Bay 12 Games Forum

Dwarf Fortress => DF Adventure Mode Discussion => Topic started by: Tamren on May 03, 2007, 02:36:00 am

Title: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Tamren on May 03, 2007, 02:36:00 am
Personally i like all of them, though hammers are the same as maces pretty much.

My top favorite has to be the whip though. I had the fortune of seeing a masterwork iron whip in a shop once and i snapped it up. Never looked back. THWACK TWHACK THWACK it works on everything. Inflicts HUGE amounts of pain, nixes those organs with ease. Near the end with ultra mighty i was cutting off limbs with it. WHips are defenitly NOT good to start off with, hammers are the best, never get stuck and if your lucky youll start with a maul.

That character basically became a god with 4 layers of chest armour and iron everything. plus the 3 masterwork loincloths   :D

So now im starting again as another human, this time with swords.

Whao combat is so much different. Now i have to worry about unjamming my weapon and those random decapitations are great, hammers cripple well but watching limbs fly is more fun   :cool:

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Asehujiko on May 03, 2007, 03:55:00 am
Nothing beats the 120mm "live fly" artilery cannons you can find all over the place...
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: FaultyLogic on May 03, 2007, 03:55:00 am
I'm still waiting for Dragon Punch to be implemented.

"Haayyyuuuken!"

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Tamren on May 03, 2007, 02:39:00 pm
I carried around a masterwork greatax that i would throw sometimes.

Howly crap, it was DEVASTATING, anything it hit would be lopped off. Elite bowman? no problem! FLING, cuts him in half! Even worked on ettins too. Never tried it on a dragon though.

Throwing damage obviously depends on what you throw. But what are the exact factors i wonder. Weight is probably an issue, damage type is accounted for and such.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Bricktop on May 06, 2007, 10:44:00 am
One thing though.,.. if weight is a major part of this... how does a butterfly crush the skull of a Giant Jaguar?

[ May 06, 2007: Message edited by: Bricktop ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: herrbdog on May 06, 2007, 12:24:00 pm
With enough speed, a butterfly can crush ANYTHING! (theoretically...)

F=ma (or f=MA or some combination, I ferget my fizzicks, it's been a long long time.)

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: TotalPigeon on May 06, 2007, 01:45:00 pm
Duh... Fizzicks?

Yup, Force = mass x acceleration. I presume DF assumes things come to a halt from collisions in 0 seconds. Acceleration = change in speed/time to change, so when things stop instantaneously acceleration is infinite. This in turn would make the force of impact infinite, no matter what you throw. Game of catch anyone?

[ May 06, 2007: Message edited by: TotalPigeon ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Captain Mayday on May 06, 2007, 03:53:00 pm
"You throw the spinning butterfly"
"The wolf becomes one with the universe"
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: ricemastah on May 06, 2007, 07:09:00 pm
Actually for damage and pain work would make more sense to use. Which would of course be Fd, or force times distance. Since work can be related to kinetic energy via the work-kinetic energy theorem it would more realistically be (1/2)m*v^2. In short the velocity of the object being thrown is much more important.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Tamren on May 06, 2007, 08:57:00 pm
I think damage might have a few bugs though.

Im currently beating on this lion that ambushed me, stopped playing for a moment to type.

Anyhow, its a wreck... ive cut off all 4 legs and the tail, all the organs and the spine have heavy damage, and this thing is still clinging to life, hasnt even given in to pain yet!

Okay lets see what happens when i hit it again.

... ouch cleaved in 2, thats one dead lion ^ ^

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: PvK on May 11, 2007, 11:30:00 am
I found that modding the damage values for ranged weapons (actually, the ammo) down by a huge factor (about x1/10) made their damage much more reasonable and in line with the damage from other weapons. Still deadly, but not uber-super-mega-pierce-both-eyes-at-once deadly. Unfortunately (IIRC) I didn't see a way to mod down the damage from improvised non-weapon thrown crud, but if one avoids the temptation to use them it's ok since the AI doesn't.

