Bay 12 Games Forum

Pfp

Okay, I can see there might be more risk (hell knightwing's role showed us there are horrible things outside of the cults)— there might be four cults each with different conversion rules, each playing off the different numbers — town might not even outnumber the cults all added up.

Four cults

FOUR CULTS

AND I'M STILL TOWN

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 14, 2023, 02:17:17 pm

Knightwing's other win condition caught me by surprise. My only wincon is the Town wincon.

Are you entirely sure of this, insofar as your wincon looks exactly like the first part of Knightwing's, and doesn't even have the words 'OR' or 'AND' in it?

Yes.

I just have the Town wincon. There's no OR or AND or anything else.

On a second look...Fallacy does mention KYOSN as an inspiration for my role. I didn't know what he meant by that, but I looked into it and I think they're talking about this 2014 game I wasn't in where everyone was Shakerag. Or at least, it appears to be based around a Shakerag role if I had to guess.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 14, 2023, 01:17:24 pm

Max is Max. He's probably town since I don't think he boon'd himself. I think that's pretty good logic.

I don't get this thinking when there are 2+ rival scum teams. I think that's pretty bad logic.

I'm assuming Jim is guilty. It's possible that a third cult leader boon'd Max and was also correct in Max being scum.

I don't think it's very likely.

I dunno, maybe I'm overthinking it and the right play is just to do the simple thing and hit Jim now, but I'm just very very wary of repeating the mistake I made in the last game. Toony, Max, you were at the heart of this dilemma in the last game. What do you reckon?

From (recent) personal experience Jim is probably guilty and it's better not to have him alive for another night.

I think my second pick is you or Web.

I guess Toaster is my a third pick. With a dash of Jack.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 14, 2023, 01:04:56 pm

...You're the one that did the boon on yourself yesterday aren't you?

No. I don't know what that was.

I believe you.

I wonder who grey goo'd me. Probably Toaster. Toaster is probably town?

Who else is suspect? I think Jim is probably caught, but there's still a lot of day to burn.

NJW is town.

Are NQT and Web both scum? It looks unlikely.

Tric and Jack make me mad. Egan feels the best out of those three.

Max is Max. He's probably town since I don't think he boon'd himself. I think that's pretty good logic.

N1 Report

NQT - glows gold (doesn't know why), has two votes, have they claimed being blocked?
Tric - claims bupkis
Jim - tried to inspect Web which would have also learned their wincon but it fails, receives item from Toony
Toony - gets an offer to give up one of their abilities, gives item to Jim, gives item to NJW, fails to give item to Webadict, gets grey goo'd
Jack - claims nothing
Egan - gets offer to give up one of their abilities, prevented anyone from targeting Webadict
Webadict - gave a deluxe hotdog to NQT which blocked him, but now NQT is probably unblockable tomorrow but Web says they can track NQT, claims they did three actions
NJW - inspected Jim result was Cult, hasn't confirmed item from Toony
Toaster - claims nadda
Max - claims they did three actions, otherwise nothing


PPE:

My green number went up by 2, and my ability cost 2 AP. It might be a counter for our positive Town abilities. Who had another number go up again?

Okay..."Jack - Has an ability that cost 2AP". Great.

Quote from: ToonyMan on May 14, 2023, 12:44:42 pm

Like I said: I don't have anything worth offering. Anything I could offer wouldn't do anything for other players.

Try to think at least half a step ahead. This is your opportunity to demonstrate that this claim is true, at least.

I don't really see why I have to do that when you already think I'm town.

...You're the one that did the boon on yourself yesterday aren't you?

It would be odd for Jim to try to convert Webadict who would have actually died D1 if he got one more vote. I wouldn't put it past his Jimmy Neutron brain though.

NJW inspecting Jim instead of Web was clever and makes sense to me from his perspective. I don't think he's lying. So either NJW is being messed with, or Jim is lying.

I don't think Cult!Jim tries to convert me or Tric because he'd be scared we wouldn't be town. Cult!Jim probably converts Knightwing last night...oh wait he died.

Also, one of my numbers went up but the rest stayed the same. It was the green one which is... probably good?

If Green is town then I actually find this really odd.

Since it was my lowest number that went up which would definitely not be Green.

I know I said we should be a bit hush hush but if Green was already your lowest number...is this true? It's probably important to identify this.