Bay 12 Games Forum

Dwarf Fortress => DF Modding => Topic started by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 08:21:35 am

Title: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 08:21:35 am
I've been curious about eggs, and have been wondering a few things about how the game handles them in certain ways. Here goes.


That's all I can think of for now. I have no idea when/if I'll be able to test these things myself, but there are some pretty amusing questions here.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Flaede on February 17, 2011, 09:20:49 am
I don't have any testing yet to add, but I'm marking this to follow.
I am interested in all of these questions. As well as ones like "can different castes be given different egg properties?" and "what are the properties beings from hatched trader eggs?" (assuming they hatch).

I am also curious about someone's comment about trying to get chickens to s*#% bricks. They said the game crashed (can't find the comment now. dangit!)
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 09:21:57 am
Yeah, someone said that getting chickens to lay iron bars crashed the game, but we can't be sure how he tried to implement that, either.

Added some more stuff to the OP based partly on what you said.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Vorthon on February 17, 2011, 09:28:30 am
Yeah, someone said that getting chickens to lay iron bars crashed the game, but we can't be sure how he tried to implement that, either.

Added some more stuff to the OP based partly on what you said.

That would be me. It crashed when I selected 'Design New World With Advanced Parameters'.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: FearfulJesuit on February 17, 2011, 10:31:08 am
That'd be a good idea. I'm gonna see if there's a way to make ducks lay charcoal, chickens flux stone and turkeys iron, since steel ingredients are so rare now.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Miko19 on February 17, 2011, 10:31:52 am
I'm so damn tempted to make dwarves lay eggs.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: FearfulJesuit on February 17, 2011, 10:33:02 am
You know, if we made dwarves bird-like in other ways, then what? If, for example, they could fly, could we get rid of stairs?

!!SCIENCE!! is needed.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 10:33:51 am
So I modded the egg material templates (including shell) to all have very low melting points, then specified that chicken egg shells should be liquid.

I genned a world, embarked with a bunch of chickens, set up a nest box, and this was the result:

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

To make it clear what's going on here: A hen went and laid "eggs" in the nest box, and they were labeled inside the nest box as being a stack of 4 "Chicken n/a". I made a kitchen, and the cook didn't seem to want to use any of it as an ingredient even if another solid ingredient was available (the announcement being that no second unrotten cookable item was available).

After deconstructing the nest box, the second image resulted: A pool of liquid egg goop ("chicken n/a") next to the nest box.



So, out of curiosity, I changed the liquid state name of eggshells from "n/a" to "liquid eggshell", made eggshells edible-when-cooked, genned a new world, and embarked. Now, all cases of "chicken n/a" became "chicken liquid eggshell". It still cannot be cooked.

I find it very strange that the game seems to think the shell is the important part. Maybe the shell is always used as the "material" for the egg itself? I'm going to do some more tests now regarding this.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Deon on February 17, 2011, 10:38:44 am
Yes, it looks like the egg item is made out of the "shell" material, and the internals are used as "extracts" when it's used.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 11:02:52 am
Yeah, the raws don't even specify liquid density for whites/yolks, which is pretty messed up.

So, I changed egg whites and yolks to have a density of 10,000 (very very high!!) and the weight of eggs didn't seem to change, supporting the theory that eggs are "made out of" their shells.

I had my cook make a meal out of two egg stacks (which apparently clutters the shop, because it seems that a dozen eggs is enough to make a kitchen "cluttered" in DF). The resulting egg biscuits also were not heavy.

However, modding eggshell to be heavy, the weight of both eggs and their biscuits went up. In fact, the weight of the biscuit stack was greater than the total weight of what went into them (almost twice as heavy, in fact).


In conclusion, even when cooked, it seems like eggs are "made" of eggshell, and presumably, the white/yolk materials themselves are never used. Hooray!?


[edit]
Update: Apparently, if you mark the whites and yolks as also being inedible, you can't cook eggs. The game must check for EDIBLE_COOKED in the whites and/or the yolks. So you can't cook eggs made out of rock, but you could probably have eggs with rock shells, and the properties of that rock will be the properties that carry over into the finished meal.


These results have pretty clear implications for anyone trying to make exotic eggs. For instance, if you made eggs with normal shells filled with super-valuable god-chocolate, the properties and value of that filling will almost certainly not matter. Seems like nothing matters except the shells, as far as I can tell. This is a little disappointing, as it limits what we can do here. Enjoy your eggshell-munching!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 12:43:07 pm
These results have pretty clear implications for anyone trying to make exotic eggs. For instance, if you made eggs with normal shells filled with super-valuable god-chocolate, the properties and value of that filling will almost certainly not matter. Seems like nothing matters except the shells, as far as I can tell. This is a little disappointing, as it limits what we can do here. Enjoy your eggshell-munching!

I imagine that this will probably be changed in the next update.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 12:44:38 pm
I'm curious to know why you think that. I mean, egg items being multi-material isn't supported whatsoever by how items work in the game (all items are a single material), and as a result, the meals produced from them will suffer similarly. I don't think we'll see this change until more sweeping updates are introduced to how items work.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Assassinfox on February 17, 2011, 12:48:11 pm
What if you set a creature's eggshells to be made of gold, but have edible yolk/white?  Would you end up with eggs that could either be cooked or melted down?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Drawde on February 17, 2011, 01:32:20 pm
Is it possible to create a reaction that makes an egg?  And if so, could you hatch it, either where you made it or elsewhere?