Of course, there is also still an issue with ranged weapons in terms of the rate at which they can be fired (about one shot per step??? uh... way too fast!).


code:
 [ITEM_AMMO:ITEM_AMMO_BOLTS]
[NAME:bolt:bolts]
[CLASS:BOLT]
[DAMAGE:15:PIERCE]

[ITEM_AMMO:ITEM_AMMO_ARROWS]
[NAME:arrow:arrows]
[CLASS:ARROW]
[DAMAGE:10:PIERCE]

[ITEM_AMMO:ITEM_AMMO_BLOWDARTS]
[NAME:blowdart:blowdarts]
[CLASS:BLOWDART]
[DAMAGE:5:PIERCE]


[ May 11, 2007: Message edited by: PvK ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: TotalPigeon on May 11, 2007, 12:01:00 pm
The AI does occasionally throw... tantruming dwarves have been known to decimate their fellows. And I saw a dwarf throw the refuse he was carrying at a batman that ambushed him! Quality.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Bien on May 14, 2007, 02:32:00 am
My favorites are pikes, long swords and spears and the occational hammer and axe.
One time I was fighting with a guard so I used the hammer and I hit him and he flew halfway through town, the hammer hit his upper body and he hit a wall but did not die so I just threw rocks, spears, swords, swordfish bones, axes, hammers, armour, corpses, heads and etc.

And I went on to exterminate the town that way but once someone was stuck to a wall beside a tree so i burnt the tree!

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: bittersweet on March 02, 2008, 01:43:00 am
I rather like beating goblins to death with the corpses of local children, but thats not really practical all the time so I usually end up using axes.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: PTTG?? on March 02, 2008, 01:47:00 am
quote:
Originally posted by FaultyLogic:
<STRONG>I'm still waiting for Dragon Punch to be implemented.

"Haayyyuuuken!"</STRONG>


I'm still waiting for magic to be implemented...

Haaaaadoken!

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Mulch Diggums on March 02, 2008, 01:54:00 am
I love using swords. Usualy when I start an adventurer I go to the armor store and steal the best stuff and go on a rampage to the sword shop and take every single sword. I use the best sword as a weapon and use the others for throwing. When I get ambushed by wolves I wait till they get close and start sword throwing... Usualy I can inleast slow them all down if I have enough swords.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: JoRo on March 02, 2008, 02:25:00 am
I usually use swords for limb lopping awesome, but it's so satisfying to bust out the hammer and send your enemies flying.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Torak on March 02, 2008, 03:02:00 am
I weapons all seem a bit monotonous for me lately, so I'm using wrestling. Only. The weapons just make a good finisher/opener if I want to overkill/cheat.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Deathworks on March 02, 2008, 03:18:00 am
Hi!

I have played only a little in adventure mode. I started with a female swordsman but once she was quite good with the sword, I tried out a warhammer.

Now, I am back to the sword (or rather scimitar, still the one she started with), because I like all the stuff flying around. And among the useless kills (those without even a loincloth, for crying out loud), I have become to love antmen. So much stuff flying around :) :) :) :) :)

So, swords it is for me. (Not thrown, of course, but rather used for hacking and slicing)

Deathworks

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Keiseth on March 02, 2008, 03:26:00 am
Not a weapon, but I always liked being a wrestler and picking up whatever I could find in a pinch. A rock, that last goblin's pants, a silk shoe or even the weapon the guard just had.

Sort of like improvising as I go along.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Kagus on March 02, 2008, 04:18:00 am
Wrestling is all well and fine, but there's just something satisfying about smashing someone so hard with your hammer that they're sent flying back into a wall, causing them to explode in a shower of bodyparts.

And if you use swords for hacking pieces off, why not use an axe?  They're better at it.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Wooty on March 02, 2008, 04:47:00 am
What I do is make one 'Adventuring world.' I start a fortress on it, with modded reactions and items and whatnot that let me mass produce iron and steel weapons and armor like mad. Meanwhile, I make a 'training chamber' for swimming, that lets mah dude pull three levers to let water in at a fast, medium, or snail-slow rate.

I then start all adventurers in the same town next to the fort, and immediately arm them with X1 Steel spike, X4 iron spear, and extra armor. Also booze and plump helmets to supplement my Xbear meatX.

I love spears, I love pikes...And throwing spears isn't as exploit-y either.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Greiger on March 02, 2008, 04:46:00 pm
I prefer wielding swords, I usually keep extras for throwing too.

