Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 191 192 [193] 194 195 ... 1978
2881
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 08, 2021, 09:20:31 am »
I want Tric dead more than NJW: TricMagic

Have a better sense of the game now today Tric? I would like to know how you feel about everyone.

2882
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 08, 2021, 01:55:22 am »
My previous post about Max wasn't directed at them, but towards the "crowd". Otherwise I would have used "you" like I did with Web.

The same way my current post is towards everyone.

I usually stick an @ at the top of a quote when I'm directing towards someone, but not always. I'm here to determine a player's alignment, not who they are behind the screen. I'll respect someone's wishes if I'm aware but otherwise I'll probably go with they or he by default, generally the former nowadays.

2883
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 08, 2021, 01:15:29 am »
Anyway, my point is that you shouldn't vote for ToonyMan because it's not ToonyMan.
Why have you decided to not interact with me in this game Web? That's no fun.

I like your reads, but I feel like they're really familiar.

...Have you noticed anything with any of the players so far?



Making assumptions is a choice!
Having seen Max's play now in the last round this looks exactly the same to me. That's why I think they're probably town. It's kind of whatever now, but you'll likely see me much more openminded if say they're trying to explain themselves on Day 2 after people think they're lying about their claims.

2884
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 11:17:45 pm »
Probably town
Jack
Webadict
Maximum Spin
Roden

Null
Vector

Suspicious
NJW
Tric

2885
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 10:15:45 pm »
@Tric:
To be fair, ... I've got a headache, wha... Right, RVS.Unvote.

I got nothing right now. Other than a headache and too much web.
Weaksauce Tric, weaksauce.



@Max:
I really don't want to give reads d1. It changes the facts on the ground too much. If I tell you what I think of what NJW is doing, then he also knows that, and what he does afterward has to be interpreted in light of his possession of that information. I don't like that kind of feedback loop.
Yeah, but what if you die tonight? Or is that not something you are considering?



@NJW:
Roden: How confident do you feel that you can recognise Toony's scum play after the last game?
I don't feel confident at all lol. His scum play doesn't really seem that different to his town play, even his tone read the same to me until the endgame. He's really good at flying under the radar especially early on, so early pressure on him honestly might be a good idea from now on.

I did originally want to poke Tric but I'm fine seeing how Toony reacts to pressure.
You can't read him at all, so you're going to pressure him with an RVS stage vote. How convenient. No question or anything either, you're just going to plonk that vote down and leave it. And any poking of Tric is just going to be a blue-text declaration of poking.

What's going on here? Is voting/FOS-ing people while declaring it's entirely to see how they react your typical scumhunting method, or do you just like the pretty colours?
It's a good point, although would mafia!Roden try to push a vote on me for Day 1?

I suppose they haven't really pushed me at all so that could be suspicious, but...

2886
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 10:09:07 pm »
I'm going to guess that what Vector wants us to conclude is either that A) Vector has poison, or B) Vector is particularly vulnerable to poison.
I'm feeling charitable enough to imagine that one of the two positions might be the truth. Anyone have poison so we can test this?
I'm in.
I was a day poisoner in Round 2. I was also town. Why are you sure scum specifically has poison?

You don't have to reveal your role just give me a second look through and make a conclusion based on what I've said.

2887
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 10:07:03 pm »
Scum has poison. I will not explain why I know that, so take it or leave the information as you will. Longer post later.
I don't believe you.
Why not? I believe Vector.

2888
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 02:04:33 pm »
Tric, if Roden is mafia they've now forced what they're capable of fake-claiming down to exactly one thing: a delayer. This narrowing of possibilities is undesirable and I don't get the same impression I got of them claiming as mafia in Round 2 when they were with you. In fact, you should know Roden best having been mafia partners with them prior. Does that make sense? You're not even using that as part of your reasoning here.

2889
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 01:55:36 pm »
-
Good stuff Toony. The chance of the roles being assigned exactly as they were in the last three games is already 1/(7!)(7!)(8!), in other words 0.000000000097638%, so your case looks pretty watertight already. More seriously, I know what this play is and I don't like engaging with it.
Thank you, thank you. I would be lying if I said I wasn't being at least semi-serious.

-
This is bad logic, and you were right to say so last game. I see your point about the probing Max thing, in that you can't really expect to read someone whose town game is so deeply scum-sided, but generally speaking I don't like excuses for not scumhunting people, Jack. If you think one of Max and I are scum, you should at least be asking me questions.
What do you think of Max so far, being the Maxpert? Can you promise to keep extra scrutiny on Max?

