Bay 12 Games Forum

@Toony:  Cult can't be me, Tric, and Egan because we control half the votes, and we probably win.  Also... That means that you accept that NJW and EuchreJack are definitely Town, which, like, sure.

It's a good point, but not necessarily. Both NJW and Jack have guns that could possibly kill one of you, and what if Max comes back tomorrow?

Outing yourself by quickhammering or something isn't a guaranteed win only a likely win.

It's impossible for Cult to be Egan AND Tric, either, since they were almost entirely likely to be Town Day 3, unless you think both were recruited last Night.  I don't see that as being possible.

It's not impossible just not likely from my perspective and intuition.

Also, you could still be the Cult Leader.  It's not entirely unlikely, either, but it involves a bit of thinking.

You could've attempted to recruit either Jim or I on Night 1, tried to recruit Max Night 2 (and got NJW and EJ), and then maybe you tried to recruit Max on Night 3 again.  That's all completely believable, no?

It's very unlikely.

The main issue is that who is the other cultist? As we are, we know you're one.

Wrong.

NQT/Jim team is dead. Which means you're likely part of the last and don't actually have the numbers or recruitment to deal with this, given I'd spend Night 4 investigating Jack/NJW.

This game will be over for one side or the other by the beginning of tomorrow. Inspects don't matter, let alone double inspects or triple inspects.

How many Pink Lucky Numbers do you have?

It's gone up to 6 at this point. It went up to 5 yesterday.

I might as well share everything at this point.

I've had 8 Red and it hasn't changed.
I had 3 Green but it dropped to 0 last night.
I've had 2 Purple and it hasn't changed.

You can probably figure it out Web. I believe in you.

I'll even give you a hint: I've been right this whole game.

Also, I know NJW is scum because he didn't immediately claim an Inspect target.

That's because he's...poor at mafia.

Why would a recruited player lie?

Did anyone receive a gun today? Anyone?

I literally can't do anything but make guns. I can't make guns without the forge.

One In The Chamber let's me reuse a gun I have but I have no guns because I haven't made a single gun for myself. I could use this without the forge.

Magnum Opus makes a megadeath gun but I need the forge which was disabled unless you believe Jack is also lying.

Well, what if I wished you were Town?

Would you want that?

Web I've spent the whole game wishing I was Cult.

I think the Fairly Odd Parents would say that's against Da Rulez.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 21, 2023, 09:43:58 am

I'm guessing one possibility is that NJW or Jack (or Toaster?) converted Tric last night. With Max out of the game that's 3 Cult vs 4 Town I think. So they just need to kill one of us.

I still think Egan is town here.

It's also possible Tric is still town, but then a Max-style bus or some Jack-copying shenanigans is going on.

I actually DON'T think that NJW or Jack (or Toaster) converted Tric last Night.

Right, since Tric has a Hotdog.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 21, 2023, 12:35:48 am

And this is why you don't vote every player on D1.

I couldn't give any guns out last night because of somebody.

Who killed NQT?

Lol.  Was it me?  Because I did not intentionally target you if that's the case.

In fact, I'd hasten a guess that multiple people did not target the person they were aiming for.

My Metaforge was disabled last night so I couldn't do anything. Jack claimed that. It was like black slime not unlike NQT. NQT also had my One In The Chamber ability. I feel like NQT and Jack keep sharing things in common and it's bizarre. Like how my Red Rifle never got to Max and instead NJW/Jack/Tric all got copies of it.

Max, you did not call yourself a Commuter. I completely failed to target you with my inspect.

On the other side of things, would the real ToonyMan stand up. You are accused of crimes against felines. Why are you Cult?

I don't know. Why am I Cult?

Just because you think only Web visited you doesn't mean a plethora of things couldn't have happened.

It looks like Jack and NJW are claiming the NQT kill. NJW is also saying that NQT visited nobody. Tric is saying they also tried to kill NQT, but they were already dead. It doesn't look like NJW was using their gun, unlike Jack and Tric.

Why was Jack allowed to shoot NQT but not Tric?