If I make an adventurer storage house I typically stock it with large serrated disk blades for throwing instead.  They kinda make sense for throwing and are strong even if all ya have handy is glass.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Helmaroc on March 02, 2008, 04:49:00 pm
Spear. STAB Heart pierced, lungs pierced. STAB heart pierced again, lungs pierced again. STAB hear-target has bled to death.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Boksi on March 02, 2008, 04:56:00 pm
Halberd. No question there. One of my adventurers once hit a mayor so hard, it clove his upper body asunder and propelled him into the wall where he exploded in a gory mess.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Mulch Diggums on March 02, 2008, 11:01:00 pm
quote:
Originally posted by Kagus:
[QB]Wrestling is all well and fine, but there's just something satisfying about smashing someone so hard with your hammer that they're sent flying back into a wall, causing them to explode in a shower of bodyparts.
QB]

Its even more satisfying if your adventurer is so strong he does that almost every time with his swords.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: grelphy on March 02, 2008, 11:55:00 pm
Whips all the way. Somehow the idea of shredding the mayor with an *iron whip* is just irresistible.

Plus, they cause lots and lots of pain and at high levels are just as deadly as any other weapon.

Though one has to wonder how hearts get pierced by a whip...

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Sean Mirrsen on March 03, 2008, 03:53:00 am
I prefer to play either spearmen or wrestlers. Spears make nice criticals, and wrestling with the MA mod is plain fun.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Sithlordz on March 03, 2008, 04:08:00 am
I use axes or mauls.  Axes for lots and lots of lopping off and blood, mauls for turning goblins into fireworks.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Aegis on March 03, 2008, 04:33:00 am
I like axes. They're a cross between a hammer AND a sword. SWAAAAAMER!
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Fenrir on March 03, 2008, 09:28:00 am
quote:
posted May 14, 2007 03:32 AM
Nobody noticed?
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Kagus on March 03, 2008, 09:54:00 am
Well I'll be darned.


How the hell do the new guys manage to dig up old threads like this?  Are they naturally drawn towards the topics that are far back in the archives?

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Fenrir on March 03, 2008, 09:57:00 am
Hang on...

Now it's telling me that this topic was started today! What gives?

The AI emerging in the forums is playing mind games with us...

[ March 03, 2008: Message edited by: Fenrir ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Wiles on March 03, 2008, 10:10:00 am
quote:
Originally posted by Kagus:
<STRONG>Well I'll be darned.


How the hell do the new guys manage to dig up old threads like this?  Are they naturally drawn towards the topics that are far back in the archives?</STRONG>


Forums are a funny place. A member will make a new topic and he'll get told to use the search feature, the topic has already been discussed. A member will use the search function and post and he'll be told that he shouldn't be posting in old posts.    :p

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Kagus on March 03, 2008, 10:18:00 am
Yeah, no kidding...  But you see, we have seniority, which means we get to do whatever we damn well want and then blame it on the new guys.


But there really is an art to finding out whether or not to post a reply or a new thread...  You have to strike the balance juuust right, in order to cover all your bases.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Fenrir on March 03, 2008, 10:57:00 am
quote:
Originally posted by Kagus:
<STRONG>we have seniority</STRONG>
Who exactly? How long do you have to be a member of the forum? Well, it should probably be measured by the number of posts.

My stats:
Member Status:  Bay Watcher  
Member Number:  8962  
Registered:  November 04, 2007  
Posts:  1674  
Title:  Monstrous Wolf

Am I a part of this 'senority'?

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Kagus on March 03, 2008, 11:25:00 am
It's hard to tell jokes over the internet...  


I don't honestly think that any sort of seniority should/would affect how we are allowed to behave.  I was just making a comment on how after a while, forumgoers become an integrated group who tells off new folks when they make a slip-up.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Fenrir on March 03, 2008, 11:28:00 am
quote:
Originally posted by Kagus:
<STRONG>It's hard to tell jokes over the internet...</STRONG>
Yeah, isn't it?   :D
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Deathworks on March 03, 2008, 01:37:00 pm
Hi!

Talking about favorite weapons, I am happy that I finally found a store that sold interesting swords - thus far, I either saw two-handed swords or short swords and I really wanted a replacement for my scimitar. Now, I have a nice long sword.

And it is really nice to see cougars cloven asunder and propelled about one screen away by the blow :) :)

(Even with the scimitar, I recently had a tigerman who nearly did the black knight number for me. I think he still had one leg, but the other arms and legs ...)

