, can't resist and not say "so, Alice is as useful as a human as she would be as a night troll?")
I'd say attack elves with our spear AND create illusionary allied troll or two.
Eon manipulation may be a better option for direct damage, but we need decoys, and act as a decoy ourself... So my vote for outright attack and creating illusions
Throw Alice in to the future, so when this is all over we can get some medical supplies and take care of her pretty major wound. She's out of this fight.Agreed, saving Alice is our first priority. In addition to her value to us, her death could potentially jeoperdize our alliance with Foghorn. Once she's clear we can dispose of the two onrushing elves.
Take care of the two elves with time magic by splitting parts of them in to the future, or stopping their heart.
Throw Alice in to the future, so when this is all over we can get some medical supplies and take care of her pretty major wound. She's out of this fight.Liking this plan.
Take care of the two elves with time magic by splitting parts of them in to the future, or stopping their heart.
Throw Alice in to the future, so when this is all over we can get some medical supplies and take care of her pretty major wound. She's out of this fight.Agreed, saving Alice is our first priority. In addition to her value to us, her death could potentially jeoperdize our alliance with Foghorn. Once she's clear we can dispose of the two onrushing elves.
Take care of the two elves with time magic by splitting parts of them in to the future, or stopping their heart.
Great update btw, aside from the Nat 1 heh.
I am quite tired of that throw everything in the future... Reusing same things time after time is just boringShe's currently gushing blood from a pierced artery. She'll bleed out in minutes if we don't act immediately.
Nothing will kill Alice if we kill elves first, but our failed spell can kill Alice easily ... and it well tie us to the barn.
We just need to distract enemy from Alice with illusions and\or our attack.
Let's not waste our magic on anything that doesn't harm elves
So yeah after this is over we may want to quickly convert Alice I would think should also heal her. Or we could just loan her our necklace that has healing powers.I'd suggest amulet; I don't think night trolls actually have greater injury tolerance than humans.
All you act if she can't mend her own wound. I am pretty sure she can plus she has some rope on her that can be use to slow the blood flow. With some shredded leather she should be able to make some sort of make shift bandage and once we reveal ourselves most the elves will be focus on the big evil troll not Alice.Actually, I'm acting like the elves advancing on Alice might not die at once...
I think illusions of monsters are a great idea, as they don't think magic works in this barn and will assume they are real.
I think illusions of monsters are a great idea, as they don't think magic works in this barn and will assume they are real.
Why would they think illusions don't work in the barn? As far as I know they shouldn't even be aware of what type of magic we are capable of casting. That said I agree that illusions have a good chance of being useful. Are we limited to only one action per turn or can we mix illusions with eon magic perhaps?
I think it would be more they think there are more and scarier night trolls that what there really is.And from whence did these monsters come?
Laugh evilly.And monologue a bit.
Use our hypnotic gaze as well! They won't run if their self preservation instincts are gone (well, not away from us, at any rate).
Quote misfire!
I suggest we jump to buy time, cast a spell at the elves, and land if we haven't yet. After that, we deal with Axey. Okay?
Jump directly above, perhaps into rafters or another suitable perch, if no such perch exists then perhaps directly on top of an opponent.
We probably have a great disadvantage with the time limits here. I vote for dodging and otherwise buying time.This is what jumping into the rafters is for.
If you give an elf a torch, he's warm for a day. If you burn him alive, he's warm for the rest of his life.
Time to break out the Fire Manipulation!
I disagree... We need Gwen healthy, because we'll have at least 3 females (maybe 4) that we somehow need to transfer to safer place for conversions... Leapstab one of the elves fighting Gwen with the spear... And shout to Alice that she should treat her woundGwen IS a valuable asset, but her two enemies aren't very formidible and have substandard wooden weapons. Imo she's very likely to dispatch them in short order.
I vote we help Alice then deal with the elves in the pit.+1
I don't suggest it, but if anything we should speed time in the barn *up* not down, we don't need to give our enemies more time to think of a way to deal with us.
Oh, yes I meant speeding up the time, just used the wrong word
It's a bad idea to fight with enemy mage, we know nothing about him... and we are in a bad strategical position to face him... He is waitying for us, not vice versa
If we speed up the time we may allow Gwen to give birth ( that's why we need to kill survivors sloooowly) and convert at least 2 females. Then we'll ready to face next wave of the elves if retreat can launch it that fast
Really guys, killing elves fast it's a waste of fear
We shouldn't kill the female warrior leader so hastily - we should restrain her, she could prove to be a strong consort.+1 to all, and to all a good night troll.
Next, we should cripple the other wounded elves so that they die slowly and helplessly, to feed Gwen some fear.
The elf contemplating suicide gives us a good opportunity to deal with the mage. Go up to him, and make him a deal - he can die in agony at our hands, or he can live if he does but one little task for us. Tell him to call out to the mage, to shout triumphantly that the night trolls are dead and the artifact spear won't budge for those who have no magical talent. We should warn him beforehand that if his performance is unconvincing or treacherous, his will die in even greater agony that if he refuses outright.
Okay but if he doesn't go for our deal can we decapitate him and throw his head outside?+1 if that happens, so long as we prolong his pain a bit. After all, we're a man of our word. Er, troll of our word, rather.
We shouldn't kill the female warrior leader so hastily - we should restrain her, she could prove to be a strong consort.
Next, we should cripple the other wounded elves so that they die slowly and helplessly, to feed Gwen some fear.
The elf contemplating suicide gives us a good opportunity to deal with the mage. Go up to him, and make him a deal - he can die in agony at our hands, or he can live if he does but one little task for us. Tell him to call out to the mage, to shout triumphantly that the night trolls are dead but the artifact spear won't budge for those who have no magical talent. We should warn him beforehand that if his performance is unconvincing or treacherous, he will die in even greater agony than if he refuses
outright.
Then, assuming that goes well, we can lie in ambush for the mage, ready to take off his head with eon magic.
Let the one elf go, we promised him.
Save the axeelf, convert the rogue, between two consorts and us we should be able to carry the axeelf and Alice. If we weren't to convert anyone yet and head home, we'd probably need to abandon both consorts since I can't imagine Gwen would be good at carrying people when that heavily pregnant.
While we convert the rogue, have Gwen loot the bodies.
Once we have a second consort, we can reassess our situation, interrogate the axeelf, and go from there.
Sound like a plan?
Let the one elf go, we promised him.+1 to all, sounds good. Especially agreed about the surviving elf - villains who keep their word are invariably more dangerous than ones who do not. Besides, one terrified survivor speaking of the posse's massacre will spread fear and may discourage elves from joining such ventures in the future.
Save the axeelf, convert the rogue, between two consorts and us we should be able to carry the axeelf and Alice. If we weren't to convert anyone yet and head home, we'd probably need to abandon both consorts since I can't imagine Gwen would be good at carrying people when that heavily pregnant.
While we convert the rogue, have Gwen loot the bodies.
Once we have a second consort, we can reassess our situation, interrogate the axeelf, and go from there.
Sound like a plan?
Let the one elf go, we promised him.+1 to all, sounds good. Especially agreed about the surviving elf - villains who keep their word are invariably more dangerous than ones who do not. Besides, one terrified survivor speaking of the posse's massacre will spread fear and may discourage elves from joining such ventures in the future.
Save the axeelf, convert the rogue, between two consorts and us we should be able to carry the axeelf and Alice. If we weren't to convert anyone yet and head home, we'd probably need to abandon both consorts since I can't imagine Gwen would be good at carrying people when that heavily pregnant.
While we convert the rogue, have Gwen loot the bodies.
Once we have a second consort, we can reassess our situation, interrogate the axeelf, and go from there.
Sound like a plan?
I recommend the Gift of Puppetry for the Warrior, the Gift of Amnesia for the Rogue.
A mindlessly obedient soldier and an assassin who can erase the memories of selective targets for us - quite a combo.
I also like the idea someone posted about trying to influence the surviving elf - perhaps tell him that he can go with no strings attached as we promised, but if he wished he could forge an alliance with us. Play on his fear by telling him that allies of ours need not fear the rising forces of darkness. Play on his greed and ambition by promising gold and power for those who aid us.
Fiery wings are useless for stealthy ranger... even more - it's bad
Natural armor is also bad for stealthy characters
Alice is AMAZING. period.
She has many skill to convert into useful traits. Her orientation and genetics may convert nuicely too... We may wait forever for someone better
If our first child is a daughter, she wouldn’t be to have kids that are night trolls, but can still have kids with a mortal and have half-trolls right?nope, we'll have only sons
Night trolls can not die of old age, right?Yep
If you are suggesting conversion, please suggest a gift to convert with.I was hoping for discussion on that.
Plus, it's common courtesy.Let the one elf go, we promised him.+1 to all, sounds good. Especially agreed about the surviving elf - villains who keep their word are invariably more dangerous than ones who do not. Besides, one terrified survivor speaking of the posse's massacre will spread fear and may discourage elves from joining such ventures in the future.
Save the axeelf, convert the rogue, between two consorts and us we should be able to carry the axeelf and Alice. If we weren't to convert anyone yet and head home, we'd probably need to abandon both consorts since I can't imagine Gwen would be good at carrying people when that heavily pregnant.
While we convert the rogue, have Gwen loot the bodies.
Once we have a second consort, we can reassess our situation, interrogate the axeelf, and go from there.
Sound like a plan?
I recommend the Gift of Puppetry for the Warrior, the Gift of Amnesia for the Rogue.Sounds good.
A mindlessly obedient soldier and an assassin who can erase the memories of selective targets for us - quite a combo.
I also like the idea someone posted about trying to influence the surviving elf - perhaps tell him that he can go with no strings attached as we promised, but if he wished he could forge an alliance with us. Play on his fear by telling him that allies of ours need not fear the rising forces of darkness. Play on his greed and ambition by promising gold and power for those who aid us.Hm...
And it's really an ideal time to leftstone Alice... Admit that We will not get good enough gift for her soon, might as well upgrade her, get a strong ally NOW and don't care about less number of kids that muchI'm not sure if converting Alice while she's unconscious is a good idea, but this is as good a time as ever to discuss the gift to give her.
Let's not waste the left stone gift to - maybe, someday we will find a way to convert the mermaid and deliver her to the sea
We should make a little army of consorts, NOW and go back to the elves... and burn them down. they lost their best fighters we should not let them to recover
-snip-Ooh, good idea!
Agreed. We should also tell the elf that if he sides with us we could heal him at our tower.
Side Note: Can we please try and learn necromancy soon? Maybe send out one of our soon to be new consorts to find the necromancer who escaped before.Who?
Oh and no left stone to Ukrainian Ranger! The gift that gives fiery wings and limited immortality sounds like a better gift to me. I really want to save the left stone for someone AMAZING or use to just have a female child. The rest of its good though and I agree about not wasting our best gifts on consorts.We're not stoning the GM!
We have stealth based party... and use stealth constantlyWell, not at home, but yes. It's also stupid to give someone a gift that destroys one of that person's greatest talents.
And I fail to see, combat gift = immortalityThe Phoenix gift has a 1-Up built in. Emphasis on "1."
Let the elf go, even though he almost killed Alice, he made up for it by possibly saving the lives of all of us by betraying the mage. Loot the mage for any thing which could be helpful with magic. I think Gwen should eat until she is satisfied, even if it includes the warrior. I think that our raid was successful, enough with getting one captive, a caring for Gwen’s and the future child’s well being by feeding them, and most importantly coming out alive. I do not think we should risk all that was gained by staying any longer than needed. Also I think that the elf warrior should not be brought along because of two reasons. One is that it will be harder to feed a growing group since, we already have Alice, the merwoman (Something the III), Gwen, a child on the way, maybe another wife, and our night trollself. Our only steady and no risk option for food is our flock of lovebirds. The other reason is that with more night trolls and night trolls consorts, there is going to be a high demand/need for mortals to eat. More mortals killed= more enemies in some cases. Although, I know there are some plus to getting the warrior, I just don’t like the feel of getting her as a consort.More consorts also means more people we can send out to hunt.
One more thing is, I rather have our guy just start a family with Gwen and spend our gifts on the children because we can teach our children the way of the night troll more easily than a grown adult.More consorts means more buns in the oven, and anyways the consorts don't start as infants.
In short: let’s just get home.How? Two or three people plus gear plus loot to carry, two people (one pregnant) to carry it.
2 Q’s for Weirdsound:Half-trolls?
If our first child is a daughter, she wouldn’t be to have kids that are night trolls, but can still have kids with a mortal and have half-trolls right?
Night trolls can not die of old age, right?
Let the elf go, even though he almost killed Alice, he made up for it by possibly saving the lives of all of us by betraying the mage. Loot the mage for any thing which could be helpful with magic. I think Gwen should eat until she is satisfied, even if it includes the warrior. I think that our raid was successful, enough with getting one captive, a caring for Gwen’s and the future child’s well being by feeding them, and most importantly coming out alive. I do not think we should risk all that was gained by staying any longer than needed. Also I think that the elf warrior should not be brought along because of two reasons. One is that it will be harder to feed a growing group since, we already have Alice, the merwoman (Something the III), Gwen, a child on the way, maybe another wife, and our night trollself. Our only steady and no risk option for food is our flock of lovebirds. The other reason is that with more night trolls and night trolls consorts, there is going to be a high demand/need for mortals to eat. More mortals killed= more enemies in some cases. Although, I know there are some plus to getting the warrior, I just don’t like the feel of getting her as a consort.
One more thing is, I rather have our guy just start a family with Gwen and spend our gifts on the children because we can teach our children the way of the night troll more easily than a grown adult.
In short: let’s just get home.
2 Q’s for Weirdsound:
If our first child is a daughter, she wouldn’t be to have kids that are night trolls, but can still have kids with a mortal and have half-trolls right?
Night trolls can not die of old age, right?
