Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 321 322 [323] 324 325 ... 1978
4831
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Day 1: How To Land A Plane
« on: June 18, 2015, 10:58:00 am »
Unvote Cheeetar

Everyone else If you had to daykill someone right now, who would you kill?
Right at game start? You or NQT. Eager beaver posters can't be up to any good
Ooh, interesting.
What do you think of non-posters and lurkers? Better or worse than an Eager Beaver?
What I think? Not posting is worse than anything else, but you can't tell that immediately.



So Lenglon has a post restriction? Interesting.
How do you know that?
It's just a guess based on the fact that people usually don't post like that.
Is that so? Understood.



My thoughts? Lynching Shakerag is probably in our best interests, but he could be screwing the scum just as much, and there's not direct reasoning against his play.

My doubts? IronyOwl being "confirmed town" is weird, I have to agree with TheDarkStar here.

My suspicions? Origami is being dumb, but Blackmagechill deserves the noose.

My reasoning? Wish-wash vote patterns, voting Cheeetar after he brought up a fair point, and then pushing an attack on Shakerag...for...some...reason.

4832
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Day 1: How To Land A Plane
« on: June 17, 2015, 02:18:46 pm »
So Lenglon has a post restriction? Interesting.
How do you know that?

ToonyMan: Why are you a terrorist?
Woah woah woah, whoa, whoa whoa? Just because I record myself being scared in video games does not make a terrorist make.



ToonyMan
Also, really? Your role already seems terrible, if it's the truth.
Dude.  You haven't seen my role yet.  On that note, would you describe your own role as "terrible"?
I wonder? I say no.

Furthermore, what do you think of me putting a third vote on you so early in the game?
Meh? I've had worse, probably.

No Lynch:  Who are you and where did you come from?
Another player?? The secrets, the hidden, the mysteries.



Toonyman: Who would you roleblock tonight if you had a role similar to a paranormal style vengeful guard?
Shakerag? Maybe Cheeetar if he's alive.



Toonyman: Was
Quote
[who would I daykill] Right at game start? You or NQT. Eager beaver posters can't be up to any good.
part of your joking attitude this game or a serious statement that you'd daykill someone for being active at the start of the game?
You don't know? From my experiences, a lot of scum get first day posts in, because they're either coordinating with others or to lead the crowd.

A fair counterpoint? Early on in games, especially Day 1, there could also just be players generally excited about the game.

My conclusion? Not the most convincing argument until later in the game.

4833
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Day 1: How To Land A Plane
« on: June 17, 2015, 07:21:38 am »
Rather than speaking up, I walk over to each person in turn and hand them a simple pre-typed sheet of paper.
Quote from: Me to Everyone
Inspect with %chance kill. use?
I wonder? I would say yes.

Also, really? Your role already seems terrible, if it's the truth.

4834
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Day 1: How To Land A Plane
« on: June 17, 2015, 07:19:33 am »
blackmagechilli, how do you intend to find the terrorists?
Who are we trying to fool here? That's not his name!

Everyone else If you had to daykill someone right now, who would you kill?
Right at game start? You or NQT. Eager beaver posters can't be up to any good.

I watch Cheetar's face for an extra couple seconds before looking down at the dirt we're standing on and drawing two letters in it.
Quote from: Me to Cheetar
S
K
Are you serious?! Cheeetar started the fire!

4835
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Now In Sign-ups! [15 / 13+]
« on: June 09, 2015, 06:58:02 pm »
Every BYOR is made better by a Shakerag role.

4836
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Now In Sign-ups! [13 / 13+]
« on: June 07, 2015, 11:03:08 am »
BYOR 14 isn't starting until after Supernatural 8, that probably won't be too soon.

4837
Mafia / Re: BYOR 14 - Now In Sign-ups! [4 / 13+]
« on: June 05, 2015, 10:28:26 pm »
It'd be a sin to miss this.
Joining could only be ultimate bliss.

4838
Mafia / Re: Games Threshold Discussion and List
« on: June 03, 2015, 11:08:25 pm »
Danganronpa mafia will not be starting until November.
... Is this a perpetual joke or will it actually start in November?
Upupupu

4839
Mafia / Re: Games Threshold Discussion and List
« on: June 02, 2015, 03:44:02 pm »
Might as well put BYOR 14 into the Queue. Good to go whenever anyone wants. I have just enough time this summer to run a game.
Hell..

yes

4840
Mafia / Re: Supernatural 8 - Day 1 - Dark Night heralds a Bloody Dawn
« on: June 02, 2015, 03:38:47 pm »
Wait a second....
The opening post mentioned Rot. Doesnt rod spread? Wouldnt that imply that this actually is a cult?
Possibly.

And if it is a cult, that would make cheesecake much more suspicious, wouldnt it? Because if he had picked up on that, why didnt he tell us? And if he hadnt, then he got it from his role PM. Or, he could just have been reading the Cult game like he said...
Still, assuming that I'm right about the rot part, that's two-thirds chance that Cheesecake is scum. Thoughts on this theory?
What.



