Bay 12 Games Forum

Quote from: ToonyMan on August 21, 2022, 11:09:57 pm

Big brain theory: Mafia are Max and NJW.

Okay. Why?

*cracks knuckles*

Max hasn't told us if Knightwing is town or mafia yet, this is very odd.
NJW's questioning line towards Lidku was odd, though nothing definitive.
Jim and Web both don't have townreads of Max or NJW, neither do I.

Jim and myself are siding with NQT. Web is reading NQT as mafia, but also reads Max and NJW poorly.

I'm not fully confident in this theory, maybe switch NJW with Lidku.

i think it not jim.
i think it not knightwing.
i think it not lidku.
i think it maybe not toony.
i think it maybe not lenglon.
i think it maybe max.
i think it maybe njw2000.
i think it maybe nqt.

that what i think

Webadict for now.

Hmm, I like your spunk NQT. You went above and beyond the call of duty with extra categories of reads.

I'm gonna say NQT is town. Knigtwing is probably town too though I need to see non-roleplay posts.

Alright maggots, give me your personal lists of how easy it is to read each player ASAP.

Here's mine:

Difficult
Jim
Web
NJW

Not Sure Yet
Max
Lidku
Lenglon

Will confirm their alignment in their first post
NQT
Knightwing


Lt. Toony finishes their completely appropriate demands. Secretly he feels Lenglon is town, but doesn't have the nerve to say that after stating they are not confident about them yet. Toony thinks Lenglon roleplaying shows casual playfulness of a town member, and their question towards Knightwing is exactly what he would do, to get a good check on a player you'd want to see post early.

Banning self voting is restrictive. There are situations where a player would want to self-vote, such as outted scum at L-1 to end discussions preemptively.

Banning self voting loses creativity. Look at how scum!Roden voted themselves in this game to appear more town.

I don’t think that was a beginner friendly game.

Neither do I.

Mylo and lylo were good though.

Quote from: hector13 on July 27, 2022, 08:32:54 pm

It didn’t help that KW made no effort and gave up early doors, which made it very easy to eliminate him.

Knightwing is just new to being scum. He was doing GREAT after he had been functionally caught. If he had pulled that out earlier, NQT probably would've been executed, and then who knows how the game would've gone.

It's true. I didn't want to hammer Knightwing at the end because it would have been really bad if he was town and I wasn't 100% sure.

Friendly reminder that TricMagic has once again protected a mafia member from me targeting them.