Deathworks

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Kyselina on March 03, 2008, 02:01:00 pm
Fenrir, more of a spammer, huh?  :roll:
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Fenrir on March 03, 2008, 04:06:00 pm
quote:
Originally posted by Kyselina:
<STRONG>Fenrir, more of a spammer, huh?   :roll:</STRONG>
What?
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: BlueDestiny on March 03, 2008, 05:38:00 pm
I like to use axes, mostly for the bits and pieces flying around. If I need to kill something dangerous though, I'll stick to a pike/spear or bow/crossbow.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: bamorrow on March 03, 2008, 06:20:00 pm
I'm getting the impression that I perhaps should feel some guilt for going after the easily acheived masterwork obsidian rock swords.

and carrying seven of them.

and throwing six of them.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Dark on March 03, 2008, 06:55:00 pm
Tis a fact that my favorite weapon is an exceptional bronze morning star. Nothing like bashing goblin swordmasters with spikey balls-on-sticks.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: umiman on March 03, 2008, 07:00:00 pm
Using arrows makes a nice melee weapon. It's like a light mini spear. It's fun to do this:
1. Stab enemy with arrow. Arrow gets lodged.
2. Release arrow and take new one out.
3. Stab enemy with arrow. Arrow gets lodged.
4. Release arrow and take out a stack of iron bolt(28).
5. Stab enemy with stack of iron bolt(28). Enemy explodes.
6. Pick up arrows.

Or if you're particularly cruel:
1. Grab right upper arm with left lower arm.
2. Take-down via right upper arm with left lower arm.
3. Lock right upper arm with left lower arm.
4. Grab left lower arm with iron shield.
5. Grab right upper leg with left lower leg.
6. Lock right upper leg with left lower leg.
7. Grab left upper leg with right lower leg.
8. Lock left upper leg with right lower leg.
9. Grab head with right hand.
10. Pinch nose with right hand.
11. Gouge left eye with right hand.
12. Gouge right eye with right hand.
13. Attack enemy with stack of steel iron arrow(11).
14. Stabbity stab stab stab.

^ And the above is why I become a legendary wrestler in adventurer mode in minutes.

edit: I'm not particularly sure if arrows get lodged since whenever I attack with arrows, it skips to step 5.

[ March 03, 2008: Message edited by: umiman ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: shadow_archmagi on March 07, 2008, 07:37:00 pm
Hammer. I love it when I bash something against a wall and every single limb goes flying. Or when I smash something off a cliff. Or when it just lies there with no bones left.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: SmileyMan on March 07, 2008, 09:13:00 pm
Have just spent an enjoyable session learning the forgotten art of halberd throwing, having picked one up that was just lying around (next to the body of the guard I just killed)

Thrown halberds seem to have a higher-than-average propensity for scoring headshots.  I can now pile up heads like cannonballs after all the decapitations.

Either that, or I managed to find a magical vorpal halberd!

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Psyco Jelly on March 07, 2008, 10:18:00 pm
quote:
Throwing damage obviously depends on what you throw. But what are the exact factors i wonder. Weight is probably an issue, damage type is accounted for and such.

Anything moving THAT fast deals piercing damage.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Greiger on March 07, 2008, 10:26:00 pm
I vote senority be based on the date the person joined not just posts. Makes me look better.  :D

Aaaanywho.  In regards to throwing weapons, is the throwing damage the same as the weapon's damage or is it just a fraction of it? Related to throw skill?

I'm positive the objects damage numbers influence the damage when it hits but is the damage reduced? Increased? What?

And do heavier things with no damage numbers do more damage than lighter things?  Say if I threw a fly and a statue, would they do the same damage or would the statue do more?  These are the mysteries that keep me awake at night, when I need to go to sleep so that Smash Bros. seems to get here sooner.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: umiman on March 07, 2008, 11:51:00 pm
quote:
Originally posted by Greiger:
<STRONG>I vote senority be based on the date the person joined not just posts. Makes me look better.   :D

Aaaanywho.  In regards to throwing weapons, is the throwing damage the same as the weapon's damage or is it just a fraction of it? Related to throw skill?

I'm positive the objects damage numbers influence the damage when it hits but is the damage reduced? Increased? What?

