Bay 12 Games Forum

@Tiruin (I know I shouldn't do this but I couldn't resist):
"I damned well won't give up!"
*votes self*

@Tiruin:
How do you know you didn't kill Persus?

@Scientist:
You might not have done anything N1 because you were doing the mafia kill.

Oh and I believe Makeinu's claim of vanilla townie, because otherwise he bussed ultra hard on TDS yesterday.

Tiruin already claimed serial killer so I don't see why the day has to go on any longer.

Also it's not exactly lylo, if Tiruin is somehow town then if I can shoot scum tonight we'll be okay, but I'll probably be killed tonight too.  Anybody have any ideas who I should shoot?  Scientist is probably telling the truth about being a jail keeper so he's clean.  I don't think Makeinu is scum either so that leaves

Elephant Parade
Superblackcat
NativeForeigner

If Tiruin is SK then two of these three players are scum.

I'm thinking Elephant Parade is one of them.  I'll shoot him tonight (unless Tiruin flips mafia then the SK likely does not exist and I will not be shooting).

You can have more than one vigilante.  If you flip town (and vig), then that's exactly what happened.  I just don't believe that to be true right now.

I don't really feel like answering your questions because I have a severe lack of time to waste (school started) and you're probably mafia.  If you have any questions you want to ask me you can repeat them and if they're not too annoying to answer I'll do so, but there's no way in hell I'm going to read the last few pages word for word and digest every little detail, because really, the major points are what matter and if you really are scum (which I think is very likely) then this whole discussion of details is pointless.  If you somehow are another town vigilante, then great, I'll shoot Scientist tonight.

If somebody can claim a redirect on Scientist that would be useful, but if it was scum that did that they probably won't!

I could shoot Scientist if Tiruin is town since that would mean Scientist is probably making stuff up.

The roles we know exist:

Hider
Townie
Townie
Townie
Vengeful
Mafia Goon

There are also seven hidden roles.  I will keep my role hidden for now.

What we can deduce from this (using this page):

We rolled at least one H and one K.  Because the only mafia that flipped is a goon this gives us no information on the number of Ts.

This means out of the seven letters rolled, one is an H and one is a K.  We could list the possibilities of what scum team we're up against, but the the ones with six Ts and seven Ts are now impossible.

This means that a two mafia scum team (six Ts) is impossible.  Which means there has to be at least two scum left and maybe an SK (which I doubt).

So, if we lynch wrong today it's most likely going to be lylo.  I highly doubt there's an SK.  That means there's two scum left.

At day end I did not think Makeinu or Hapah were scum at all.  I still don't think Makeinu is mafia, definitely.

My picks for last two scum are Tiruin and +!!scientist!!+.  What say you?