4621
Mafia / Re: Banter Thread: Has this really been a thing for four years edition
« on: December 18, 2020, 02:57:46 pm »
Something I forgot to mention because I haven't read YTTD in awhile, but votes are anonymous. This means that on Day 1 more than likely two or more people will be tied with two votes. Players selected to be voted in the second vote phase also aren't allowed to vote, it's the remaining players that do it I believe. And yeah I don't see any reason for the Sacrifice not to vote themselves. The events that go down in the actual story I think are really neat and I wouldn't want to spoil that, and there's stuff that happens between the main games of course so I'd probably want to add more ways to make it interesting.
Possible Variant Ideas to make it more interesting for real players:
1. Add in a mafia team that aren't assigned roles? Or maybe they can too? Not sure how that would work since every other player is basically a survivor or jester.
2. Add in a night phase that allows players to screw with each other, for example, maybe have a thief or trickster that can steal roles and/or swap them with other players? The players targeted wouldn't know where their role ended up, or who had the role they were given. This would also allow other players to lie about what they did at night.
Possible Variant Ideas to make it more interesting for real players:
1. Add in a mafia team that aren't assigned roles? Or maybe they can too? Not sure how that would work since every other player is basically a survivor or jester.
2. Add in a night phase that allows players to screw with each other, for example, maybe have a thief or trickster that can steal roles and/or swap them with other players? The players targeted wouldn't know where their role ended up, or who had the role they were given. This would also allow other players to lie about what they did at night.