EDIT  I've read that it's possible to make ane "egg" so far, but it's not a creature egg.  Looks like there's still some ways to go for my plans.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 02:13:03 pm
What if you set a creature's eggshells to be made of gold, but have edible yolk/white?  Would you end up with eggs that could either be cooked or melted down?

I doubt you can 'm'elt eggs no matter what. However, the meals you produce will probably be pretty damn valuable!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 03:54:31 pm
I've posted in another thread some experiments I've been doing with fortress civ egg layers, and since this thread is convieniently here I'll repost what I found in testing so far. (testing is ongoing)

What I seem to have determined:

- Intelligent, civ races will use box nests.  Unlike what Toady One theorized would happen.

- The boxes almost immediately get claimed by a female.

- If the female has not laid an egg (recently?  At all?) she will immediately lay an egg in the box on arrival.

- If any stockpile is set to take eggs from the race the egg will be hauled there by the mother. Otherwise the egg will stay in the nest.

- the mother will spend all of her free time sitting on the nest afterward.  She will still go eat, drink, sleep, and work.  But will return to the nest instead of meeting zones when they have "No Job"

- If the egg is removed from the nest at any time, the mother will still own the nest for a time after, and still go to it until a short time passes (so far it appears to be about a season) after which the nest will become unclaimed again allowing a new mother to move in.

- The mother DOES NOT have to be married.  In-fact all of the nesters so far are unmarried.

What I haven't determined yet:
- Will the eggs hatch?  It has been a season and a half so far for the eggs that have stayed in the box, none hatched.  Rumor is that for chickens it takes only a season. But it may be possible that the date on the race's [Child:] tag may determine how long it takes for an egg to hatch.  It could also be that the mother is required to be married for the eggs to actually hatch.

- Are the race's eggs edible to the parent race? Due to other variables I am unable to test this.  My test race is [CARNIVORE] which seems to prevent the race from eating any eggs regardless, judging from the peahen eggs in the stockpile that so far haven't been eaten.

Maybes:

- Caste Relationship?
The egg may be related to the mother's caste.  The race being used in the tests have 10 castes. 5 castes with male and female of each.  And each egg so far is of the same caste type as it's mother. Gender is unfortunately indeterminate at this point.  However coincidence is still possible.

Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 03:56:28 pm
Someone on IRC had a player race that laid eggs, and he said they never managed to hatch. Perhaps this is related to how much time they spend on the nest, though?

Also, he said they would gladly cook and eat their own eggs, but this might be related to civ ethics.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Scaraban on February 17, 2011, 03:57:53 pm
Watching
<.< >.>
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Jurph on February 17, 2011, 04:08:07 pm
Quote from: Bill Cosby
You've got to be careful with eggs...

Posting to generate ovology bookmark
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 17, 2011, 04:51:38 pm
Is it possible to create a reaction that makes an egg?  And if so, could you hatch it, either where you made it or elsewhere?

EDIT  I've read that it's possible to make ane "egg" so far, but it's not a creature egg.  Looks like there's still some ways to go for my plans.

Yes:
This reaction makes eggs.  The game seems to recognize them as belonging to the specified species.
Code: [Select]
[REACTION:MAKE_EGG_ROCK]
[NAME:make egg]
[BUILDING:SOAP_MAKER:CUSTOM_T]
[SKILL:COOK]
[REAGENT:A:1:TOOL:ITEM_TOOL_NEST_BOX:NONE:NONE]
[PRESERVE_REAGENT]
[DOES_NOT_DETERMINE_PRODUCT_AMOUNT]
[PRODUCT:100:1:EGG:CREATURE:BIRD_CHICKEN:CREATURE_MAT:BIRD_CHICKEN:EGGSHELL][PRODUCT_TO_CONTAINER:A]
[PRODUCT:100:1:EGG:CREATURE:BIRD_CHICKEN:CREATURE_MAT:BIRD_CHICKEN:EGGSHELL][PRODUCT_TO_CONTAINER:A]
[PRODUCT:100:1:EGG:CREATURE:DWARF:CREATURE_MAT:BIRD_CHICKEN:EGGSHELL][PRODUCT_TO_CONTAINER:A]
[PRODUCT:100:1:EGG:CREATURE:BIRD_CHICKEN:CREATURE_MAT:BIRD_CHICKEN:EGGSHELL][PRODUCT_TO_CONTAINER:A]
Note that it produces a dwarf egg!  The bad news, however, is that the game doesn't notice that the egg box already contains eggs when it is constructed.  So these probably won't hatch.  A test is ongoing.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Sphalerite on February 17, 2011, 04:56:05 pm
It could also be that the mother is required to be married for the eggs to actually hatch.
This would actually make sense from a biological point of view.  Chickens and many other egg-layers can still lay unfertilized, sterile eggs even if they haven't mated.  A sentient egg-layer might find themselves having to lay sterile eggs periodically, even though they're not married or having children yet.  I have no idea if that's what's actually going on in the DF code, someone needs to embark with an egg-laying race and let some of them get married.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 05:03:30 pm
Correction: Someone needs to embark with a race where the females and males lay eggs.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 05:17:21 pm
I have a married couple in my fortress,  I'll see if I can get the wife to claim a nest too.

