Bay 12 Games Forum

->OBJECTION!<-
I mean, Extension!

On to the case of Toony versus Town:
Does it not make sense to redirect our lynch from Toony, and at least give him a day to verify himself? Do we not want as many living allies as possible? Moreover, if his role is as stated, we would get to keep powers around after people died. Look at your role, and think if it would be useful to have around after the event that you died. For instance, if nothing else, mine can be used tactically, and would still be of some benefit to town were I to die.

In short, the lynch case on him seems misguided to me, and we would better spend our votes on any of the lurkers, questionably logical people, and/or bandwagoners.

The defense rests.

I have to disagree with you there, Solifuge. Why would a townsperson with such an absolutely *awful* role be so worried about dying? I understand not wanting to be lynched for no reason, but he's gone above and beyond that. He's very obviously trying very hard not to get lynched. That's a major scum-tell, along with the word-twisting baseless accusations.

No, I'm pretty sure Toony's not town. And I don't see any reason to let him 'prove' that he has the horrible role he mentioned. At best, with that role, he's a Survivor and a distraction from lynching scum when we need to the most.

I say lynch him today and get it over with.