Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 203 204 [205] 206 207 ... 1978
3061
They will know they were poisoned so they can confirm this before dying which confirms my kill, or they can lie which proves they're mafia.

3062
Could have mentioned that. Does it still proc if we lynch you?
Yes. If people try to push for me I will absolutely bring down my top suspect with me.

For some clarity, my daykill only pops at the same time the lynch happens. We can't flip someone and then decide on someone else the same day. It'll be simultaneous. I guess it's for game balance.
That's not a day kill lol. This changes everything, it's way less safe than an actual day kill if it's conditional on there being an elimination.
Can you tell us the name of your role? And does your day kill count as an actual Vig shot or is it technically a second lynch?
There doesn't have to be an elimination, they die at the end of the day regardless. I apologize for not clarifying this sooner but I wanted to get some good reactions and voices on who people would like to see dead during the day, this is why I'm stating it now.

The full name is One-Shot Day Poisoner. My flavor's hidden profession is toxicologist.

3063
I have some posts I need to respond to still so I'll get to that later tonight.

3064
For some clarity, my daykill only pops at the same time the lynch happens. We can't flip someone and then decide on someone else the same day. It'll be simultaneous. I guess it's for game balance.

3065
In terms of my final decision making for today...

I'll be shooting NJW or Tric if the lynch isn't one of them today so.

If the lynch is one of them I might still kill the other or Met during end phase, not sure right now.

PPE:
Also means Toony has a way to survive tonight if Jack is telling the truth.. Sorta inclined to believe him.

I would hope so, your statements gave the impression you wanted the doctor to out themselves:

Turning this on it's head. Do mafia have a nightkill? We have a lot of roles that can mess with things so far. Vector isn't talking, and you bring this out an ask who we want dead. Even though...
Hmm. Do we have a doctor or not is my question. Right now we have a redirect, a track, and vig. Of the remaining, if two are mafia alligned. Granted, one of us could be.. Are you attempting to draw the doctor to target you?
... Not that that makes sense with the idea there is no mafia kill, but still. Perhaps as an ally. (Not enough info here. Day 2 gives a lot more based on what happens at night.)

3066
Jack you shouldn't have claimed that, I don't think you're in any danger of being voted off today and you're probably the only doctor of this setup. Although it does make the mafia's choices more difficult if I don't use my shot today as I have a lylo breaker and you can easily stop a nightkill.

3067
Busy right now but I will say NJW is correct that I don't think Roden and Jack are mafia unless it's exactly both of them together. Which I find incredibly unlikely as I townread both independent of each other.

Jack's reasoning on Roden is spot on, it's a nice parallel to NJW's reasoning on Tric last round.

3068
I'm kind of interested in how we went from trust tric to tric to kill tric for tricking.

Hmm... I'd play revisualization, but this isn't the end of the case. I'll do it anyway though.
Do you think you're playing differently than last round? If so, is this a conscious decision?

Who is a more likely mafia hit between NJW and Met?

3069
I don't like jack's play. It's similar to last game but instead of never taking a real stance this game jack is taking many weak stances. NJW seems like a player I will have difficulty reading. Ultimately I'll have to do some kind of agenda meta analysis. The way Tric tunnels on roden is notable
I think the way Jack is flopping around is indicative they're town.

I trust Roden who believes in Jack.
I trust Jack based on their behavior.
If I trust Vector then I should suspect Tric.
I don't trust Tric.
I'm mixed on NJW (I would shoot Tric or Met over NJW right now).

I think there's at least one mafia between Tric and Met.

@NJW:
Between Tric and Met who do you think is a more likely hit?

3070
@Tric:
If Toony shoots scum, we should definitely vote today. But if he hits town, we can't vote. If Toony misfires and then we mislynch, scum wins by shooting town tonight unless a protective role comes in clutch.
Roden.. Just a question. Why do you assume there are two mafia? What applies to one game may not apply to the other.
You don't think there's two mafia Tric? I think it has to be that or one mafia + one mafia-ally.



@Roden:
This is just an aside, but I haven't actually seen Toony's scum play yet, and every game I'm wondering if this is gonna be the one even though I'm not really noticing any differences in his playstyle.
Hehehe, I feel the same about you Roden.

Although you do have the advantage on me in the form of past games. I've been mafia a couple times this year, but only once in a significant game: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 2. That's seriously it. I'll be a bit miffed if I don't roll mafia a single time in these rounds.



Reads

Roden - town as fuck
Jack - mega town

Vector - I don't knooow
Met - "why are there many rounds?"

Tric - suspicious
NJW - bullseye


Met are you able to play additional rounds? I want an extension at this point.

3071
Ouch, didn't even think of that.  I just picked a color.  Yeah, poor choice on my part.
Oh...hah, that's not even what I meant it's just hard to read with my forum layout.

I commend Tric for being consistent, although we should pick another color.  I like the idea that it is color-coded though. You can certainly suggest the color, or ignore us.
Unsure if NJW2000 is generally behind the eight-ball or mafia, so Suggested Daykill remains.
You could just bold it. I think your reasoning for me to kill NJW is weak, same for Tric.

@Toonyman: Don't shoot Met, please.  At least not for "a while".
But it's okay to shoot NJW?

3072
@Jack and Tric:
Suggested Daykill for Toonyman: NJW2000
Suggested Daykill for Toonyman: NJW2000
What is this bullshit? You're telling me to kill a man and you color it brown?

And Tric, why did you color it the same as Jack?

3073
Wait, why are there many rounds?
haha

hahahahahaha

3074
NJW:
If you think I might be mafia repeating my past behaviour to look like town, why are you asking me to reflect on my thought processes?
Because I think you're wrong about Roden, again. I'm trying to determine if this is intentional or not.

I'm currently eyeing NJW and Met since suspecting low posters worked so well last round.
Now this is genuinely mystifying. There are over twenty hours left in the day, and FoU specifically said there was a replacement and an extension available if Met didn't show. I've always seen you as someone capable of basic reading comprehension, but apparently the dopamine buzz of constant back-and-forth interferes with those faculties.
I was bored at work and nobody was posting.

Perhaps you could read other people's posts as closely as you expect them to read your own.
Welcome to Tric.



@Roden:
I definitely do want to make a no lynch happen today, that's part of the strat. I think it would be scummy if I suggested it but then weakly pushed for it IMO, since it would be clear I didn't really believe in what I was saying. However things do change with the possibility of a day kill. We should mass claim before the shot so we don't kill the Cop or Doc.
True enough. I'd feel bad if I killed a cop or doc.

Since Tric and Toony have essentially full claimed, I will too. I'm a Tracker, and I am gated, but I won't say how so that a potential Roleblocker has to guess on whether or not I can even do anything tonight.
Sounds good, I believe this.

3075
Actually Vector and Tric could be distancing. I was about to say their interactions weren't scum vs scum but Day 1 distancing is really easy to do, especially since no one usually feels like they have to commit to have a vote.
Possibly.

I'm currently eyeing NJW and Met since suspecting low posters worked so well last round.

@FallacyofUrist: Pokey Met sometime please?
Also, should Met be town and not post, we'd have to consider policy lynching Met instead of more interesting suspects.  Not opposed to the extension.
I'll prod them. If they show up, no problem. If they don't show up by day end, I'll replace them with someone - I already have someone lined up for the position. (And then I'll do a 24 hour extension for the sake of the replacement.)
Gee I wonder who that could be.

Pages: 1 ... 203 204 [205] 206 207 ... 1978