The only problem I'm getting is that the goblins are due to show up any time, and I so far have no defenses to speak of.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 05:21:47 pm
Just wall yourself in, then. If you have farms, it should really be no problem, right?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 05:34:34 pm
Carnivore race.  Farms don't help.   This is a normal play modded race I do that just happened to become test subjects when something I totally didn't expect to work worked.  But yea, walling myself in should give me enough time to conclude the current tests. I do have a decent meat supply, and a small horse breeding program.  Not enough to be self sufficient, but enough for a year or two of solitude.


In other news the married female in the fortress just laid an egg for SCIENCE!

I also seem to have confirmed the caste relationship. 4 more eggs, each one with caste matching their mother.  My bet is that they will all be female too.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 17, 2011, 05:36:38 pm
I have a married couple in my fortress,  I'll see if I can get the wife to claim a nest too.

The only problem I'm getting is that the goblins are due to show up any time, and I so far have no defenses to speak of.

I modded dwarves to lay eggs, and I had a married dwarf who came in an immigration wave claim a nest. But it's been ~two seasons since she came, and no eggs have hatched. Two females of my starting seven have been sitting on egg boxes for a year with no result.

I'm going to mod child to take one year and then retest. Male geese don't have the egg laying tags, so it's hard to see why they'd be necessary for sentient races.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 05:47:23 pm
What if you set a creature's eggshells to be made of gold, but have edible yolk/white?  Would you end up with eggs that could either be cooked or melted down?

Here's some raws that you can use for testing. I haven't actually tested them myself yet, but that's why I'm posting them; So that someone with a longer attention span can test their effects.

Spoiler: FABERGE_CHICKEN (click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 05:55:55 pm
It could also be that the mother is required to be married for the eggs to actually hatch.
This would actually make sense from a biological point of view.  Chickens and many other egg-layers can still lay unfertilized, sterile eggs even if they haven't mated.

Exactly correct. I like to think of it as the avian equivalent of getting one's period...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 06:02:26 pm
It is and it isn't. Obviously, chickens don't menstruate and have nothing analogous to that at all, but they're both at least related to ovulation, which you just don't really notice (per se) in people because we don't lay big honkin' eggs.

Of course, that doesn't stop PETA from saying "EGGS ARE CHICKEN PERIODS!!" in all caps on their children's sites, but hey, who says political propaganda has to be grounded in reality?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 06:10:33 pm
Okay, does anyone know if [LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:<item tokens>] takes the place of [LAYS_EGGS] or is a subtag of it?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 06:27:01 pm
I'm going to assume it takes place of it, but at this point, I don't think we even have verification that it works.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 17, 2011, 06:46:13 pm
It appears that if you include a LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS tag it crashes DF.  I tried it with a longsword, and someone else on the boards tried it with metal bars.

Also, it seems reaction-created eggs don't hatch  :(.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 06:51:19 pm
It appears that if you include a LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS tag it crashes DF.  I tried it with a longsword, and someone else on the boards tried it with metal bars.

Also, it seems reaction-created eggs don't hatch  :(.

I am using it right now to make Golden Geese. However none of them have laid eggs yet. Instead a WILD turkey came in and laid eggs!!!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 06:52:29 pm
You shouldn't need that tag to lay golden eggs, if that's what you're doing. You can specify any material for egg shell, whites, or yolks.

Unless you want it to lay gold bars or something, of course.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 06:56:23 pm
You shouldn't need that tag to lay golden eggs, if that's what you're doing. You can specify any material for egg shell, whites, or yolks.

Unless you want it to lay gold bars or something, of course.

Someone suggested they weren't meltable so I decided to try for plain gold ore. Still waiting. Still surprised that a wild animal would come in and give me free eggs  ;D
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 17, 2011, 07:01:31 pm
It appears that if you include a LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS tag it crashes DF.

I am using it right now to make Golden Geese. However none of them have laid eggs yet. Instead a WILD turkey came in and laid eggs!!!

Could you post the tag you're using?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 07:04:19 pm
You shouldn't need that tag to lay golden eggs, if that's what you're doing. You can specify any material for egg shell, whites, or yolks.

Unless you want it to lay gold bars or something, of course.

Someone suggested they weren't meltable so I decided to try for plain gold ore. Still waiting. Still surprised that a wild animal would come in and give me free eggs  ;D

Good point.

But yeah, anything that can lay eggs will do so in your nest boxes. I got accosted by waterfowl during my first test.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 07:07:54 pm
[LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:INORGANIC:GOLD:SOLID]
         [EGG_SIZE:52]
         [CLUTCH_SIZE:8:13]


I haven't modded before so I may be Doing It Wrong. However at least it hasn't crashed.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 07:13:29 pm
That doesn't look like an item token to me. I think the token for stones is "STONE", and you'd need to use the native gold material if you want to be able to turn it into bars like you would actual native gold rocks.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 07:15:04 pm
That doesn't look like an item token to me. I think the token for stones is "STONE", and you'd need to use the native gold material if you want to be able to turn it into bars like you would actual native gold rocks.

