Bay 12 Games Forum

I will join, I guess.

Oh right, if I claimed vig we would just no-lynch and shoot each other, which guarantees a town victory since mafia wouldn't be able to get it down to less than 3 people for the next day no matter what they did.

That's game then. I'm not going to stamp my feet over it.

If you thought I was that good you wouldn't be pulling the same strategy every game since you clearly believe it to be effective and reliable.

Did I even win any of those games? I remember the MVM3 Round 3 one distinctively as a loss. That's not effective or reliable.

Though actually now that I think about it, I'm guessing the point was to draw out the real Cop. Jim hammered the Cop claim with little hesitation, so the mafia team were able to deduce he was the real Cop from there. That's actually pretty smart, might've been better for me to just hammer then.

That was pretty smart, yeah.

Either way, I think that more or less proves I'm not aligned with Blu. If the plan was to try to save Blu by eliminating Knightwing, then Blu should've come up with a believable fake claim. Otherwise, if the plan was to sacrifice Blu in order to find the real Cop and gain town cred for myself, I wouldn't have been putting any pressure on Knightwing at all and definitely wouldn't have brought the two people I was arguing with to ELo. My play this game doesn't match up with any viable scum motives or strategies.

WIFOM

Quote from: Knightwing64 on March 03, 2022, 07:23:35 pm

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 03, 2022, 06:08:26 pm

I'm out tonight but I'll be on later.

@Knightwing:
Anything else to add?

Roden seemed to switch up very quickly after voting himself.

I mean, I got yelled at and guilt tripped for my previous tone.

I'm voting the player I 100% know is mafia. From your POV the same is true if you were town. I think it's incorrect to not be voting a player you 100% know is mafia. I believe you only made this "BP doesn't exist" argument and self-voted as a last chance way to get me lynched today even if this makes you a 5D chess master like Web has said. I don't believe you would give up the game because of posts like this one. In addition, you aren't posting like a player who has no chance of winning. Which I believe heavily hints that you are in fact BP and just need someone lynched to win.

Roden has no reason to unvote themselves before going to bed unless the selfvote really was a way to get Knightwing and Web on me for the hammer, though that implies he is BP.

ToonyMan actually shouldn't believe Roden is Bulletproof anymore, unless he thinks Roden is a 5D chess master.

If Roden isn't BP then self-voting does end it for him sooner as there's nothing he can do now.