Bay 12 Games Forum

Shorten? I'm pretty much confirmed Town, and we'll need to see what happens Tomorrow.

Days are already only 24 hours.

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 30, 2022, 04:32:50 pm

So I think we could pretty reasonably say the Whisperer is:

3. Maximum Spin, which makes this game kind of evil and I don't approve.

I don't really want to interfere with the theorycrafting, but I want to stipulate that, besides the weird mechanics which we agreed to from the start, this isn't any kind of bastard game and I'm not sending secret messages.

Okay, mod confirmed.

How about this post:

Everyone hears that ToonyMan is Town.

Is this guaranteed? At least at the moment it was said?

Quote from: ToonyMan

1. Webadict himself, he makes himself look like the first target and then starts sending them to other people.

So is this an imply that webadict might be the SM, with some sort of ability that can misdirect people? Get the first D1 vote on him as well, to clear any suspicions of him as the SM going forward in the game?

Voting the SM is actually bad I think? Since we'll waste one of our townconvert votes. I don't think it does anything to vote the SM since they can't be converted. I chose Webadict as my townconvert vote simply because they claimed Cult, but Egan would work perfectly fine here as well now that they've claimed. I don't think either are SM.

That makes me think though, maybe the SM has some ability to switch people's alignments to prevent unity? That would be powerful enough to disrupt our plays.

Something that bothers me about Webadict is that he asks if anybody "whispered" to him 2 hours into the game here. I have no idea who that could be unless it was Knightwing with their Factchecker claim. It wasn't Lidku. It could be Jim or NJW. Or Max is sending them himself, which would be bastard. Or Webadict is lying, but that would make him the Serial Moleman.

Anybody else want to claim getting these weird whispers?

All silent here.

I vote Town winning.

I'm a Town Brainwasher.

Since Webadict is claiming Cult we should vote him today to make him town.

Quote from: webadict on June 30, 2022, 10:58:17 am

I have a question: Did someone whisper me Lidku's alignment?

What did the whisper say?

What do you think it possibly could have said? Think about Web's POV. I can take a guess what he was told, if he's even telling the truth.

Quote from: ToonyMan

Lidku or Jim? Maybe

I can understand me to some extent being suspected, since NJW has put it up in the air that I might be the "SM," but why Jim though? All he has done so far is ask a question.

I have no confidence one way or the other. I'm actually leaning everyone who's posted so far as less likely than likely, so not exactly being suspected.

I think it's really difficult to find a single target on D1, but maybe it'll happen.

I don't think anyone who's posted yet is the Serial Monstercat, maybe Knightwing?

Is it Web or NJW? Probably not.

Lidku or Jim? Maybe.

Knightwing? TBD

I wasn't really following until I saw it was D3 and that Jim was still alive and being a mushroom. So I sent this PM to Web since I like giving private thoughts on games:

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 25, 2022, 08:31:57 pm

Oh my god Jim is still alive and being lazy? He's mafia. Who's it with? I don't know I'm not really following closely...Jack or Tric?

That's all I want to say.

EuchreJack. Tric is being too ridiculous to be Mafia.

So I did have mod confirmation throughout D4, although I was already convinced of Jim.

You really carried town hard at the end there Lidku even if it didn't work out. You were emitting townie energy by giving a ton of effort that also had purpose. I hope I can play a game with you in the future.

For example:
Even when you were told Jim was town, you were still uncomfortable and were giving thoughts and commentary on his posts still. The suspicion was clearly still there because your natural talent/instinct was telling you something was wrong.

Live by the sword, die by the sword.

I warned people about roles, man, all game long. I shut up when it benefited me though.

No longer a dunce...oh wait it's still theeeere.