Bay 12 Games Forum

I don't actually remember how Thieves work so I might be wrong about that part.

I would very much like to hear everyone's possible scenarios and if there's any mechanical or behavioral contradictions.

@Vector:
You made a case before about how it would be incredibly foolish to convert Lucky, even if you were to get Blue for free. And yet you happen to have a case at the start of Day 3 that is highly incriminating towards Lucky being a convert. I also think there's a 100% chance you would convert Webadict if you were the Dark Magus.

Here's what I'm thinking:
Webadict is probably a real Thief, he was converted by Vector on N1. He knew I was probably a Wizard because he checked me probably on N1? Then he does the factional kill on NQT.
Vector is Dark Magus and is bullshitting a case on Lucky the newb for a lynch on them today. They convert Webadict on N1. They do something else on N2 since Web is performing the kill.
Blue is res'd as a SK Devil and killed Toaster. Why wouldn't Blue just fake-confirm they blocked Webadict? It would be an easy out, doesn't matter what kind of third-party they are. It makes no sense to me...

IcyTea, Caz, and Persus: I need some insight on this. Lucky is impossible to understand, Blue's claims make no sense, TricMagic is super bad, and 4mask just cares about surviving.

I'm not saying I believe this is true, but I don't want to get blindsided by how simple lynching Lucky or Blue seems.

If Blue is claiming the kill on Toaster then...

what...

Luckyowl said the Devil visited them on Night 1. The Devil is now dead. Blue couldn't have Devil killed unless they're a Devil too.

Why would Blue admit to killing Toaster.

Can somebody link the differences between known third-party kills?

Lucky, if you're town this is the most important day of your life.

You need to explain to me why you're town and who is scum.

Who is the Dark Magus?
Who is the convert?
Where is the second kill coming from?

If this is all a ploy to deceive town and cause us to mislynch you I don't think we can recover from it.

If you are playing to town's wincon you will take this seriously and answer me.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 05, 2021, 06:52:48 pm

@Webadict:
Sure go ahead. I said I wanted to wait for Blue but it doesn't really matter.

Do you often put on your cape and wizard cap?

That's right.

I'm a Wizard.

Night 1 I protected Luckyowl because I believed Web's read on them. We didn't know what the scum team would be like so I did it to deny scum from killing the priest before they could res anyone.
Night 2 I protected Webadict. I was this close to protecting NQT instead, sorry NQT...

I assumed that my targets weren't aware of the protection since Lucky didn't say anything on Day 2 about it. I actually slipped that I protected Lucky at the beginning of Day 2 but I'm not sure if anybody saw that...

If scum decide not to kill me tonight I'll try my best to outguess them and prevent anyone from dying.

Vector:
I have no strong cases against.
Very active and contributing.
My trust of Vector ---> [XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX]

Luckyowl:
I have spent most of this game finding them suspicious, have a huge case against them.
Has done nothing.
My trust of Luckyowl ---> []

---

@4maskwolf:
TricMagic doesn't read the thread dude. They just post.