Bay 12 Games Forum

Dwarf Fortress => DF Gameplay Questions => Topic started by: WingDing on May 24, 2008, 06:21:00 pm

Title: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: WingDing on May 24, 2008, 06:21:00 pm
Ok, I've heard a lot of things can cause food to wear such as temperature, vermin, "trampling", being outside a barrel, and being outside a stockpile, but I'm wondering what really makes food rot?

I've never actually had this problem myself (or at least I don't remember anything like that) so I'd like to hear everyone else's experiences with rotting food.

I find myself rather skeptical about all this so I would appreciate if you provide some evidence for your explanations if you can.

Thanks!

edit: I should have clarified that you should give information on your fort relevant to this discussion such as if you have cats, vermin, barrels, site temperature, that sort of thing.

[ May 25, 2008: Message edited by: WingDing ]

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Jhyn on May 24, 2008, 06:37:00 pm
Food left in a kitchen without beeing taken to the stockpile eventually rots. Even if they are quarry bushes exceptionnal roasts [30], worth twenty thousands.

Yes, my current fortress is quite low on haulers.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: lastofthelight on May 24, 2008, 06:48:00 pm
I've heard that food inside doesn't rot (the wiki notes this several times) - but as shown above, food inside a kitchen certainly rots, and food left in my stockpile will often rot as well. Unless....

...Unless....

I have barrels! Barrels and bins are my best friends now, and I'll spend hundreds of logs on building them incessantly, and my problems with that went away.

I'm also pretty sure the rain thing is true, I had a /lot/ of problems getting food to grow before I turned off weather (which also sped up my framerate a ton) - and now I have massive food surpluses.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: RPB on May 24, 2008, 09:03:00 pm
My experience: Food in stockpiles does not rot. Food outside stockpiles turns rotten after a period of time. "Damage" does not appear to factor into this.

Every once in a great while I will see xFoodx, but it's a rare freak occurence for me. Most of the floorspace for my fortress is used for storage, so even though the food gets trampled continuously I don't see it taking any wear & tear.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: toast on May 24, 2008, 09:09:00 pm
i keep seeing these posts...so i just took the time to check out my food stocks. none of my prepared meals are worn at all, but some of the raw materials are. (i.e dog meat, turtles etc. stuff that hasnt been turned into a *whatever roast*)

i dont know this for sure, but i have seen someone somewhere imply that vermin cause wear by eating stuff.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: BurnedToast on May 25, 2008, 12:48:00 am
I'm fairly (but not 100%) sure the xXfoodXx is caused by vermin. Also I am sure that cold enough weather will rather quickly destroy meat by 'wear' but this is only usually a problem on glaciers.
Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: WingDing on May 25, 2008, 01:04:00 am
quote:
i dont know this for sure, but i have seen someone somewhere imply that vermin cause wear by eating stuff.
quote:
I'm fairly (but not 100%) sure the xXfoodXx is caused by vermin.

I've heard of this but I'm rather skeptical about it. I never actually saw any proof of these claims nor heard anything like that from Toady. I want to figure out if this is true or not because misinformation really bothers me.

That and I actually like vermin more than say, most animals in DF, because vermin don't crowd in my dining rooms or cause massive traffic jams...

And because wild vermin can't mangle my dwarves' lower bodies.  :(

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Derakon on May 25, 2008, 01:14:00 am
The only food I've ever seen become worn is meat. Everything else is either fine or rotten, and will not rot in a food stockpile (they're magical that way). I don't know what causes wear in meat, though.
Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Name Lips on May 25, 2008, 02:04:00 am
I bring tons of meat when I start out, unless I'm doing a challenge. It always goes bad eventually, and has little x's on it: xMule Meatx

In my experience, dwarves will not eat such food, even if they are starving. They will instead hunt vermin.

However, such food CAN be cooked into non-spoiled meals.  :) So when it goes bad, I start cooking it, and all of a sudden my dwarves will eat again.

I think it spoils faster when it's outside. And faster if it's in hot or cold weather.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: BurnedToast on May 25, 2008, 05:06:00 pm
quote:
Originally posted by WingDing:
<STRONG>

I've heard of this but I'm rather skeptical about it. I never actually saw any proof of these claims nor heard anything like that from Toady. I want to figure out if this is true or not because misinformation really bothers me.

That and I actually like vermin more than say, most animals in DF, because vermin don't crowd in my dining rooms or cause massive traffic jams...

And because wild vermin can't mangle my dwarves' lower bodies.   :(</STRONG>



http://www.bay12games.com/cgi-local/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=6&t=000871  has a post by Toady saying vermin eat food, though I guess they just eat it totally and not nibble it.

I seem to remember something about some vermin damage food, and other just eat it outright it but I can't find it now so maybe I am remembering wrong.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: WingDing on May 26, 2008, 02:19:00 am
quote:
http://www.bay12games.com/cgi-local/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=6&t=000871  has a post by Toady saying vermin eat food, though I guess they just eat it totally and not nibble it.

I seem to remember something about some vermin damage food, and other just eat it outright it but I can't find it now so maybe I am remembering wrong.



Well I stand corrected. But that still doesn't answer what makes food wear. I remember reading a long time ago that temperature has a wearing effect on food so that is most likely the answer.

[ May 26, 2008: Message edited by: WingDing ]

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Metalax on May 26, 2008, 07:08:00 pm
I did quite a bit of testing for this a couple of months ago.

Any food left out of a stockpile will over time rot(plants will wither).

If food is inside a barrel this slows the rate of wear/rot.

Freezing or scorching temperatures do seem to speed up the rate of wear/rot, remember once inside they are no longer subjected to such temperatures.

Meat, prepared fish and raw fish will suffer wear over time even if left in stockpiles.

Plants, cooked meals, fat/tallow, milled plants, etc, do not suffer wear over time if in a stockpile(at least over the ten years I tested).

Vermin do not cause wear, however they will sometimes consume units of food. Their ability to do so is greatly reduced if the food is inside a barrel. It is further reduced if the vermin is inside a cat.

As for trampling, I have personally never seen evidence that this has caused wear in food, but this is one thing I've never explicitly tested for.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Tenebrous on May 27, 2008, 01:56:00 am
quote:
Originally posted by Metalax:
<STRONG>It is further reduced if the vermin is inside a cat.</STRONG>

I am very curious as to how you have accomplished that feat. My lazy felines just gut vermin, leaving a nice little miasma bomb in the middle of my fortress.

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: YolkFolk on May 27, 2008, 07:38:00 am
I use restricted traffic areas on top of all of my food stockpiles, just in case trampling damages food (a path of normal traffic remaining around the edge of the stockpile, or into its center if it is very large)

I suppose you could always make a zero barrel, prepared food stockpile in the center of your meeting hall, and forbid the food on it. After a year or so, you could compare it with a similar forbidden food pile kept behind a locked door...

Title: Re: Dwarf Mythbusters: XfoodX
Post by: Fooster on May 27, 2008, 10:04:00 am
Here is my personal experience on how slow meat and fish rot inside, in a barrel, in a stockpile(this last bit I personally don't believe matters in theory or practice).  I usually embark with a truckload of turtles so that I have plenty of shells from the get go.  So I know these existed from the exact beginning of Spring.  By the end of one year, they are always XturtleX.  I do not have the exact time during the year when they were just xturtlex, but always the big X after a year passes.

Now about dwarves not eating XfoodX.  Well that is utter BS.  I always forbid all other food around this time so that those buggeres all get polished off before becoming XXfoodXX.  And they gobble 'em up every time.  I have no idea if they would eat XXfoodXX though.