April 23, 2024: Dwarf Fortress 50.13 has been released.
News: February 3, 2024: The February '24 Report is up.
News: February 4, 2021: Dwarf Fortress Talk #28 has been posted.
News: November 21, 2018: A new Threetoe story has been posted.
Forum Guidelines
Yeah, biotics are pretty light but it goes into enough detail and makes it almost plausible enough to overlook.Spoiler: The end (click to show/hide)
Well most technology is abusing physics ;P
Mass Effect tries to be on the "One Big Lie" Spectrum of Science Fiction Hardness, which means it tries to stick to real world physics but has one or two pieces of phlebotinum (eezo in Mass Effect) that it uses to explain the less realistic aspects.
In comparison, you have things which take known and developing world technologies and try to extrapolate from there, whilst sticking as close to what is possible as they can.
For example, take Ghost in the Shell or Deus Ex Human Revolution, which at least try to take what people are trying to do with real life prosthetics and go from there, assuming "major and sudden breakthroughs" in the whole brain-device interface. Assume we have a breakthrough make a learning machine that can be plugged into the brain so the brain and device can learn to work together like it's a limb, suddenly a lot of Human Revolution's augmentations become more plausible.
And you have soft science fiction which basically shrugs and says "science did it" to explain what amounts to space magic.
Mass Effect, at least the first one, did make attempts to be somewhat "hard" outside of "ezzo did it", especially if you read the codex, so those attempts at hardness can be at least considered and scrutinised.
You know what we need?
RACHNI-BASED FTL COMMUNICATION.
No quantum black box. Rachni box. Rachni-with-a-typewriter box.
Yeah, it's in magic brain cancer world, but it clearly states that it's (ab)using an actual property of quantum physics. If they wanted to magic brain tumor it, they could. They used real physics, and therefore they're subject to scrutiny using real physics.
That is not the discussion we were having. We were discussing real world physics, not magical brain tumor world physics. Believe it or not but sometimes threads in this forum meander as to their topic.
Except this isn't mystical mass effects and eezo, this is real life quantum entanglement which we know how it works. It's like having perfectly normal objects stop following parabolic trajectories or having a binomial distribution suddenly give different values. It doesn't matter if it's science fiction, this is the science part of that label.
Except it is, because you're talking about how this works within the confines of a video game about banging blue space chicks and shooting bad guys with space magic. They have spaceships that enter and leave atmosphere willy-nilly. They have hard-light hologram knife computers. There is literally a new macguffin element that basically works as a "whatever is cool happens now" device. Arguing about the technology of the ME universe is pretty much pointless anyway, as the writers basically change how and why things work depending on whatever the plot calls for.
Look, all I've ever been talking about is the real life practicality of an ansible or whatever name ME uses for it's ansible analogue. According to the lore, it uses the real life physics of quantum entanglement. If you want to say a wizard did it that's %100 a-ok and feel free to do it. But we aren't discussing that because it's a pretty short discussion.
I have no idea if we're talking about IRL quantum entanglement or Mass Effect quantum entanglement any more.
Except this isn't mystical mass effects and eezo, this is real life quantum entanglement which we know how it works. It's like having perfectly normal objects stop following parabolic trajectories or having a binomial distribution suddenly give different values. It doesn't matter if it's science fiction, this is the science part of that label.
