241
DF Community Games & Stories / Idea: Writing workshop
« on: November 26, 2008, 03:36:14 am »
Good evening (or very early morning) folks.
I am Jamini, author of the (somewhat semi-)successful community forts "The last dwarves in the world: Ulolgeshud", "Ulengoddom : The First Dwarven Democracy.", and "Stories of Terror and Energy: Kobold Fortress", and a participant in the Second Battle of the Gods RP.
My time in the community games section of the forums (and the community forts before this section was created) is fairly extensive, and I have a particular love for the English language. The two main things that drew me most strongly to DF were the extremely cooperative and helpful community, and Nist Akath. I wouldn't have stayed to explore the forums much without the former, and I would not have stayed on much longer than that without the latter.
However, ever since the creation of the Community Games forum I've noticed a slight, but ever increasing, decrease in the quality of the written works here. Where before when a community game pretty much always had the equivalent of two to three soft-cover book pages worth of writing as an intro, as well as pictures, now all too often you find that an intro post consists of little more than, "I am planning to do a community fort. Here is the location. :picture: you know the drill."
While I'm not necessarily saying this is wrong, it certainly is disturbing. While the upper and middle tier quality of the works on this site have remained relitivly (and fortunatly) fairly static. The average quality of works, when you compare the number of written stories to the number of good/excellent stories has fallen considerably. This causes the main page of the community games section to become cluttered and clogged with new and fledgling stories, not only dilluting the entire pool of skill that exists currently, but also driving the higher-quality works away from the front page.
This is why I am suggesting this: A thread where people of any background, with writing of any type (including professional, if you so choose, although I do not recommend it!), can post their works and have it reviewed and critiqued relatively anonymously.
I believe such a place has the potential to improve the overall quality of the works on this site that we all enjoy spending our time at. Potentially bringing up (or out) the great writers among us who need a push in the right direction, and improving the ability of all of us as a whole.
What are your thoughts?
I am Jamini, author of the (somewhat semi-)successful community forts "The last dwarves in the world: Ulolgeshud", "Ulengoddom : The First Dwarven Democracy.", and "Stories of Terror and Energy: Kobold Fortress", and a participant in the Second Battle of the Gods RP.
My time in the community games section of the forums (and the community forts before this section was created) is fairly extensive, and I have a particular love for the English language. The two main things that drew me most strongly to DF were the extremely cooperative and helpful community, and Nist Akath. I wouldn't have stayed to explore the forums much without the former, and I would not have stayed on much longer than that without the latter.
However, ever since the creation of the Community Games forum I've noticed a slight, but ever increasing, decrease in the quality of the written works here. Where before when a community game pretty much always had the equivalent of two to three soft-cover book pages worth of writing as an intro, as well as pictures, now all too often you find that an intro post consists of little more than, "I am planning to do a community fort. Here is the location. :picture: you know the drill."
While I'm not necessarily saying this is wrong, it certainly is disturbing. While the upper and middle tier quality of the works on this site have remained relitivly (and fortunatly) fairly static. The average quality of works, when you compare the number of written stories to the number of good/excellent stories has fallen considerably. This causes the main page of the community games section to become cluttered and clogged with new and fledgling stories, not only dilluting the entire pool of skill that exists currently, but also driving the higher-quality works away from the front page.
This is why I am suggesting this: A thread where people of any background, with writing of any type (including professional, if you so choose, although I do not recommend it!), can post their works and have it reviewed and critiqued relatively anonymously.
I believe such a place has the potential to improve the overall quality of the works on this site that we all enjoy spending our time at. Potentially bringing up (or out) the great writers among us who need a push in the right direction, and improving the ability of all of us as a whole.
What are your thoughts?