Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 180 181 [182] 183 184 ... 1978
2716
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 07:08:20 pm »
sigh

I just realized a really, really meta reason for why 4mask and Vector are possibly not mafia, but I don't know how messy that will make the game at this junction so I'm afraid to use it as reasoning.

2717
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 06:53:23 pm »
@Roden:
I can ask but there's nothing saying I can't use the double vote for lylo so I doubt it. I will say that the restriction is quite bad if I use it.

I'm reluctant to vote Max. Max/4mask is possible but Max/Vector likely is not. In which case I still think 4mask is a better hit.

2718
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 03:21:30 pm »
Anyway, Vector, I guess. I understand that Vector has time constraints, but every day without a Vector post feels incrementally more like "scum Vector tries to hide from the thread".
Max/Vector is unlikely since Max seems serious about voting out Vector here. I don't think they would make a vote like this if they were partners with Vector, it feels too dangerous with how the end of day is going. I haven't seen Max as mafia which is one reason I can't read them well and have them as null, but it just seems like a foolish play.

2719
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 03:16:54 pm »
My double vote is activatable, although I would prefer not to use it today if possible.

I don't think Vector not being around is inherently suspicious, which is why I'd prefer 4mask who is around and also actively being suspicious. I disagree with Web's assessment that 4mask is staying quiet on purpose - or at least - is doing so as town.

2720
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 10:45:03 am »
Reads

Strong Town
Knightwing
Jack

Weak Town
Tric
Useless

Web
Roden

Null
Vector
Max

Suspicious
4mask

2721
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 26, 2021, 10:36:03 am »
I prefer 4mask over Vector, however I will vote Vector if it looks like a tie is going to happen.

2722
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 25, 2021, 02:28:57 pm »
I'm busy today but the Day goes to Friday so that's fine

@4mask:
Also I'll let you in on a little secret: Trying Too Hard (tm) isn't a scumread. Or even suspicion. It's a frank analysis of the way they are playing early D1, taking posts a little too seriously and building mountains out of molehills.
Okay, does me saying I think that's a big towntell for Tric and Jack change how you feel?

@Jack:
Edit regarding Toonyman: It is quite easy to read his thoughts and arguments, just not so much his alignment.  Good job Toonyman!please be town
I admit I am paranoid about Web and Roden, but similarly to Web I don't want shit to go horribly wrong again, plus their posts have been townie and even if I don't fully trust Web and Roden I have faith in the Jack and Tric townreads. I'm usually not wrong about you and I don't think I'm wrong about Tric here. Knightwing is almost a freebie too. I don't think mafia!Web would knock out so many players without including themselves as well, which they haven't. Although they are trying to include Roden which I don't understand. So yes, I am considering Web/Roden or more unlikely Web/Knightwing in the back of my mind, but it is outweighed by what is right in front of me.

2723
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:23:15 pm »
@Jack:
@Jack:
Upgrading UselessMcMiner to town lean.  Have my posting crown, good sir.
Why?

Two things really:
1) UselessMcMiner reminds me of my very first game as town.
2) Going off the assumption of newness, UselessMcMiner is posting too much to be mafia.  If they were mafia, they would be posting a lot in the scumchat and not here.  The rabid attacking seems like new townie.  So yeah, no voting Jack Jr, ok?

You should instead look to see who is attacking UselessMcMiner and why.
Fair enough.



@Webadict:
I can believe both of these. In which case if I make the daring assumption that Web and Roden are town as well that leaves the mafia inside Tric, Vector, Max, Useless, and 4mask. I can't tell currently for Web and Roden but I think this reasoning is alright.
I like these and can agree. Who do you think is scum in that 5?
I'm going to extend this reasoning further by removing Tric and Useless from the list. I agree with Jack that Tric and Useless feel town. I believe it's likely there's at least one scum inside Vector, Max, and 4mask. I think Max is the least suspicious out of these three from what I've read so I will say I think Vector and 4mask are scum right now, however I don't have strong reasoning for Vector as they haven't posted much.

