Bay 12 Games Forum

WoTs freakin' everywhere.  Unvote Tiruin.

@Tiruin:

On that note, by the fact that you aren't--or not currently--addressing my other points mean that either you are evading the case, or all I say is true about you. Am I correct to infer such?

I didn't have anything to say to anything else.  I'm not really denying or accepting, but I can't take your word that Caz is a liar just because you say he is.

Explain concisely, why is Caz a liar (well either way, your vote on Caz is bogus)?  I was mainly voting you because your vote in response to his question looked jumpy and now you seem to going down Caz's throat for uh, making a case on you?

---

@Imp:

Toonyman:

Quote from: ToonyMan on November 05, 2013, 01:15:45 pm

@NQT:

Quote from: notquitethere on November 05, 2013, 10:15:59 am

If a town monster hunter has an investigate and a kill ability, should they investigate their targets before killing them?
Should a priest use their resurrect power?

I would probably investigate first.  I haven't had a vig role in awhile though.

Does it matter to you what sort of investigate power you have?  Reminded that you had a hunter in S1, who could detect vampires in a vampire-free game (there were two priests, but both were defined as pious, so no chance of them creating a vampire), do you think you'd probably still use your inspect, whatever that inspect was?

I was given a really bad hand in S1.  There wasn't any way for me to know my inspect was useless.  I still would at least try using my inspect, since shooting blindly on N1 sounds like a good way to screw the town in the long run.

---

@Toaster:

Toony:

Quote from: ToonyMan on November 05, 2013, 01:15:45 pm

I'm worried about Toaster though

Are you a lyncher to me or something?  You keep pointing a finger at me without backing it up with any solid facts or reasoning.  See also:

Quote from: ToonyMan on October 31, 2013, 03:09:14 pm

I had the thought of there being a Toaster/Jim scum team and that was very scary to ponder.

No, why do you care?

---

@Cmega3:
Did you die?

---

@Max White:

Quote from: Jim Groovester on November 06, 2013, 11:10:20 pm

Blah blah reasons blah blah text wall

That... Is actually a good point.
NQT was attacking somebody who seems to be the most likely suspect for as monster hunter for their night action preferences, rather than being scummy.

You seem to be twisting NQT's argument here (he unvoted Jim too remember) while sticking with your target from last time (a safer vote) while riding on Jim's steam.

PFP

@Tiruin:

..And I believe you're deriving your case from Caz because he was the first who mentioned my switchiness. Is that true, Toony? Or are you just being lazy?

It was Toaster actually, here.  Second quote below your name.

You are calling Caz defensive, and while his actions at day start were odd, you weren't even here...and now...you don't think you're acting defensive?

---

Nerjin

Quote from: Nerjin on November 05, 2013, 08:59:50 pm

I will be honest. I was kinda upset that I was revived. I'm having much more fun in the other thread because I haven't let it get away from me. I let this one do that, and when killed I was thinking "Awesome! Now I can just enjoy the fire-works and not have to pay too much attention." But now I do...

Oh Nerjin, I hope you are still town.

You can never tell!  It's scary!

Also Cmega, you lied about giving a post yesterday!

@Imp:

Quote from: Caz on November 04, 2013, 02:36:47 pm

Well, we're back to Day 1 again. Did anyone learn anything useful?

Is there more 'wrongness' than rolefishing in what Caz has said?

Saying we're back to Day 1 again is wrong.  In general I would say that was a pretty iffy thing to start the next day with.

---

@NQT:

If a town monster hunter has an investigate and a kill ability, should they investigate their targets before killing them?
Should a priest use their resurrect power?

I would probably investigate first.  I haven't had a vig role in awhile though.

I wouldn't have resurrected Nerjin.  I guess that's a gamble, but eeeeh

---

Jim being a monster hunter seems really likely at this point, and I'm pretty sure that is an exclusively town role (as he said), so there's pretty damn convincing evidence he's not scum.

I'm worried about Toaster though, now he's leading a lynch on Caz with Tiruin who doesn't have time to answer me.

Also Cmega3 I await your post today.

---

As for Persus13?  Well, scum Toaster & Tiruin probably wouldn't lead a lynch on Caz if he was their partner, so the votes on Persus13 are likely genuine.  You can have scum Knights too, so it's certainly not out of the question.

Extend

Post-edit:
Oh hello there Toaster.

I had the thought of there being a Toaster/Jim scum team and that was very scary to ponder.

@Toaster/Jim:

Why I, and everyone, should be voting Nerjin:

Nerjin.

You two seem to be getting along well (joshing one another with silly ribs), what do you think of the other, exactly?  Would you be surprised if the other flipped town or scum?

I have reasons but they're mostly reiteration of other people's points. Passive, defensive, reactionary, unwilling to take a stand, vote Cmega3 just to break the tie in his favor, etc.

Voting to break yourself out of a tie I don't think really means anything.  Since town will want to live just as well especially since they know they are town.

@Nerjin:
You think Max White and NQT are both scum?  That would mean they were double bussing each other, and on Day 1?  I don't believe it.

Though, NQT has their vote on you (Nerjin) right now so either Max White is town and stubborn or scum while NQT is scum going for a town lynch or town going for a reasonable case.

I believe the latter.  NQT's case on Nerjin is lynch-worth (for Day 1 anyway) and I don't get what Max White is trying to pull on NQT since the not-a-cop thing isn't very valid.  So I would say either NQT and Max White are both town or NQT is town and Max White is scum.

And Nerjin, NQT is voting you, and Max White is not.  If I have to break the tie (because Cmega3 never shows up or something) it's going on you.

PFP

Yeah alright.  Unvote Jim.

---

@Cmega3:
Your vote on Max White was poor and Persus13 seems to have retaliated against you.  This seems fishy.  What's your read on Persus13?

---

@Tiruin (FoS for emphasis):
What do you think of Caz?  Why are you switching your vote so much?

@Nerjin:
Wait so, everybody in this post you have null or null-lean-town reads on?  You're on the chopping block for being lynched, do you suspect anybody besides Max White?