Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - UselessMcMiner

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 29
31
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 25, 2021, 07:11:40 am »
kinda thinking toonyman is v

I think his handling to the knightwing situation was pretty villagery cause he didn’t immediately try to shut it down at least from what I remember

it’s 7 am and I just woke up so this might be a bit messy

32
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:38:06 pm »
Overall I generally like to focus a lot on the progression of reads and the actual logical backend of reads

generally I don’t like responding to questions like these cause they’re kind of pointless lol

vote: Euchrejack
That's an odd statement given that Euchre's attack on me was very logical and generally feels like active progression. I don't see voting him as a logical conclusion of that. Your defense of your vote doesn't support it. I'm gonna stick with Roden on this one and say we keep EJ for now..

I'm also gonna throw in a bit of a crazy spin and say that it's proooobably not Useless either. Wrong conclusion and everything, some of the evidence feels genuine, so I'm gonna say no to that elim either. At least, not for now.

I mean to me at least it felt more like Euchre was trying to justify his push while he was doing it, or when that failed try to dig himself out of the hole he dug

although I think that in a forum like this I suspect most of the wolves are probably not going to be extremely aggressive

/vote TricMagic

I think the push on me is just bad, it doesn’t even really feel like they’re trying to say that I’ve done anything wolfy. They’ve just taken random posts of mine, ignored the surrounding posts. And then going “wow aren’t these posts strange? Quite weird amirite?” And then voting me for no reason

again getting hung up on details but they said “convince me youre town” but they never even implied that they had a read on me before that post

it just came out of thin air

33
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:33:18 pm »
4mask, can I ask why no push against me?

why do you care
And then ask me why I care someone who suspected me never put forth a case against me. UselessMcMiner, what is your goal for Day 1?

again there’s another logical gap here, I already described how I made my reads and my goals for this day so what’s the purpose of this question exactly

34
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:31:49 pm »
@Jack:
Upgrading UselessMcMiner to town lean.  Have my posting crown, good sir.
Why?

@Useless:
Wow that's a lot of posts, but can you answer my question in my first post? You kind of answered it indirectly but I'd still like a direct response.

I agree that mech discussion could be harmful, however two players spamposting at each other can be even worse and let's scum hide in the chaos. I really don't want that to happen again either.

Overall I generally like to focus a lot on the progression of reads and the actual logical backend of reads

generally I don’t like responding to questions like these cause they’re kind of pointless lol

vote: Euchrejack
... K, you are not giving me confidence in you being town.. Pointless info, or useful info. Why is something useless to you, when it's needful to town?

firstly why would I care about your opinion on this matter

secondly I already revealed how I made reads? There’s a logical gap here where you’re implying that I’m somehow being cagey when I’m not.

What was the purpose of this post exactly?

35
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 04:34:37 pm »
Tell me you've never played with Jack before without telling me you've never played with Jack before.

FYI, I don't want to write Jack off as locktown this early, but he's very much playing into his town meta AKA caffeinated paranoia. If he's scum we'll know because his posts will be muted beyond belief. If he calmed down now I could only assume he was targeted by a day mafia converter, that's how consistent he is.

Btw Jack if you actually did find one of Web's scum tells, that's honestly impressive. The best I've noticed is that Web has played bad cop/good cop both times he was mafia, and was generally less prone to being mean as town unless he genuinely thought somebody was being dumb.

Like this post a lot, especially the last part

it’s definitely not aligned with Jack and Web at the very least

36
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 04:32:47 pm »
4mask, can I ask why no push against me?

why do you care

37
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 04:32:21 pm »
@Jack:
Upgrading UselessMcMiner to town lean.  Have my posting crown, good sir.
Why?

@Useless:
Wow that's a lot of posts, but can you answer my question in my first post? You kind of answered it indirectly but I'd still like a direct response.

I agree that mech discussion could be harmful, however two players spamposting at each other can be even worse and let's scum hide in the chaos. I really don't want that to happen again either.

Overall I generally like to focus a lot on the progression of reads and the actual logical backend of reads

generally I don’t like responding to questions like these cause they’re kind of pointless lol

vote: Euchrejack

38
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:48:32 am »
@UselessMcMiner: Please ask players questions.  What do you want me to answer?

What exactly is your opinion of webaddict

I don’t get why you started shading him in the first place or why you keep pivoting off of him

Also what are your townreads?

39
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:35:01 am »
I’m pretty sure I meant tricmagic instead of 4mask

he’s been here but idk what he’s done

40
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:34:27 am »
I remember getting good vibes from maximum spin earlier but I’m not sure why

think the vote on me is a good look regardless of euchre’s alignment since it’s too obvious of a sheep vote that would be questioned if I ever flipped

41
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:33:27 am »
also I’m automatically FoSing anyone who’ve posted basically no content by this point which I’m pretty sure includes only 4mask?


42
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:32:30 am »
anyways while I was reading over vanilla mafia it felt like the wolves basically just got away with posting no reads cause of all of the mechanical bullshit in the game

so I heavily discourage any mech talk for at least a few days

43
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:28:42 am »
Oh, to be sure. I'm arguing that it's NAI, not that it makes him look town. Wubadicts gonna wub.

Anyway, I say we vote out the guy who hasn't showed up yet.

Well, if we had an idea they were going to show up, I would like to see their response to reading the forum and seeing everyone voting them.

But if they just disappear, then we gotta get a replacement.  So possibly pointless?

Hey, let's check it out though: UselessMcMiner

again more of this shit

he’s playing in a way that’s extremely reactive to thread instead of trying to do his own thing

I’m not sure if I can adequately explain it but to me it just feels like I’m trying to spin his wheels

he can’t just flat out say “let’s wagon the zero poster” when the zero poster is town

but he’s worried that if he says nothing about me people will question it, and he wouldn’t want to defend me for obvious reasons

ergo he sheep’s a vote for no reason

also I don’t know why he pivoted off of webaddict

44
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:26:16 am »
/vote Euchrejack

les go

45
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 11:24:28 am »
Webadict constructing elaborate castle-in-the-air theories based exclusively on faulty assumptions is well within his town meta, though, Euchrejack.
Reread Mafia-ally (Pirate) Captain Webadict of Round 3.  This looks more like that, and less like town!Webadict shenanigans.

euchrejack’s hitting basically all of my classic wolf tells

1: during the early game they tried to make a mountain out of a molehill out of stuff that was basically just NAI

2: they were pushing people in a way that I think could easily either transition to an actual push on people, or if thread disagreed easily be cast aside

3: immediately trying to focus hard on denying townreads on players for vague and unspecified reasons


Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 29