166
Mafia / Re: Paranormal 25 - Day 3 brings no sign of Spring
« on: February 22, 2017, 03:11:51 am »
You're talking about 'more suspicious' or 'less suspicious' but there is no such thing.
There are players who are scum and players who are not.
You've not addressed a single scenario presented.
If a scenario presented would not result in a win, explain why.
Otherwise, you have not explained why the plan will not end in a town victory.
That's what matters; the ending.
Not lynching scum right now, but lynching scum before the game ends.
If you can explain how the plan fails to do that, then you have a valid point.
Otherwise, please just take the win.
You're talking about passing the bot N3 like it's a risk, when the shield is being passed at the same time.
Stop it.
Your concern is valid if scum have two assassination bots - and they don't.
Lynching town!DA before he can scan someone does nothing to clear Leafsnail at all (as a voting player), and so gives us only the information that there are two non-Leafsnail scum voters in the game. Leafsnail still needs to be killed at some point because he isn't clear, and that breaks the ability of the actually clear players to become the voting majority.
Lynching town!Leafsnail has no negative impact and needs to be done because he can't be cleared. Leafsnail is literally the only useless player who serves only as an obstacle to reaching a clear town, and his play is the most disgusting and scummiest thing I've seen in four years. If this is his towngame, he shouldn't be playing mafia - it really is as simple as that; beyond merely gamethrowing, he's attacking the game and the players within it on a meta level, and the only purpose a mafia role has for that is if it doesn't want a co-ordinated town.
The bot is better off staying with Tiruin N3 rather than being used, even if DA is outed as non-town, since DA could still be a third party and she's safe with the bot.
There isn't any WIFOM to be had with DA dying while scanning a guard, since the lynch order is predetermined and guaranteed to result in a town victory.
The tracker goes on doll because it does nothing on webadict/4mask except confirm them as scum ... at times where they are the only candidate for scum.
Deus Asmoth is dead by the end of D4, so doll is the only non-clear candidate for the tracker which isn't strictly 100% useless.
You've made inferences about implications which can be drawn about players and called them holes in a clockwork plan.
It doesn't matter whether or not a player is scummy if they are cleared or killed before the game ends.
Decide whether or not TDS and Tiruin are town, then stop hunting and think about the plan in purely mechanical terms. If you can find a flaw, let us know. Otherwise, just follow along and take the win.
There are players who are scum and players who are not.
You've not addressed a single scenario presented.
If a scenario presented would not result in a win, explain why.
Otherwise, you have not explained why the plan will not end in a town victory.
That's what matters; the ending.
Not lynching scum right now, but lynching scum before the game ends.
If you can explain how the plan fails to do that, then you have a valid point.
Otherwise, please just take the win.
You're talking about passing the bot N3 like it's a risk, when the shield is being passed at the same time.
Stop it.
Your concern is valid if scum have two assassination bots - and they don't.
Lynching town!DA before he can scan someone does nothing to clear Leafsnail at all (as a voting player), and so gives us only the information that there are two non-Leafsnail scum voters in the game. Leafsnail still needs to be killed at some point because he isn't clear, and that breaks the ability of the actually clear players to become the voting majority.
Lynching town!Leafsnail has no negative impact and needs to be done because he can't be cleared. Leafsnail is literally the only useless player who serves only as an obstacle to reaching a clear town, and his play is the most disgusting and scummiest thing I've seen in four years. If this is his towngame, he shouldn't be playing mafia - it really is as simple as that; beyond merely gamethrowing, he's attacking the game and the players within it on a meta level, and the only purpose a mafia role has for that is if it doesn't want a co-ordinated town.
The bot is better off staying with Tiruin N3 rather than being used, even if DA is outed as non-town, since DA could still be a third party and she's safe with the bot.
There isn't any WIFOM to be had with DA dying while scanning a guard, since the lynch order is predetermined and guaranteed to result in a town victory.
The tracker goes on doll because it does nothing on webadict/4mask except confirm them as scum ... at times where they are the only candidate for scum.
Deus Asmoth is dead by the end of D4, so doll is the only non-clear candidate for the tracker which isn't strictly 100% useless.
You've made inferences about implications which can be drawn about players and called them holes in a clockwork plan.
It doesn't matter whether or not a player is scummy if they are cleared or killed before the game ends.
Decide whether or not TDS and Tiruin are town, then stop hunting and think about the plan in purely mechanical terms. If you can find a flaw, let us know. Otherwise, just follow along and take the win.