I'm not really sure how to do this. The raws are kind of confusing  :-\

Edit well FRIG I definitely did it wrong, gilt goose has given birth to gilt goslings XD
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 17, 2011, 07:18:59 pm
My exact experience was that LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS does nothing unless it is invoked like so: LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:MATERIAL:MAT_SUBTYPE:ITEM:ITEM_SUBTYPE
In which case all it does is crash the game.

For example [LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:WEAPON:ITEM_WEAPON_SWORD_LONG:LOCAL_CREATURE_MAT:EGGSHELL] or
[LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:WEAPON:ITEM_WEAPON_SWORD_LONG:INORGANIC:IRON]
both crash the game, while [LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:WEAPON:ITEM_WEAPON_SWORD_LONG] has no effect.

In the second case creatures don't lay eggs unless they have the LAYS_EGGS token.  So my guess is that those geese won't lay eggs.  Do you have unclaimed egg boxes?

EDIT:  Nevermind that last question  ;)
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 07:20:31 pm
I'm assuming it works similarly to ITEMCORPSE.

I checked out how bronze colossi use that: [ITEMCORPSE:STATUE:NO_SUBTYPE:INORGANIC:BRONZE]

In this case, it's the item token followed by the subtype followed by "inorganic" (to draw from the inorganic object raws, I guess) followed by the material. I think "subtype" is for items that have different, well, subtypes, like instruments, but I'm honestly not sure when you use that.

So you PROBABLY want:

[LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:STONE:NO_SUBTYPE:INORGANIC:NATIVE_GOLD]
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 07:22:24 pm
Okay, I am regenning now with [LAYS_EGGS]
      [LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:STONE:NO_SUBTYPE:INORGANIC:NATIVE_GOLD]

If it's successful, time to add silver, copper, and rusty geese :D
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 07:23:30 pm
SUCCESS!!!!!

(http://img.ie/images/77ba4.png) (http://img.ie/)

The egg of the married dracon has hatched successfully and created a bouncing baby boy!

New Observations:
- Only eggs from MARRIED fortress members will hatch.  All others are infertile.
- Although the egg claims to be the egg of a certain caste once hatched the caste is randomized normally.
- The hatched child gets mother and father information properly.
- It seems to take about half a year for an egg to hatch.
- The mother does not have to be present for the egg to hatch (the mother was sleeping in the barracks)
- The mother will collect and carry the baby around normally.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 07:24:21 pm
"A boy have hatched."

Cool grammar!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 07:25:31 pm
Okay, now DF is crashing when I try to Create New World, something about deallocating an array. I tried undoing my changes but it didn't work...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Girlinhat on February 17, 2011, 07:37:30 pm
This is a great success!  We have the very first egg-born fortress dweller!  Congrats on making DF history!

Quick question though: Can you tell if the egg is fertile or not, or who the mother is easily?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 07:39:20 pm
You can see who has a nest box claimed by 'q'uerying the building, so that should help.


Also: When the unusual egg tag is fixed, we should mod in a species of bunnies for good-aligned regions that lay toys as eggs. Made out of opal.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 07:45:30 pm
There is no direct indicator no.  But it seems you can do some detective work to tell if the egg is fertile.  You pretty much look to see who owns the box the egg is in, and then look at their description to see if they are married.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 08:00:23 pm
Okay, the earlier suggestion for a gold token caused the game to crash when I tried to gen a world. I played around and it accepted [LAYS_UNUSUAL_EGGS:STONE:NATIVE_GOLD] without popping anything in the errorlog. However the eggs appear to be normal and hatch normally. Well fooey.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 08:06:56 pm
When the token is malformed, it probably just discards it, causing nothing abnormal to happen. It's likely that the crash is happening when you do it right.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 08:34:49 pm
It could also be that the mother is required to be married for the eggs to actually hatch.
This would actually make sense from a biological point of view.  Chickens and many other egg-layers can still lay unfertilized, sterile eggs even if they haven't mated.

Exactly correct. I like to think of it as the avian equivalent of getting one's period...

It is and it isn't. Obviously, chickens don't menstruate and have nothing analogous to that at all, but they're both at least related to ovulation, which you just don't really notice (per se) in people because we don't lay big honkin' eggs.

Of course, that doesn't stop PETA from saying "EGGS ARE CHICKEN PERIODS!!" in all caps on their children's sites, but hey, who says political propaganda has to be grounded in reality?

I didn't get that from them. i just have a perverted mind.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 08:36:33 pm
I know you didn't, it just made my mind segue into that.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 09:00:45 pm
It could also be that the mother is required to be married for the eggs to actually hatch.
This would actually make sense from a biological point of view.  Chickens and many other egg-layers can still lay unfertilized, sterile eggs even if they haven't mated.

Exactly correct. I like to think of it as the avian equivalent of getting one's period...

It is and it isn't. Obviously, chickens don't menstruate and have nothing analogous to that at all, but they're both at least related to ovulation, which you just don't really notice (per se) in people because we don't lay big honkin' eggs.

Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 17, 2011, 09:08:06 pm
Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...

