Bay 12 Games Forum

Dwarf Fortress => DF Adventure Mode Discussion => Topic started by: Zeebie on February 28, 2018, 10:40:29 am

Title: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Zeebie on February 28, 2018, 10:40:29 am
I'm a long-time fortress mode player just getting into adventurer mode.  I'm having a little bit of trouble making sense of how things work in combat, if anyone can enlighten me:

- Where do the various striking options come from?  What determines whether a given target is easy, normal, etc.? Are there things that can be done (eg, particular defense strategies) to set up better attacks?

- How much time do attacks take?  Sometimes I feel like I can get in a couple blows before the opponent; sometimes I take a step and a dozen things happen.

- I don't understand wrestling at all.  I'm a legendary wrestler (thanks, geese) but any given midnight creature seems able to toss me around without trouble.  Wrestling attacks also seem to happen so fast that I don't have a chance to break a grip - I've been bit, shaken around multiple times, and bled to death all in between two of my attacks. How do I counter this?

- Do wounds just heal on their own (anything other than amputation, anyway)? Is medical care and healing available anywhere?
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Cathar on February 28, 2018, 12:16:50 pm
> Where do the various striking options come from?
Random factor. Direction of your body relative to enemy (if you're flanking from the right, you'll attack right limbs easier). Opponent current move (if someone uses his right hand to attack, his right hand becomes a easier target). All of this is also true for you.

>How much time do attacks take? 

Can't say for sure, but the answer is on the wiki. Kicks take more time, slow& heavy attacks take more time. Some weapons (whips) take more time intrinsicly. Attack is separated in three phases ; windup, attack, recovery. During windup and recovery, you're stuck on place and the limb you extended becomes an easier target

> Any given midnight creature seems able to toss me around without trouble

Size matter. Night trolls are much bigger than you are. You're trying to wrestle a giant, of course you'll be tossed around

>Do wounds just heal on their own

Cut nerves never heal, but flesh wounds do. Basically, if it doesn't heal when you fast travel it's permanent.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Zeebie on February 28, 2018, 01:08:19 pm

> Any given midnight creature seems able to toss me around without trouble

Size matter. Night trolls are much bigger than you are. You're trying to wrestle a giant, of course you'll be tossed around


Ah, I didn't realize they were so big. Is there a way to see size of critters in-game?
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Cathar on February 28, 2018, 04:47:59 pm
Sure, if you use PNP, you can use dwarf portrait and compare size directly. I was surprized too, when that Moon Horror exploded the head of my dwarven companion like a melon with a single kick. Then I saw its size and...yeah it makes sense !D
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: hertggf on March 07, 2018, 05:15:45 am
- How much time do attacks take?  Sometimes I feel like I can get in a couple blows before the opponent; sometimes I take a step and a dozen things happen.
Either you're crawling (moving while lying on the ground) or you're trying to shoot your enemy with a ranged weapon.  Shooting a crossbow with dabbling skill takes just an insane amount of time; even at high levels of skill it's not worth it.  Bows aren't much better. Stick to throwing.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Ragnarock on March 07, 2018, 06:14:48 am
Although you specified your questions, I'm gonna rant a little.
Be mindful of the fact that certain enemies will be able to strike more often than you do. It's just how it is. For combat tips, this is usually what I go with

- Change your dodging preferences to stand ground and dodge manually when convenient (unless you're facing a big boi, then parry/dodge, don't stand ground)

- In the limb menu, there will be small cyan-ish exclamation marks to the right of the list (or likewise coloured arrows marking the fact that such an exclamation mark is somewhere lower on the list), these are opportunous strikes that you can make and are usually very easy and will surely connect. Be mindful of these, sometimes you can go for very vital parts and afford to throw a heavy strike here and there.

-  I wouldn't wrestle anything other than human/dwarf/elf though, it's always very risky and rarely yields any potential payoff. The attacks just aren't very damaging and most beasts are stronger than you anyways

- Wounds heal on fast travel and sleep. Some of them never heal, nerve damage especially (unless that was changed in the newest build)

- Go for the feet and the hands.

- You can use your hands to catch incoming attacks through wrestling menu if you're skilled enough.

- As a Legendary Wrestler, go on a blinding rampage and pinch eyes of everyone in the hamlet/town. It's fun.


Generally speaking, always keep tabs on the size of your opponent, more often than not tissues scale with it, yesterday I fought a giantess whose skin was so thick it was mostly impenetrable, the only reason I won against her is I cleaved her so many times with my axe she fell and gave in to pain. Weird stuff.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Urist Sonuvagimli on March 07, 2018, 10:46:12 pm
Always use Fast attack option (u) when selecting an attack. Speed matters more than damage. Also, use "," key to wait for 1 tick instead of "." that waits 10 ticks.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 09, 2018, 04:26:42 pm
I'm playing an unarmed character and disarms/limb breaks via wrestling are key.

I like grabbing a weapon away and then dodging back and flinging it at their chest. Also, good god I was unaware of the difference between , and .

I am new to adv mode.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: bloop_bleep on March 09, 2018, 05:19:46 pm
Always use Fast attack option (u) when selecting an attack. Speed matters more than damage. Also, use "," key to wait for 1 tick instead of "." that waits 10 ticks.
I would recommend using fast attacks to disable your opponent so they can't run away/fight back, and then using heavy attacks (v) for the finishing blows.

