1
DF Dwarf Mode Discussion / Are marksdwarves a waste of time (macedwarves, too?)
« on: February 17, 2016, 03:48:23 pm »
I'm more and more thinking marksdwarves are just a waste of time. Almost every bolt gets blocked, and those that don't seldom do much damage. Maybe it would help if my marksdwarves would shoot the copper bolts that I have marked as "combat use" and not the wood bolts that are marked "training use only". And then there is their tendency to charge into melee with a full quiver instead of staying back and shooting. Given all the effort it takes to get them to actually shoot useful bolts, I'm more and more thinking I'd be better off just taking away their crossbows and handing them real weapons so they can do something useful.
Then there are macedwarves, who also seem pretty low on the utility scale (but better than marksdwarves). They seldom seem to break bones like hammers do, and they don't lop off limbs. All the bruising they do might be useful against goblins, but against undead and weres (which are what I'm been facing mostly lately) they don't seem to accomplish much at all. Had a fort where the first 2 migrants with military skills were both macedwarves, so I started my first squad with them. Then an axedwarf showed up, followed immediately by a bunch of undead. The axedwarf had a copper axe and no armor, the macedwarves had silver maces and full armor. In the end, the axedwarf killed all of the undead, except for one that got killed by a lucky blow to the head from a mace. But I saw dozens of headshots from maces fracture the skull, but not enough to drive it through the brain like hammers would have done. What can a mace do that a hammer can't do better?
Then there are macedwarves, who also seem pretty low on the utility scale (but better than marksdwarves). They seldom seem to break bones like hammers do, and they don't lop off limbs. All the bruising they do might be useful against goblins, but against undead and weres (which are what I'm been facing mostly lately) they don't seem to accomplish much at all. Had a fort where the first 2 migrants with military skills were both macedwarves, so I started my first squad with them. Then an axedwarf showed up, followed immediately by a bunch of undead. The axedwarf had a copper axe and no armor, the macedwarves had silver maces and full armor. In the end, the axedwarf killed all of the undead, except for one that got killed by a lucky blow to the head from a mace. But I saw dozens of headshots from maces fracture the skull, but not enough to drive it through the brain like hammers would have done. What can a mace do that a hammer can't do better?