We have a stealth based party... and use stealth constantly
And I fail to see how combat gift = immortality
The mermaid seriously advised us not to pray to Nocteclaw without adequate training. If you wanna risk we may do that... but I suspect that failure will lead to seriuos problems
Problem with impregnating consort with the left stone
And Alice is smart enough to have kids (Besides I know that she'll answer something like - "I don't want to but if that will be required I'll do" + night troll instincts will kick in + I think that some lesbian trait is likely)
And we do need to convert Alice now,and if you all are so opposed to the left stoning let's use the combat gift... But don't delay conversion further.
The mermaid seriously advised us not to pray to Nocteclaw without adequate training. If you wanna risk we may do that... but I suspect that failure will lead to seriuos problemsI agree that converting her is a good idea, but not right now. We can do it after we get back to the tower and she has a chance to recover.
Problem with impregnating consort with the left stone
And Alice is smart enough to have kids (Besides I know that she'll answer something like - "I don't want to but if that will be required I'll do" + night troll instincts will kick in + I think that some lesbian trait is likely)
And we do need to convert Alice now,and if you all are so opposed to the left stoning let's use the combat gift... But don't delay conversion further.
Why waste time and wait until Alice recover? And why do we need to go back to the tower? We need to keep terrorizing the retreat.
I have AN IDEA!
As we know, while we convert someone we deconstruct them... Let's try to combine 2 elves while they are blobs. And use the puppeting gift, in that way we may get big night troll consort with split personality, probably mad, but loyal and obedient...
I have AN IDEA!
As we know, while we convert someone we deconstruct them... Let's try to combine 2 elves while they are blobs. And use the puppeting gift, in that way we may get big night troll consort with split personality, probably mad, but loyal and obedient...
+1
Why stop at two? Have one of them be the immortality/wings gift.
I have AN IDEA!
As we know, while we convert someone we deconstruct them... Let's try to combine 2 elves while they are blobs. And use the puppeting gift, in that way we may get big night troll consort with split personality, probably mad, but loyal and obedient...
+1
Why stop at two? Have one of them be the immortality/wings gift.
two = less likely to mess up.
And puppeting gift is a must, mad night trolls need to be controlled
So I propose
1) Force the elf at exit to stay and watch
2) Let Gwen enjoy the meal
3) Combine the rogue elf, the axeelf and gift of puppetry in one new consort
Then we'll decide what to do with Alice
I am opposed to converting Alice for many reasons that I will explain later, once it become more relevant. As for converting the rouge elf, it should be done some other time, instead of out in the open. I don’t think the warrior needs to be taken because, it will encumber us. I feel so hesitant to expand the number of consorts we have because the negative consequence of doing so is that we will not be able to be have a good relationship at all with the wives, if we just covert them and then move on to another. Numerous consorts would unhappy with their change (if not wooed and comforted) and not be mentally health as a result. I would think that a solid intimate wife-husband relationships, is the best environment for raising children in. If the wife (wives) is happy and the children are happy, then our character will be happy.
We should stay low for a few days at the tower and just learn and train.
I'm pretty sure it says in the description that just once, the person can be brought back to life after dying (that's the limited immortality I spoke of). Yeah we do use stealth a lot but we don't need Alice specifically to use stealth that much. It's usually just us. I'm not saying we never need her to be stealthy just saying the need for her to be stealthy isn't really any stronger than the need for any other member of our group. It is also important to keep in mind we just got another stealthy female capable of being transformed into a consort. This one might even be better in that regard although honestly we have relatively little to go on as far as guessing how skilled she is. Last thing, I want to be flexible and reach an agreement with everyone as often as possible. I personally do not think the Left Stone is the best gift for Alice. I also think it could be put to better use elsewhere. I understand you feel strongly about converting Alice, specifically with the left stone gift, even though I disagree. So yeah I was trying to suggest a decent compromise but you seem to dislike my suggestion. Do you have another gift you'd like to use other than the left stone that we might all be able to agree on?Alice would lose her woodlore and stealth abilities to the Phoenix gift. Alice actually has stealth and such; we can't expect our new consorts to learn stealth and whatnot right off the bat.
The mermaid seriously advised us not to pray to Nocteclaw without adequate training. If you wanna risk we may do that... but I suspect that failure will lead to seriuos problemsHm, forgot that. Did she mean "Asking for aid" prayer or "What people do IRL" or "Ask for advice" prayer?
Problem with impregnating consort with the left stoneWhy do we need to convert Alice while she's unconscious? Couldn't we at least wait until she's awake so it's less...creepy?
And Alice is smart enough to have kids (Besides I know that she'll answer something like - "I don't want to but if that will be required I'll do" + night troll instincts will kick in + I think that some lesbian trait is likely)
And we do need to convert Alice now,and if you all are so opposed to the left stoning let's use the combat gift... But don't delay conversion further.
And force the elf to stay, not kill but let it see how her friends get eaten\converted and generate sweet fear... Then release a mad elf
Why waste time and wait until Alice recover? And why do we need to go back to the tower? We need to keep terrorizing the retreat.With an increasingly pregnant consort and a bunch of loot? We should drop at least the loot, prisoner(s) if any, and Gwen off at the more defensible location. Anyways, the elves know we're here, we can't stay until Alice heals...
I have AN IDEA!...
As we know, while we convert someone we deconstruct them... Let's try to combine 2 elves while they are blobs. And use the puppeting gift, in that way we may get big night troll consort with split personality, probably mad, but loyal and obedient...
So I proposeI'm not sure about 3, and am against 1. 2 and 4 are fine.
1) Force the elf at exit to stay and watch
2) Let Gwen enjoy the meal
3) Combine the rogue elf, the axeelf and gift of puppetry in one new consort
Then we'll decide what to do with Alice
In fact I'd prefer to have Gwen as our only real wife and few babymaking gift sinks... I also prefer quality over quantity... (that's why I want to risk with fusion)
But we must convert Alice, that's out of the question... One of the reasons I want to left stone her - to not create jealousy between Gwen and Alice... Technically Alice will not be our wife if we turn her into female night troll
I think there's plenty of fear in the elves who know they're next.You can't have enough fear. And we need to delay the second way of attack
Why do we need to convert Alice while she's unconscious?It's imposable to convert unconscious, we need to extract soul, remember? so we'll have to wake up her
Hm, forgot that. Did she mean "Asking for aid" prayer or "What people do IRL" or "Ask for advice" prayer?Hm, reread that update, she meant invoking power, probably simple praying isn't dangerous
We have a grand total of one consort at the moment - I would not advocate risking Alice by attempting a conversion while severely wounded, nor do I think trying the risky unknown process of combining two potential consorts at once is wise - don't get me wrong, it's a fantastic idea but one that we should try once we're more established, after we have at least four consorts.
I still advocate transforming the warrior first then making our way back to the tower to provide Alice with further medical treatment and a safe base of operations to convert the rogue and for Gwen to give birth, if the fear and food of today's events push her over the edge.
As for Alice's gift when we do convert her - I suggest a powerful one like the Wings of Flame. Her personality and orientation make her unsuited for the Left Stone gift, in my honest opinion.
I would not advocate risking Alice by attempting a conversion while severely wounded,What risk? Do you release that conversion is melting body and soul in one glob... wounded or not it doesn't matter
I suggest a powerful one like the Wings of Flame.I see nothing really powerful in it
UKR makes a good point. We should do any and all conversions at our tower.
One more minion would be great at this point, and it would be nice to have a warrior in case our stealth and magical abilities don't always hold up. I recomend turning the warrior, looting, and retreating with our prisoner in tow, during which giving alice the healing necklace so that by the time we are done here she may be capable of travelling on her own, or at least being in less pain/dazed from bloodloss.+1 to all, very sensible.
The elf who has aided us deserves to be let go, and i think we should seriously consider offering our friendship to him.
We can discuss and consider our options with much greater freedom at the tower.
Very sensible to travel with huge penalties to navigation roll? IMO It's insanityI think people got that negative idea already instilled in their minds, it is just matter of time for Weird to decide on what ideas he/she likes.
Furthemore let's not forget that Alice will look very tasty for newly converted consorts. The puppet one is controllable, but rogue isn't
After some analysis I am now sure that converting the rogue is a bad, bad idea. We'll get very freedom loving, unloyal consort that can create many-many problems, I suggest to either try fuzion or use the rogue as food (and saving time used for the conversion)QuoteUKR makes a good point. We should do any and all conversions at our tower.
So, you want to travel to the tower with?
a) wounded Alice
b) badly wounded prisoner
c) Very pregnant Gwen
d) prisoner
e) loot?
It's even better idea!!!
Don't forget consorts are automatically loyal to us until we have our first child with said consort.They are instinctively loyal, one can overcome instincts
That too but she gains a 1-up and the ability to fly.And that's it. She also loses stealth and pretty much all ability to use her woodlore, her two biggest strengths. Save the phoenix for a son, or someone who doesn't have skills negated by flaming wings.
IIRC, Alice said something like "I let you decide how to use me"...It's still nice to ask, especially since there's still people considering the Left Stone gift...
Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do that
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
Name: the Male Night Troll "My father says I earn a name when people fear me enough to give me one."
so somebody dubbed you Fellsoil Dreamender.
I think it's officially time to choose Alice's Gift I'll tally votes tommorow if nobody else wants to, but I've changed my vote to Inferno's embrace or battle lust, depending on others votes. I'd rather keep the gift of Hideousness for ironic and spiteful uses.
Please use inferno gift on a child instead of on a consort. It would give us a great backup to play as if our main dies and if the baby night trolls also get "The First Gift," for breeding, then we can assume there is a possibility of multiple inferno baby trolls in the future.O.k. That those sound cooler so my vote is officially
Lets give all three consorts explicit instructions to leave Alice be and threaten them with confining them to be starved of fear by putting them in a time bubble if they disobey. In the meantime, lets help Gwen prepare for the birth.+1.
Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do that. New consorts are dangerous, especially pregnant Gwen+1
If you want you may bring Alice in the secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
We got a special gift already... let's not ask for favors until we do something for the goddess+1
Please use inferno gift on a child instead of on a consort. It would give us a great backup to play as if our main dies and if the baby night trolls also get "The First Gift," for breeding, then we can assume there is a possibility of multiple inferno baby trolls in the future.Ooh...
We also need to talk with Alice beforehand, so we know what she's willing to doShe told us that she don't want to discuss that, twice Can you stop requesting that?
The tiger person (Rox) was a woman. This is one of the reasons why I am against converting Alice. She has a lover already and it would be cruel to take them away from each other.But they couldn't mate as they are already the same sex, but they are also different spicies, if they were both night trolls they could live the rest of their lives together and be happy.
Also I think having Alice at the birth of our child will help build relationships between her and Gwendoline and help her re-evaluate her choice when she realises she will have to go through that.I was actually making a joke about Alice's fear pushing Gwen's baby over the edge.
Gwen will not give birth until she gets a prey, It's pointless to wait. Learn mechanics of the gameThe tiger person (Rox) was a woman. This is one of the reasons why I am against converting Alice. She has a lover already and it would be cruel to take them away from each other.Alice has said we can convert her. Foghorn has said we can convert her.Gwen will not give birth until she gets a prey, It's pointless to wait. Learn mechanics of the gameFear is what she needs. Remember, she didn't stick around the tree with us because she was afraid the elf would put her into labor.QuoteWhat is wrong with this woman and why is this always mentioned in such unnoticeable fonts?QuoteWe also need to talk with Alice beforehand, so we know what she's willing to doShe told us that she don't want to discuss that, twice Can you stop requesting that?More to the point, they'd be more or less like they are now. Just more...nightey.The tiger person (Rox) was a woman. This is one of the reasons why I am against converting Alice. She has a lover already and it would be cruel to take them away from each other.But they couldn't mate as they are already the same sex, but they are also different spicies, if they were both night trolls they could live the rest of their lives together and be happy.Rox is a servant of Foghorn, messing with her is a bad ideaGood point. We could still invite Rox over. I'm sure Foghorn would love having a "spy"/"double-agent" in our tower.
Seriously, stop ninja'ing me! That's four times this post!
Gwen will not give birth until she gets a prey, It's pointless to wait. Learn mechanics of the gameQuoteWe also need to talk with Alice beforehand, so we know what she's willing to doShe told us that she don't want to discuss that, twice Can you stop requesting that?
I mentioned that in my most recent long post.Gwen will not give birth until she gets a prey, It's pointless to wait. Learn mechanics of the gameI don't think she needs prey, just to be around fear.QuoteWe also need to talk with Alice beforehand, so we know what she's willing to doShe told us that she don't want to discuss that, twice Can you stop requesting that?
Yeah Rox might be po'd about us changing Alice but I don't think we should really base our decision on that. Worse case scenario is that we kill her. Maybe with our new stealthy consort.And that would be sad. Bright side, source of fear.
Yeah Rox might be po'd about us changing Alice but I don't think we should really base our decision on that. Worse case scenario is that we kill her. Maybe with our new stealthy consort.
I mentioned that in my most recent long post.Gwen will not give birth until she gets a prey, It's pointless to wait. Learn mechanics of the gameI don't think she needs prey, just to be around fear.QuoteWe also need to talk with Alice beforehand, so we know what she's willing to doShe told us that she don't want to discuss that, twice Can you stop requesting that?QuoteYeah Rox might be po'd about us changing Alice but I don't think we should really base our decision on that. Worse case scenario is that we kill her. Maybe with our new stealthy consort.And that would be sad. Bright side, source of fear.
My order of preference for Alice's gift
1) TLS
2) Gift of Battlelust
3) Gift of the Phoenix
But 2 and 3 are close ( if we knew that Alice will be able to extinguish her wings, phoenix would be cool)
My order of preference for Alice's giftI'd consult with Nocteclaw before giving Alice the Left Stone gift. If she approves, I'd vote for it. If not, Battlelust. I'd like to save the Phoenix gift for a child, so we can have grandchild Phoenices.
