Scum IC unless you object.... Not going to be crazy?
Nope. I wil give helpful information to the scum.Scum IC unless you object.... Not going to be crazy?
Then feel free to coach.Nope. I wil give helpful information to the scum.Scum IC unless you object.... Not going to be crazy?
I will try my best.
Am I too new to Town IC?You can IC if you feel you'll be up for it.
If you use both Roleblocker and Godfather, I would have more than 9.Nah. It's RNG.
Can I get through a game without shit coming up and forcing me to leave? Shall we find out?Best not leave...
You are a Townie.
The Mafia has infiltrated your precious Town and are causing havoc. Root them out and stop the Mafia menace.
Each Day, you will attempt to lynch a Mafia member by voting for them. But beware, at Night the Mafia prowl the streets.
You are a Cop.
The Mafia has infiltrated your precious Town and are causing havoc. Root them out and stop the Mafia menace.
Each Day, you will attempt to lynch a Mafia member by voting for them. But beware, at Night the Mafia prowl the streets. Luckily, your detective skills can find whether a player is Town or the ne'er-do-well Mafia!
You are a Doctor.
The Mafia has infiltrated your precious Town and are causing havoc. Root them out and stop the Mafia menace.
Each Day, you will attempt to lynch a Mafia member by voting for them. But beware, at Night the Mafia prowl the streets. Your advanced medical knowledge allows you stalk a person and save them from harm!
You are a Mafioso.
You have rolled into Town to cause some trouble and bootleg some liquor, but them bothersome Town is getting in your way!
Each Night, your killer instincts lets you "remove" a player.
You are a Roleblocker.
You have rolled into Town to cause some trouble and bootleg some liquor, but them bothersome Town is getting in your way!
Each Night, your killer instincts lets you "remove" a player. However, your lockmaking skills can bolt a player's door shut all Night, keeping them from leaving.
You are a Godfather.
You have rolled into Town to cause some trouble and bootleg some liquor, but them bothersome Town is getting in your way!
Each Night, your killer instincts lets you "remove" a player. However, your prestige and fame allow you to look "Town" to any nosy Cops.
man i can't wait to find out how dis game works
Rabble, your name is meaningless. Why is that?
Rabble:
–noun
1.
a disorderly crowd; mob.
2.
the rabble, the lower classes; the common people: The nobility held the rabble in complete contempt.
–verb (used with object)
3.
to beset as a rabble does; mob.
[/quote
Everyone should say what role they have, then we can easily start to find who's lying through little tests such as "who did you block last night" or "why are there two police claims?"
Why would the real cop not claim after night 1? Claiming makes it easy to know who's lying or not.
Why would the real cop not claim after night 1? Claiming makes it easy to know who's lying or not.
Criptfeind, why is your name spelled that way?
Criptfeind - Do you think Ottofar's being out of town during RVS will hurt the game? Or will it help to have some fresh perspective in case something like Bandage's slip sends us off on a newbhunt, rather than a scumhuntz?
Unless he is scum of course.
I gotta agree Bandages is suspicious.... anyways
Who do you believe would be the most dangerous to be against character?
I have Dysgraphia and I was eight when I made the name for my second online account.
And the first second vote rears its ugly head. I'm not quite ready to crucify Bandages for that. Not with Org as scum IC. Under his guidance I would be surprised to see any major scumslips out of the newb scum, and more expectant of them out of newb town. Unless that's what they want us to think.
Isn't there a saying or something for this?
Gind mames
I gotta agree Bandages is suspicious.... anyways
And the first second vote rears its ugly head. I'm not quite ready to crucify Bandages for that. Not with Org as scum IC. Under his guidance I would be surprised to see any major scumslips out of the newb scum, and more expectant of them out of newb town. Unless that's what they want us to think.
Let me tell you it is a lot harder to play as town because as scum you get to lie cheat and steal, I am still working on the entire "playing as town" game.
Gind mames
What? Is there a meaning to this?
