Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 68 69 [70] 71 72 ... 1978
1036
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - 1 Replacement needed
« on: January 07, 2023, 05:11:39 pm »
FoU may have more luck staying alive if they voted Knightwing (or Vector).
Knightwing is literally obvtown.
Why?

1037
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - 1 Replacement needed
« on: January 07, 2023, 05:02:20 pm »
I'm disappointed that Knightwing hasn't done my assignment - or at least - hasn't told me he wasn't planning on doing them.

I still kind of just want to clear the replacement slot so the game doesn't suffer.

1038
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - 1 Replacement needed
« on: January 07, 2023, 04:54:55 pm »
FoU may have more luck staying alive if they voted Knightwing (or Vector).

1039
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 01:51:03 pm »
Toony going after Vector implies that he doesn't see anyone scummier than no one, which implies that there is experienced or low-lying scum, especially given that one of his targets (FoU) is high on the chopping block.
I am indifferent about the demise of NQT or FoU. I'm not confident enough they're scum because I usually find their behavior inherently scummy. I'm this wishy-washy about it that I would genuinely prefer Vector right now, especially as a replacement slot that will only hurt the game flow if they're alive, even if it's not ideal. I would rather the game be more fun for everyone.

Knightwing saying they are "not able to post much" due to reasons, but then posting filler anyway is suspicious. Knightwing coming in to defend themselves when Webadict votes them and nothing else is suspicious. This is in fact Knightwing's major scumtell which might convince me enough that they're worth voting over Vector if they don't knock it off.

PPE:
ToonyMan... am I really that far down on your list? Are you sad I didn't PM you? :(
If you're really town there might be a good reason for you to distrust me, but don't worry it's not what you think.

1040
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - 1 Replacement needed
« on: January 07, 2023, 01:35:44 pm »
I have two assignments for you Knightwing:

1. Read Day 1 of Demon Mafia, how did you behave in that game? Why is your behavior right now suspicious?

I will let past town!NQT give you a hint:
KW, dude, people think you're suspicious because you post 100% reactively. Defense is losing play, it helps no one, not even yourself. If you're town, place a vote on who you think is scum and give some reasons.

2. Give everyone here a "town confidence percentage".

I will share you an example of mine...

Town Confidence
Tric - 80%
Jack - 80%
Jim - 75%
Hector - 60%
Web - 60%
Knightwing - 55%
Max - 55%
FoU - 50%
NQT - 50%
Vector - unknown%

1041
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - 1 Replacement needed
« on: January 07, 2023, 01:05:17 pm »
Knightwing, what are you doing?

1042
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 03:09:26 am »
Also I like how Jim PM'd Hector after Hector said he wasn't going to do PMs. And I like Hector coming to the conclusion that Jim feels town because of that. I think that's good.

1043
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 02:55:23 am »
My pragmatic self wants to continue voting Vector so that we can at least remove a replacement slot for this game. I don't think it's the worst thing ever either since it's possible they're mafia.

1044
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 02:51:46 am »
Earlier Reads

Town
Tric - protector claim, will protect mafia on N1
Jack - enchantress claim, I think they're being upfront and paranoid like proper Jack
Jim - kook claim, feeling pretty honest
Knightwing - need more, can't have any

Time Will Tell
Hector - I think this post pretty much reveals that Hector is town or a dopp leader
Webadict - playing 4-D chess, probably town?
Max - what's going on here, I think they're probably town right now

The Suspects
Vector - gone with the wind
FoU - Roden called out FoU for being incredibly fake sounding in like Matrix6 or something and he was exactly right so maybe there's merit to Jim's suspicions
NQT - why the attack on Knightwing?

1045
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 02:38:42 am »
… y’alright there Jim?
He's just telling us how he feels. I do the same thing a lot (as town).

1046
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 07, 2023, 02:32:34 am »
I find it odd that we have Knightwing up to vote here, and you're not doing much to stop it, Toony.  I feel like you kinda have a prerogative to step up and start directing people if you think Knightwing is Town.
Why work much when do work little?

