Bay 12 Games Forum

Drunk can't swap cards with the middle. The Robber is the same as a Drunk except the Robber knows the role they're taking, the Drunk does not.

So yeah, I think you're a wolf NQT.

PPE:

Me: so confident I know the rules of this game, having played it loads before, I don't even bother reading the OP closely
Also Me: robber is basically a drunk that can look at his card, right?

Yep. I would say they're strictly better than a Drunk.

---

Funny observation: there's a possibility that mafia have a majority in this game.

If the Alpha Wolf, Dream Wolf, and Minion are players that's three.

If the Robber targeted one of these players they'll become wolf-aligned and know it. This does mean the player they targeted is now a villager, but they wouldn't know and would still vote as mafia.

If the Alpha Wolf turned one of the active player cards into a wolf card, like the Seer. They couldn't have done the Bodyguard because I checked Leafsnail right after the Alpha Wolf actions.

That's 4 wolf-aligned, possibly a pseudo-5 if the robber hit a wolf too. Since the original wolf will still think they're a wolf.

More things line up if NQT is telling the truth, but that doesn't mean it's right.

Secretdorf, both Lucky and NQT's claims counter your own. Who do you think is more suspicious?

Luckyowl, who did you investigate to become tanner?

Leafsnail, who do you think is lying?

FallacyofUrist, claim your role now.

I'm the Apprentice Seer and I saw  Alpha Wolf in the centre.

notquitethere - Apprentice Seer -> Troublemaker is in the middle.

So which is it? I think Secret is telling the truth and you're the Alpha Wolf fake-claiming.

Alpha Wolf has to swap a card with the wolf card they add. If they're a player this is the first thing that happens.

Quote from: ToonyMan on February 04, 2021, 09:23:58 am

Lastly can the Paranormal Investigator claim if they are a player? It's somewhat likely they are a wolf or tanner at this point and won't say anything though...

Yeah, I'm the PI...well was.. Now I'm tanner. Whatever that is.

...Who did you investigate?

And... if someone IS tanner, can't we lynch them to win?

Only the tanner wins if they are lynched. Everyone else loses.

I don't think the Troublemaker is a player so just claim the role you saw my young apprentice.

It's possible the Alpha Wolf started as a middle role which means they wouldn't swap a player with the added wolf card. When I'm saying "exist" what I really mean is "started the game on a player".

Can the Apprentice Seer claim if they are a player? Knowing one of the middle roles would help.