1) TLS
2) Gift of Battlelust
3) Gift of the Phoenix
But 2 and 3 are close ( if we knew that Alice will be able to extinguish her wings, phoenix would be cool)
Yeah I was in the middle of writing my post when you put yours… sorry. Anyway immolation gift seems the most powerful to me and that's the one I'd like most to pass onto our child.I hate when that happens.
No. The description states it just gives her natural armor and martial trances, which are controlled bursts of power and luck.My order of preference for Alice's gift
1) TLS
2) Gift of Battlelust
3) Gift of the Phoenix
But 2 and 3 are close ( if we knew that Alice will be able to extinguish her wings, phoenix would be cool)
Would battle lust mess with her sense of self control? Just wondering because of what the name implies. Anyway I would rather Alice get left stone than mermaid but my first choice is just using it to have a daughter. We could get the daughter from Alice after converting her I you want to honor her and respect Foghorn or whatever.
Thirded.Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do thatThat sounds good.
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
Although implied earlier, officially thirded.Thirded.Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do thatThat sounds good.
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
Numberd.Thirded.Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do thatThat sounds good.
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
Although implied earlier, officially thirded.Thirded.Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do thatThat sounds good.
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
The god/dess would choose who she thinks is best. And even so, if Nocteclaw wants us to use the gift on the mermaid...is this such a bad thing?Wouldn't the god(ess?) just pick the mermaid because the mermaid is a devout follower? Still might be a good idea to ask though.Although implied earlier, officially thirded.Thirded.Seriously we must convert Alice, use whatever gift you wish, but we must convert her. She asked us to do thatThat sounds good.
If you want you may bring her in secure room with us and mermaid and have jointed prayer to Nightclaw, Let's show both of possible first female night trolls and let the goddess choose
Ok, here is my piece/list on why Alice should not be converted. It’s in a spoiler so you don’t have such a long page to scroll down.Reasons Alice should be converted:P.S. Thanks you to anyone who actually read through this suggestion because it is just in fact kind big argument for “goody two shoes”-ness and doing something "morally right".Spoiler (click to show/hide)
The sharks are circling...Ok, here is my piece/list on why Alice should not be converted. It’s in a spoiler so you don’t have such a long page to scroll down.Reasons Alice should be converted:P.S. Thanks you to anyone who actually read through this suggestion because it is just in fact kind big argument for “goody two shoes”-ness and doing something "morally right".Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Alice asked to be converted.
Foghorn asked for her to be converted.
The other three consorts will likely harm her greatly if we don't.
Ok, here is my piece/list on why Alice should not be converted. It’s in a spoiler so you don’t have such a long page to scroll down.i agree with this. i think we should try to keep her alive until she fully heals, and then let her go on a quest of her own... a quest for true love. gwen and alice get along well enough now, and our new consorts are firmly under our influence, so i don't think she's in much danger for the foreseeable future, and i think her humanity and her forbidden love story keeps the story a lot more interestingP.S. Thanks you to anyone who actually read through this suggestion because it is just in fact kind big argument for “goody two shoes”-ness and doing something "morally right".Spoiler (click to show/hide)
It's not even about morals, it's just about not making a whole lot of sense. We don't want to have to babysit alice all of the time and force her to have children, it's one more thing to worry about. If we're going to give such a powerful gift it should be to someone who's going to use it of her own volition and with eagerness instead of disgust.Agreed.
That "force" is what making me laugh. The whole idea that we need a hive mother, not a sister and ally is a a pure minmaxing (IMO, bad minmaxing)
BTW, I prefer lesbian to nymphomaniac. I am sure that Alice will use her brain when choosing partners. Not the place between her legs (could use, I am sure that we will consort Alice and then minmaxers will advocate raping her to make nice kids, while absolutely ignoring our relationships)
She may have less kids (she will, it's just not in her character to become a hive mother and be pregnant 100% of time.) but she will be a very good, friendly and loyal matriarch
Alice is so close friend to us , that making her effectively a sister is logical and much more respecting than adding to our harem.
We have plenty of other mates to use, so we should never need to impregnate her except in great need.Then there are two problems if we don't impregnate her
Pretty much any other female of some capability and ambition is betterAmbition = potential enemy. Why don't you value loyalty at all?
Gwen would have been better, for instanceIf we found a way to ensure her loyalty... And I am quite sure that Alice would get more useful traits.
We're the last hope of the night troll race, the very last hope, we need to think in the long run.That's we need to put fate of our race in the hands of someone we trust. Not someone random. That's obvious logic for the character.
Can I put something out for future plans, when the baby is born we should ask Gwendoline to examine the mermaids transforming bracelet, it could be incredibly useful if she could recreate it to make us look human, elven and dwarven.This is a good idea
Can I put something out for future plans, when the baby is born we should ask Gwendoline to examine the mermaids transforming bracelet, it could be incredibly useful if she could recreate it to make us look human, elven and dwarven.+1
Can I put something out for future plans, when the baby is born we should ask Gwendoline to examine the mermaids transforming bracelet, it could be incredibly useful if she could recreate it to make us look human, elven and dwarven.+1
First can we trust Gwendoline will stay with us seeing as she's about to give birth and stop being completely loyal to us.I repeat two things:
Alice if she would be willing to have lots of little girlsI can answer that for her. No, she doesn't want to act like a hive mother and turn herself in a baby-making machine. No self respecting woman want that role.
I'd like to bring something up.In that case I wouldn't be opposed to using the Battle-Lust Gift on Alice, but I still attest that the Phoenix Gift would be the best choice. Alice is a ranger, not a rogue - stealth was something she was mildly good at, not her forte.
People keep talking about the Gift of Bloodlust being bad because it would make Alice lose control.
To that I have the following counterargument:
IT DOES NOT DO THAT.
Thank you.
Why do people want to give Alice the Phoenix gift? It pretty much removes the chance of having Phoenix descendants, and also negates Alice's abilities of stealth and existence in flammable environments.
Anyways, I would be fine with giving the Gift of the Left Stone to Alice if she would be willing to have lots of little girls, but Alice has stubbornly refused to tell us anything related to her choice. Can anyone think of some way to discern this? Maybe some kind of magic I've forgotten about?
In that case I wouldn't be opposed to using the Battle-Lust Gift on Alice, but I still attest that the Phoenix Gift would be the best choice. Alice is a ranger, not a rogue - stealth was something she was mildly good at, not her forte.Yeah, and it would be pretty nifty, wouldn't ya say?
I never said that, but it would make sense that because of the fact theirs about 4 living night trolls that each female is required to give birth at least once( except Alice as a favour for her friendship), also we already have a puppet for baby making....
I never said that. But, it would make sense if each female is required to give birth at least once (except Alice as a favour for her friendship) because there is only one night troll left, and we have only three consorts.Uhh... is this what you meant? I guess it sorta makes sense. Especially the puppet gift, that seems like a good use of it to me.
Though, we do already have a puppet for baby making.
Give our wife a certain gift, impregnate her with another, and the child may have some aspects of his mother's power as well. (We can do this, right? I don't want to be misunderstanding the game.
Oh, Weirdsound, you impregnated the wrong consort in the stats :)
Oh, Weirdsound, you impregnated the wrong consort in the stats :)Not if we give her a reason to come back, perhaps we can also enchant some sort of tracking bracelet.
As for rogue, she is too immature to send away without escort
Not if we give her a reason to come back, perhaps we can also enchant some sort of tracking bracelet.She is unfamiliar with her body and can't control her hunting instincts... That may get her killed
Good point, we should train with her a bit first, and possibly her to know her, like it or not this is the 1st generation of the new night trollian empire, and these are the matriarchs of the new species, so we should make her more comfortable.QuoteNot if we give her a reason to come back, perhaps we can also enchant some sort of tracking bracelet.She is unfamiliar with her body and can't control her hunting instincts... That may get her killed
We should order our ghost to make a new chainmail for our puppet, second dagger for the rogue and light helmets for everyone
Where are people getting the idea that Alice is super duper stealthy? She is a good tracker and is deceptive, yes, but she is not especially subtle. Her plan at the retreat was not "I'll sneak in and abduct someone." - that was Gwen who said that. Alice was the one saying, "I'll go on the other side of the retreat and make a huge distraction."Anyone who's stealthy can also be obvious.
Her actual demonstrated strengths are talking to plants, talking to animals, archery and maybe some other magic that she's just not shown off. The one time she made a stealth roll, it was at a +3 one worse than us and one better than Gwen.Plants won't want to talk to someone who will set them on fire if they get too close. Animals won't kike her much more. +3 stealth is still pretty good--as noted, it's better than Gwen's. And don't forget the possibility of making a son with the Phoenix gift...
There's a difference between "Queen Bee" and "Has lots of kids." Lots of real-life women like having and raising children; not all families with 5+ children are that way because of the father, after all. Are those women not self-respecting?QuoteAlice if she would be willing to have lots of little girlsI can answer that for her. No, she doesn't want to act like a hive mother and turn herself in a baby-making machine. No self respecting woman want that role.
Mindless zealot that will likely betray us (follow her own goals) and is very hard to convertWhy do you assume this? She follows the god/dess that MADE night trolls, we're a night troll. Sure, she might, but Gwen might too. Or Foghorn. Or Alice. Or our unborn child.
anailater, don't mix male and female kids.... I am perfectly fine with having only male kids but all here want MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORE kids...Huh? Why not have kids of both genders?
Nail, if you wanna make your wife happy you don't send her off, magically disguised, into a place filled with magic people who want to murderize her.Remind me to sig this.
You massage her feet.
Plans: I think we should stay low for few days or at the most a week. Even though Everpine is just one town, it’s still a important to keep a low profile, until things cool down. While waiting we should:
-Have Illtheuim (however you spell it) teach us how to smith. We should have let him build his artifact, once we have materials to hopefully not have such a big list on our hand when the time comes. Once he is gone, we wouldn't have a smith anymore, so we have to get prepared in case we can not hire one.
-Have Kelpmier III teach us how to fight with a spear as she learned how to fight with pole arms a long time ago. (I could be mistaken, but she did say she fought with pole-arms, right?)
-Go into cavern and see what kind of plant life lives there. If there are bugs or birds speak to them as well. This will hopeful get us a +1 in animal empathy.
-Talk to Gwen more about here family, especially what her father does (I think he might have been a merchant or a politician).
-Ask Jimma about her past, she sounded like a very strong warrior.
I am not exactly sure what to do with Cherlyn, but you guys thought of some fine ideas. I wonder where we get our water from, is there a well somewhere in this tower Weirdsound?
Maybe allow her to shift into bisexualism...but I essentially agree.If we can, sure. This would solve the problem of her not having children.
Personally I like dabbling in as many things as possible so it would be nice if we could at least have him teach us the basics.Dabbling in smithing may allow us to make crappy gear... We don't need crappy gear. We have better things to do than crafting a crappy gear
we eventually transform Roxso, after forcing our best friend to love us and marry us against her desires, you also want to steal her lover?
we eventually transform Roxso, after forcing our best friend to love us and marry us against her desires, you also want to steal her lover?
No we give Rox a choice in the matter, and while yes we will have to impregnate each at least once we then let them choose how to go about the rest of their lives.we eventually transform Roxso, after forcing our best friend to love us and marry us against her desires, you also want to steal her lover?
What do you have against necromancy?An inability to learn it?
I'm ambivalent on this, but I think it makes sense to try and reunite them. Ideally, Alice would get a gift that let's her turn Rox herself, but that's slightly more likely than Nocteclaw coming in and giving us a high-five before kicking the sun into a black hole.we eventually transform Roxso, after forcing our best friend to love us and marry us against her desires, you also want to steal her lover?
Hope that Alice will not dislike the gift that she'll get in the end... Well, then it's her problem for being so stubborn and no choosing herself.Mostly agree.
Necromancy is bad for our reputation... it's a one thing to be enemy of elves who eats them (many races dislike elves) and another to be a stinky necromancer (No race like necromancers) and 1 level in skill will not give us any strong minions. But that's another longterm thing not worthy to discuss nowI don't see why being able to raise the dead would cause us more ill will than being a night troll,especially if we don't raise an army of crappy undead off the bat. These enemies aren't psychic.
I really don't think raising the corpses of dead elves will aggrevate them any more than killing them, eating them, kidnapping, and (sort of) raping them.They would be very upset, and rightly so, but not for the reason you seem to think.
Wait why are people against necromancy? Its just another vector through which we can increase our numbers, seems like a good idea to me.Because, like I said, it's seen as an affront to almost all religious customs, including those of the Elves' theocratic society.
Wait why are people against necromancy? Its just another vector through which we can increase our numbers, seems like a good idea to me.Not just numbers - expendable numbers, at that. Minions that have neither mind nor soul nor importance to the plot are very useful to have around, to be thrown away as needed to protect us and the unexpendable npc's.
Necromancers need not be evil - it's a form of magic, it all depends how you use it. I'm not suggesting we unleash zombie plagues on the world, merely that all the skeletons that we generate could be put to use.Spoiler (click to show/hide)
As for necromancy and other morality stuff
Our character is not evil, it's clearly seen from his relationships with Gwen and Alice. Stop applying the video game logic. We kill to eat and in self-defense. We rape because we have on other means to reproduce. It's just our way of life. Even from strategy point of view it's better to maintain a nice reputation, we constantly get mortal allies here and there
But our character has already showed he doesn't view necromancy as right or needed, and killing those kids was a dick move from us, they could have lived none the wiser.
anailater,
It was a simple hunting, nothing more nothing less
Corruptor
This is DF world, and in DF known necromancers are supposed to get killed on sight.
If we have a grain of respect to the prey suggest to not use it's remains as "robots"
As for the Dwarven Madam , I am sure that she wouldn't be accepted in dwarven society. Also I am sure that if her necromancy would be known to the public she would get lynched.
