Bay 12 Games Forum

I kept looking in on Supernatural and shaking my head. One of the more important things to do when playing in Supernatural is reading previous games to get the idea of the mechanics (and they're all good reads too) and paying attention to flavor. And the only player who was consistently doing that was Tiruin.

That reminds me how I didn't do that in my first Supernatural...

That was a thing.

well well well, another NQT game.

Don't mind if I do.

By which, of course, I mean in.

I see Persus won KotM.  Congratulations, Persus!

Quote from: Lenglon on June 20, 2017, 04:43:19 pm

Quote from: 4maskwolf on June 20, 2017, 02:22:41 pm

Quote from: Lenglon on June 20, 2017, 01:31:09 pm

note - My vote is NOT pressure. that's a lynch vote. redirecting the information gathering role is a pure-scum move, through and through, helps town noway, nohow.

Blah blah blah that's not true in the slightest, especially in a BYOR where role's are crazy.

Prove it.

Or at least make an argument to back it up. I see no way what you did wasn't scummy enough to make you prime lynch on the spot.

How about you actually read the post I made right before that and respond to it rather than beating a dead horse?

4mask - Why did you redirect TDS?

Because I was curious what Tiruin was up to, and lacking an investigative ability of my own I was obliged to borrow someone else's.  I only have two actions I want to use right now and the other was a protect and I didn't fancy my odds of actually protecting the scum's target.

Why was I curious about Tiruin?  A mix of gut feeling and difficulty reading her.  A lot of the other players here I have an easier time with reading and establishing connection between, but it's been a long time since I played regularly with Tiruin (the last couple games don't really count) so I've lost my edge on reading her.  Why didn't I have TDS watch, say, TBF?  Because TBF, if mafia, is pretty easy to find out and lynch anyway, so it'd be a waste of a night action on something we already know.

It's also a good way to poke at TDS's alignment as well, insofar as how much information he reveals on the matter and in what manner he goes about it.  I'm pretty convinced he's town at this point.

Sorry by the way, TDS, I won't hijack you again in the future now that I've gotten all the information I wanted out of it.

I was hoping to see some bussing going on with FoU's lynch, but I don't think the people who were voting him would be aligned with him... 'cept maybe 4mask's attempt to vote him when he didn't have a vote to use.

Jeez, I'm sorry, okay?  Mistakes happen, especially when the day has gone on for a while and you forgot about your loss of a vote.

Imma go back and read FoU's posts from the last couple days and see if I can't puzzle something out.

Quote from: 4maskwolf on June 12, 2017, 09:05:09 pm

Fallacy: is your nyah nonsense a post restriction or something you're doing for RPing purposes?

... nyah?

Quote from: hector13 on June 12, 2017, 08:59:19 pm

Why not scum hunt someone who is not Tolyk instead of incessantly saying "waiting on Tolyk, nyah. Tolyk hasn't responded yet, nyah."

That's a good idea, nyah. Finding another scummy target will probably be much easier than thoroughly examining everybody, nyah. As a bonus, it'll hopefully get some activity going, nyah.

Nope, I'm not letting you get away with that non-answer.  Not good enough.  Given that you didn't do this D1 this obviously isn't a mandatory post restriction, which almost certainly means that you can tell me about it if it exists, fallacy

Fallacy: is your nyah nonsense a post restriction or something you're doing for RPing purposes?

If no one has received a majority of votes at deadline, is there no lynch?

The person with the most votes is lynched at the deadline in semi-hammer games like this one.