Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 204 205 [206] 207 208 ... 1978
3076
But...how do we know that Toonyman's daykill is Town-aligned?  Maybe FOU gave the mafia a daykill?
Ah, I miss these absurd reasonings. You're either town!Jack or playing mafia well.

3077
Fair point. I can't really tell you who to shoot but I at least heavily recommend against shooting Jack, their tone has been fairly town.
I agree.

And I doubt scum would have a day kill so it would essentially confirm you as town if you did shoot someone.
Exactly. Another reason I felt like claiming since it removes a player from the D1 lynch pool. Or at least, if we start seeing people die during the night. If the mafia feel like framing me by not killing at night then be my guest.

3078
Because people aren't posting as much as I'd like. Maybe the fear of dying by my hand will bring people in.

3079
Mafia / Re: Games Threshold Discussion and List
« on: October 07, 2021, 02:03:09 pm »
Paranormal

3080
Surprisingly similar to your last round's ability albeit in a different way. I think you're being honest here. Which means that only some of us have stated public professions.

My ability is also one-shot and easily confirmable. I was thinking to target someone right before day end since I feel like mafia will just want to kill me N1 again and I'm selfish enough to want to actually take someone out myself. I had a 100% mafia read rate last round after all.

3081
It's an excellent point Vector,  Tric fucking loves claiming his PR on D1 as town without being pushed into it at all. Your mentioning of him claiming Knight (truthfully) in Supernatural on D1 brings my brain to a boil.

.... Fine, I can redirect someone's action to me. Kinda a weak man's doctor. Especially since it's a one-shot. You happy Vector? And what's with the talk against Jack anyway?
Are you only just a psychologist?

3082
My question to you Tric is why openly state your flavor role in the first place?
That is the question isn't it? Why did I do so?
I think it's because you don't want to reveal your actual ability, but sure be annoying and difficult. This is different from last game where you were much more forthcoming. I'm probing to get a better idea of your motivations.

This round has been boring. My flavor has my stated profession (biologist) along with my actual profession. Hence my extreme raised eyebrow at you simply claiming Psychologist and nothing else.

Also I have a day-kill. Should I use it today? Who's a good player for me to kill Tric? Somebody who isn't playing?

3083
My question to you Tric is why openly state your flavor role in the first place?

3084
I'll vote NJW for going at Roden again, I think he might be doing this to look natural.

Do you think you're voting Roden for legitimate new reasons or are you not reflecting on what transpired in Round 1 with your feelings towards Roden? Remember that you even wanted Roden over Met on D1.

3085
Honestly? No. I have plenty of town-Tric to compare him with.
Go on...

3086
Also, should Met be town and not post, we'd have to consider policy lynching Met instead of more interesting suspects.  Not opposed to the extension.
How do we determine Met is town before policy lynching them? Why would we want to vote a town player?

3087
@Vector:
3. TricMagic doesn't sound crazy, which means that he's probably scum.
He didn't sound crazy to me in Round 1 either, does this change your feelings?

3088
@Jack:
Do you think mafia!Roden would try to rock the boat by announcing his new D1 game plan? Or do you think he would play more cautiously and reserved as mafia to not stand out? I also haven't seen Roden as mafia yet so I think this is a reasonable conclusion to make.

3089
I have to come to the decision whether Jack is being his town self or trying to look like his town self.

Currently I can't tell, but time will reveal the truth. My eyes see all. He seems better than last game at least.

@Jack:
Alright, what do everyone think about the tactical utility of Not Lynching?  Is is good/bad/indifferent?
No.

Also: I have an active pro-town ability.  Maybe I'll share more on D2.  Declaring now so nobody thinks I'm making things up to avoid the lynch.
Thought: Some/Many/Most Town players have an active pro-town ability.
Hmm you were unwilling to share anything on D1 of Round 1. This makes me think you're town now.

Toonyman: What do you think of my self-narrating?
It shows you're eager to play.



@TricMagic:
Also, I'm a psychologist this time around. Make of that what you will.
Heh, and I'm a biologist. Are you being honest with your profession here?

I have a distinct feeling you're lying about your real profession.



@Roden:
The idea of no-vote Day 1 into mass claim Day 2 is that it quite literally gives scum only minutes to come up with a fake claim that doesn't contradict the town mass claim + night action reveals. And with four town vs two scum that's one extra PR that can catch a slip up.
Meh, I don't know. I like the idea of changing the D1 game plan each time though since in this game players are going to have recent memories of past rounds to use and exploit. Plus, a meta strategy is questionable with unknown setups each round. I think your intentions feel honest here which strikes me as town.

3090
Mafia / Re: Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3 (R1, Round Over): One Final Discovery
« on: October 06, 2021, 07:32:29 am »
I only ask that you share the horrible imbalance after the game is over.

Pages: 1 ... 204 205 [206] 207 208 ... 1978