What we need to decide is what to do with enchantments, night trolls considered that unethical and waste of souls, but we can't just prohibit Gwen to use it. She likes the art. And sometimes it's required
Remember that our character was disgusted by soul gathering, when Vindel ordered to do that
We really need to know what Nightclaw thinks about enchantments and necromancy, should ask the mermaid
(I suggest to bold suggestions that aren't part of this huge long term discussions and may be useful for the next update)
Simple hunting? Good point children make much better prey. They have more fear and they are much easier to kill. Sure they have less meat but I'm sure we can just compensate for that by killing more of them right? That sounds much more "good" than necromancy.Yep, it's a feeding, logic of a predator. Neither good nor evil. Stop using CRPG scales
Are we really going to let nocteclaw or whatever decide everything for us? We can't have all our decisions made for us, it would ruin the point of this entire thread.
I'm willing to discuss the subject of necromancy if we ever find a way to learn it, otherwise... what's the point?+1 and what was our name again?
Personally i'm quite pleased by our current name.
Also, I k l ow they are quite ugly but can someone with drive discriptive/drawing talent help me understand what I night trolls looks like?Depends on the night troll.
You have a funny understanding of good and evil - if it's useful than it's neither good or evil.... (Yes we are taling about different set of morals, but that doesn't matter)Untrue, torture is useful to interrogation yet considered evil by most. Friendship and love is useful for binding alliances, yet considered good.
And yes, I'd prefer more neutral, less hated god than Nocteclaw becase of the exactly same reason why I don't want necromancy: That will get us more enemies and fewer alliesNocteclaw is diminished and out of sight, out of mind for the vast majority of the "good" races. We are unlikely to garner significant enemies as a result of our unpublicized affiliation and patronage of It. The only ones who still seem remotely aware of him are potential allies, the merfolk. Thus does Nocteclaw bring us only gain.
Some possible alliesOther night creatures would likely be indifferent or supportive of Necromancy.
1) Trees
2) Animals (We may choose a druid route easily... just protect forests from... elves. Isn't that ironic? We got two loyal trainers that can train us empathies to a nice level)
3) Other night creatures
4) Night creature empaths.
5) Humans that want to end elven domination
6) Various animal people (they are discriminated heavily by civilized races)
7) Various gods and their followers
8) Maaaaybe dwarves
9) Merfolk
Necromancy make it harder to cooperate with all that groupsRegarding consorts, see the above statement about night creatures. I'm sure they would not consider feasting on elven flesh before their transformation either.
Necromancy make us less acceptable for some future consorts (and we don't know opinions of current on that matter)
As are all humans, but their should be some average.Not so much...
Alice will be cool in the future.Agreed.
But for now we basically lost her as a useful combat unit for our stealth based operations and that's sad. Half of her skills became obsolete
I am still so sad that she wasn't leftstoned...
One more thing, I think we should advice her to learn fire magic and gift her the book. She said that she doesn't interested in another magic schools, but situation changed.Advise, but yes. This should take priority over flying lessons; since her wings are made of flame, the fire manipulation could help.
...+1 - we know more than her about the subject, and teaching is a fantastic way to deepen and reinforce one's own knowledge.
Tutor Alice in Fire Manipulation with all our spare time.
Maybe the wings will let her hunt easier. Y'know, like a falcon or something.Indeed, just think of the scouting and rapid messaging she could do now - and if she becomes an adept in Fire Manipulation *grins* Death From Above.
But, yeah, definitely +1 to fire manipulation from her dad.
Eh, I hoped for a more spectacular phoenix...
Quiver is not a huge problem.
Hip quiver will counter that problem
I suggest
1) Order the ghost to make the said quiver (or rather modify existing), remake chainmail for our puppet, make steel swords for Gwen and make helmets, boots and gauntlets for the whole party. The puppet should aid him and try to learn thing or two.
2) We and Gwen should spend our time with the mermaid, we need to know more about Nocteclaw (We should focus on scriptures, not invocation skill. Learn about the Goddess before considering to use her powers)
3) Alice should start training to fly, surely she'll find some birds that will aid her in that
4) The rogue should try to snatch someone, we need a fear source for our preggos. Also she may try to steal magic books and trap components
Shall we vote on the name? :PSpoiler (click to show/hide)
Nope, just anticipating and hopefully averting a messy debate with some clean voting heh.Shall we vote on the name? :PSpoiler (click to show/hide)
Other actions would be nice as well. You are not spending a whole turn naming a baby I hope.
Does Cherlyn the rouge have the gift of amnesia? Because it is still listed as an unused gift.Yes she does, incidentally we should have her practice that. It'd be fantastic if she could selectively remove certain memories.
You must be a saint amongst monsters.Hehehehehehe
I am in favor of giving our children a baby name. Personal choice if Gwen doesn't have her heart set on a different name, would be Grimehammer after our beloved eldest brother, who taught us so much.+1
We should probably spend this time caring for our new consorts, the baby, etc. instead of focusing on training. We are going to be a Family Troll.
+1 and tell Gwen that she may be able to re-enchant her new swords soon.I am in favor of giving our children a baby name. Personal choice if Gwen doesn't have her heart set on a different name, would be Grimehammer after our beloved eldest brother, who taught us so much.+1
We should probably spend this time caring for our new consorts, the baby, etc. instead of focusing on training. We are going to be a Family Troll.
Maybe the wings will let her hunt easier. Y'know, like a falcon or something.Falcons don't use the same hunting methods Alice did, she'll have to relearn everything. Also, falcons don't glow. Fire sorta does. That will mean that the whole "stealth" thing gets defenestrated.
But, yeah, definitely +1 to fire manipulation from her dad.
...Cigars? Why?Because we are classy!
Do cigars even exist in this world?...Cigars? Why?Because we are classy!
Elves prefer wooden weapons, we all know thatProbably because they can only make wooden ones, and do it very well.
And enchantment transfer can easily fail, at least she need the soul catching sword online... losing it is badWell, how do we know? Besides, if we're planning to not use the old swords once the new ones are enchanted, it would make sense to use the magic, whereas if we aren't we'd likely want the enchantments on the swords to stay as they are and therefore wouldn't discuss this. There's no harm in trying any time we would.
And 4 swords are useful, you can always lose sword or two in a battleI'd be surprised if you managed to knock a sword from Gwen's grasp without cutting her hand off.
Also, she'll have two long swords and two short swords for different situations (For example: outdoor and indoor fighting, armored and unarmored opponents and so on)
And the most importantly - let's not upset our wife on such a minor issue. We love her and should be forceful. We have other consorts to force them to do what we likeI'd suggest at least discussing the issue with her--did she not want to give up her wooden swords because she thought the enchantments would make them more effective than the steel swords, or for sentimental reasons? If it's the latter, I'll gladly drop the enchantment-transfer thing.
Feast prep:Sure, if we have time and are fine with crappy furniture at first.
Ask Foghorn how many people are coming and when. If there are a lot of guest, we don’t have enough tables and chairs, and we have time, go out it the forest with Alice, Jimma (both have axes), a few lovebirds, and Fellsoil to cut trees and build a tables and chairs. Clean the tower up a little so it is not grimy and dirty. Tell everyone (Alice, Kelpmier, Gwendolyn, Jimma, Cherlyn (hopefully she comes back in one piece), Itheium) that the guest are coming. Even though Rox is getting food, we might want hunt some animals ourselves just in case.
Son:I assume this is "By Fellsoil, about the son?"
Thank Notcheclaw for blessing our child, and Kelpmier for helping with the delivery. Go hunt for some meat to feed our son and family. Might be interesting to try hunt in the plains or caverns.
It can wait until Rox get here. It's her duty to prepare for Foghorn's visit.I'd rather Alice practice flying BEFORE chasing birds. Especially in a forest.
If you want to hunt, try to fix the quiver issue and send Alice to do that ( or she may catch birds, eagle style, nice flying practice)
But I still prefer to gather family (We, Gwen, Alice) and practice fire magic together. Even the kid may benefit from itSure, as part of "family time." We can't be alwayth a-learnin, or alwayth a-workin.
Oh, and order our ghost (and the puppet) to make some kitchenware, we lack thatWe also lack surplus metal. Why not practice our woodworking skills (or at least someone's) by making wooden kitchenware for what we can first? We probably have Phyros's stuff, too.
Idea !Something like that. Not sure about the exact teaching, though.
We need to find use for Phyros brain. Let's use it to enchant it into something that can boost fire magic(or teach it) Gwen should have some souls in her soul catching sword after the last battle
Maybe enchant our fire magic book? brain+soul(s) + the book may make a very nice item. ( basically it should generate fire magic knowledge)
We also lack surplus metal.We always may melt down it if we'll need more metal. Also we have our own armor ( I doubt that we'll use it ever)
I'd rather Alice practice flying BEFORE chasing birds. Especially in a forest.That is a practice. Surely she should hunt between trees or other dangerous places, luckily birds are everywhere
Just wait until we remember we have it...QuoteWe also lack surplus metal.We always may melt down it if we'll need more metal. Also we have our own armor ( I doubt that we'll use it ever)
Our growing family need kitchenware anyway, we are civilized night trolls :)Let's use wooden spoons and such before using our limited platinum reserves on this...
I want platinum kitchenware! We have a plenty of that and that's classy to use
She's a new flyer, she could easily crash. She has flaming wings, she could set stuff on fire. Those are both bad. Do you send your kid (or will you) to practice driving on the Indy 500 when s/he just learned to drive? When his car is made of fire?QuoteI'd rather Alice practice flying BEFORE chasing birds. Especially in a forest.That is a practice. Surely she should hunt between trees or other dangerous places, luckily birds are everywhere
Let's use wooden spoons and such before using our limited platinum reserves on this...
She's a new flyer, she could easily crash. She has flaming wings, she could set stuff on fire. Those are both bad. Do you send your kid (or will you) to practice driving on the Indy 500 when s/he just learned to drive? When his car is made of fire?She doesn't need even to get close to the ground to hunt flying birds. Of cause she shouldn't do mad divings and the like, but no it's not that dangerous as you want it to look like
1. Some metal will probably be lost to the forge or whatever, we're not perfect.QuoteLet's use wooden spoons and such before using our limited platinum reserves on this...We can remelt it. It's not DF when you lose metal in the process.
Wooden spoons for Foghorn and his family.... Don't be cheap. It's a feast
I meant crash into trees. And yes, she does have to fly near trees, that's the first place birds will go when pursued by flying predators. And yes, flying is hard the first time. Riding bikes is hard at first, and you don't use different limbs for that.QuoteShe's a new flyer, she could easily crash. She has flaming wings, she could set stuff on fire. Those are both bad. Do you send your kid (or will you) to practice driving on the Indy 500 when s/he just learned to drive? When his car is made of fire?She doesn't need even to get close to the ground to hunt flying birds. Of cause she shouldn't do mad divings and the like, but no it's not that dangerous as you want it to look like
If gift of amnesia can erase all memories, then we could kidnap someone, wipe their mind and reprogram them sort of like an agent or servant of ours. Well I'd like to try it anyway at some point.Heh, my thoughts exactly.
As to the baby name: I suggest a short name for now, with nice titles gained as he earns them. The best of both worlds.I was going to suggest this too! I do like naming him for our brother initially though, or perhaps another member of the family.
I am in favor of giving our children a baby name. Personal choice if Gwen doesn't have her heart set on a different name, would be Grimehammer after our beloved eldest brother, who taught us so much.
We should probably spend this time caring for our new consorts, the baby, etc. instead of focusing on training. We are going to be a Family Troll.
Still, our most beneficial victories came with risk, and here i think the potential gain is higher than the risk.Agreed.
I support family time, then practice magic (maybe earth but any magic is good), and maybe as a longer term goal, try and pose as a god and take over a human civilization. It works for demons why not us? After we get human allies we can have them conduct raids on elven or goblin civilizations to sate our hunger for fear and flesh (lol). After we take over the humans, I say we slowly weed out all the humans that are magic users who don't swear complete loyalty to us. The ones that do get set up as a top tier priest like class that administer our territory for us. This should cement our power quite nicely and we can declare all magic users who don't serve us heretics. Of course this all assumes humans are unaware of what we truly are and that it is possible to trick them.Demons can fake being human gods. Any gods of jumping chameleon things? Green, flame-winged harpies?
Still, our most beneficial victories came with risk, and here i think the potential gain is higher than the risk.Agreed.I support family time, then practice magic (maybe earth but any magic is good), and maybe as a longer term goal, try and pose as a god and take over a human civilization. It works for demons why not us? After we get human allies we can have them conduct raids on elven or goblin civilizations to sate our hunger for fear and flesh (lol). After we take over the humans, I say we slowly weed out all the humans that are magic users who don't swear complete loyalty to us. The ones that do get set up as a top tier priest like class that administer our territory for us. This should cement our power quite nicely and we can declare all magic users who don't serve us heretics. Of course this all assumes humans are unaware of what we truly are and that it is possible to trick them.Demons can fake being human gods. Any gods of jumping chameleon things? Green, flame-winged harpies?
I don't think they can take human form. I'm pretty sure they just pretend to be a god that matches their description. We don't have to be an exact match just close enough and maybe with the help of a little magic. If that fails we could take over a goblin civilization. If I recall correctly we would just need to prove ourself being more powerful than the current ruler.I support family time, then practice magic (maybe earth but any magic is good), and maybe as a longer term goal, try and pose as a god and take over a human civilization. It works for demons why not us? After we get human allies we can have them conduct raids on elven or goblin civilizations to sate our hunger for fear and flesh (lol). After we take over the humans, I say we slowly weed out all the humans that are magic users who don't swear complete loyalty to us. The ones that do get set up as a top tier priest like class that administer our territory for us. This should cement our power quite nicely and we can declare all magic users who don't serve us heretics. Of course this all assumes humans are unaware of what we truly are and that it is possible to trick them.Demons can fake being human gods. Any gods of jumping chameleon things? Green, flame-winged harpies?
Animalmen tribes don't have any system of government except for the occassional bandit leader, they'd be the easiest to bring under our spell, it would make good practice i think.Right, especially if we can convince them we're a mythical demon or some such bullshit.
Eh, I hoped for a more spectacular phoenix...
Quiver is not a huge problem.