And do heavier things with no damage numbers do more damage than lighter things?  Say if I threw a fly and a statue, would they do the same damage or would the statue do more?  These are the mysteries that keep me awake at night, when I need to go to sleep so that Smash Bros. seems to get here sooner.</STRONG>


One more day.  ;)

I would assume from experience that weight determines the knockback of the thrown item. So... a thrown statue would give you the "the human is sent flying by the force of the blow" or related messages more often.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: nunix on March 08, 2008, 01:41:00 pm
Gotta say I enjoy using the whip/scourge as well. It's an uncommon weapon, and lets you get your vampire slayin' action on.
Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Doctor Lucky on March 10, 2008, 07:08:00 pm
For a long time, my favourite weapon was a masterwork adamantine spear.  On my way out of the defunct fortress after retrieving it, my brand-new adventurer walked smack into a tentacle demon.  I threw the spear, it went through the brain, nuff said.

Since I was trained as a swordsdwarf, I switched to the masterwork short sword and  reserved the spear (and the 500 adamantine coins, heh heh) for distance work.  The sword has a tendency to overkill anything I meet.  It doesn't *always* kill *immediately* with the first shot, but it usually does.

Recently, however, I "bought" a basic craftelfship alder short sword from an elven "merchant". (Read: stole from a guard).  It's now my favourite, since it actually allows me to hit things repeatedly, thus increasing my sword skill quickly.

As an aside the rest of the elves actually drew blood!  Couple of pine arrows in the hand.  That's the first time I've been hit with this adventurer, and he's been through dozens of cyclopes/minotaurs/trolls/ettins and hundreds of ---men. (ant, rat, bat, trogs, etc.)  I've taken out a handful of elite gobbo bowmen, but I was always careful to sneak close and spear them.

I'm currently on a quest to find a bronze colossus, but he's in a HUGE cave system, and so far I've only found caveswallowmen, ratmen, antmen, trogs, naked mole dogs, rats, goats and the like.

I want to wrestle him  :)

Oh - I haven't tried it out, but I *did* make two adamantine/birch ballista ammo.  I figure they ought to do good throwing damage.  Didn't find them on my first visit to my fort, and I got spooked by that demon.

Fear the were-carp.

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Shadowlord on March 17, 2008, 12:29:00 am
I've got an adventurer running around in full masterwork adamantine plate+chain armor, with an adamantine backpack, quiver, and cloak...

I made a masterwork adamantine short sword, spear, mace, and crossbow. All in all, I like the sword best. It kills 90% of the time on the first hit, by slicing the target in half. If it doesn't do a fatal hit, it still slices some limb off. It tends to send the enemy flying too (usually when it chops them in half).

I killed the goblins' demon god with it: http://www.screencast.com/t/5Xo6obd6jyz

He gave me a yellow finger (badly burnt, from a fireball) and some sprains and minor burns (brown) from the same fireball. He only hit me with one before he got sliced in half and sent flying 20 spaces into a tree.

I also killed a bronze colossus (twice):  http://mkv25.net/dfma/movie-434-killingcolossuswithanadventurer1  http://mkv25.net/dfma/movie-435-killingcolossuswithanadventurer2

I've kind of run out of things to do with him, though - it was a tiny world, so there was only one goblin fort, two human towns, a dwarf city, and I don't think there are any elves.

P.S. Your colossus probably isn't in the caves at all. The first time mine was standing outside around 30 squares away from the cave entrance. The second time he was nowhere nearby, but eventually going to 'Creature' and wandering around in increasingly large circles resulted in me finding him.

P.P.S. I severed one of the colossus' limbs in the second movie with a thrown masterwork adamantine crossbow.

[ March 17, 2008: Message edited by: Shadowlord ]

Title: Re: Favorite weapon?
Post by: Doctor Lucky on March 17, 2008, 06:12:00 am
I did eventually locate the colossus.  He was on an adjacent map square, which I noticed had the "migrant" marking.  

When we met, I dropped my sword and shield, and wrestled him until I'd broken everything except one shoulder, which I'd crippled.

Sensing that throttling a non-breathing creature was getting me nowhere, I bludgeoned him to death with the alder sword.  It wound up taking off a leg before I was done.

Now one of my favourite throwing weapons is a masterwork bronze statue...

DL