Bay 12 Games Forum

@Jack:
For a self-proclaimed sheep your vote on Hedgerow is awfully sticky and not sheepy. Why do you want this Hedgerow elim so bad? Why aren't you vote hopping like a madman?

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 27, 2021, 10:39:32 am

I actually agree with Bluarian about Jack which seems to be a minority opinion. I think this makes mafia! Bluarian less likely. Even if we're wrong I don't believe Blu would trying to go against the flow of shading Jack as mafia when blindly reading them as spew town is easier. It feels to me they aren't sure of player's alignments.

This isn't true, Blue has a "tiny scumlean" on Euchre, although for unspecified reasons. Where you thinking of someone else?

No I wasn't, but you're right. I thought Bluarian's read was stronger when I read it the first time. I still think their feelings seem genuine like they don't actually know player's alignments.

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 27, 2021, 11:44:34 am

Weak Town Reads
Prefuzek - has posted once, but the post was good

Can you elaborate a little please?

I'm not alarmed by anything in it. I also like the pressure on Jack. They haven't posted since then so I can't say much more than that. I probably should have them in Neutral along with one-time poster Rolan.

Quote from: ToonyMan on June 27, 2021, 11:44:34 am

Webadict - pocketing everyone, also Jack gives strange reasonings for why they're town here

Are you seriously scum-reading webadict for saying that he's putting people in his pocket? I don't think that's what that phrase means, and him simply saying it certainly doesn't make it true. What am I missing here?

I think it's something he would do as mafia, but fine. Webadict is having a mental breakdown so I'll give him a break today.

Quote from: Roden on June 27, 2021, 05:01:38 pm

Oh. That was unexpected. I had a question for Web too.

I wanted to know, if he thought I was hinting at a PR, why he would openly state that. Why did he then also try to reiterate just how town I am? That's weird to set up a potential PR as easy night kill choice.

It could be a sneaky way to tell his partner about a PR read before he replaced out.

Ehhh...scum can communicate in private via scum chat Magma. No reason to signal in public.

---

PPE:

Rolan7, please vote someone.

Yes.

I would prefer to learn more about Rolan and Hedgerow, but sure I promise to aim for your head today. I don't believe town!Web would read me so poorly.

I want more from my neutral reads. This is also a newbie game so I want to encourage players to post.

I would actually vote Web over you right now Jack, because Web is more likely scum between the two of you.

Unvote Prefuzek

This doesn't feel like a newbie game at all.

Town Reads
Roden - reasoning here
BluarianKnight - reasoning here, if they are mafia then it's likely with Magma or Pref but I don't think it's likely currently

Weak Town Reads
Magma Mater - are we even in a newbie game? they're insanely proactive so I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt this isn't expert mafia play, and unlike Jack their posts don't make my mind melt
Prefuzek - has posted once, but the post was good

Neutral
Rolan - one time poster, feels slightly town
hedgerow - two time poster, have no read

Suspicious
EuchreJack - freaks the heck out when hedgerow votes them declaring that Hedgerow is likely mafia forming a bandwagon on townie Jack! I think they're spewing themselves as mafia currently so I guess they should keep posting for town's benefit
Webadict - pocketing everyone, also Jack gives strange reasonings for why they're town here


For now, Rolan7, where you at?

@Hedgerow:
Got anything to say besides BP mechanics?

I recommend that players should vote people unless it would put them at L-1. So keep it at three votes max on someone right now, although you could say where you vote would be if it would put someone into L-1.

@hedgerow:
Don't edit your posts!

Web didn't mention Pref in his list so maybe the scumteam is Web/Pref?

do "Faction Inspect" Toaster