Hip quiver will counter that problem
I suggest
1) Order the ghost to make the said quiver (or rather modify existing), remake chainmail for our puppet, make steel swords for Gwen and make helmets, boots and gauntlets for the whole party. The puppet should aid him and try to learn thing or two.
2) We and Gwen should spend our time with the mermaid, we need to know more about Nocteclaw (We should focus on scriptures, not invocation skill. Learn about the Goddess before considering to use her powers)
3) Alice should start training to fly, surely she'll find some birds that will aid her in that
4) The rogue should try to snatch someone, we need a fear source for our preggos. Also she may try to steal magic books and trap components
Okay, perhaps now is a good time to get to work making a table and chairs. Have Alice help us coax would out of trees, taking the opportunity to ask her what she thinks of her new form, suggest she make a hip quiver. Then get to work forming the furniture. If it's a failure? Ah well, at least we practiced plant empathy.Sounds like a plan. Why just Alice, though? Make it a family outing. We know Gwen also knows plant empathy (I think), and the other former elves may, too. Besides, it's fun to do things together...or at least more fun than doing it alone.
Talk to the family about Foghorn and his family, emphasize that severe repercussions will follow from any unauthorized violence against any of them, gauge their reactions.Nothing against this. Foghorn is our guest, and a very powerful one at that.
Spend time with the child, talk to him about our plans for the future, and how we look forward to seeing what kind of night troll he'll grow up to be.Nothing wrong with this. People talk to their babies before they'll really understand them in the real world, too.
Notes on Long Term Planes: For building walls and trenches, i just realised something that would make travel for those friendly to us back and forth relatively easily. We could have saddles for some of our 36 lovebirds made. Teach some of them how to bear riders. That way we could easily ferry those friendly to us back and forth.Aside from referring to this as infinite 2-dimensional figures, nothing wrong and much agreeable here.
Just a thought: What if we found a 'playmate' for our son, one that he can learn to terrify and torment and eventually choose to convert or kill? I think that would be quite useful.Hm. Maybe when he's older. I'm sure a real playmate wouldn't go unappreciated either.
As I mentioned above, Alice used the plural when stating that she'd rather watch others try raising a child first. Who should we impregnate before Alice, and what gift should we use?1) I'd not take her words literally. She just said that she is not ready to make children right now.
2. Huh?QuoteAs I mentioned above, Alice used the plural when stating that she'd rather watch others try raising a child first. Who should we impregnate before Alice, and what gift should we use?1) I'd not take her words literally. She just said that she is not ready to make children right now.
2) Jimma is pregnant already
3) Impregnating our rogue is a bad idea
4) Gwen deserves a rest from baby making
I think we may send Alice away someday (her mother's land look fine enough), pregnant with the left stone. It's a way to ensure our survival, new basket for our racial eggs
As for the play mate idea, it's a double edged sword, he may find love and fear, but he may also become to attached and refuse to kill.My thoughts exactly.
I actually think it's a great idea for him to develop a childhood friend for him to attach to, that might help teach him the lesson we know well that some of our consorts do not: restraint. Once his instincts kick in he probably won't want to kill his friend, and the lesson will be learned that even though night trolls tend towards evil we need not be evil in every action, sometimes compassion and friendship is a better tool than tooth and nail.I like this idea.
But we don't want him to dissociate mortals and food.Just have him eat other people. He should learn that while most people are okay to kill if you must, some people are worth keeping alive if you can.
Give him a lovebird or bear cub as a pet instead. Same general lesson, with not eating everything he finds, but this way he won't become hesitant when told to kill Elves or Humans.
I think he's a bit young for a pet right now. I mean, he's not really going to be talking or walking well until he's 2 months.
-Decide if we want to give the chest on the roof to Foghorn while he's here and, if so, anything we want to ask him for it in exchange.Too early to decide, that may wait for the next update
try to teach our son to say Fellsoil while Alice and Gwen try to convince him to say their names. IT IS TRADTIONNow that is too early
Quotetry to teach our son to say Fellsoil while Alice and Gwen try to convince him to say their names. IT IS TRADTIONNow that is too early
Lets leave the decision up to him if we go down that route of thinking, give him some free will of consequence.Agreed. Because saying +1 seems silly.
I agree with your idea, but doubt that the implementation will succeed.Spoiler: Long rant (click to show/hide)
Yeah, if opportunity arise bring some small animal to our son, and teach him that it is not for food but to play with, Gwen should aid him in getting mutual understanding with the pet, that will be a kickstart for a future animal empath. I think young lovebird is good for that role, if Rox will bring some nice alive animal from the hunt we may use thatThis sounds like a good idea.
I think he's a bit young for a pet right now. I mean, he's not really going to be talking or walking well until he's 2 months.Nit a pet to take care of, a pet to play with. Like a dog, except not a dog. Which has to be the most semantically null sentence I've said in a while.
Tradition is good. If a future night troll gets interrupted by an adventurer, I'd rather have the adventurer see a (twisted parody of a) person carrying on traditions older than anyone can remember than a monster bored out of its (probable) skull.It is a traditional thing and it may even be a bonding exercise. I'd rather not be seen as an evil monster, rather be percieved in the same way as a predator, not a monster.Quotetry to teach our son to say Fellsoil while Alice and Gwen try to convince him to say their names. IT IS TRADTIONNow that is too early
Dude, I love your conception of short and long. Reminds me of my Uncle. :PSpoiler: Long rant (click to show/hide)
So, we have a blacksmith apprentice, I think our ghost just got a student. And you know that I prefer not to eat humans and concentrate on elves and and later, goblins
I am little worried about the Rox. Surely she is quite upset by Alice's new form and may do something stupid and get in a trouble. anyway we can't go and search her
Family playing with the fire at the forge is a nice way to spend some time and improve our teaching abilities.
So, we have a blacksmith apprentice, I think our ghost just got a student. And you know that I prefer not to eat humans and concentrate on elves and and later, goblinsMaybe have the mermaid talk with him first. Ghosts aren't as much like people as people are.
I am little worried about the Rox. Surely she is quite upset by Alice's new form and may do something stupid and get in a trouble. anyway we can't go and search herDon't count your...dead chickens before they...um...look, wait for the problem to come up before expecting it. I suspect that if Rox truly loves Alice, she'll be more unhappy about the slight changes in personality than the wings and such.
Family playing with the fire at the forge is a nice way to spend some time and improve our; abilities.As bad of an idea as that sounds like, it's a good idea.
Let's try to catch someone less interesting this time. :P
We've come upon at least as many useless folk as special one's, we've merely been using our resources efficiently.Truish. Next time, we need to find someone more useless.
1. Promise to spare the boy in return for the info about Nocteclaw's followers in town, then send him off to be 'educated' by our merfolk friend.Ask nicely; don't threaten unless needed.
2. Send word to Leaf - who has a great deal of economic influence, at least until his father returns - and request that the worshippers the boy mentioned be given preferential treatment, such as lower interest rates on loans and so forth. Assure him that any expense will be vastly overshadowed by our future successes, and that this is a crucial step in our plans.Who is that, again?
Also finding and killing that guys father could be useful. Or at least having a word with his father.Why would we kill him? Do we really want to kill one of the few people we know who might not want to kill us on sight?
Ukranian Ranger: We can time skip, and i suspect we will be doing so in the near future.How about a meeting with worshippers of Nocteclaw in town and some way to contact them easily?
I propose that if we do talk to our friend leaf that we send him a bar of platinum, or perhaps some leftover platinum from the silverware or something. This ought to convince him that we wern't lying when we offered wealth, and that alliance with us is profitable. Though a request of some kind should go with the platinum.
Quote2. Send word to Leaf - who has a great deal of economic influence, at least until his father returns - and request that the worshippers the boy mentioned be given preferential treatment, such as lower interest rates on loans and so forth. Assure him that any expense will be vastly overshadowed by our future successes, and that this is a crucial step in our plans.Who is that, again?
If I remember correctly he was the one that help us lure in the mage on the last major fight, we then let him go as ally. He is also a son of a trader and has some influence where he lives.
Of course, I never meant to imply that we should overtly threaten.1. Promise to spare the boy in return for the info about Nocteclaw's followers in town, then send him off to be 'educated' by our merfolk friend.Ask nicely; don't threaten unless needed.Quote2. Send word to Leaf - who has a great deal of economic influence, at least until his father returns - and request that the worshippers the boy mentioned be given preferential treatment, such as lower interest rates on loans and so forth. Assure him that any expense will be vastly overshadowed by our future successes, and that this is a crucial step in our plans.Who is that, again?Also finding and killing that guys father could be useful. Or at least having a word with his father.Why would we kill him? Do we really want to kill one of the few people we know who might not want to kill us on sight?Ukranian Ranger: We can time skip, and i suspect we will be doing so in the near future.How about a meeting with worshippers of Nocteclaw in town and some way to contact them easily?
I propose that if we do talk to our friend leaf that we send him a bar of platinum, or perhaps some leftover platinum from the silverware or something. This ought to convince him that we wern't lying when we offered wealth, and that alliance with us is profitable. Though a request of some kind should go with the platinum.
Okay, lets divvy up tasks by individual perhaps.Not a bad idea.
Us: Spend time with the child, split time between talking to him and practicing fire manipulation, hunt down some more advanced fire manipulation books. Thank our smith for his kind service.I agree, except add "or teaching" after "practicing."
Cherlyn: Go out for a quick trip to get food.Sure.
Alice: Practice flying and getting used to her form, perhaps read one of our introductory fire manipulation books. (Explain that you realize she doesn't have much interest in fire manipulation, but that given her form it may be prudent to at least dabble.Make sure that someone is watching when she's practicing flight. She's new--quick response to a crash could save her life.
Gwen: Help take care of the baby while we are distracted, have the impromptu dining area put together. (I am not suggesting that she become a mere housewife, but somebody needs to do it right?Yeah.
Jimma: Try out her new armor, patrol around the tower, keeping an eye for potential threats. This ought to help her get used to her body too.Sure.
Kelpmier: Interview and talk to the child in our dungeon.Agreed.
Yeah.Eon displace present? It will be more of a surprise.
Let's pull an Oprah and put it under his seat when he gets here as a present.
It would need good timing, but if we can pull it off, the look on Foghorn's face will be so worth it...Yeah.Eon displace present? It will be more of a surprise.
Let's pull an Oprah and put it under his seat when he gets here as a present.
We don't need to baby them. Let them go into the cave, they can handle themselves.Sending Jimma with them isn't "babying" them. It's taking a reasonable precaution. The caverns are slightly dangerous...
My personal vote for what to do with the Left Stone gift: Pass it on to our son with instructions that he is to use it to impregnate whichever consort of his that he bestows his First Gift upon. This will give the first female troll Hypnotic Gaze, Tattoos, Teleportation Tumours, Camouflaged Body, Springy Legs, Divine Blessing AND possibly another talent that our son passes on himself.Nice idea, but I don't think gifts work like that...
We don't need to baby them. Let them go into the cave, they can handle themselves.We would have to impregnate his consort, but she wouldn't care
My personal vote for what to do with the Left Stone gift: Pass it on to our son with instructions that he is to use it to impregnate whichever consort of his that he bestows his First Gift upon. This will give the first female troll Hypnotic Gaze, Tattoos, Teleportation Tumours, Camouflaged Body, Springy Legs, Divine Blessing AND possibly another talent that our son passes on himself.
Assuming we can impregnate another troll's consort (probably possible, but you never know), and WOULD do so (imagine your parent having a child with your spouse), it wouldn't grant all those abilities. Better to encourage our son to earn a gift from Nocteclaw himself.We don't need to baby them. Let them go into the cave, they can handle themselves.We would have to impregnate his consort, but she wouldn't care
My personal vote for what to do with the Left Stone gift: Pass it on to our son with instructions that he is to use it to impregnate whichever consort of his that he bestows his First Gift upon. This will give the first female troll Hypnotic Gaze, Tattoos, Teleportation Tumours, Camouflaged Body, Springy Legs, Divine Blessing AND possibly another talent that our son passes on himself.
Ukranian, you keep throwing around the idea of writing a fire magic book, and i don't mean to be a dick, but i don't think that's how it works. Books about magic are books filled with knowledge, not necessarily magical books, how we enchant the book doesn't matter, what we write in it does.You completely misunderstood my idea....
I don't think that would work, or be worth it.QuoteUkranian, you keep throwing around the idea of writing a fire magic book, and i don't mean to be a dick, but i don't think that's how it works. Books about magic are books filled with knowledge, not necessarily magical books, how we enchant the book doesn't matter, what we write in it does.You completely misunderstood my idea....
Haven't you note that I proposed to use Phyros brain in the enchantment? I want to extract his magical knowledge to the paper
Another option is to make it generate new texts like connecting to some global fire manipulation knowledge base.
As for why female night trolls need traits, I quite suspect that they have a different gift system and their own traits may be more important. Or may not.I suspect not...
And guys, let's not make long term megaplans that need years to become viable. It's not how young trolls think. And Nochteclaw asked us to use the left stone not save it for ages.I agree with pretty much all of this.
Also, we can't be sure that our son will get the same first gift as we did
(And fucking son's wife..... ewwwww)
And don't be mad, sending Alice and Rox Alone is a way too dangerous. Underground is a dangerous place, it's not wise to not use someone used to caverns.Well, they're both powerful warriors...but as they're not too used to the caverns and Jimma has nothing better to do, I suggest sending her with. If they'll let Jim a come, of course.
Fire book probably not worth a gift... ( But I'd try that if we got a a soul) That could make learning fire magic way easierFire book possible not even possibility.
Maybe discuss the possibility to make such a book with Gwen? Or extracting Phyros knowledge from the brain in general (BTW, do we know IC that brain = mind? Is it even true for the setting? )
BTW, I am not sure that family fire magic lesson without Alice is viable... If we don't train her it's a waste of time. Gwen doesn't really need fire manipulation, except, maybe, for making fire enchantments.Sounds acceptable.
