Bay 12 Games Forum

Also, lol at scumchat:

Quote from: FallacyofUrist on July 02, 2021, 03:24:19 pm

Quote from: ToonyMan on July 02, 2021, 03:16:23 pm

Nope. Not if you both leave your votes on me for a full 24 hours or something. There's going to be at least one or two hours in that time span where mafia can communicate and do the quickhammer.

... what? Brain hurty.

Let me help little brain FoU.

Scum #1 posts at 9am - "Hey Toony has two votes on him, let's coordinate a quickhammer so we just win."
Scum #2 at like 2pm - "Alright man, how about at 9pm today or if that doesn't work for you I can be around for 9am tomorrow to perform the quickhammer."
Scum #1 posts at like 3pm - "Cool cool, yeah 9pm works for me."
or
Scum #1 posts at like 3pm - "9pm is too late for me sorry, but yeah I can do 9am tomorrow, see you there."

I'll be online all day, let me know when you can do a quickhammer

Right, let me know when you're available. If there's still a town vote placed, we can go ahead and win this.

I'm online now

at :45, in 4 minutes?

Got it.

I'm actually surprised my original guess on Magma was correct lol. Even if we got FoU today I think Magma likely wins in a final three scenario since I'd moved on from suspecting them. GG to mafia.

This is true. I would have never voted Magma in a F3. I expected FoU to die during D3 honestly.

Jack since you were town I would seriously take to heart what I said during the game as it will improve your play whether you're town or mafia.

Mostly Vanilla Mafia 3

*Eyes light up*

Reads:

Town
Magma
Roden

Pref

Jack
FoU
Mafia

Toony: how do you explain scum Euchre defending hedgerow D1?

TMI.

He even says this after on D2:

You all, except Pref, mislynched Hedgerow after I told you not to do it.  You've played with me before.  You should expect me to be rude to you for that.
Yes, I know it isn't "optimum townie play".  But you were wrong, I was right, you didn't listen to me, and now Hedgerow is dead.

Jack is surprisingly confident in their Hedgerow town read. The "I told you so" attitude comes off really bad.

Another thing I find extremely annoying is that Jack specifically has been bugging me to explain terms like TMI and POE even though I know for a fact Jack read the Championship game I was in for MU and players used those terms consistently throughout the game. Why in the world does Jack ask me what these mafia definitions are if he already knows them? The only thing I can think of is that Jack is trying to "generate content", it's a form of active-lurking you would do as mafia:

Could you tell me what TMI means?

If nothing else, give us your POE.

@Toonyman: What is POE? I thought it was Person of Interest, but I'm having some trouble with the concept.  Is it one person or several?
I know we're supposed to be doing it, and maybe I already am, but I'd like to know how to correctly be doing it.

They sound very fake here, just like FoU.

As far as I can tell, the favoured pairings are currently:

Magma -> FoU/pref
Toony -> FoU/Jack
Jack -> pref/Magma
pref -> FoU/Magma
FoU -> Toony/Magma
Roden -> FoU/Magma

Do I have that right?

This pretty much cements in my mind that it's FoU/Jack or Pref/Roden. Pref/Roden is a lot less likely in my opinion. FoU/Magma and FoU/Pref both don't make any sense to me.

@Toonyman: Are you going to be able to do the Magma ISO you promised?

I didn't promise a Magma ISO and no because Magma is town and I'm busy today. I have no idea why people are willing to vote Magma.

Here's a question for you, actually. Is it scummy, at this point, to post speculation on who has the last town power role? Because I think I know who it is. And of course that person must be town, so I find myself in the position of needing to fake a worse read on them so the scum don't catch on. I might have spoiled it already by saying this much, unfortunately, but I think it's more valuable to share this fact so I don't create confusion.

I strongly discourage any genuine PR hunting when it's the only thing mafia want today.

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 25, 2021, 04:55:14 pm

Quote from: EuchreJack on June 25, 2021, 03:54:15 pm

Are you planning to lead town like usual?

Yes. I would also expect more standard play from me.

What is Toony's standard play?

When I said this at the start of the game I didn't mean standard Toony play, I meant standard play in general. Hence why I didn't want to rock the boat too much and didn't push cases very aggressively. I was going to ask Tric if I could still post green text advice if I died N1, but I didn't have to since I'm still here.

Now that it's D2 and everything has gone wrong I want to do as much as possible before mafia probably kill me tonight. Pref is right that I'm basically playing as I would in a serious champs game at this point because town have been severely hurt by a D1 dead PR and D2 town modkill. I don't expect or even want to be around tomorrow and would like to see the rest of town win the game through their own effort.

Overall conclusion: Either I can trust him completely or I can't trust him at all. Leaning towards the latter, though I admit I may be lying. Or just wrong.

Insightful. You should be honest with your scumhunting, there's no reason to mask your reads. Scumhunting is not the same thing as PR hunting, at all. What happens if you're killed tonight and your deceitful reads are used against town? Or is this not something that comes to mind since you're mafia?

I'll have more to say after some sleep. Before that though...

FoU's posts are comparable to porn acting in terms of believability.

This is the funniest shit I've read in this game so far.