The problem here is that "what comes out of it" is what's actually being discussed, and there is no physical relation at all between a chicken egg and, well, anything that comes out of a mammalian female during menstruation (except maybe the egg cell, which isn't what they're talking about and isn't even visible).

Also: Chickens lay eggs to use them. They're not being "discarded".
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Fortis on February 17, 2011, 09:49:07 pm
Got a question about the eggs. If one mods a player race, and an unmarried female lays an infertile egg, will she eventually abandon it, or just keep sitting on it until the end of time?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: abadidea on February 17, 2011, 09:56:14 pm
Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...

The problem here is that "what comes out of it" is what's actually being discussed, and there is no physical relation at all between a chicken egg and, well, anything that comes out of a mammalian female during menstruation (except maybe the egg cell, which isn't what they're talking about and isn't even visible).

Also: Chickens lay eggs to use them. They're not being "discarded".

What is a chicken going to do with an unfertilized egg?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 10:01:44 pm
Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...

The problem here is that "what comes out of it" is what's actually being discussed, and there is no physical relation at all between a chicken egg and, well, anything that comes out of a mammalian female during menstruation (except maybe the egg cell, which isn't what they're talking about and isn't even visible).

IIRC the yolk is technically considered to be a highly specialized organelle of the egg cell, so in the chiocken's case the cell is visible once you cut away the shell, membranes, and amnion...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 17, 2011, 10:01:54 pm
Looks like sit on it til the end of time so far.  Egg can still be dumped though, and it seems they'll eventually abandon the nest sometime after.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 17, 2011, 10:17:08 pm
Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...

The problem here is that "what comes out of it" is what's actually being discussed, and there is no physical relation at all between a chicken egg and, well, anything that comes out of a mammalian female during menstruation (except maybe the egg cell, which isn't what they're talking about and isn't even visible).

IIRC the yolk is technically considered to be a highly specialized organelle of the egg cell, so in the chiocken's case the cell is visible once you cut away the shell, membranes, and amnion...

Ah yes, here we are, according to Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yolk) "Prior to fertilization, the yolk together with the germinal disc* is a single cell"

(And for all those of you who still don't trust Wikipedia, Please note that Wikipedia was not my original source for this information. I first learned it in a college embryology course, and merely used Wikipedia to confirm that I was remembering it correctly)

*The germinal disc is the part that divides off after fertilization (if fertilization occurs) and eventually develops into the actual hatchling.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 17, 2011, 10:51:36 pm
so does this mean My Female Human adventuress not going to have egg babies because she ain't married and not apart of the civ? If so then Horse poop what am I going to do with these Human eggs she laying other than throw them at creatures.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 17, 2011, 10:54:27 pm
If there's a male human who also isn't part of the civ on the map, you may have a chance. 

Otherwise yeah, throwing weapon.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 17, 2011, 11:11:42 pm
If there's a male human who also isn't part of the civ on the map, you may have a chance. 

Otherwise yeah, throwing weapon.
looks like I have to abandon and add some type of Pet tag so I can buy a human or wait until a Human caravan comes and impregnates her. wait I do have DEAD Humans will they knock her up?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 18, 2011, 01:02:56 am
No, I don't think so. 

The only observation I have to go on is that in animals, there needs to be a male on-map.  In the case of a duck that invaded one of my nestbox experiments, the male came over and stood by the female while she guarded the nest. 

I doubt that a member of a trading civ would count.  A dead male almost certainly wont.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 18, 2011, 03:28:16 am
SUCCESS!!!!!

(http://img.ie/images/77ba4.png) (http://img.ie/)

The egg of the married dracon has hatched successfully and created a bouncing baby boy!

New Observations:
- Only eggs from MARRIED fortress members will hatch.  All others are infertile.
- Although the egg claims to be the egg of a certain caste once hatched the caste is randomized normally.
- The hatched child gets mother and father information properly.
- It seems to take about half a year for an egg to hatch.
- The mother does not have to be present for the egg to hatch (the mother was sleeping in the barracks)
- The mother will collect and carry the baby around normally.

Sweet: the conversion rate from egg to child is one to one. Hard to predict when the mothers spawn eggs though.

"Decaplets have hatched."
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 18, 2011, 07:44:22 am
Both phenomena consist of a female's body discarding an unused ovum. The only difference is what comes out with it. Blood and uterine tissue in the case of humans, or eggshell and amnion (and some membranes) in the case of chickens...

The problem here is that "what comes out of it" is what's actually being discussed, and there is no physical relation at all between a chicken egg and, well, anything that comes out of a mammalian female during menstruation (except maybe the egg cell, which isn't what they're talking about and isn't even visible).

IIRC the yolk is technically considered to be a highly specialized organelle of the egg cell, so in the chiocken's case the cell is visible once you cut away the shell, membranes, and amnion...

Right. I'm saying the cell (ovum) isn't really relevant/visible in the case of a human. My point being that they're comparing apples and oranges.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: FearfulJesuit on February 18, 2011, 08:27:25 am
So, how can we mod dwarves themeselves to lay eggs?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Deon on February 18, 2011, 08:28:25 am
Copy the tokens from a chicken.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: RiderofDark on February 18, 2011, 09:20:50 am

Sweet: the conversion rate from egg to child is one to one. Hard to predict when the mothers spawn eggs though.