Better to try experiment with the artifact or try level up animal empathy by training lovebirds\looking for owl. Fire magic is not our combat skill. Eon manipulation is. Having two high level combat skills is much less important than improving utility skills
You completely misunderstood my idea....I don't blame myself for not guessing this, you never really made it clear that this is what you were thinking. Anyway, how would we accomplish this? Even if we had some kind of magic relevant to making a fire magic internet, or transferring knowledge through some kind of magic osmosis, we would need huge amounts of power to accomplish such a feat. Power we do not possess.
Haven't you note that I proposed to use Phyros brain in the enchantment? I want to extract his magical knowledge to the paper
Another option is to make it generate new texts like connecting to some global fire manipulation knowledge base.
Of cause that enchantment( as all others, should be done by Gwen)
And don't be mad, sending Alice and Rox Alone is a way too dangerous. Underground is a dangerous place, it's not wise to not use someone used to caverns.
You completely misunderstood my idea....I don't blame myself for not guessing this, you never really made it clear that this is what you were thinking. Anyway, how would we accomplish this? Even if we had some kind of magic relevant to making a fire magic internet, or transferring knowledge through some kind of magic osmosis, we would need huge amounts of power to accomplish such a feat. Power we do not possess.
Haven't you note that I proposed to use Phyros brain in the enchantment? I want to extract his magical knowledge to the paper
Another option is to make it generate new texts like connecting to some global fire manipulation knowledge base.
Of cause that enchantment( as all others, should be done by Gwen)And don't be mad, sending Alice and Rox Alone is a way too dangerous. Underground is a dangerous place, it's not wise to not use someone used to caverns.
I can understand this sentiment, and won't get muchly in the way of sending Jimma the bodygaurd along with them, but i also feel it prudent for them to have privacy to work out their problems. Whatever the case i don't feel it is much of a big deal either way. Something of a compromise would be to explain to them that if they go underground they may need Jimma's protection, as we don't know what's down there and Alice shines like a beacon in such a dark place, suggest that if they would like privacy that they may go for a walk outside.
I dislike the whole gift to Foghorn idea. Does he have a birthday or what? We are allies, not his vassal. Let's not behave like that
We may give it to him... well because we learned that he looked for it from the tree and decided that he have full right for the trophy . That how he views that. I am sure
Or we may say the truth - that we aren't sure that opening the box is a good idea and think that he will find a better use for it
Same goes to the feast... It's look like you want to impress your lord not meet an ally to discuss future plans.
I dislike the whole gift to Foghorn idea. Does he have a birthday or what? We are allies, not his vassal. Let's not behave like thatThree things.
We may give it to him... well because we learned that he looked for it from the tree and decided that he have full right for the trophy . That how he views that. I am sure
Or we may say the truth - that we aren't sure that opening the box is a good idea and think that he will find a better use for it
Same goes to the feast... It's look like you want to impress your lord not meet an ally to discuss future plans.
Also, with Rox and Alice, how would you feel if your lord (she is our consort) sent your rival to protect you during your romantic time with your lover?Since when Alice and Jimma became rivals?
We definitely should clear it with her first, though I suspect she would not like it.
B. she'll send Jimma away when she wants to be alone with Rox.
Sure.B. she'll send Jimma away when she wants to be alone with Rox.Jimma would not leave. If we tell her to protect them, she will protect them no matter what Alice says, and leaving them is not protecting them. Alice isn't her master, we are. If we send Jimma, we need to say that Alice is her boss as well, or at least have her listen to Alice's requests and follow through with them if they are acceptable.
Hey, gift of puppetry. Need to be precise with what we tell our mindless slave. I'm assuming it works with exact orders. Not implied orders.Yup.
Tiny tiny details. <3
A. she'll let us know, or B. she'll send Jimma away when she wants to be alone with Rox.Or C. They'll have a threesome :D
QuoteA. she'll let us know, or B. she'll send Jimma away when she wants to be alone with Rox.Or C. They'll have a threesome :D
I told you so.Well, I chose phoenix as a second choice because battlelust was just a bland meatshield type of gift, not the best role for a friend or a daughter of a wizard. Not that my second choice mattered
You... you do realize it's possible to be romantic with someone without actually having sex, right?It's possible. That's why I said that she is limited to purely platonic relationships. And it's not only about sex, it's about any physical contact. She can't get hugged. She can't sleep in a bed. She should be extra careful indoors and have millions of other problems...
Left Stone was so the best choice...but let's try not to bring up old arguments...I told you so.Well, I chose phoenix as a second choice because battlelust was just a bland meatshield type of gift, not the best role for a friend or a daughter of a wizard. Not that my second choice mattered
I think we should convert Rox because of two things, Alice loves her and Night trolls live a long time, Rox will die and Alice will become sad, if we convert her, they can live together forever.Good idea. Give her Battlelust?
But Don' t bring it up now, that would be bad.I think we should convert Rox because of two things, Alice loves her and Night trolls live a long time, Rox will die and Alice will become sad, if we convert her, they can live together forever.Good idea. Give her Battlelust?
We discussed Rox conversion with Alice, she clearly said that it is a bad idea because Foghorn will not allow her that. Rox is his friend and important servant.True enough. We'll need to discuss the matter with Foghorn and Rox first. After cementing an alliance with Foghorn...maybe the box would help?
And Rox loves Foghorn at least as much as she loves Alice
And Rox loves Foghorn at least as much as she loves AliceI thought she lesbian? Does she like Foggy the same way? I could have missed it if she did.
Silly cardMuch better. :Dmanfish, animal people don't grasp the concept of homosexuality, they simply let their urges run wild and free
There is more than one kind of love, Card.And Rox loves Foghorn at least as much as she loves AliceI thought she lesbian? Does she like Foggy the same way? I could have missed it if she did.
In either case, she is definitely very loyal to him. He'd have to give it the go ahead, but he probably won't.Yeah...maybe if we emphasize how happy she and Alice are together and make him feel indebted to us...say, by giving him the box?
Yeah, that's what I meant by the "loyalty" thing. I just feel like she might love Alice more than she loves Leghorn.There is more than one kind of love, Card.And Rox loves Foghorn at least as much as she loves AliceI thought she lesbian? Does she like Foggy the same way? I could have missed it if she did.
Yepperoni.QuoteIn either case, she is definitely very loyal to him. He'd have to give it the go ahead, but he probably won't.Yeah...maybe if we emphasize how happy she and Alice are together and make him feel indebted to us...say, by giving him the box?
Yeah, that's what I meant by the "loyalty" thing. I just feel like she might love Alice more than she loves Leghorn.She never tried to save Alice from tortures and forced marriage. So I really doubt that
Did Rox even know about it?QuoteYeah, that's what I meant by the "loyalty" thing. I just feel like she might love Alice more than she loves Leghorn.She never tried to save Alice from tortures and forced marriage. So I really doubt that
Whatever we do we shouldn't tell Foghorn about romantic affair between Rox and Alice.I thought he already knew...
I am against converting Rox, that is bad for many reasons:True. Possibly.
1) Foghorn
2) Weird love triangle will create problems
3) Alice may get upset that we want to raise our power and convert her love just to use for our cause. She is overprotective about RoxAren't most of our arguments for converting Rox so the two of them can stay together? Wouldn't this affect their feelings towards us and each other?
4) Alice and Rox may break up (most likely they will) Considering their characters they may become fierce rivals
5) If Rox will ever fall in love with a male... she'll hate us because they will not be able to have a child ( that's true for Alice, too. But it's too late to change anything)Alice is a lesbian, it was never an issue for her. I thought Rox was, too?
Can some people please stop acting like Alice has had a horrible curse inflicted on her that will forever ruin her life and any chance she has at happiness? We didn't punish Alice, we gave her a gift. Maybe not the gift everyone wanted for her, hell maybe not even the gift she wanted most but in my eyes and probably in the eyes of our character it was a great and valuable gift. We took her in when her own father acted like he didn't want her and we have been a very good friend in my honest opinion. Sure Alice has to overcome the temporary hurdle of unfamiliarity with her body but we took away her fears, gave her power and immortality barring death by violence. She has a very long time to grow in harmony with her gift and she has a lot more opportunity for experiencing life now than she would have had as a mortal human. If Rox and Alice really love each other, then they will find a way to make things work and if not then they never really loved each other in the first place. Alice has a long time to find that special someone and all the better if we work our way in there.Aside from the flaming wings, it was a good gift. We did make her life...different, at least. Once she gets over the issues with being partly bound to us and figures out how to live with the flaming wings (which I am surprised she hasn't burnt anything with yet--does she sleep on a stone floor?), she'll be better off than she was before. Probably.
Sorry if that seemed like a rant. Don't know why it even bothers me but I just feel like we did what most of us felt was right at the time but it's never enough if some people don't get what they feel is right.
Did Rox even know about it?She was the one who told us about it
It's entirely possible that I forgot about that if she did.
I thought he already knew...He threw Alice in torturing device for being a lesbian... How do you think, what would he do with someone who "seduced" his little daughter?
Aren't most of our arguments for converting Rox so the two of them can stay together? Wouldn't this affect their feelings towards us and each other?That will affect. In some unpredictable way.
Alice is a lesbian, it was never an issue for her. I thought Rox was, too?Pure homosexuality is very rare for women.
Pure homosexuality is very rare for women.
she hasn't been there yetHuh? We converted her at that place
Unless alice and rox are going on a camping trip underground it should not be a problem.If he come and no Rox and Alice present that will be awkward. And that's quite possible
[/spoiler]Spoiler: Rant about Alice (click to show/hide)
I don't agree with all of your arguments (for instance, flying is kinda the quintessential superpower), but I agree with your conclusion. If Alice wasn't good enough for the left stone, who was?QuoteOh. Thanks.QuoteDid Rox even know about it?She was the one who told us about it
It's entirely possible that I forgot about that if she did.QuoteI thought it was the relationship with Rox that got her tossed into the torture room.QuoteI thought he already knew...He threw Alice in torturing device for being a lesbian... How do you think, what would he do with someone who "seduced" his little daughter?
He didn't even knows that we know that Alice is a lesbian and I think it would we better if that will stay the sameQuoteBright side, if we explain our logic to Alice, she won't feel betrayed.QuoteAren't most of our arguments for converting Rox so the two of them can stay together? Wouldn't this affect their feelings towards us and each other?That will affect. In some unpredictable way.
Theoretically.QuoteAlice has mentioned being disgusted by...some aspect or other of heterosexual relationships, I don't remember the exact quote. Anyways, you could argue the same argument for all of our consorts who aren't Jimma. The only real difference is that we knew about and cared about Alice before conversion.QuoteAlice is a lesbian, it was never an issue for her. I thought Rox was, too?Pure homosexuality is very rare for women.
Eternity is a long enough time to switch
Alice is 16 year old... that's only the beginning of sexuality.
It may be only result of teenager rebelliousness against social norms
Consorts are changed by conversion, some instincts are added. I am sure that if turn on any gift near Alice she will do whatever is needed for mating( that's a form of a rape, but still)
I see no reasons to assume that Rox is a lesbian and not a biI am concerned with the power of Cherlyn, problems expectedTreat her well, make her realize turning her was a blessing, and don't impregnate her until she does.
Prepare for the feast, spend time with the family, consider trying to teach Cherlyn some magic, wait for Alice, Jimma, and Rox to return.
I suggest we be impressed by Cherlyn's cleverness and a bit worried by her... independence isn't the right word, but something about how she uses it.We should be glad, Initiative is always good, we just need to make sure she doesn't use it against us, perhaps a present?
Perhaps...but we DID give her that platinum bar to spend on herself...I suggest we be impressed by Cherlyn's cleverness and a bit worried by her... independence isn't the right word, but something about how she uses it.We should be glad, Initiative is always good, we just need to make sure she doesn't use it against us, perhaps a present?
My personal suggestion: Use the Drought of Perception Blotting to make ourselves invisible to elves. Walk into town. Kill as many as we can before the potion wears off. Quaff a second potion and escape.Can we leave an evil note in elf blood?
Can we get five+ gifts every year, or are you planning to eat most of them?My personal suggestion: Use the Drought of Perception Blotting to make ourselves invisible to elves. Walk into town. Kill as many as we can before the potion wears off. Quaff a second potion and escape.Can we leave an evil note in elf blood?
Something like, we are your new gods, leave 5 maidens of skill by (Safe location) every harvest and we shall not smite you?
Alice seemed to know about it, and we've never talked with her about it.Quote? I finished reading the story recently and don't remember that
Alice seemed to know about it, and we've never talked with her about it.Quote? I finished reading the story recently and don't remember that
"You asks Alice. She informs you that because of the spiritual consequences of soul collection she has not been stockpiling the things."Why should we talk with Alice about soul collection?
Still, access to magic that can be used to discern the nature of the universe, (in particular the use of magic such as enchantment that gives insight into the nature of the mortal soul), leaves a little less up for debate in such areas, it allows one to apply scientific principles to metaphysics.
Let's face it, golems are just better than zombies. They're tougher, stronger, and less terrifying to the peasants. A bit more expensive, but meh.Golems could also suit our needs, agreed. Though the terror that the undead inflict is a perk, imo.
...Who is suddenly wanting a platinum golem?
Golemancy would require many souls. Bad option for our ethicsWe don't know that, or anything. For all we know, you can make golems from dirt and badger blood (although as dirt golems, they would be sucky...you get my point.)
She could have been talking about being haunted by the souls, or some sort of "going-to-heaven-or-hell" spiritual consequences. We didn't ask for more detail."You asks Alice. She informs you that because of the spiritual consequences of soul collection she has not been stockpiling the things."Alice seemed to know about it, and we've never talked with her about it.Quote? I finished reading the story recently and don't remember that
Still, access to magic that can be used to discern the nature of the universe, (in particular the use of magic such as enchantment that gives insight into the nature of the mortal soul), leaves a little less up for debate in such areas, it allows one to apply scientific principles to metaphysics.Do people have such magic? I don't think I've heard of it...
