Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 300 301 [302] 303 304 ... 1978
4516
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 07, 2021, 09:12:38 pm »
@Webadict:
Should we vengekill whoever hammers us?
[...]
Hammers him right now? If 4mask flips town then more than likely, yes. I think the pressure from L-1 should reveal some interesting factoids about our players here. I don't think putting someone at L-1 is town or scum.
What would you say if I told you that I initially was going to unvote 4maskwolf but deleted that before I posted because I figured that anyone that hammers 4maskwolf would be incredibly suspicious? I had a similar thought, which is why I figured that anyone that hammers without sufficient evidence is bound to be vengekilled. Thus, it feels possible that putting someone at L-1 might be more suspicious, on account of it being safer, no?
How do we lynch scum then? Why would you immediately think of unvoting 4mask? Did you change your mind because I voted them?
Screw it I think you're scum. Die.



@4maskwolf:
@4maskwolf:
Why shouldn't we hammer you?
Because your buddy would get vig'd and you'd get lynched.  Or the other way around, I'm not picky who I kill as long as its scum.
Toonyman: Mind telling us who the "we" you want to hammer me with is?
You tell me. I'll have more to add once everyone posts.
Once the dingbats get here, I will too. In the meantime, you've played with me enough, why did you think flinch-checking me was a good idea?
Sure. If we lynch the flagbearer first then we'll just win. The flagbearer is going to be protected by their mafioso buddy, hence anybody who defends somebody I think is incredibly suspicious.



@NQT:
Toony
The game is pure day game, my posts are all there are to figuring me out. Is hammering inherently scummy in this set up?
No, I don't think hammering is inherently scummy. It depends on how the hammer happens.



@Luckyowl:
Hector: is the flagbearer unsure who is the mafia?
...Did Webadict tell you to say that?

4517
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 07, 2021, 09:05:45 pm »
Webadict

Scum team is Luckyowl and Webadict.

4518
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 07, 2021, 05:54:08 pm »
@4maskwolf:
@Luckyowl:
Did you get your wish?
Why don't you ask him in scumchat?
I'm sorry, but I was asking Luckyowl not his scum buddy.

@4maskwolf:
Why shouldn't we hammer you?
Because your buddy would get vig'd and you'd get lynched.  Or the other way around, I'm not picky who I kill as long as its scum.
Toonyman: Mind telling us who the "we" you want to hammer me with is?
You tell me. I'll have more to add once everyone posts.



@Webadict:
@Webadict:
What's the biggest scumtell in this game?
No idea. I don't usually play Vengeful. My guess would be going hard on Luckyowl with insufficient reasoning because they're a newbie. Also, hammering is potentially scummy if not defended well.
Should we vengekill whoever hammers us?

@ToonyMan: Would you think that anyone that hammers 4maskwolf is scum? Is putting someone at L-1 scary to you? Does that make you more or less scummy?
Hammers him right now? If 4mask flips town then more than likely, yes. I think the pressure from L-1 should reveal some interesting factoids about our players here. I don't think putting someone at L-1 is town or scum.

4519
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 07, 2021, 03:38:19 pm »
I'm not singing.

@NQT:
Why should I read your posts?

@Webadict:
What's the biggest scumtell in this game?

@Luckyowl:
Did you get your wish?

@4maskwolf:
Why shouldn't we hammer you?

4520
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 06, 2021, 11:06:17 pm »
I think the rules saying a player is lynched at 2 votes on Day 2 is kinda weird, but... you know what? I kinda like it.
If there's a Day 2 there will either be three townies and a mafia or two townies and a mafia, depending on what happened Day 1.

So that weird rule would only matter for the four players on Day 2 case, but I think that's okay as long as everybody is reminded when the day starts.

4521
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 06, 2021, 10:55:27 pm »
You should allow a Day 3 if there's no vengekills after Day 1, I would say. There's no case where it could last longer than Day 3.

Worst case scenario:

Day 1 mafioso lynch
Day 2 townie lynch, no vengekill
Day 3, two townies and a mafia flagbearer left, game will be decided after the lynch.

EDIT:
Most likely scenarios:

Day 1 townie lynch, vengekills another townie, mafia win

Day 1 mafia flagbearer lynch, town win

Day 1 mafioso lynch
Day 2 mafia flagbearer lynch, town win

Day 1 townie lynch, vengekills either mafia
Day 2, two townies and a mafia, game will be decided by the lynch

So chances are it won't last to Day 3, however I think it's good to keep that a possibility.



Hopefully I get mafia.
You and me both.

4522
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 06, 2021, 04:28:41 pm »
Do townie have to vengekill? There's one case where it's possibly not worth doing:

Lynch mafiaoso Day 1
Lynch townie Day 2

At this point the townie probably shouldn't vengekill because there's two town and one mafia left. Hitting a townie would cause a loss.

4523
Mafia / Re: Vengeful Mafia 12.5 - WHERE ARE THE COOKIES!?
« on: January 06, 2021, 04:13:03 pm »
In.

4524
Mafia / Re: Games Threshold Discussion and List [Vote for games now!]
« on: January 06, 2021, 12:16:10 am »
I wouldn't mind playing in a mostly vanilla open or semi-open setup.

4525
Mafia / Re: Games Threshold Discussion and List [Vote for games now!]
« on: January 05, 2021, 09:08:58 pm »
I could probably run some silly 5-man I pulled off of mafiascum or something.

The most intensely cursed 5-man I've ever seen.
This sounds amazing.

4526
Mafia / Re: BYOR 15: Day 2 - Fixed The Glitch
« on: December 31, 2020, 06:24:18 pm »
Yes, that is the only problem with the vote count.

Also, bah.

4527
Other Games / Re: XMAS 2020 GIVEAWAY
« on: December 31, 2020, 04:01:52 pm »
I totally would have donated Iconoclasts if I got into this sooner. It's a game more people need to play.
Agreed, had a lot of fun with Iconoclasts.

4528
Caz why did you point that out. *face palms*

Some people just have really small Grinch hearts.

EDIT:
This isn't towards you Caz, fyi.

4529
Sure, but playing mafia isn't illegal where I live and I would get banned from the forums saying certain things.

4530
We could create some sort of civility clause. Ban cursing, the use of certain words like idiot, insults to intelligence etc.

I don’t take any of it personally anymore, I think it’s just part of the game, but very new players can find it very bothersome.
While I understand wanting to cater to people's sensitive skin, I think censoring people's behavior is just detrimental to mafia.

Certain words shouldn't be allowed obviously.

If somebody is going to replace out because they can't handle the pressure or anxiety then I'm not sure what you could change without mafia not being mafia anymore.

Pages: 1 ... 300 301 [302] 303 304 ... 1978