Bay 12 Games Forum

Yeah. When players were actually scumhunting it was scary, but as soon as mechanical info became more important everybody stopped thinking about why players are behaving the way they are and such.

For example, why would town!Toony stay quiet during mylo? That was a good reasoning based on behavior, not mechanics. I don't know if this game was entirely fair, you'll have to judge that when it's over, but I think it shows it's better to not overly rely on unknown mechanics of a closed setup game.

Thanks Magma

Maximum Spin

Hammertime

I'm also going to say that I don't think it's EuchreJack, and that it's probably ToonyMan, but I think I die Tonight either way.

Nobody dies tonight if you're wrong, the game will probably end before then. So good job.

@Toony, why did you give Max a bulletproof vest?

Because I believed mafia tried to kill him on N1 for some reason and would want to do it again. I could have given the BP to Jim, but I overthought it. I did something similar in the Gnosia game here as the Guardian Angel.

Quote from: EuchreJack on January 25, 2022, 02:36:52 pm

I wanted to add my second neighbor before using the device.
You'll find out what Toonyman gave me...when I use it.  Not before.
Why is Mr. No Claim asking me this?

@Toony, in your mind, was Jack justified in doing this? Is your invention less useful than a neighbor?

I don't know, maybe.

---

Roden and Max have conflicting claims which means one of them is probably mafia. I've felt both Roden and Max were town this whole game so I can't confidently say I know who to vote here. I walked into today thinking the mafia were Magma and Webadict, however Max's claim throws extensive doubt on Roden. I think it's unlikely mafia win if we no-lynch and I think that is how we raise our chances of winning.

No Lynch

Cool. I gave Max a bulletproof vest last night.

Who do I believe at this point??

I can't really think anymore. Why isn't Webadict voting anyone?

Toaster since if Magma is town we at least share a POE.