Lonewolf I, WIFOM is anti-town, stop trying to confuse us, that's what scum want, and since you are attempting it, you look scummy. Why are you doing this if your town?
Well I am of the belief that it is useless to lynch anyone day one, just because we have NO information to go off of.
At least day 2, we can get cop information as well as see if there are any people that are doubling up on a proffesion.
Well I am of the belief that it is useless to lynch anyone day one, just because we have NO information to go off of.
At least day 2, we can get cop information as well as see if there are any people that are doubling up on a proffesion.
Well I am of the belief that it is useless to lynch anyone day one, just because we have NO information to go off of.
At least day 2, we can get cop information as well as see if there are any people that are doubling up on a proffesion.Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Unvote
I give up. Bandages. Burn him. Burn him alive.
That's mean. At least tell him what he did wrong. It can help him grow as a mafia player.
I give up. Bandages. Burn him. Burn him alive.
If I thought Bandages looked scummy I'd have voted him from the getgo. I was operating under the assumption that scum will try to capitalize on his frequent newbslips by either pushing a lynch on him or simply lurking. What you claim are my efforts to defend him are my attempts to nip those possibilities in the bud, and further my own scumhunting. If I was scum and trying to buddy someone, I certainly wouldn't pick the guy who's actively getting himself lynched. Of course, these points are moot, as of this post:I give up. Bandages. Burn him. Burn him alive.
As for worrying about scumchat? I'm not worried about it. I am thinking about it, is all, and I took a shot in the dark. It's likely missed, now that I've explained it, but I never had anything riding on it, and can always take another in the future.
FAKEEDIT
Bandages, scum defending town to look like town is the definition of buddying. Cript knows what he's talking about, and you are starting to look better and better as a Day 1 lynch choice.
Cript, that's not WIFOM. That's just plain idiocy.
That's just what a scum would want us to think.
I give up. Bandages. Burn him. Burn him alive.
Lonewolf, if we lynch bandages, we lynch him because we think he's scum not town, we can do our own reasoning. Trying to defend a scummy looking player without reason is called buddying in my opinion, and that is scummy.Since no one else has even suggested that I might be buddying, I have to assume that you are making stuff up, which is certainly worth further investigation. Unvote.
Why are you buddying?
Bandages made a large slip up early. He looks like scum to me, but since everyone knows he's scum I will focus on someone else, namely...
Gind mames
What? Is there a meaning to this?
Gind mames = Mind GamesLonewolf I, WIFOM is anti-town, stop trying to confuse us, that's what scum want, and since you are attempting it, you look scummy. Why are you doing this if your town?
As far as WIFOM goes, now I understand that term, though I don't believe the assessment is valid. WIFOM means forcing your opponent into such circular reasoning, using the pressure of the situation to obtain a single, irrevocable decision that is usually either a blind guess or a Third Option born of hasty, hopefully fallacious reasoning.
Certainly my analysis of the situation is the product of some circular reasoning, but there is no decision being made. Any confusion my statement creates is the result of a perceived False Dilemma. Scum could easily adopt a different strategy, and negate my reasoning completely. Indeed, they probably have.
The purpose behind my particular wording was threefold:
- Point out one possible scenario in which Bandages is not scum, and one in which he is. I was using both scenarios as support for my caution that we not rush into lynching him blindly.
- Remind everyone that there is an elite IC over in scumchat. Whatever plan scum settle on will have likely passed his scrutiny.
- Take potshots at the scum planning process, attempting to sow disorder and confusion, however brief, into scumchat.
UnvoteUnless he is scum of course.
Naturally.I gotta agree Bandages is suspicious.... anyways
Who do you believe would be the most dangerous to be against character?
And the first second vote rears its ugly head. I'm not quite ready to crucify Bandages for that. Not with Org as scum IC. Under his guidance I would be surprised to see any major scumslips out of the newb scum, and more expectant of them out of newb town. Unless that's what they want us to think.