"Decaplets have hatched."
Perhaps we're witnessing the gestation cycle/period of a dwarf as an egg?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Vattic on February 18, 2011, 10:03:34 am
It will be interesting to see what people do with this new feature and I can finally get my antman queens laying eggs.

On the topic of civilised creatures laying eggs: do we know if the mother needs to have been married when she laid the egg for it to hatch? I can imagine a female laying many eggs, getting married, and suddenly having many, many, children hatch at once.

This next question sounds so sexist but it's not, really. Does anyone know if a non intelligent female caste member will produce offspring if there are only intelligent male cast members around or will they never reproduce?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Vorthon on February 18, 2011, 10:09:14 am
This next question sounds so sexist but it's not, really. Does anyone know if a non intelligent female caste member will produce offspring if there are only intelligent male cast members around or will they never reproduce?

This reminds me of the Kzin from the Known space books by Larry Niven, only with egg-laying involved.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 18, 2011, 10:13:11 am
It will be interesting to see what people do with this new feature and I can finally get my antman queens laying eggs.

On the topic of civilised creatures laying eggs: do we know if the mother needs to have been married when she laid the egg for it to hatch? I can imagine a female laying many eggs, getting married, and suddenly having many, many, children hatch at once.

This next question sounds so sexist but it's not, really. Does anyone know if a non intelligent female caste member will produce offspring if there are only intelligent male cast members around or will they never reproduce?
well if past experiment taught me it is yeah intelligent creatures will spawn if another one of the same race is near but this was when they where tamed I don't know if two friendly characters will poop babies in your nest.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 18, 2011, 10:18:42 am
On the topic of civilised creatures laying eggs: do we know if the mother needs to have been married when she laid the egg for it to hatch? I can imagine a female laying many eggs, getting married, and suddenly having many, many, children hatch at once.

I'm not sure of the answer to that.  It seems like it may be possible, except that they won't go to meeting halls or anything to socialize to drag home a hubby after laying an egg.  They just sit on their nest all day.  One of my theorys is that the egg is just waiting for a husband to pull father data from, but I haven't been able to get any of the mothers married after laying to test it.  My first 6 subjects are nowhere near the meeting hall (they're in the chocobo pen) and the ones I placed in the meeting hall so far aren't getting hitched.

And shouldn't those intelligence tags be the other way around? *rimshot*
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 18, 2011, 03:09:06 pm
Solution: Fill your meeting zone with nest boxes.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Flaede on February 18, 2011, 04:13:52 pm
Solution: Fill your meeting zone with nest boxes.

That way when the giant Rocs and Cave Crocodiles turn up you'll know where they're going! :D
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 18, 2011, 05:31:43 pm
Bit of an update.  The mother of 'the first ever hatched fortress resident' laid another egg shortly after collecting the hatching.  This one however doesn't seem to be hatching.  So there may be something I'm missing.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Fortis on February 18, 2011, 05:57:59 pm
Quote
That way when the giant Rocs and Cave Crocodiles turn up you'll know where they're going! :D

Yeah, through the corridors with cave traps and such. Two birds, one stone.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 18, 2011, 06:07:49 pm
One bird, one lizard one stone cage trap?

Sounds like a squick video....

*rimshot*

...I think I may need psychiatric help if that's the first thing that came to mind from that statement...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Dora Feddy on February 18, 2011, 06:53:21 pm
I was wondering if it would be possible to mod a plant to act the same way as a nesting box does. Though having alligators invade my fort for the nest boxes sounds Fun, I would rather collect the eggs from out in the wild.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 18, 2011, 07:02:41 pm
No.  Nesting boxes are buildings.  The wild animals using your nestboxes thing has been reported as a bug, so Toady may do something about it in the next release.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: NW_Kohaku on February 18, 2011, 07:13:51 pm
Greiger, you are a dwarven hero of !!SCIENCE!!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Protomith on February 18, 2011, 08:24:27 pm
I modded dwarves to lay eggs (Lol) so now the outpost liaison is on a nest box.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 18, 2011, 08:25:42 pm
Bit of an update.  The mother of 'the first ever hatched fortress resident' laid another egg shortly after collecting the hatching.  This one however doesn't seem to be hatching.  So there may be something I'm missing.

Hmmm. The mother dwarf whose eggs hatched into decaplets laid another 12 eggs, which have also hatched; the woman is carrying around 24 bouncing baby shields now, and sitting on more eggs.

Maybe you need to wait a bit longer?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Greiger on February 19, 2011, 12:07:44 am
Yea I haven't given up on her yet.  And I actually managed to get lucky and get a good supply of adamantine so my military is decked out, despite the utter lack of any of the metals the embark said was here, so I'm in no real danger of losing the fortress to a siege anymore.

So far she's still the only mother to have successfully hatched a child.  I had 2 other attempts, but I lost both of the other eggs to a combination of 'dwarven stupidity' and overseer oversight (needed a new food stockpile, forgot to forbid eggs...).
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 19, 2011, 12:55:10 am
No.  Nesting boxes are buildings.  The wild animals using your nestboxes thing has been reported as a bug, so Toady may do something about it in the next release.
what a bug? If I didn't want animals to go plop eggs I could just built it inside or made a hen house. poop I'm so close to figuring out how to breed adventures with out hacking with that feature.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Girlinhat on February 19, 2011, 01:12:45 am
The problem is that if you build a nest box inside, a crundle will path its way all the way through your base, slaughter your chickens, and claim a nest box.  This is troublesome.

