Bay 12 Games Forum

Jack got Jim's old gun when he swapped roles.

That would explain why it wasn't in the role flip.

I'm at work, so dunno how much I can post.
I got Toony's gun.

Why? I didn't give you a gun.

NJW, Web, and Max should have guns.

Jim had a gun but he is dead.

Tric says he has a gun, but I was told I wasn't able to give him it.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 17, 2023, 07:44:48 am

@Tric:
Yes I tried to give you a gun.

Egan and Tric are town.

NQT and Jack are scum. I think we need to kill whoever Jim swapped with first though.

I believe Jim swapped with Jack.

That is the same conclusion I came to last night.

It doesn't make sense to me for Jim to swap with NQT. He'd want the player who was townread by most players on D1. NQT got a lot of heat on D1.

We could kill Webadict. And in order for Jim to swap with Jack, I would need to be redirected to Jack. Jack would also have to avoid talking about the protection role.

Jack didn't talk much at all about their role on D2.

Also, if NQT gooed me N1 like he claims then he can't be the Firefly.

I gave items to Web, Max, and Tric last night.

I failed to give Tric an item for some reason.

Also I have been even further Disabled by black slime so now I can barely do anything. Thanks NQT.

---

Who did Jim swap with?

It's a player that had this Firefly role until now.

Egan - no, doesn't match what they claimed N1
NJW - no, doesn't match what they claimed N1

webadict - most likely not, doesn't match their Hotdog claim and nobody else would be the Hotdog Vendor

Max - probably not, they're probably the devil deal person and the firefly role doesn't match
Tric - probably not, they learned about the Lifetime tag on N1 so it doesn't seem like they had the role
NQT - probably not, doesn't match what little they've claimed, but more important I don't think Jim targets NQT

Jack - could be
Toaster - could be

I think Jim targeted either Jack or Toaster or maybe NQT.

I feel like it would be Jack personally.

It's also not whoever grey goo'd me, because it's not in this role.

If Toaster isn't lying about not gooing me, then NQT is probably the one that goo'd me N1. (And now black slime'd me N2)

It really doesn't look like Tric meant any harm since they're asking a question that wouldn't be answered after "hammering".

I blame NQT for being scum. If they're town it's absolutely baffling at this point.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 15, 2023, 12:47:54 pm

It's possible.

This assumption is difficult to make with nothing to go on.

In addition, this implies NQT is a townie and Egan is not.

That seems likely to me.

I don't really think Egan is a cult leader.

Unlike Jack/Tric/NQT/Toaster, Egan has been very open about what they did or tried to do last night.

Did Egan suggest they had a Pink number greater than zero?

Egan said their Green number went up last night which implies their Green number was greater than their Pink.

They said their Green number is higher than some numbers but lower than others.

Anyway, everyone who wants to convince me you're town, buy a hot dog with pink.

No.

Today seems to just be ten pages of mostly number speculation. When you could just be looking for cult leaders. Not much worth responding to here, so I'm just going to reread D1 when I get a chance. Still have work to finish.

I think Jim is probably a Cult Leader, sadly.

I don't think you're Cult, NJW.

I don't think Egan is Cult.

I don't really think Tric is Cult like Jim feels. They openly bought dogs from Web and I think I agree with Web's read on them. It would be odd unless they were with Web but I don't think that's likely.

Web is maybe okay. I tried grilling him at the end of D1 and he seemed defeated and willing to die. Not a guarantee of anything.

Max is possible. I don't think it's likely mainly due to the boon thing on D1, but it's still possible.

NQT is possible. I still think he's Cult. I guess he wasn't really blocked by Web on N1. If he's Cult then the gold glow is likely his own doing. It's at least by scum since nobody is claiming it. On that note: The grey goo that hit me is most likely from scum too, since nobody has claimed it. Toaster said he didn't do it.

Jack is possible. He's been really quiet and I hate this Knightwing vote. I kind of want Jack if NQT is innocent.

Toaster I'm not sure. I would say null. I suspect them more than my town reads but don't think they're worth voting over others.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 14, 2023, 11:06:48 pm

Hate me for thunderdoming NQT and Web.

Eh, I would've stuck to it if Knightwing had said anything helpful.  I even warned him I wanted to shift to him!  I also had a Roleblock, so it wasn't particularly dangerous for me.

Egan, if you plan on blocking me or NQT, let me know, because I am going to Roleblock NQT.

You said earlier you wouldn't be able to block NQT tonight?

@Jim:
Thanks for the insight.

@Jack:

Hm, my picks for Cultist other than Jim are:
NQT, although somebody apparently believes in his innocence. Or he Golden'd himself
ToonyMan - Begging the cults to recruit him is EXACTLY what he would do as a Cult Leader
Max as a distant third for misreading Knightwing

Yes I would!! Hahaha! And I would convert Jim under the guise of giving him an item, which I would explain him to do in Cult Chat. In addition, it would explain NJW's result. It would also be a lie.

It does bother me that Max voted KW over NQT, but I believe he has been wrong as town at least once before.

@Toaster:
Then hate me!

Hate me for thunderdoming NQT and Web.

Hate me for tying the votes so you had to kill Knightwing.

Hate me for mildly suspecting you.

Hate me for being me.