Bay 12 Games Forum

So is Jack confirmed town now? Pretty sure their partner would be yelling at them in scum chat at this point.

Personally I want Web around for N1 to see what happens.

@NQT:
Why did you give a full player list of reads already?

If there end up being a lot of Paladin claims it might be worth verifying that a couple of them actually inspect town like they're supposed to. I think we've heard from everybody and only have one paladin claim, however.

Yeah I think we're good on that front. The only claimed Paladin is Webadict.

7. Currently, there is no sharing or trading of items, even among mafia teams.

It's in the rules, Jack.

The inspect scrolls are nice, but it's also important to know which players are saying they'll (normally) always come up town.

If only one Paladin claims then that's fine too since we have a lot of town with items tonight *wink wink*. I agree with Jim that this is likely a 2 scum setup so.

Toonyman: "Scroll of Shapeshift: Target inspects as an alignment of your choice tonight.  You may choose Town, Mafia, or Third Party."
Looking over the various scrolls, I came across that one.  Any good Town uses for it?  Seems a "mostly scum" scroll to me.
I mean, it could be used for a crazy unhelpful town gambit, hence my qualify it is Good Town play.

Only scum would use that scroll. A player with that item isn't necessarily scum though.

I'm pretty sure Jack isn't lying about their Class at least, and their earnestness makes me think they're town. Jack would have to be spinning lie after lie unless they're just honestly telling us everything about themselves, which doesn't strike me as very advantageous for mafia!Jack.

Unless they're actually just mafia with Web, but I don't think that's the case currently.

ToonyMan, webadict, if I did nothing and let you do the heavy lifting would I still win the game?

Maybe.

D3 players will have had two chances of questing, so it's likely there'll be one or two powerful Rares or Artefacts floating around. If this proceeds like a normal game death-wise, we'll be down to four players and it'll look like LYLO, but given player items it might not be. What am I missing?

Are you there?

Is someone picking paladin automatically suspicious?

Not really. It makes town inspects mean less though.