Zako, Penngo, neither of you have spoken since Bandagegate. You're not trying to lay low while we burn him at the stake, are you?
Your arguments are null and void.
I do have a life outside the computer Lonewolf, I cannot be there all the time to comment on everything exactly on time.You specifically stated that I voted bandages in order to defend myself. At the time that I voted bandages, there were no accusations to defend myself from. Commenting on something a bit late is acceptable. Fabricating arguments for my being scum without even bothering to make sure your arguments are internally consistent, at least chronologically, is downright sloppy.
And instead of jumping on the bandages bandwagon, I instead go after the WIFOM scumtell you gave out here:Didn't I already point this out in my own argument? Oh, yeah. I did.Spoiler: Long quote of mine. (click to show/hide)
You certainly managed to hide it well, jumping on me and all in the same post.
You specifically stated that I voted bandages in order to defend myself. At the time that I voted bandages, there were no accusations to defend myself from. Commenting on something a bit late is acceptable. Fabricating arguments for my being scum without even bothering to make sure your arguments are internally consistent, at least chronologically, is downright sloppy.
You certainly managed to hide it well, jumping on me and all in the same post.
You still haven't answered either of my questions. Here they are again, in case you missed them:
Why claim that I was defending myself when I voted Bandages, when there were no relevant accusations to defend myself from at the time?
Why is it that you did what I said scum would do?
Not to mention the fact that I'm a townie, so Lonewolf has no reason to save me unless he were also a townie or some variant.
Now I know that anyone who defended me is not a scum, otherwise they would have frothed at the mouth to lynch me. Just like Zako.Spoiler (click to show/hide)
That's just what a scum would want us to think.
Only a scum would get that angry..
Yeah, you guys should just lynch me.
And lose a townie vote later 8)
You certainly managed to hide it well, jumping on me and all in the same post.
How the hell does this prove anything?
Why would the real cop not claim after night 1? Claiming makes it easy to know who's lying or not.
Who would really post that they are the cop. Wouldn't it make sense for the cop to find proof before he accuses or reveals himself?
Zako is mean, so I'm still voting for him.Also, don't vote based on emotion, but on logic.
Don't be a jerk, it's rude :-\
Can a town really WIFOM?
P.S. just storywise, why would the town lynch someone before the mafia have killed anyone? Seems kinda crazy in a "the lottery" kinda way
Eh I'll vote for kilakan
It makes sense
This is all part of my elaborate plan.
You'll see 8)
Lonewolf is also suspicious because he said this-
I can't rightly say, as I've only ever been town. I think scum would be more fun, as constructing and maintaining plausible lies and picking apart holes in truth seems a whole lot more interesting than straight scumhunting.
The %s woud eventualy add up to a high chance of being scum beause, it is randomed and he is refering that he has played multiple games in the past and saying he has never been scum. And the more games you play the higher chance of being scum.
Achievement Unlocked!Lonewolf is also suspicious because he said this-
I can't rightly say, as I've only ever been town. I think scum would be more fun, as constructing and maintaining plausible lies and picking apart holes in truth seems a whole lot more interesting than straight scumhunting.
The %s woud eventualy add up to a high chance of being scum beause, it is randomed and he is refering that he has played multiple games in the past and saying he has never been scum. And the more games you play the higher chance of being scum.
I've subbed into two games so far as town. Vote Mafia 6 and Paranormal Mafia 16. Three games does not constitute a large enough sample size for that argument to hold water, and even then it still falls victim to Gambler's Fallacy.
Welcome back, Ottofar.
Let's Shorten and rid ourselves of this Xanatos wannabe.
This is all part of my elaborate plan.
You'll see 8)
Why you gotta lynch me like that?
Why lynch an obvious townie when you now have a higher chance of getting a scum from the remaining 8
I also vote Shorten, we need to get rid of this confusing scumbag. Unvote vote bandages. We have no risk in voting bandages since this is a traditional Mafia and there are no special roles to screw us over.The only possible roles are those that were listed in the original post. These are Townie, Town Cop, Town Doctor, Mafioso, Mafia Roleblocker, and Mafia Godfather. That is it.
