Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 139 140 [141] 142 143 ... 1978
2101
Knightwing was the King. I couldn't tell if Jack or Roden was the other Guard. I had to play a little dirty given the situation, sorry. I 100% thought Jack was the other Guard halfway in so I was wrong about that. Their complete silence when Jim told them to vote Knightwing made me really confident, but I guess that was incorrect.

2102
Pheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeew

2103
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 10:20:13 am »
But, if that's true, why would Euchre and I be your top suspects? Why not Jim and Max?
I don't see who could possibly be the third scum if Jim and Max are. It's not Knightwing. It's not Jack. It's not you. It would have to be Roden which I don't believe.

2104
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 10:17:23 am »
You always do this as mafia. You always act like you're untouchable and power control the game. You're fine with Jim and Knightwing dying because it just wins you the game. I am not fine with this.

2105
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 09:30:16 am »
That wasn't a scumslip. This game is hopeless for town because King Webadict is propping himself as confirmed town with their double lynch ability which you and Jack are simply supporting unabashedly.

It's Roden, Jack, and Web.

2106
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 08:00:54 am »
Also, Toonyman, you seem pretty grumpy, are u okay?
This game is hopeless and unfair.

2107
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 07:59:30 am »
Honestly, I’m at a loss here, what would you have me do to convince you?
Vote Webadict.

2108
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 06:39:09 am »
What are your thoughts Roden?

2109
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 01:26:23 am »
I refuse to believe you're this dumb.

2110
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 04, 2022, 01:11:01 am »
*reads three pages of nonsense*

Bite me, Webadict.

You have an absolute stubbornness and arrogance in logic. Your "holier than thou" attitude disways other players from disagreeing with you (whether through timidness or exhaustion) and tricks more sheepy players to nod their head and accept your crooked reasoning.

Your congo line of death involving myself and Jim/Max is purely to fuel your ego and gloat if it resolves.

This ability you've claimed has driven me mad up the wall. I want to believe you're just boldly claiming something that Tric bestowed the King, as behaviorally I strongly believe you're scum even if the OP ability mechanically clashes with it. I just wouldn't put it past Tric.

...To hell with it, I should have done this earlier. Webadict. Let's throw down. As Max put it I'm sick of your smugness and think you deserve a smack to the face. I think it's possible your behavior about Knightwing has been staged and Jack has been playing along. In other words in this scenario: you're King and Jack is one of the guards. Your plan would grant an autowin if you could lynch two Rebels today, which is likely to happen with you in control.

2111
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 03, 2022, 09:15:13 pm »
Okay, I'll copy Jack then.

Who do I vote for Webadict? Who's the King if it's not Jim?

2112
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 03, 2022, 08:39:44 pm »
Dunno, something he said just rubbed me the wrong way
Wow. Great.

AND I WON!!!!

Primarily because NQT's logic got buried.  So we can't let that happen here.

Voting Toonyman.  Who else can vote Toonyman?
Maybe I wasn't clear but the point I was trying to make to ToonyMan is that he shouldn't be brushing his misgivings about you away so easily.
Yeah I see that, it's just that voting Knightwing seems better than Jack here if it's the case I can believe you.

So Jim & Toony are a team.  Interesting
It's possible we're both town, yes.

My vote's in the right place. I don't vote if I don't mean it.
Conviction, I like it.

I'm switching back to Jim Groovester, but note with concern how many people seem unable to vote Toonyman.
You mean like you jumping back off me? If people don't want to vote me then that's on them and means I'm doing a good job, sadly.

2113
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 03, 2022, 05:31:50 pm »
Fine, maybe I will vote you Jim, if you want it to be that way.

Jim Groovester
Good there's a vote, now why is Jim scum?

2114
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 03, 2022, 05:29:49 pm »
So, you think EuchreJack, Max, and Roden are Town, which infers that you think Jim, Knightwing and I are scum?

If that's the case, why would I be okay with voting Knightwing and Jim? I feel like that implies you think I'm the Traitor King, which is fair if you think being the Traitor King gave me an ability, or it might be a setup to swap the vote to me, but this makes it feel like you think Jim is a Traitor?

Seems a little confusing to me.
I don't know. I'm just assuming you're town because of bullshit powers even though I don't really like your posts. I'm voting Knightwing because I believe Jim more than Knightwing. If Jim is town there's a very strong possibility that Jack and Knightwing are both mafia. So voting Knightwing makes the most amount of sense here. If we vote off both Jim and Knightwing today with the double lynch I think at least one will be a hit. There's no way both are town.

Why is Roden scummy?

2115
Mafia / Re: Traitors in the Fortress: Day 1 - The First Arguments
« on: May 03, 2022, 03:45:25 pm »
Hm, I am OK with voting Knightwing.
Web is OK with voting Knightwing.
Max, Toonyman, & Jim ARE voting Knightwing.
So...probably Knightwing is NOT the King.

What was happening shortly before Max suggested Knightwing?

I'm fine with dying if we can agree on a top hit alongside me. It would remove me as a suspect and we only instant lose if the other player is also town. This should prove I'm not the King at least. It also means I won't have to play in this game anymore.
If you are on the chopping block as wrongly-accused town, shouldn't your view of the game be better than ours?
Which player(s) do you think deserve the honor of dying with you? By your POV, you have a 50/50 chance.
...you can do better than Knightwing
I think I would be okay with Knightwing or Jim. Although I note your extreme hesitance to vote Knightwing along with Webadict. I would find this more compelling to pursue if I didn't think you were town. If we lose to mafia!Jack here then you deserve to win again.

Max and Roden are probably Rebels since I agree with them.

I was at schollllllllll.
What can I do to convince you guys that I’m not the king? I really don’t want to y’all to waste a vote.
Well maybe you can vote someone.

Roden is also highly suspect. Would consider eliminating him.
Why?

Pages: 1 ... 139 140 [141] 142 143 ... 1978