Also, if you're worried about sieges, why not turn invasion off while performing egg tests?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 19, 2011, 01:16:47 am
Yea I haven't given up on her yet.  And I actually managed to get lucky and get a good supply of adamantine so my military is decked out, despite the utter lack of any of the metals the embark said was here, so I'm in no real danger of losing the fortress to a siege anymore.

So far she's still the only mother to have successfully hatched a child.  I had 2 other attempts, but I lost both of the other eggs to a combination of 'dwarven stupidity' and overseer oversight (needed a new food stockpile, forgot to forbid eggs...).

Yeah, I've also lost a few other potential mothers to similar things. I've also had a few dwarves lay eggs in boxes without being married, and since the eggs would not hatch, I deconstructed their boxes. However, they have since gotten married and claimed nest boxes, but have yet to lay eggs.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Max White on February 19, 2011, 02:39:42 am
Always remember folks; If knowledge is power, then it is nice to have a battery. Store your power today! (http://df.magmawiki.com/index.php/Category:DF2010:Modding)
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: rarborman on February 19, 2011, 02:46:42 am
I moded gobbos to lay eggs...fun ensued and I caught several and gained some goblin eggs...since gobbos dont marry they cant quite spawn in your slave pits now unless you change them a tad.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 19, 2011, 11:38:06 am
I moded gobbos to lay eggs...fun ensued and I caught several and gained some goblin eggs...since gobbos dont marry they cant quite spawn in your slave pits now unless you change them a tad.
so any one seen a wild animal egg hatch in their nest yet? If so then removing the smart tags on your creatures might be the solution to get them breeding.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Girlinhat on February 19, 2011, 12:01:10 pm
Considering the intelligence of dwarves, in their ability to run across a siege to retrieve a sock, run away from magma by running INTO it, and farmers die of starvation while at a party hosted next door to their assigned farm plot...  I don't think being smart has anything to do with it!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: D_E on February 19, 2011, 12:05:11 pm
so any one seen a wild animal egg hatch in their nest yet? If so then removing the smart tags on your creatures might be the solution to get them breeding.

Yeah, I had a pair of ducks hatch some eggs in one of my outdoor nests. 

The male and female ducks both guarded the nest while the eggs incubated.  The hatchlings were wild.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 19, 2011, 01:51:03 pm
I moded gobbos to lay eggs...fun ensued and I caught several and gained some goblin eggs...since gobbos dont marry they cant quite spawn in your slave pits now unless you change them a tad.

I know that invaders are capable of becoming pregnant and giving birth on the map. If this is possible, it should also be possible to eventually cause some goblin eggs to hatch. For example, I recently read about an invading tiger woman giving birth to cubs while trapped in a murky pool over the course of several tigerman sieges. The problem is that the exact factors that lead to invaders becoming pregnant are unclear.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: StephanReiken on February 19, 2011, 02:11:36 pm
But if you could get invaders to lay eggs and hatch, you could make your own Goblin colony :P
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: silverskull39 on February 19, 2011, 02:36:09 pm
But if you could get invaders to lay eggs and hatch, you could make your own Goblin colony :P

or, even better, breed them for training purposes.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Rumrusher on February 19, 2011, 03:42:16 pm
But if you could get invaders to lay eggs and hatch, you could make your own Goblin colony :P

or, even better, breed them for training purposes.
wow when did Dwarfs go snatch the babies and children of Goblins?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: NW_Kohaku on February 19, 2011, 10:23:15 pm
Hmm... I just had a thought...

Is it possible to have multiple types of eggs tied to one creature if we get the bug to do with unusual egg types fixed?  We could have creatures laying regular eggs most of the time, with an occasional unusual egg.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: silverskull39 on February 19, 2011, 10:29:27 pm
Hmm... I just had a thought...

Is it possible to have multiple types of eggs tied to one creature if we get the bug to do with unusual egg types fixed?  We could have creatures laying regular eggs most of the time, with an occasional unusual egg.

I, also, just had a thought. once unusual eggs get fixed, eliminate the need for females of egglayers; have the unusual egg of one creature (say, a chicken) be the egg of whatever other creature you don't want to have to have a female for. perhaps mermaids.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Flaede on February 20, 2011, 12:52:35 am
I moded gobbos to lay eggs...fun ensued and I caught several and gained some goblin eggs...since gobbos dont marry they cant quite spawn in your slave pits now unless you change them a tad.

I know that invaders are capable of becoming pregnant and giving birth on the map. If this is possible, it should also be possible to eventually cause some goblin eggs to hatch. For example, I recently read about an invading tiger woman giving birth to cubs while trapped in a murky pool over the course of several tigerman sieges. The problem is that the exact factors that lead to invaders becoming pregnant are unclear.