Like before, I said we should tell Foghorn that there is not need for a siege on Dawnmaiden and he can save his resources. We can tell him that we will speak with Vindel to stop chasing after that girl, especially with our communication bonus. Kill a mass of people over maintaining an enchanter and trying to get a tribute out of it will most likely come with a big cost; lives. We do not have enough resources, power, and skill at the moment to launch a siege on a full fledge city. Working for smaller easier goals is important before going for huge plots for power.I don't think you mentioned this before, but it's a good point...we should give him the box first, to make him not think we're trying to weasel out of dangerous jobs because we're a bad minion or whatever.
Edit: Also killing many people that have not done anything to us will give people the 'right' of go off and kill all the night trolls in to world like they did a few hundred years ago. We can't just become a monster just because people became monsters to kill all the night trolls in the world (night troll babies, children, physically or mentally impaired, or even trolls that were integrated with mortals).
Ask the Foghorn family if they know anything on the night troll genocide.
Also killing many people that have not done anything to us will give people the 'right' of go off and kill all the night trolls in to world like they did a few hundred years ago. We can't just become a monster just because people became monsters to kill all the night trolls in the world (night troll babies, children, physically or mentally impaired, or even trolls that were integrated with mortals).Err... I'm not really sure what you mean here, could you clarify?
Ask the Foghorn family if they know anything on the night troll genocide.
If we kill a bunch of people, people will want to kill us. We don't want to be killed.Also killing many people that have not done anything to us will give people the 'right' of go off and kill all the night trolls in to world like they did a few hundred years ago. We can't just become a monster just because people became monsters to kill all the night trolls in the world (night troll babies, children, physically or mentally impaired, or even trolls that were integrated with mortals).Err... I'm not really sure what you mean here, could you clarify?
Ask the Foghorn family if they know anything on the night troll genocide.
As i've pointed out, zombies are next to useless when fielded against any intelligent opponent.
Perhaps we should prepare defences before we go on the offensive?
Ah. But aren't we kinda the very definition of monster? What else do you call a people that can't live without killing and converting sentient beings?
Took me a second to get that. :PAh. But aren't we kinda the very definition of monster? What else do you call a people that can't live without killing and converting sentient beings?Haha sounds like religion gone bad.
I'll sum up what i think we should do. Give our gift to Foghorn, request some kind of significant distraction for our initial attack. Prepare defenses, firstly a trench, we can practice using our staff (EDIT: SPEAR why do i keep doing that?) to accomplish this.
Prepare attack.
I think an attack might be beneficial because it gives us a powerful reputation in the immediate area, and a negotiation allows us to gain a foothold into the elven towns, set us up to peacefully interact with the elves, we could even set ourselves up as a kind of dark benefactor trading in favors. Example: We are an Eon manipulator, we could ask tips from foghorn and then ply a trade among humans and dwarves to let them live longer, more youthfully, i'm sure that there is a lot of pressure to in a predominantly elven society in regards to age.
Once all is said and done i think we should talk to Foghorn, make it clear to him that we arn't his servant, but that at the same time we consider him our friend, and that we appreciate partnership with him.
The small issue of Cherlyn, i think her initiative can be appreciated, but her impudence is unacceptable, how are we to assert authority over her?
The small issue of Cherlyn, i think her initiative can be appreciated, but her impudence is unacceptable, how are we to assert authority over her?Treat her like a person, she will grow to like us and stop complaining.
Good point on the subject of Foghorn, maybe best to let it lie for the moment.I'll sum up what i think we should do. Give our gift to Foghorn, request some kind of significant distraction for our initial attack. Prepare defenses, firstly a trench, we can practice using our staff (EDIT: SPEAR why do i keep doing that?) to accomplish this.
Prepare attack.
I think an attack might be beneficial because it gives us a powerful reputation in the immediate area, and a negotiation allows us to gain a foothold into the elven towns, set us up to peacefully interact with the elves, we could even set ourselves up as a kind of dark benefactor trading in favors. Example: We are an Eon manipulator, we could ask tips from foghorn and then ply a trade among humans and dwarves to let them live longer, more youthfully, i'm sure that there is a lot of pressure to in a predominantly elven society in regards to age.
Once all is said and done i think we should talk to Foghorn, make it clear to him that we arn't his servant, but that at the same time we consider him our friend, and that we appreciate partnership with him.
The small issue of Cherlyn, i think her initiative can be appreciated, but her impudence is unacceptable, how are we to assert authority over her?
We aren't Foghorn's servant but until he asks us to do something crazy dangerous or that we are extremely apposed to, why bring the subject up?
He hasn't treated us like a servant and in fact has given us a lot of leeway and space to do whatever it is we want. Maybe we should just try and keep things on an upbeat note unless we have to.
An direct attack on the community isn't a good idea unless we have the manpower to back it up, hence my multiple suggestions for either recruiting soldiers or creating soldiers. So until we get that kind of power I would like to remain subtle and hopefully alive.
Tower defenses are quite an agreeable idea as I said before, so that's good.
Giving the gift to Foghorn is a good idea and might be an opportune time to ask about where we can either recruit soldiers or learn magic to make soldiers for offensive and defensive measures.
Cheryln is getting out of hand but also seems to be one of the more useful and intelligent consorts we have. We should talk to her and assert authority but be respectful and tell her that while we appreciate her many talents and her intelligence, we can't have her challenging our authority, especially openly in front of others like Foghorn.
Does eon manipulation work like that? Can we make people younger? Sounds like a good long term plan if that does work but I still think that's a more long term goal and we might be better off opening shop somewhere else instead of so close to our enemies. Might be a good chance to get in good terms with the humans or dwarves.
He is from Everpine. We are going to attack another townI was under the impression that Everpine was our target.
Yeah Sorry about the lack of updates this weekend. I'm busy with my maptools games and housework during the weekend. Might be able to get an update tonight. Here is a quick guide to the elven settlements for those confused.Which one had the Nocteclaw worshippers, Oakworshipped?
Oakworshpied: The largest settlement. Highly progressive and cosmopolotian. Lots of humans and even a fair few dwarves live here. Vindel (And his love intrest) lives here. This is the retreat Foghorn wants you to attack.
Everpine: A smaller backwoods settlement that prides itself of traditional elven values. Non elves are not welcome here. Leaf lives here. All of your consorts (except Alice) have ties to Everpine.
Dawnmaiden: You have yet to visit, but this retreat is supposedly a busy market for all sorts of supernatural beings and goods. Nobody is likely to investigate your disguise here, as dark mages and lesser night creatures make up a good percentage of business for the town. Cherlyn, despite being a consort, was able to spend her platinum bar here and buy goods.
The boy is from the human town, where cherlyn got the trap components.After Foghorn leaves and we do his attack thing and we get in contact with them? Sure.
We could offer those worshipers sanctuary in exchange for service. We could set them up at the ranch or have them build a communal house outside the tower, could be the start of a community.
I think we should bait their military forces somehow. Create something that they have to deal with.
Right then, here's what I propose we do:
1. Send our Rogue out to the town to sabotage defenses. Steal quivers of arrows, poison competant guardsmen, grab any healing potions that she can get her hands on.
2. While that's happening, let's ask Foghorn to tutor Alice and us in Fire Manipulation. A flier tossing down fireballs from above would be a devastating combat asset.
3. Ask if Foghorn has any spare enchanted items handy that Gwen and our puppet-consort could use in the attack.
I think we captured bears before didn't we?I think they were cubs, weren't they?
I know we do own lovebirds, which I was under the impression are quite large and rideable. Maybe I just got the wrong impression though.I was under the impression that mounts needed combat training so they wouldn't spook.
I'm not sure mentioning it would be beneficial. But we happen to have a full suit of armor fitted for us in our basement.We should at least practice moving in it. Whether or not we actually use it in battle will wait to be seen...
I think that his offer of assistance was not a promise to directly commit forces in our attack.Perhaps then we should plainly ask him what sort of assistance he can provide for the mission - the fire manipulation tutor for Alice is all very well and good but such training wouldn't be feasible before the raid.
Agreed. Distractions are good. Alice would make a great distraction--Alyce, Alyce, burning bright/In the forests of the night would be visible yet protected by all those trees.
I am back! :) I was banned for a week by Toady himself 8)May I ask why?
1) Order our ghost to make gauntlets, helmets and boots, any unused metal is bad. Any body protection is goodOut of what, platinum?
2) Train armed combat, friendly sparring is always good way to improve relations and we need to not rely only on our magic. Train armor usage, tooCan't really argue with any of these, if we have the time to do this stuff and still spend time with our family. Wait, no, delay impregnation of Alice until Jimma has her kid.
3) Train fire manipulation. We need practicing our teaching skill, and all our casters may benefit from this. I'd consider to send Alice to train fire manipulation but she need little more experience in being a night troll consort
4) Don't waste time on fortifications. It will not help against any serious attack
5) If a nice opportunity arise: impregnate Alice with the Left Stone or Inferno Embrace (you know what I prefer) Then we may send her away, to train fire manipulation in safe place, or even further away to her mother. I really want to have back up plan in case we fail in a very dangerous upcoming attack and possible counter attack on our tower
6) Ask our mermaid to pray and ask for assistance of the goddes in the upcoming attack
7) Contacting Nochteclaw worshipers may help us , too
Thanks!Agreed. Distractions are good. Alice would make a great distraction--Alyce, Alyce, burning bright/In the forests of the night would be visible yet protected by all those trees.Blake is one of my favorite poets. You get a gold star GWG.
Tell Gwen to enchant her damn swords so she'll stop bitching.Doesn't she, you know, need souls?
If she isn't doing too well with them we may want to get her her enchanted swords back for now.Agreed.
May I ask why?It was a bad idea to participate in a religion\atheism discussion thread.
Out of what, platinum?I am quite sure that we didn't spent all 50 steel maces we had
Can't really argue with any of these, if we have the time to do this stuff and still spend time with our family. Wait, no, delay impregnation of Alice until Jimma has her kid.As I said - Don't actively try, just don't miss an opportunity if it will arise. While it may be not ideal having too many preggos before attack, I really don't want a game over if our attack goes too badly
Yes, she does need souls. So she goes to get souls.No thanks, we need Gwen safe. Besides I prefer to consider enchantments unacceptable except for extreme cases
Ah. Yup, bad choice.QuoteMay I ask why?It was a bad idea to participate in a religion\atheism discussion thread.
Ah. Yup, good choice. Idea. Whatever.QuoteOut of what, platinum?I am quite sure that we didn't spent all 50 steel maces we had
BTW, it would be nice to have a home sections in the stats. Description of the tower, it's surroundings, facilities, resources, etc
Less the number of "preggos," more Alice's wish to not have a kid until she's had a chance to watch a couple other consorts try their hands.QuoteCan't really argue with any of these, if we have the time to do this stuff and still spend time with our family. Wait, no, delay impregnation of Alice until Jimma has her kid.As I said - Don't actively try, just don't miss an opportunity if it will arise. While it may be not ideal having too many preggos before attack, I really don't want a game over if our attack goes too badly
Aside from "extreme," sure. "Important," I'd say.QuoteYes, she does need souls. So she goes to get souls.No thanks, we need Gwen safe. Besides I prefer to consider enchantments unacceptable except for extreme cases
If we do send Gwen somewhere... (Everpine would be my choice) then together with Jimma (Jimma need to give a birth before the war with Oakworshiped, so she needs to hunt)Aside from impregnating Alice, sure. And I doubt Gwen has much skill with bows; not impossible, but I'm guessing it's an either-or thing, it doesn't usually make sense to focus on both two-weapon fighting and archery.
We may use that time to spend it with Alice without distractions Chat, discuss her fate, train armed combat and\or communications. We may get an opportunity to impregnate her. Also, I'd consider using Alice's old bow to train ourself, our stealth and eon manipulation mix nicely with bows. (BTW Is Gwen good with bows? Blinking archer is a machine of death... The main problem is that her arms are way to big for the bow)
What if Alice will be in good mood? If we get a romantic moment or something? As I said don't try actively, just keep that in mind if opportunity arise.Sure, if it comes up. Don't push it, though.
BTW, we'll need someone to guard our son while we fighting. Alice is a good choice for that because she can ran away with him... Add babygirl to the oven (like our GM likes to say) and we have guarantee that Night troll will survive even if we don'tGood point and good idea.
I don't think we should impregnate alice yet, for a number of reasons.Agreed on all counts. Besides, we might come across some consort-material in the upcoming raid, and we're almost certainly going to get Vindel's girl - need to save what gifts we have remaining for that imo.
I think we need to figure out what's going on with the child we already have on the way before we add a third to those we need to care for. Three children is a lot to take care of, particularly if we plan on getting to any more shenanigans in the near future.
We don't really know much about caring for a child, this goes back to the "too many children" thing again, basically, we have no idea how much of a handful the one/two will be, we don't need to exasperate problems if any of our children prove difficult to deal with.
Alice *also* has expressed a wish to learn more about caring for children before having her own, we should follow her reasoning and respect that decision.
I think we need to figure out what's going on with the child we already have on the way before we add a third to those we need to care for. Three children is a lot to take care of, particularly if we plan on getting to any more shenanigans in the near future.Infants don't need anything expect food. No fear, no magic. It's not much harder to protect 3 than protect one.
Besides, we might come across some consort-material in the upcoming raid,Or we might die with highly valuable unspent gift. And the left stone don't mix well with anyone who aren't very loyal
Improving Communicator: Your Communication skill will increase if you succeed in 1 communication actions, or train extensively under a superior communicator.We have this for a looooong time (I admit that it's way to easy to raise communication skill, because we make so many rolls, but still)
Time Displacement Specialist: Take a +1 to any attempt to send something foward in time.We lost that when we leveled up eon manipulation
Budding Fire Manipulator: You will gain the fire manipulation skill if you succeed in 2 fire manipulation actions or train with somebody who has itObsolete
Gift of Amnesia: Can be spent to convert or impregnate a mate. The night troll created will have a hypnosis power capable of removing the last few minutes of a mortal's memory.Spent
I certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)
I certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)Same here. I was planning to start a forum game. You?
i was planning on being the alchemist or somethingI certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)Same here. I was planning to start a forum game. You?
