That's some very specific knowledge you [ToonyMan] seem to have on the Cult in this game. I mean, really specific. How could you know all that?
Your last post about Red's soul-selling and powerboost also worry me, though I can't explain why. You're shockingly cavalier about the fact that he took a kill and basically acted as a Vigilante. Your reacting doesn't seem right.
He's not the only one coming up with rather in-depth analyses of the night kills.
Jokerman-EXE, questions:
- Why are you picking on ToonyMan in particular?
- So far as the RedWarrior0's choices, would you have done differently? Either turned down the deal, targetted someone else, or waited? Why?
It's not his analysis that worries me. It's his reactions and how his statements are phrased.
I'm looking at Toony, specifically, because his posts stick out the most to me. Janus, your posts are organized and easy to follow as you accuse and explain. His posts are confused-sounding, and their style keeps shifting as he plays. I'm not saying that that makes scum, but this is how he played in Para16 and I was on his scumteam. He reads like scum Toony to me.
As to Red's choices...his explanation implies that there were multiple power options (is that correct, Red?) so I can't REALLY answer that. But as far as killing Toaster? I say, if you're not scum and you have a valid suspicion and the power to kill the target of your suspicion, then no one can blame you for acting on it. I won't say Red's not scum, because I'm still looking at that option, but I won't accuse him for killing someone that he thought was scum. I might have saved the power until N2 if possible, depending on my choices.
So to be honest you have nothing on me for your vote, okay. You're voting me because of how I post and that's all you got, which is nothing. That changed
a lot from your previous accusation of having highly specific suspicious knowledge.
Question:
Why would you publically claim this information, now in particular? It doesn't seem to help anything and reveals yourself to the remaining scum as a potential target tonight.
Because the evidence I have suggests that Leaf killed himself accidentally. Scum will target me anyway, eventually, and I want this information out there so that his death causes as little confusion as possible. Besides, I have no idea what I'm doing with this role, so I figured I got lucky n1 finding something useful and decided not to push my luck further.
If Ottofar is a Zombie I think Mephansteras would have made some comment about him still being in the game. And I'm guessing that the Warlock (A mage who seeks knowledge from the shades of the dead) is a weaker version of Paranormal's Medium that can choose to talk to one dead player each night.
I don't think we'd get such a warning from Meph, and you're probably right about it being a weak medium. As I understand it, there's a small chance of failure anytime a magical action is taken. I'm assuming that Leaf failed, and died as a result. I am theorizing that since Otto's body was involved, a critical failure may have turned him into a zombie. Something rammed Leaf's head on to a candlestick, we didn't find Otto's body at his house, and we have no way of knowing if the body's still in the grave without Sexton claiming (Don't. If we're dealing with ghouls, we'll need you alive, if you're out there.)
ToonyMan - You seem positively adamant that there are vampires and they killed Org. Why didn't you even consider the possibility that there are werewolves? You aren't a werewolf, are you?
You're voting ToonyMan for assuming that there are Vampires? When you are doing the exactly same thing with the Werewolves? Sure I'd agree that Werewolves are more likely than Vampire from the flavor, but your vote is on really shaky ground Lonewolf I.
Lonewolf, why are you voting me about being adamant on vampires when I was simply assuming? Because this is just making me more convinced dude.
I voted you because the way you phrased it makes it seem like you've completely overlooked the possibility that it was something else. I dunno, I might be acting unreasonable. A big chunk out of the neck and long claw marks say werewolf to me, maybe ghoul, but not vampire. Plus, you're saying vampire cult, which is ridiculous. Those two are completely separate classes.
Anyway, this wasn't supposed to be an attack. I asked you a simple question and now you've gone all defensive instead of just giving me an answer and moving on. If you keep this up I might start thinking you actually are scum. Please answer the question.
...
No I'm not a werewolf, that looked rhetorical. And what do you mean a vampire cult is a ridiculous class? Isn't that what vampires do?
ToonyMan: You're not helping yourself, here. You are adamant about there being a cult- you have talked about nothing but how there could be a cult, how this piece of flavour supports a cult idea, how we should consider the possibility of a cult- never about the other possibilities, like, say, there isn't a cult, because there being a cult doesn't really make sense anymore? Your posts are short and lacking in real content, an accusation to which you responded 'I do what I like'... I'm afraid that, on the balance, you are scum number one. Unvote, vote ToonyMan
...That makes no sense, I AM NOT ADAMANT ABOUT VAMPIRES OKAY. I was just making an assuming claim on the kill flavor. Why the hell is everyone saying that, oh my god. It's like it's getting shoved down your throat, it just keeps making me think vampires do exist because of these BLOWN out PROPORTIONS. Please stop it damn.
I might as well make a list on this unnatural responses,
THIS IS HIGHLY IMPORTANTMr.Person - overreacted to my assumption
Jokerman - first claims I'm scum for my "highly specific" knowledge of the game, then says that he actually was just voting me because of "meta-reasons" vamptrash move
Lonewolf - "You seem positively adamant that there are vampires and they killed Org. Why didn't you even consider the possibility that there are werewolves?", just laugh a little at his hypocrisy, then realize his overreaction to my
assumptionNUKE - his vote came the hell out of nowhere and is utterly nonsensical, I explained above
So yeah vampire guys, you should probably stop punching me in the face that there is no vampires and there is instead werewolves because you're doing it terribadly.