Also, I've found that sometimes it takes a lot of hits to actually finish an opponent, so a very effective option is actually jumping into them repeatedly. If you have disabled both their legs, they won't be able to dodge in time, making them fly into the air.

A quick way to potentially immediately kill an unsuspecting opponent is to sneak up behind them, bite them (v)ery hard in the neck, and then shake them around. This may sever their spinal cord, if you're lucky.

My general method when fighting gobbos or other pretty weak opponents:
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 09, 2018, 06:36:00 pm
Tangent: I have an itch for unarmed combat. What race, including animal-person, would be best for this, do you think?
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: bloop_bleep on March 09, 2018, 07:45:44 pm
Tangent: I have an itch for unarmed combat. What race, including animal-person, would be best for this, do you think?
If you like overkill, elephant man.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Fruitsbrain Weapon-tosser on March 10, 2018, 04:53:30 am
Tangent: I have an itch for unarmed combat. What race, including animal-person, would be best for this, do you think?
If you like overkill, elephant man.
Elephant Man is easily the most OP animal-person, possibly followed by Giant Desert Tortoise-men, and Elephant Seal-men. I haven't experimented with too many animal races, but I'd imagine any well sized animal would get good base stat/survivability bonuses (Deers and other animals of comparable size, Bears, Tigers, etc). Dunno if anybody has done the SCIENCE on if animals with claws get a natural bonus to scratching, or if there is any comparable difference between the different variations some races get based on their limbs and grasps (snatching, snipping, goring, etc), but in general being bigger just makes you better in almost every way. The only thing you need to watch out for is if the base animal is incapable of things like say jumping. Many animals can swim innately, so you can even save on spending a skill point for that.

I had some fun with a Saltwater Crocodile-man whose only form of offense was biting people.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 10, 2018, 11:47:30 am
Gonna make a GRIZZLY BEAR MAAAAAN and name him Fuzzlewumpus. Thank you all.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: gnome on March 13, 2018, 07:07:13 am
Tangent: I have an itch for unarmed combat. What race, including animal-person, would be best for this, do you think?
If you like overkill, elephant man.
This or Rhino Man. Both can quite easily punch the heads off small/medium sized opponents.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 13, 2018, 12:56:55 pm
Tangent: I have an itch for unarmed combat. What race, including animal-person, would be best for this, do you think?
If you like overkill, elephant man.
This or Rhino Man. Both can quite easily punch the heads off small/medium sized opponents.

Ok that does sound pretty good.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: rhavviepoodle on March 13, 2018, 04:20:06 pm
If I recall, using horns to gore uses the biting skill. I can't say I've ever played as a rhino man, but I have modded satyrs in my game to be playable, and they get to gore things. They also have the added benefit of having very resilient hooves, which makes a lot of weaker blows glance off.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: IndigoFenix on March 14, 2018, 12:26:17 am
Animals with claws don't get a special bonus to scratching, but scratch attacks are always calculated as if the nail is the size of the finger it's attached to, which is why (for humanoids) scratching is much more effective in combat than it ought to be.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 14, 2018, 12:53:09 pm
Yeah my grizzle man would rip things up with his scratch attacks, but that was probably due to his size? He would routinely shred up muscle and  arteries and sometimes organs on smaller humanoids.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: bloop_bleep on March 14, 2018, 01:07:59 pm
Yeah my grizzle man would rip things up with his scratch attacks, but that was probably due to his size? He would routinely shred up muscle and  arteries and sometimes organs on smaller humanoids.

Well, I mean, he is a bear.  :P
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Fruitsbrain Weapon-tosser on March 14, 2018, 11:08:09 pm
Animals with claws don't get a special bonus to scratching, but scratch attacks are always calculated as if the nail is the size of the finger it's attached to, which is why (for humanoids) scratching is much more effective in combat than it ought to be.
That brings to mind... how long are an Elephant-Man's fingers? When I used one, I was capable of decapitating humanoids and chipping Bronze Colossi. Really weird to think of an Elephant with fingers  :P
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Rumrusher on March 19, 2018, 07:54:37 am
Animals with claws don't get a special bonus to scratching, but scratch attacks are always calculated as if the nail is the size of the finger it's attached to, which is why (for humanoids) scratching is much more effective in combat than it ought to be.
That brings to mind... how long are an Elephant-Man's fingers? When I used one, I was capable of decapitating humanoids and chipping Bronze Colossi. Really weird to think of an Elephant with fingers  :P
considering elephantmen are just Head and variation animal bits grafted on to a Human body then scale size accordingly to animal size, their nails are probably similar to a Giants.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 19, 2018, 01:47:21 pm
Rhino man is OP, his gore can pulp any medium creature's torso.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Broseph Stalin on March 19, 2018, 02:03:12 pm
[Shameless Self Promotion]I made a martial art for adventure mode, link in my signature.[/Shameless Self Promotion]

Your speed problems can be addressed by going from walking to jogging and carefully pausing one step to set up attacks.
Title: Re: Getting the hang of combat
Post by: Dunamisdeos on March 19, 2018, 02:17:07 pm
I've lurked there before, I enjoy your martial artistry. :)