Right webadict?
That is not physically possible!That's what HE kept saying!
Wow. Just... Wow.
Bandages. I've never seen anyone that scummy, and I've seen me. Seriously, take a look at some other games before playing. Those posts - pure WIFOM, and rolefishing on D1.Zako is mean, so I'm still voting for him.Also, don't vote based on emotion, but on logic.
Don't be a jerk, it's rude :-\
Phonepost.
Also bandages you should learn more before you play look at other games and stuff or look up a guide of some sort. You can't start from scratch even in a beginner game.
Can we get a poke on Rabble?
Also budding is helping to win. I cannot help bandages to win because he is DEAD.
Diablous, why would you kill Criptfeind? What was your reason for killing him?
Ottofar a beginner is meant to teach us newbies that is why i told bandages to look at other games. He didn't learn anything from this.
I see kilakan as a proper target because of his inactivity he could have been a inactive scum player.
Going after lurkers is scummy, since they're easy targets.
No, but usually scum go after lurkers, to avoid attention.Going after lurkers is scummy, since they're easy targets.
Does that make being a lurker not scummy?
Lonewolf I, what do you think about Cript's death? Why do you think he was killed.
Lonewolf You've been desperately trying to turn people against each other with little to no proof or evidence, I find that scummy.
Kilikan - Why would Bandages think voting you makes sense? :P
Kilikan - Why would Bandages think voting you makes sense? :P
Lonewolf I, what do you think about Cript's death? Why do you think he was killed.
Same reason you do. He has more games under his belt than any of us. The only people he attacked are Zako and Bandages, so unless Zako is scum, the panic theory is out, and I haven't thought of any other plausible ones.
Kilikan - Why would Bandages think voting you makes sense? :P
8)
Lonewolf You've been desperately trying to turn people against each other with little to no proof or evidence, I find that scummy.
I'm here. Did you guys need me? I thought you were doing damn fine on your own.
I thought you were doing damn fine on your own.
I thought you were doing damn fine on your own.
Well I'm trying to think of ways to help, but I'm pretty new and really don't know what types of things to do/ questions to ask.
Well I'm trying to think of ways to help, but I'm pretty new and really don't know what types of things to do/ questions to ask.
Kilikan moved his vote to me, though he didn't say why. Other than that, it's accurate.
I'm not lurking, I only get around an hour I can go on a computer a day during the week.... So I haven't been on, anyways.
Lonewolf You've been desperately trying to turn people against each other with little to no proof or evidence, I find that scummy.
Well I'm trying to think of ways to help, but I'm pretty new and really don't know what types of things to do/ questions to ask.
anyways I'm not sure bout lone so Unvote Lonewolf
The only replacement I might need is a mod replacement.
No. Penngo's still here. And you were a player, so you can't replace anyway. Web just can't change the title for whatever reason.
The only replacement I might need is a mod replacement.
I can do that too if ye want.
I saw that it was going nowhere because he never answers! Look in Bay 12 Mafia, he does the same there! I thought it would be pointless to continue pressuring him and decided to move onto a new suspect. Turns out they were both town, but I have a suspicion.
I think that penngo009 is scum. Look through this thread, he has said the smallest amount of everyone, other than Ottofar, has made little to no scumhunting and just smells scummy to me.
penngo009, why are you not scumhunting?! Is it because you are trying to fade into the background? Explain yourself!
Bah-post.
Anyways, can I get to know the roles, now that I'm dead?
And by the way, am I the most suspicious in everyone's point of view?
Set aside your conflict, Criptfiend. We want this. Shorten
I would have liked for some replacements.
I never would have suspected Rabble. Maybe if he would have posted?
I may be letting them affect my judgement more than I thought, now I think of it.
Did I really seem all that scummy?
I'm proud of myself. I. Found. Scum.
The mod is dead. Long live the mod.