Bay 12 Games Forum

1. I have no indication of being delayed.
2. Nakeen said they performed their action on me.
3. Juicebox said their multi-block on Nakeen failed.

Read the entire post Tric:

I resolved TolyK's choice and the result was very good. It's actually similar to Jim's nuts but I can also use it to make a kill action piercing. Jim should know what the other thing is since it's basically the same thing he gave me. Jim and TolyK should not reveal what this other ability is.

I think TolyK is very likely to be town or third-party here, not mafia. Their ability basically makes a townie very good, or gives scum the ability to bypass protections. This strikes me as a not mafia role and balanced in the fact that TolyK has to risk making a mafia very powerful instead of a townie if they whiff.

The kill piercing is the other half of the ability. That part of the gift is completely useless to me because I have no kill.

The beneficial part I can actually use is very good for town. Jim and TolyK have both given me very power item (Jim) or ability (TolyK) of their own free will, well mostly for Jim since I was choosing his possible targets heh.

I was reading D1 as well since I want to figure out who Web and Jack are with if there's a third. I think a third mafia makes the most sense with either Vector or Tric. Maybe I'll do an opinion piece for D1 as well if I'm feeling really spicy. That's not happening tonight but maybe tomorrow.

I'm currently leaning Web/Jack/Vector because Tric is town-clearing Jim, among some other things. Mafia should have killed Tric last night like I recommended.

There's probably a 50% chance TolyK is third-party, but if we kill three-ish mafia and the game doesn't end we can just kill TolyK.

I do want to post quickly that I'd like to see a bit more out of Nightwing and TolyK, I don't have nearly enough from them to get a solid feel on them yet.

TolyK and Juicebox are suspicious

I disagree.

Brief thoughts.

This is a good post.

Yarr

This is a good post.

Tolyk

TolyK

I'm like 90% sure TolyK isn't mafia after the choice resolved.

Also, I tend to Suspect Web, since the most likely reason I'm soaked is because Web just lied about his targets, excluding me.

webadict: I can see Web soaking me, not telling anyone, then waiting until a wagon builds on me just to see the results.  All as town!web. I could see town!web even sacrificing me to the wagon for info.  Thanks Web.

This doesn't make any sense. You suspect Web and then immediately townread them for the same reasons.


PPE:

I disagree, he's been pretty Town as far as I can tell, and I don't want him voted out.  And I'm willing to throw myself on the fire to prove he's Town.  Otherwise, I'm letting an innocent man die.  This is how you defend someone.

Too bad.

I'm still willing to vote out TolyK or even possibly Nakeen, though, but that's assuming I get to choose.

No.

I'm unwilling to let EuchreJack get voted out though.

I will continue to vote Jack just to spite you.

Quote from: Knightwing64 on October 20, 2022, 07:35:59 pm

NGL Web, I don’t know if I’m going to vote you right now, but this kinda made me lose any trust I had for you.

But you gotta admit, that was reeeeeally funny, right?

I'm pissed

I'm home.

I haven't read the thread yet.

I resolved TolyK's choice and the result was very good. It's actually similar to Jim's nuts but I can also use it to make a kill action piercing. Jim should know what the other thing is since it's basically the same thing he gave me. Jim and TolyK should not reveal what this other ability is.

I think TolyK is very likely to be town or third-party here, not mafia. Their ability basically makes a townie very good, or gives scum the ability to bypass protections. This strikes me as a not mafia role and balanced in the fact that TolyK has to risk making a mafia very powerful instead of a townie if they whiff.

I think TolyK's late miller claim is suspicious, however I feel they are working alone which makes them third-party at worst.