Bay 12 Games Forum

I don't remember if this was said anywhere, but none of us should claim unless:

1. We caught scum
2. We're about to be voted off
3. It's lylo

Knightwing claimed Miller which I guess is fine.

The reason for this is simple, there's no doctor (a roleblocker is a crapshoot if they can succeed) and we have potential roles such as cop and bulletproof which are extremely better when mafia don't know who to hit.

@Bluarian:
Who's scummier, Max or Knightwing?

@Webadict:

There's also no Doctors, so I'm clearly the best person to kill unless the scum think I'm Bulletproof, which I'm not.

Yes. I just don't see you as the Bulletproof because you claimed Cop. Why would the Bulletproof claim Cop??

Hey I'm in. I skimmed the thread before joining so I have some thoughts I guess.

Webadict and Jim are probably town. I like this Web post.

Roden is probably town.

Don't know about Max or Knightwing.

I think Bluarian is scummy. Not only are they always mafia, but they get angry and confrontational as mafia while staying more cool-headed as town. So posts like this rub me the wrong way.

Woo we win, aliens don't exist.

Final

This is what I see:

Aliens Exist - Jack, Knightwing, ToonyMan (3)
Aliens Don't Exist - Webadict, Jim Groovester, Maximum Spin, Roseheart (4)

So that's 3 for Aliens Exist and 4 for Aliens Don't Exist. If Aliens don't exist then we win. If Aliens do exist we only win if at least one of Jack or Knightwing is a human.

I feel good about Jack and/or Knightwing so I guess if everybody else is okay with this then I'm good.

Everyone else can vote that aliens don't exist it should be fine.

There are too many people saying aliens don’t exist too fast. I’m suspicious.

Knightwing, vote that Aliens Exist with me.

Aliens Exist