Bay 12 Games Forum

I am serious, though, I think having ToonyMan nominated Day 3 is a good idea.

I mean, I approve of course.

I'm going to keep supporting Jim, as I see Jim as slightly townleaning whereas NQT as scummy.

I don't understand this logic. Doesn't NQT look better than Jim here?

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 12, 2022, 12:25:33 pm

Webadict is probably town too. I'm more sure of this then Jim or NQT or Jack right now. They seem genuinely willing to vote me as a nominee, which only works as a motive if they know they can get a Cabal member nominated.

@Toony: WTF is a Cabal?

Eh, forgetaboutit!

I could see scum and town notquitethere both making that post, but I think town notquitethere more readily and easily makes that post than scum notquitethere does. Really I'd say any town player in general more readily makes that post than any scum player does. It comes across as fun rather than a careful and calculated move to advance an agenda.

I strongly agree. I think scum!NQT would be much more cowardly.

As for Cabal, my role PM doesn't mention the word.  I do see the enemy faction is called the Onyx Cabal, so maybe I didn't understand Toonyman's post.
@Toonyman: What did you mean by your statement? I think I might understand, but maybe you can clarify for me?

I think Webadict is being serious about wanting to nominate me. If Webadict is part of the Onyx Cabal then he must also nominate himself or another one of his members or he will lose the game.

Quote from: Jim Groovester on May 12, 2022, 02:01:03 am

But we're townhunting this game.

What is the difference?

Everything.

Knightwing is probably town.

I don't understand the point of this otherwise:

Quote from: Knightwing64 on May 11, 2022, 08:03:24 pm

Also, are the sects created by players individually or by the GM?

Nothing in the rules indicates player generation of sects so they must be generated by the moderator.

are you seriously scumreading me because I got to the thread later than nqt

That does seem unfair.

Okay, you're the least suspicious of the three. But still not a good nominee.

Maximum Spin

Egan_BW

reina

Also, I'm undecided if I should accept nominations or if no one will believe I'm Town, but I feel like not accepting nominations is scummy, so, whatever.

I was thinking this, but since you've said it out loud I'll be glad to point it out.

I think anybody who plays humble is probably scum. Although the fact you're aware of this makes it moot if you're scum so whatever. But at the same time, would you say this out loud in the first place if you were mafia? It's something to think about for sure.

Wot, I was saying that I didn’t think jack was easy to read?

Do you think you're easy to read?

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

notquitethere

Man, you're just making NQT's opener even better holy shit.

I could make a third joke about Jim being King again.

I like the roleplaying Knightwing, but I don't think I could do that all game.

I knew Webadict would read me as scum so I tried to incriminate Jim as much as possible. It became apparent both were definitely Rebels so that worked out.

I was genuinely salty that Knightwing was my King and that Web had a double lynch ability so I went big and voted Knightwing when Max called out how clearly suspicious Knightwing was. It wasn't an act of self-defeat. I was still playing to win and my goal was to cause extreme confusion. Jack and Web both adamantly defending Knightwing was a bit of a miscalculation as it made them both look like Guards, which is fine, but meant Knightwing really was going to die due to the double lynch ability. Web was wise to not reveal the downside of their ability as I would have let Knightwing die with Jim otherwise.

At that point my goal had to be to get Jim and Web to kill each other. So I continued to connect Jim to myself while attacking Web. As long as I could convince Jim or Max that Web should die over Knightwing then we win. It didn't matter if Jack or Roden was the other Guard.

Max said earlier that I'm emotional as scum, but I think I'm just as emotional as town. I believe the difference is that I'm much more reserved and manipulative as scum, which Web has seen through countless times. He was exactly right that I was acting with a scum agenda in mind. The problem that occured here though is that he read my intentions straight and wanted to vote Jim over me. I was being homest when I said Webadict's logic was stubborn and arrogant because it denied anything Max (and a lesser extent, Jim) had to say.