I thought that the conditions required them to appear on the map, with their beloved - which means that they had to be Named invaders from worldgen. Possibly they can show up pregnant, or their mate may also have to show up. I would be interested in data proving/disproving this. I have only had once pregnancy, they were named, but I did not have an easy way to check if they were married in worldgen.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: darkflagrance on February 20, 2011, 02:14:35 am
I moded gobbos to lay eggs...fun ensued and I caught several and gained some goblin eggs...since gobbos dont marry they cant quite spawn in your slave pits now unless you change them a tad.

I know that invaders are capable of becoming pregnant and giving birth on the map. If this is possible, it should also be possible to eventually cause some goblin eggs to hatch. For example, I recently read about an invading tiger woman giving birth to cubs while trapped in a murky pool over the course of several tigerman sieges. The problem is that the exact factors that lead to invaders becoming pregnant are unclear.

I thought that the conditions required them to appear on the map, with their beloved - which means that they had to be Named invaders from worldgen. Possibly they can show up pregnant, or their mate may also have to show up. I would be interested in data proving/disproving this. I have only had once pregnancy, they were named, but I did not have an easy way to check if they were married in worldgen.

Every time I've experienced pregnant enemy soldiers, they have been grunts generated from scratch instead of historical figures. I know this because the mods I play force invasions by removing the ability of besieging races to speak, which also means that any of their soldiers who attacks me and is not a historical figure will be generated without a name.

In other words, it is possible for enemy civs to reproduce by spores without an apparent marriage recorded in the histories. The only issue might be whether this ability is tied to the lack of the ability to speak.

Still, it would then be trivial to change the goblin's INTELLIGENT tag to only CAN_LEARN to arrange this effect.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Urist McAddict on February 22, 2011, 11:26:13 am
COuld you add up a little question there?
Since eggs can hatch, how the hatching works?
Would it be possible to craft eggs that hatch things like Golems and such?
I'd like that...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Mohreb el Yasim on February 22, 2011, 05:02:57 pm
hy all
i made some tests about egg laying civ (where male and female genders aren't intelligent, rare and buyable as pats) so i have 10 egglaying queen,
after the second hatching period i think they can have misscariage, (in both i only hade 9 hatching) and i think once it happens it won't let new hatchings from that nest (maybe until the eggs are removed)
but it seems to work well, from my experience you need to have child tag, can_civ on the breeding castes, no cluster size but the one for the eggs
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 24, 2011, 02:53:05 pm
COuld you add up a little question there?
Since eggs can hatch, how the hatching works?
Would it be possible to craft eggs that hatch things like Golems and such?
I'd like that...

You can't define a specific creature to hatch from an egg, no. It functions like regular birth, as far as I know.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Alocer on February 24, 2011, 05:55:50 pm
If anyone hasn't tried yet (I don't remember seeing a post in this thread), I made an asexual egg layer pet with no [MALE] or [FEMALE] tags, but its eggs wouldn't hatch either.  Unless the game defaults to one of those... although viewing the creature it did say 'it'.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 24, 2011, 06:15:38 pm
Judging by people's responses here, egg fertilization occurs the same way impregnation in general works, so an asexual caste's eggs would never hatch.

I'm still curious about a male egg-laying caste, though.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Bohandas on February 25, 2011, 12:39:16 am
If anyone hasn't tried yet (I don't remember seeing a post in this thread), I made an asexual egg layer pet with no [MALE] or [FEMALE] tags, but its eggs wouldn't hatch either.  Unless the game defaults to one of those... although viewing the creature it did say 'it'.

Judging by people's responses here, egg fertilization occurs the same way impregnation in general works, so an asexual caste's eggs would never hatch.

I'm still curious about a male egg-laying caste, though.

I'm curious as to what would happen if you had an egg-laying caste with the [MALE] and [FEMALE]  tags...
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 25, 2011, 01:16:25 am
I highly doubt that putting both [MALE] and [FEMALE] on the same caste would work at all to begin with, although people are welcome to try!
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Demonic Gophers on February 25, 2011, 01:29:07 am
I highly doubt that putting both [MALE] and [FEMALE] on the same caste would work at all to begin with, although people are welcome to try!
I asked about that once in the Future of the Fortress thread.  It will pick one of them - either the first tag or the last, I don't recall which.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 25, 2011, 02:29:48 am
Well, I got roosters laying eggs, so we know that males can do so.

However, I'm still not sure if they'll hatch. Anyone know how long it usually takes for eggs to hatch after laying?
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: Dante on February 25, 2011, 04:57:23 am
Hmm... I just had a thought...

Is it possible to have multiple types of eggs tied to one creature if we get the bug to do with unusual egg types fixed?  We could have creatures laying regular eggs most of the time, with an occasional unusual egg.

Even if you can't stack the tags on top of each other (you can't with ITEMCORPSE, which is very similar), then as long as the tag can be applied at the caste level, I'll be looking forward to having the occasional rare goose that lays golden eggs.
Title: Re: Egg-Testing Thread (or: Can you cook eggs made out of charcoal?)
Post by: G-Flex on February 25, 2011, 05:34:34 pm
Yep. Strictly speaking, you can do that now, although you wouldn't be able to eat them.

Of course, as far as the game's concerned, an egg with a golden eggshell and regular whites/yolks is still both perfectly edible and made entirely out of the gold, as will be meals produced from it.