4mask is a different story though:

1. Joke vote on Webadict - NAI

2. Joke(?) vote on Tric - NAI

3. Votes Jack for "slipping" - The phrase "I'm going to laugh my ass off" is very similar to what I said as mafia in MVM3 when Tric got the same parity results on Vector and Max. Mafia indicative. In addition I think their vote comes off as disingenuous.

4. Weird passive responses to Tric's inquiry - Could be seen as scummy, not strong

5. Vague suspicion of Jack and Tric - Doesn't take a stance on how they feel about them, but points them out regardless. Mafia indicative.

2724
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 04:29:30 pm »
@4mask:
Bzzz wrong answer.

@Roden:
I feel the same, hence my question towards 4mask.

So right now:
Web is townlocking Knightwing (and Roden I guess).
Roden is townlocking Jack.

I can believe both of these. In which case if I make the daring assumption that Web and Roden are town as well that leaves the mafia inside Tric, Vector, Max, Useless, and 4mask. I can't tell currently for Web and Roden but I think this reasoning is alright.

2725
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 12:06:46 pm »
@Jack:
Upgrading UselessMcMiner to town lean.  Have my posting crown, good sir.
Why?

@Useless:
Wow that's a lot of posts, but can you answer my question in my first post? You kind of answered it indirectly but I'd still like a direct response.

I agree that mech discussion could be harmful, however two players spamposting at each other can be even worse and let's scum hide in the chaos. I really don't want that to happen again either.

2726
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:21:12 am »
I agree with Jack that Tric looks town. I'm not sure about the rest. I don't fully buy into Web's sacrifice circle, but there's some good since he's basically clearing Knightwing. Roden and 4mask less so.

Speaking of 4mask. 4mask, is Jack town or mafia?

2727
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 24, 2021, 09:14:52 am »
I haven't played in the past Totems, but it looks like there's a number of vote-related roles in the game since Jack has claimed a restrictive double vote as well along with Web's no vote. This is possibly further evident by "Vote Phase 1" instead of "Day 1".

I don't mind voting UselessMcMiner but I would prefer a sub if they're unable to play.

2728
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 23, 2021, 10:24:08 pm »
@Webadict:
If you just fucking give it away, you can't catch people, ya dingus.
Sorry, I didn't mean to ruin the trap. While I appreciate the metagaming I don't think it should go further than "Knightwing looks really good".

I cannot vote.
Hehe. I should say this now anyway: I'm a double voter. This makes my vote count twice. There are restrictions to this power but I don't wish to share this to mafia.



@Jack:
Time will tell, I'm certainly not sure that Knightwing64 is town, but it would be a high-level mafia team bluff.
I think it's fairly convincing unless Knightwing is exactly with Webadict, which is not a rabbithole I want to repeat right now.

2729
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 23, 2021, 05:38:03 pm »
Wait, how do you tell if your town or scum?
What do you mean?
Were you told your alignment in your role PM?
No but it's easy to infer.

2730
Mafia / Re: Totem Mafia 3 - Vote Phase 1
« on: November 23, 2021, 05:21:43 pm »
@Tric:
Vector, are you scum? Here's your non-contractual interaction.

No, and here is your peppercorn uwu


TricMagic, piling a second vote on Webby already? Tsk Tsk.

Are you excited to play today?
Team is Web/Vector, calling it now.

Also, please do not yeet me while I'm asleep. It's rude. I'll be claiming day two.
That's a bold team claim. I wish I was that good at randomly gues-I mean, reading people.

Why even say you'll be claiming day two?

PPE:
That is much better since I can counter. If anyone kills me, they are in for a rude awakening.
Okay never mind you're softclaiming today anyway. That seems like town!Tric I think.



@Webadict:
Wait, how do you tell if your town or scum?
What do you mean?
Oh you fell for the trap, Toony... Oh my god, I fucking love Knightwing64.

If anyone votes Knightwing64, you are scum.
It's true, every time Luckyowl did this they were town. So I think that's a reasonable conclusion.

Pages: 1 ... 180 181 [182] 183 184 ... 1978