Jack is probably town by the way.

2890
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 01:48:41 pm »
@Jack:
I don't think both would be the mafia team, although I think there is one mafia in NJW and Max.
Hm, why? Is it because of my reasoning?



@Roden:
Toony, what's your role?
Very deadly, very stupid. It works better if mafia don't know about it.

I did originally want to poke Tric but I'm fine seeing how Toony reacts to pressure.
I appreciate the thought. I usually get to coast during every Day 1 since people just assume I'm town.

Doesn't stop me from playing though.



@Webadict:
I did originally want to poke Tric but I'm fine seeing how Toony reacts to pressure.
Nah, the right play here is that ToonyMan is actually Town. ToonyMan is so Town that I plan to pocket him without ever engaging with him. Thus, my play has begun. MUAHAHAHA!
My savior is here. Dude this shit is so easy, Webadict is town. Boom only six people left to choose from.

...As I was saying, people just assume I'm town on D1. Webadict especially likes to do this.



@TricMagic:
The fact they are using it to hide. By saying what their role is so early without promting, us being delayed would be seen as normal, town trying to stop the kill. But all it does is delay us, resulting in mafia being able to take advantage of it. It's also trying to get roles to reveal, giving them options on who to delay.

Put simply, just because they revealed, does not make them town. If anything Delayer is a very negative role regardless of who has it. For one, it would ruin my own role's ability if it's used on me N1.
Your vote on Roden is ass, but I understand the paranoid after my Gunsmith claim last round.

That is the only justification your vote has. The rest of your reasoning is poor.

2891
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R4, Day 1): Illuminating Lantern
« on: November 07, 2021, 01:38:24 am »
It's NJW and Max's turn to lose as mafia.

I think this game will have exactly two mafia if I can read FoU correctly. I don't think we would get an ally again this round since FoU would try to overcorrect since they have stated they weren't happy with last game's setup. So I will work under this assumption for the time being.

Meanwhile it's obvious NJW and Max are mafia. I don't think you could argue otherwise. FoU has been very deliberately rolling alignments on us players. What are the chances that the players that hadn't rolled mafia yet are the only ones that get mafia in these rounds? Somebody run the numbers on this as it's pretty obvious I'm right.

2892
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R3, Round Over): Cracked Composure
« on: November 04, 2021, 10:41:39 pm »
I got really paranoid since town!Web would always protect Vector with at least one layer of protection for N2. I couldn't trust the ally signals fully even though no one else was doing ally things, pretty foolish but hard to shake when you're alone and feel pressured by a role as powerful as the Captain. I even said I felt very underpowered and wanted to hope the Captain was an ally, but could not let myself be carried by wishful thinking.

I wasn't lying when I responded to Vector about having trouble reading Web. Normally when we're both town it's easy, but in this case we were both mafia and didn't know each other. This is a very odd and rare scenario I don't have much experience with. Jim and Irony did it perfectly in Bastard Paranormal 2 and I feel that would have happened here if I just killed Vector instead.

I felt there was a good chance the deflection would hit town since NJW was the only other possible ally if Web weren't. The blindspot was that if NJW was town there was a good chance he would target ME, which I should have realized and just went for Vector instead. That single kill decision between Vector and Web likely determined the game. I was extremely confused and devastated when not only Web was my ally, but also that they died.

2893
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R3, Round Over): Cracked Composure
« on: November 04, 2021, 07:48:28 pm »
On a second inspection you find a logbook within the "professional" killer's belongings.

How are you going to handle the private chats without Quicktopic now?

2894
Mafia / Re: Oh jeez, Quicktopic is shutting down
« on: November 02, 2021, 10:01:12 am »
Here's everything I have saved and zipped together in a folder.

This probably has a couple random non-mafia stuff as well.

Not sure of a good way to preserve online easily without just downloading the html files.

2895
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R3, Day 5): Truly Tired Triad
« on: November 01, 2021, 04:47:40 pm »
I had a strongkill that would circumvent protection, but only on even nights. I was multi-tasking on odd nights (so I could...role cop and kill someone unless Vector gave me something) and a strongman on even nights. That's another reason I chose not to kill on N1 since I wanted the strongkill for Tric on N2, which still would have lost to NJW's deflection. I also thought Roden was just a Jailkeeper so it would have made Roden suspicious if their protection target still died.

Basically I had a choice at the start of the game to be a multi-tasking rolecop/killer on odd nights or a strongman killer on even nights. The latter sounded more desirable.

Pages: 1 ... 191 192 [193] 194 195 ... 1978