Been working on a choose-your-own-adventure app for a while heh. Programming's all done for it, just working on the writing now.I certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)Same here. I was planning to start a forum game. You?
Sounds cool.Been working on a choose-your-own-adventure app for a while heh. Programming's all done for it, just working on the writing now.I certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)Same here. I was planning to start a forum game. You?
It did not die. Just got some new games to keep me occupied. Sorry.
It did not die. Just got some new games to keep me occupied. Sorry.Glad to hear it
Thanks! ^^Sounds cool.Been working on a choose-your-own-adventure app for a while heh. Programming's all done for it, just working on the writing now.I certainly hope not, this thread actually inspired me to start a project of my own. (Though, the project might have been too ambitious, it's a lot of work, and i feel guilty for not having it ready yet.)Same here. I was planning to start a forum game. You?
Reposting just in case (with small update)
1) Order our ghost to make gauntlets, helmets and boots, any unused metal is bad. Any body protection is good
2) Train armed combat, friendly sparring is always good way to improve relations and we need to not rely only on our magic. Train armor usage, too
What gender is the troll?Better question: WHAT troll? I thought we were going for whats-her-name, who Vindel and that elf we killed both liked.
What gender is the troll?Better question: WHAT troll? I thought we were going for whats-her-name, who Vindel and that elf we killed both liked.
Oh, thanks.Yeah, she has a part troll bodyguard who is with her at all times.What gender is the troll?Better question: WHAT troll? I thought we were going for whats-her-name, who Vindel and that elf we killed both liked.
The plan to foghorn proposed was to take out the bodygaurd and terrorize the town, so that he could negotiate taking the girl in exchange for something of a truce.
Alright then. So, if he's 25% troll, does that mean he has reduced mental capacities? That could be...useful.
Agreed. Still, if he's just a bodyguard, the elves probably didn't focus too much on making sure he had much magic--especially since his trollish strength and toughness would compensate 90% of the time.Alright then. So, if he's 25% troll, does that mean he has reduced mental capacities? That could be...useful.I don't think that's something we should rely on though, genetics only goes so far, particularly when so diluted.
We really need to practice with the magic of that spear, so that we don't keep turning our stuff to sand. (While we do so we should leave our possessions behind.)+1, ideally without turning stuff to sand in the process. Speaking of which, in the future remove all items from pockets and all important clothing from body before practicing with the spear.
Have Gwen kill an elf or two from oak worshiped, urge caution however, the last time she went soul-searching (hehehe) she almost got killed by a vampire.Certainly.
[/b]
Sure.
We should also congratulate Cherlyn, praise her for her usefulness.
+1, ideally without turning stuff to sand in the process. Speaking of which, in the future remove all items from pockets and all important clothing from body before practicing with the spear.
She's an enchanterQuote+1, ideally without turning stuff to sand in the process. Speaking of which, in the future remove all items from pockets and all important clothing from body before practicing with the spear.
You think that then failed rolls will not hurt us in some other way? :)
Gwen can't get souls now, our amulet is the only way to do it. And giving it to her, will not help. She knows no suitable magic
Oh, it will. We'll just make it more interesting and less annoying.Quote+1, ideally without turning stuff to sand in the process. Speaking of which, in the future remove all items from pockets and all important clothing from body before practicing with the spear.You think that then failed rolls will not hurt us in some other way? :)
Enchanting need souls... And she need to put someone under effect of some spell to get that soulUm, seeing as Gwen has enchanted before, and gave us the necklace, it won't be a problem. Also, she probably has backups, we're not using the soul-catcher, and the usual "spell" to get a soul involves killing someone and not a lot more.
Gwendolyn also informs you that she would not be comfortable in metal armor, but at least you are able to convince her to take a helmet. You also tell her that she can go back to using her wooden swords. She sheepishly informs you that she threw a fit and snapped both of them, and will need your help collecting souls for future enchantments.QuoteQuoteand the usual "spell" to get a soul involves killing someone and not a lot more.Nope, killing with spell is not enough, remember the elf we got soul from. We had to slowdown him to get his soul
I fail to see why this would be. If Weirdsound could give us a salient reason...but until then, Gwen's just whining or failing to realize/care that she could get souls herself if we lent her the Soulcatcher.QuoteGwendolyn also informs you that she would not be comfortable in metal armor, but at least you are able to convince her to take a helmet. You also tell her that she can go back to using her wooden swords. She sheepishly informs you that she threw a fit and snapped both of them, and will need your help collecting souls for future enchantments.
1. Not killing with a spell, killing.Quoteand the usual "spell" to get a soul involves killing someone and not a lot more.Nope, killing with spell is not enough, remember the elf we got soul from. We had to slowdown him to get his soul
Gwen has gotten souls on her own before though, i don't follow.Yeah, she used her sword for that before she broke it...
As far as we know Gwen knows no other school but enchantments... Those can't modify anything without using soulsConveniently, that's all we'd be asking her to do.
I don't remember hearing that, it doesn't make sense for her to have broken her swords if that's true, and we could always lend her our Soulcatcher.QuoteGwen has gotten souls on her own before though, i don't follow.Yeah, she used her sword for that before she broke it...
BTW, can't say that I am unhappy, I dislike enchantments for Night troll ethics reasonsWell, it's not like there aren't people deserving of nothing more than being used as an enchantment postmortem. Head to an evlen prisontree or something.
Reposting just in case (with small update)
1) Order our ghost to make gauntlets, helmets and boots, any unused metal is bad. Any body protection is good
2) Train armed combat, friendly sparring is always good way to improve relations and we need to not rely only on our magic. Train armor usage, too
(We should go into the forest to find people for souls.)
Maybe we should force Jimma to give birth first by hunting around Oakworshiped first
Toss 'em in the future and dig a pit where they were last standing. Then when they arrive, terrorize them.
Perhaps we don't want to make yet another enemy just yet. Fling their weapons into the future if possible, but either way explain that we don't want to earn the ire of their people, and that their people don't want to earn our ire either.Oh, right, we haven't run into the human nations yet. +1
"No love, it was the elves that almost killed our race not humans, these men kill our enemies, have you not heard the old saying, we should let them live, give them orders to give to their leader and start a diplomatic mission. A strong man can win a fight, a smart man can make the fight win itself"+1
How about telling the truth for a change?
"The surrounding elf villages are on high alert and heavily armed because they were recently ransacked by us. You should try other villages."
How about telling the truth for a change?We tell them the truth. We just make the elves sounds more dangerous than they are. (If they note our deception, we can say we were trying to dissuade them from what we felt was a suicide mission, without telling much of a lie.)
"The surrounding elf villages are on their toes because they were recently attacked by us. You should try other villages."
Propose this plan to them: they 'bloody' themselves up a bit to look wounded, and 'flee' to the elf settlement, claiming that they were attacked by night trolls and that they managed to wound a few before escaping - thus encouraging the elves to send out a patrol to try to finish off the weakened night troll group, ideally.+1
If the elves do send out a patrol, we'll strike once they've left, and the humans can strike from inside if an opportunity presents itself.
If the elves do not send the patrol, we'll attack at night and have the humans, as with the other plan, do some backstabbing.
We'll offer them half the prisoners captured in the raid.
+1 Muwahahahah!Propose this plan to them: they 'bloody' themselves up a bit to look wounded, and 'flee' to the elf settlement, claiming that they were attacked by night trolls and that they managed to wound a few before escaping - thus encouraging the elves to send out a patrol to try to finish off the weakened night troll group, ideally.+1
If the elves do send out a patrol, we'll strike once they've left, and the humans can strike from inside if an opportunity presents itself.
If the elves do not send the patrol, we'll attack at night and have the humans, as with the other plan, do some backstabbing.
We'll offer them half the prisoners captured in the raid.
Interesting and potentially good plan. Also, new sentencing to death method: Eaten alive by night trolls.+1 Muwahahahah!Propose this plan to them: they 'bloody' themselves up a bit to look wounded, and 'flee' to the elf settlement, claiming that they were attacked by night trolls and that they managed to wound a few before escaping - thus encouraging the elves to send out a patrol to try to finish off the weakened night troll group, ideally.+1
If the elves do send out a patrol, we'll strike once they've left, and the humans can strike from inside if an opportunity presents itself.
If the elves do not send the patrol, we'll attack at night and have the humans, as with the other plan, do some backstabbing.
We'll offer them half the prisoners captured in the raid.
I have a nice little long-term plan for us:Sounds like a nice long-term plan...okay, "nice" is a poor word to describe it...
1. Boost relations with human race.
2. Manipulate humans into disparate, yet similar nations.
3. Ensure all nations are founded on cruelty and oppression. Good rule of thumb; the more the leader is like Stalin, the better.
4. Offer our services as a... dumping ground for political prisoners.
5. Never go hungry again!
Read your Evil Overlord List and study your Tarquin. There are some important lessons about being a villain there.Indeed. Set up 3-4 nations, with us and our close allies as advisers to the heads-of-state. Guide the occasional rebellion, and make sure we advise the new leaders as well. While the world will seem to change, and may change in fact, our place in it will not.
And make sure that when you die, it's from hero's and not old age.Read your Evil Overlord List and study your Tarquin. There are some important lessons about being a villain there.Indeed. Set up 3-4 nations, with us and our close allies as advisers to the heads-of-state. Guide the occasional rebellion, and make sure we advise the new leaders as well. While the world will seem to change, and may change in fact, our place in it will not.
If we win, we become a king.And make sure that when you die, it's from hero's and not old age.Read your Evil Overlord List and study your Tarquin. There are some important lessons about being a villain there.Indeed. Set up 3-4 nations, with us and our close allies as advisers to the heads-of-state. Guide the occasional rebellion, and make sure we advise the new leaders as well. While the world will seem to change, and may change in fact, our place in it will not.
Yep. ;DIf we win, we become a king.And make sure that when you die, it's from hero's and not old age.Read your Evil Overlord List and study your Tarquin. There are some important lessons about being a villain there.Indeed. Set up 3-4 nations, with us and our close allies as advisers to the heads-of-state. Guide the occasional rebellion, and make sure we advise the new leaders as well. While the world will seem to change, and may change in fact, our place in it will not.
If we lose, we become a legend.
Whoa, ambition jump much guys XDThis happens when we think ahead.
Whoa, ambition jump much guys XDThis happens when we think.
*mercy-kills Grek and rabidgam3r*?
*mercy-kills Grek
*mercy-kills
-It's spreading.
I regret everything.I-REGRET-NOTHIIINNNG-!
Propose this plan to them: they 'bloody' themselves up a bit to look wounded, and 'flee' to the elf settlement, claiming that they were attacked by night trolls and that they managed to wound a few before escaping - thus encouraging the elves to send out a patrol to try to finish off the weakened night troll group, ideally.
If the elves do send out a patrol, we'll strike once they've left, and the humans can strike from inside if an opportunity presents itself.
If the elves do not send the patrol, we'll attack at night and have the humans, as with the other plan, do some backstabbing.
We'll offer them half the prisoners captured in the raid.
We could of course warn the elves of your presence, we believe our offer is enough.
Women are rarely brothers.That's sigworthy
What kind of moron takes their female companions along on a trip through night-troll-infested woods? (Unless she's a great fighter, of course...)They didn't know that there were night trolls here, they thought we were all dead, and they could be referring to brothers in arms or brothers in religion, there's a lot of gender neutral brothers.
Oh, and I'm pretty sure that they were referred to as brothers at some point. Women are rarely brothers.
1. So the elves have been hiding the secret of Fellsoil?What kind of moron takes their female companions along on a trip through night-troll-infested woods? (Unless she's a great fighter, of course...)They didn't know that there were night trolls here, they thought we were all dead, and they could be referring to brothers in arms or brothers in religion, there's a lot of gender neutral brothers.
Oh, and I'm pretty sure that they were referred to as brothers at some point. Women are rarely brothers.
Why would they warn those who hate them, and who would believe them anyway?1. So the elves have been hiding the secret of Fellsoil?What kind of moron takes their female companions along on a trip through night-troll-infested woods? (Unless she's a great fighter, of course...)They didn't know that there were night trolls here, they thought we were all dead, and they could be referring to brothers in arms or brothers in religion, there's a lot of gender neutral brothers.
Oh, and I'm pretty sure that they were referred to as brothers at some point. Women are rarely brothers.
Elves have never shown hatred for humans, the one settlement (Dawnmadien??) which included a substantial human population (and which we also terrorized) proves conclusively otherwise, and there's kinda some empirical evidence of our existence beyond eyewitness testimony...like those people that aren't around. Did the elves kill Gwen and the others and hide their corpses just to make their tale sound nicer to human ears?Why would they warn those who hate them, and who would believe them anyway?1. So the elves have been hiding the secret of Fellsoil?What kind of moron takes their female companions along on a trip through night-troll-infested woods? (Unless she's a great fighter, of course...)They didn't know that there were night trolls here, they thought we were all dead, and they could be referring to brothers in arms or brothers in religion, there's a lot of gender neutral brothers.
Oh, and I'm pretty sure that they were referred to as brothers at some point. Women are rarely brothers.
Ok I exaggerated a bit but they are far from friendly nations, and people being people would call our "reappearance" a hoax or a terrorist plot, and these people are actively looking for elves to kill.Well...
Yeah. They are all dudes.Aw...
Kill two of them and drag the last one back to torture his ass for disrespecting us.Yes meat for the child, fear saturated meat!
I can't help but be disturbed when I approve of murdering two people and torturing their brother...Kill two of them and drag the last one back to torture his ass for disrespecting us.Yes meat for the child, fear saturated meat!
Woo!
Capture one, travel back in time and catch the other?We could try to pause time, but if it went wrong...
To the tower!With prisoners!This sounds good.
=(+1