Also, about the rot part, if Cheese had gotten a role PM saying he was part of a cult, it would have said he was a Vampire, not a Cultist.
Why is that again?



Do 12ers play to a couple of competing wagons each day?
spruce: That would be nice, but what tends to happen is we end up with one main wagon and we end up with a bunch of scattered votes on other players from people who dislike the main wagon, all yelling their own things and none really trying to convince others.  Not enough effort to convince people of cases, not enough commentary on (or attention to) cases other than one's own aside from searching for scumtells.  I've griped about this before, and would love more acceptance of critical acceptance of cases.
Yeah, Teneb, you big meanie. Answer the guy with the terrifying avatar.
Key word being critical.  Less leaning on me, more fleshed-out thoughts about Teneb's actions and/or my attacks.
Also, this whole bit interests me. I was eating soup and an idea occurred to me. Would you be willing to continuously critically examine my works and I yours? Not as a gentleman's agreement, as in we don't vote for each other, but as a way of keeping each other's shit straight on a more constant scale and following each of our own respective leads.
Would you be interested?
Except, you would be creating a large association between yourself and Jack AT. You don't need to create an arbitrarily connection with somebody to be critical against. Just be critical of everybody. You'll end up, in part, with what you wanted here anyway.



Origami
Been busy, just popping in for a bit. From what I read, I don't think that Cheesekake is guilty, but that is mainly a gut feeling. I am getting the
Did you die writing this, mid-post? What are you doing?

Sorry about that. My brother thought it would be funny if he pressed alt+s as he called me to dinner. Anyways, I was saying that since spruce came from a different community, I don't think he should be lynched JUST because of his... odd... behavior. I think cheesekake is just making newbie mistakes rather than scumslips. The person that rubs me the wrong way is Birdie, mainly on his highly reactive behavior. Can someone tell me if this is normal for him?
Okay. Bird is acting kind of silly.

4841
Unvote Deus.

Birdy51
Roo: I've been doing a review, and I've noticed that you didn't actually reply to my RVS question. Take a minute and answer it.
You mean you didn't notice that right away? How serious are we being here?

Everyone: Thoughts on the Cheesecake affair (votes, actions, etc)?
It's suspicious. But, I find myself hesitant to push for a lynch on Cheesecake as it might just have been an innocent mistake. At the same time, his slip could have very well been a scumtell or that or he's a third party with references to Conversions in his abilities (ala, the Guardian Angel of one of the past games). If it comes down to it though... He wouldn't make a bad choice.
Are you trying to sway my vote?!

Lastly:
The Scribe's Tally Sheet
Cheesecake: Persus13, roo
Deus Asmoth: ToonyMan
EPenguin: birdy51
spruce: birdy51, Deus Asmoth, Teneb
Hiding your double vote powers??



This is getting nowhere fast.  Let's generate some information about the only major non-RVS and non-advice thing we've had so far.
Everyone: Thoughts on the Cheesecake affair (votes, actions, etc)?
It's a bandwagon train. I don't mind lynching the newbie, but I don't think it's the best idea Day 1.



Teneb: I don't remember playing with you before. What is the primary aspect of your playstyle that sets you apart?
I kept that quote in my sig so people could tell that I am Deathsword. Guess I should've made it more obvious.
Note to self: Teneb was Deathsword.



Teneb: Well, you get information your way and I'll get information my way. I just played 2 games at 2+ where they pretty much had the same response, but I Identified Scum quicker than anyone else and Town easily won both games. Yes, it is a slow game – slower even than I expected – the GM designed it that way, but you, birdy, and ToonyMan seem kind of eager to kill folk, if you ask me. Many of you know each other a lot better than I. Several of you are far more familiar with the site, the format, and previous games, so forgive me if I don't yet measure up to your standards of what is scum-hunting or content. I beg to differ. If you really thought that, you'd do do well to see that my claims are true. Looks to me like you're just struggling to make empty cases.
What do we do then?

4842
General Discussion / Re: I like anime, do you like anime?
« on: May 31, 2015, 10:47:30 am »
Aw yeah Terra Formars.

4843
Everyone: At what point in the game do you think that you personally are most likely going to be lynched or killed?
I was killed Night 1 in the last game I was in, so.

Tooney, I suppose given the number of players I'd guess at three scum and one or two third parties. How does this help you?
Not now, but we can look back and see if anything "relates" to what's been said.



I have a birthday party today so I won't be super available.

4844
...Please vote to kill.... Deus Asmoth...
Wait, what? Is this a vote to kill then?
Yes.

Tooney, I don't think it was mentioned. Did you mean that you want me to guess how many there are?
Yeah, go ahead.

4845
EPenguin: Jail him into oblivion in case he's a demon!
Oh right, I wasn't in Supernatural 4 (the best one) so I can't give any advice about that case.

Pages: 1 ... 321 322 [323] 324 325 ... 1978