Bay 12 Games Forum

Quote from: Jim Groovester on September 27, 2022, 01:58:45 am

That's very convenient reasoning to not put a claim on the line.

Why, if you claimed your results, as more of the set up is revealed we can see that i) you are absolutely not performing night kills, and ii) you could not be making your results up. Both of these things increase the likelihood that you are town, especially as the game goes on.

But you won't because I think you made it all up and don't want to be tested on it. Which is why you didn't claim the actual numbers immediately anyway.

Fair, it is selfish reasoning seeing as I’m the only one who knows the numbers, and I s’pose on reconsidering it would at least allow the holders of the roles to actually call out fakeclaims that don’t match my numbers.

*sighs* fine. For the greater good. There is 1 Mystic, 1 Wizard, and 1 Sage.

Persus was a Mystic so do any other Mystics want to contest Hector's claim?

Well then let's kill the mafia first since KW isn't that. I can shoot KW at some point so Max is happy. If KW isn't lying then he'll still win with Good and I get to make fun of Max.

Still not really here but skimming through what I've missed today I noticed a comment about destroying Tric's body because a lot of body-related actions are anti-town.
I'd like to note that I have at least one granted ability that involves bodies and is pro-town, and also that I'm pretty skeptical of NQT's claim that that was their night action, especially as what was pretty close to a last-claim I think (I don't know where NQT claimed I just saw it recently added to Leng's list).

Max claimed they role-blocked NQT quite early on D2. NQT claiming late doesn't really mean much to me in this situation.

It's also pretty unlikely that NQT killed Persus. Even if they had free actions like Jim has they would have still been blocked by Max.

Come to think of it, maybe my blunderingly claiming my PDE day action could have been useful here, since scum know that my revive is probably legit and the main way they can get rid of it would be by pushing for my Elim today. Unless they have a day-block in which case I guess I just screwed up.

Look for scum instead of thinking of excuses to save your ass.

@Egan:
Thank you for the role flavor.

Quote from: ToonyMan on September 26, 2022, 06:44:56 pm

I find it curious how hard Jack is defending Egan when Egan is my top suspect for killing Persus.

It's possible someone else killed Persus, but my money is on Egan. I really want to hear from them more.

I've said my bit. I don't have night actions. Finding the killer is fine by me, but I'm not it.

Then who? I'm voting you unless we can find them. Let's work together on this.

I'm really not buying Egan as scum.

I wanted a snappy response from Egan, but anyway while we're here let's think about this:

When I was snooping around for who killed Persus it came to the point where just Egan and Hector had not claimed night actions. I voted Egan and asked them what they did last night. Egan's response?

Quote from: ToonyMan on September 25, 2022, 07:29:38 pm

Egan, what'd you do last night?

Are we sure that we want to narrow down who killed Evil!Persus?

Egan couldn't know for sure that a town vigilante existed. One could argue that Egan's response here was to hopefully blend themselves in as a "town vig" as it seemed possible a town vig did not exist at that point. I find this suspect.

PPE:

Quote from: EuchreJack on September 26, 2022, 06:34:48 pm

Welcome back, Town-Vector!

Fuck off

haha

@NQT:
I don't think Lenglon is trying to be malicious here NQT, regardless of whether they're correct or not about you.

@Egan:

I don't have night actions. This doesn't seem so surprising given that I have a day activated revive? That's pretty powerful already.

Okay.

Describe who you are and why you're here, right now.