16
General Discussion / Hypothetical scenarions/questions thread
« on: August 11, 2020, 08:55:48 am »
I don't see a thread that has anything like this, and the random questions thread doesn't seem to quite fit... but here you may ask a hypothetical question ("would you rather", "what would you do if", etc), and others may answer it and discuss what answer would be better.
Rules:
1. Don't intentionally cause angry screaming matches. This should be a given, but if an argument that started with "would you rather live forever or be able to resurrect others" devolves into a discussion about anarchism that mostly has nothing to do with the question itself, that goes against the thread's purpose.
2. Nothing outright gross or otherwise breaking forum rules. We're not children here.
So I'll start.
Say, a kitten is being slowly lowered into a fluorosulfuric acid bath behind glass. In front of you there is a button. If you press it, the kitten will be saved but 10 billion flies will die (randomly picked from the entire fly population). There are about 17 quadrilion flies so you shouldn't do any real ecological damage. However it would be likely the largest single human-engineered loss of multicellular life.
Would you press the button? I would because for me it's downright impossible to empathize with flies. But I can empathize with kittens, especially those about to have a very painful death.
Rules:
1. Don't intentionally cause angry screaming matches. This should be a given, but if an argument that started with "would you rather live forever or be able to resurrect others" devolves into a discussion about anarchism that mostly has nothing to do with the question itself, that goes against the thread's purpose.
2. Nothing outright gross or otherwise breaking forum rules. We're not children here.
So I'll start.
Say, a kitten is being slowly lowered into a fluorosulfuric acid bath behind glass. In front of you there is a button. If you press it, the kitten will be saved but 10 billion flies will die (randomly picked from the entire fly population). There are about 17 quadrilion flies so you shouldn't do any real ecological damage. However it would be likely the largest single human-engineered loss of multicellular life.
Would you press the button? I would because for me it's downright impossible to empathize with flies. But I can empathize with kittens, especially those about to have a very painful death.



