Shooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooorten?
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Some thoughts on the NQT nomination:notquitethere - 8: notquitethere, ToonyMan, Roden, Jim Groovester, Maximum Spin, Knightwing64, EuchreJack, webadict
reina - 2: reina, Egan_BW
Scenario #1
NQT is town and mafia are trying.
This makes Reina and Egan look worse.
Scenario #2
NQT is town and mafia aren't trying.
This tells us nothing, though it puts impetus on them moving forward.
Scenario #3
NQT is mafia (and their partners are probably trying).
In this case it doesn't matter if they're trying or not, he's getting the nomination at this rate.
It's more likely that his partners are helping him though, which would make Reina and Egan look slightly better, mainly Reina.
Personally, I think Scenario #2 or #3 is most likely. Scenario #1 is too blatant, it's unlikely that Reina and Egan are both mafia. It comes down to whether NQT is town or not, and he probably is.
Day 1 Proposed CouncilsToony -> Toony, Knightwing, NQT
Webadict -> Reina, Jack, Toony
Knightwing -> NQT, Toony, Webadict
Jim -> Jim, NQT, Roden
Jack -> Reina, Jack, Roden
NQT -> NQT, Toony, Roden
Egan* -> Egan, Jim, Reina
Max* -> Max, NQT, Roden (also townreads Web)
Reina* -> Reina, ??, ??
Roden* -> NQT, ??, ??
(Webadict and Jack are both voting NQT currently even though they're not on their top3 team, so we can assume they're a top4 pick.)
Number of times a Player is on a Proposed Council6 - NQT
4 - Reina, Roden, Toony
2 - Jack, Jim
1 - Egan, Knightwing, Max, Webadict
Every player has nominated themselves besides Knightwing, Roden, and Webadict. Knightwing only has a nomination because of Toony. Webadict only has a nomination because of Knightwing. I have no idea why Knightwing is nominating Webadict. Webadict would actually be a top candidate for a lot of players except for the fact they claimed they lose if they get nominated.
NQT is the clear top tier. I went over this earlier.
Reina, Roden, and Toony make up the second tier. I think it's likely Roden doesn't want to be nominated based on what Webadict said and their behavior this game so it's actually more like Reina and Toony. If there's no Onyx inside NQT/Reina/Toony then we should see more and more dramatic behavior as the game moves forward as they're the most likely council nominations and mafia will have to do
something at that point. I think Reina is probably town so I don't mind them being nominated.
Jack and Jim make the third tier. They have minor support and are more polarizing than the top4 players. I think it's likely neither of them or one of them is Onyx, but not the other. This is because of the hostility and suspicion they've shown each other throughout the game so far.
Egan, Knightwing, Max, and Webadict make the bottom tier. Webadict is willingly bowing out so they don't really count. The remaining three have very little popularity for various reasons. Egan is extremely suspicious. Knightwing is a black hole of mystery. Max is obtuse and rubs people the wrong way.