Do you think Knightwing is Town?
Softly, yes. I feel like he is acting on his own. I'm not fully confident yet, but I don't think he's vote worthy.

I'm not surprised Max switched their vote off of them because he probably feels similarly.

I think NQT is a Dopp here, and I think there's some attempts to move that attention on NQT elsewhere.  I have no idea why Tric is trying to go after FoU, but I don't see who could possibly be on FoU's team if he's scum unless there's an active hit job by at least one of his teammates.
And I don't see how Tric could be mafia unless he's with you.

Do Hector and NQT make this exchange if they're partners? Maybe it's a neat coincidence that they took advantage of, but this does look very natural to me.
It's... literally not about the game except the PM part?  So yes?  I don't understand the issue.  That's not exactly game relevant information.  There's nothing inherently incriminating from either party in it that would point to the other as scum for doing that.
I think the important part is that it's completely unnecessary and ties to their real life circumstances. This is my personal opinion, but I feel like players that know they are partners may feel more awkward with each other when communicating in public, this leads me to believe that perfectly natural looking exchanges like this come off as two players who don't have a secret agenda together. That is my interpretation. I sometimes make incorrect assessments of situations like this, but does this seem wrong?


1047
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 06, 2023, 11:23:34 pm »
I really feel like there is high coordination between NQT and hector this game.  It feels highly w/w.

Even this?

Also also, is it xenophobia if I am also British, but don’t like it?
I didn't know that. We should get a beer the next time you're in Hampshire.

I kinda see your point about the PMs but I can think of a few cases where it'd be worthwhile. Overall, wanting or not wanting to use them is NAI, right?
I don’t think I’ve ever been down that way. England was never really on the cards as a destination, though my school apparently thought Alton Towers was a good end of year reward for whatever bizarre points game they were playing. I also went to London twice and did not enjoy it, but I was there on my own in stressful circumstances (emigrating) and the second time heavily sleep deprived because for some reason there were no flights for the time in the morning I needed to be there so had to get the sleeper train down, which is a misnomer, as there was precious little of that going on.

My point with policy voting Brits was it’s just as arbitrary for policy voting Tric for being pants.

And yes, PMs or not is NAI, I just wanted to make sure y’all knew I’m not interested. It’s like third parties, they can go… away.
I see your handle even says you're Scottish. When I was a kid I lived up near Aberdeen (went to school in Ellon) for a bit. Moving to and from there was a long way to go. The last time I was in the vicinity was to climb Ben Nevis, but that was some time ago. In a chippie in Inverness I made sure to try the infamous deep fried Mars Bar.

Do Hector and NQT make this exchange if they're partners? Maybe it's a neat coincidence that they took advantage of, but this does look very natural to me.

1048
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 06, 2023, 11:16:38 pm »
I'm going to go out on a limb, and I could be wrong, but I feel like it's not notquitethere.

FallacyofUrist feels artificial.
I usually find NQT and FoU naturally scummy at least.

I really feel like there is high coordination between NQT and hector this game.  It feels highly w/w.
Maybe. I think Hector has sounded pretty genuine though. It's like...the opposite of how FoU and NQT make me feel.

1049
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 06, 2023, 07:17:09 pm »
Hops on NQT's bandwagon. Actually, no, he places the first vote on Knightwing. Gives no reasoning. Then NQT follows up.

Could scum really be this blatant?
Welcome to Maxland. Pretty sure he does this as town here too.

I think NQT is mafia.

1050
Mafia / Re: Paranormal Mafia 27 - Day 1 wants off this rock
« on: January 06, 2023, 06:17:37 pm »
Right, and he still won with the bad guys! That wasn't a town win!
He was playing to win with town the whole game. He screamed town. I screamed he was town. He was town until the very last second. I don't have a strong opinion of KW in this game yet, but I think your attack is very malicious on his character.

Pages: 1 ... 68 69 [70] 71 72 ... 1978