Bay 12 Games Forum

@Max:
Why are you voting Web over NQT? Are you convinced by NJW? Because I don't find your vote very convincing.

It's too late no for a Fire Drill, and if I see one start up again, I am going to through my night actions out the window and gun someone so hard they come back to life and die again.

Gun someone you say? You should try gunning me tonight and see what happens.

Town
Tric - feels town
Egan - seems really active and in the game even if their content is less than adequate
Jack - good energy

Probably Town
NJW - a lot of effort posts, really wants Web dead, this stubborn conviction is probably a town mentality
Max - got hit with a boon action which was definitely from scum, I would rate Max lower otherwise because I find him hard to trust
Knightwing - pretty sure he's town
Toaster - kind of like NJW, I think he's showing stubborn conviction and unlike players like Web/Max/NJW he's actually shading me constantly. He also isn't hounding Tric so I feel like he's learned his lesson from last game.

Suspicious
NQT - more null than suspicious, but if Web is town and/or this setup is solo scum I find NQT rather suspect for their "survive at any cost" attitude
Jim - easy street
Web - cult leader trying to survive

PPE:

Oh shit I misread that deadline and thought I had all of tomorrow.  Shit.

Uhhhhhhh I've been slack today because work and other things, but I'm super happy with NQT, lean pretty town on NJW, and am moderately ambivalent on Web?  Knightwing is super noncommittal and I'd be way more interested in nailing him to the wall over it EXCEPT that he was equally quiet BYOR16 and he was town there.  Now I do think he's quieter here, and I could be overcompensating.  Jim's odd but I don't have a vibe on him.  Toony is still odd based solely on gut.

Lemme look over and see if I can find anything that pops up.

I'm not super happy with NQT and kind of dread a game where we lynch him D1 and he flips town, but maybe that will be more fun? If we hit a Cult on D1 that should make the game far less fun, but that's not my goal here.

Tric bothered you a lot in the previous game when he was town, what does he feel like now?

I really don't see Euchrejack's NJW push. Maybe I'm being pocketed here, but NJW has had such a clear appraisal of the other players. He talks himself down a bit for no good reason. Well I suppose a cult leader, as solo hunting a rival leader (or leaders?!) can just act like fairminded town. In fact, townhunting is perhaps just as important for them as it is for the town. But still, I don't see the force in it. Not when there are other players who have laid low the whole day.

I do like NJW.

I don't want NJW voted here.

Toony being okay with a thunderdome surprises me; that’s not what I would expect him to say. I also would expect Web to push back on Toony specifically; this is also a surprise to me.

Web and Max have this undying faith in me which is one reason I'm okay with the thunderdome.

I think it's really unlikely both NQT and Web are town.

I agree with the TricThunderdome.

NQT vs. WEB

We flip one today, if the first one is town then we flip the other tomorrow.

If they're both scum this is a great plan. If one is scum this is an acceptable plan. If neither are scum it's a horrible plan.

If they're both town then we're fucked anyway so...I'll put my neck on the line and say you guys can kill me so the game and our misery can be over faster.

Anyway, Knightwing was seen elsewhere just this morning. Either he forgot about this game and we should vote him out so he isn't a sitting duck, or he's lurking on purpose and we should vote him out for that.

That's true. I'd just like to hear from him so I have a better idea. I think I would be able to obviously tell if he was town or not if he simply posted. I don't find the lack of posting as a nail in the coffin. It's not like he posted anywhere else right? He may have quickly glanced the thread this morning before running out the door with toast in his mouth.

This decisions would be easier to make if I could read Knightwing.

The posts that Knightwing has made I read as town. I also don't like voting a player for simply not being here. If Knightwing is malicious I also wouldn't be surprised if he just forgets to submit a N1 action.

Toonyman, Toonyman, Toonyman.
I usually think of you as a cool guy who likes fun, but here you are liking no fun at all.
I see your problem.
You need to be more like Egan, stop thinking, and ultrakill the bad men.
You think too much.
Sit back, relax, and let the soothing waves of Jimnosis fill up that empty head of yours and carry you away to a nice Caribbean island with a sea breeze and a mojito.
Repeat after me, Toonyman:
"I'm a miller, I can't be converted, and I'm masons with Max, Jim, and web."
Repeat it until you believe it all the way down to your boots.
Then we can start this game properly.

I have more fun being different. Hence hats.

I'm town. I can definitely be converted. I'm riding solo.

Toony, Toony, Toony.

Toony.

The thing is that Max is correct.  You are doubting yourself.  The points you should be asking yourself is the following:

- Who knows what the scum team really is?
- What are people hunting for?
- Why are they hunting for it?

Keep calm and let the Revolution guide you.  You are the Commander, after all.  And I am the Bodyguard!

Anyway, I can't be converted and inspect as Mafia, so it doesn't really matter.  I can obviously only win if Town wins.

It's prooooobably Knightwing and NQT.  I highly recommend blocking NQT Tonight.  I'll still be killing NJW, so there's not really a need to figure out his slot.

Scum would have a better idea what the scum team actually is.

Town are hunting scum. Scum are probably hunting rival scum over town so I don't expect a lack of scumhunting as a tell.

Wouldn't it be a funny prank if we were dealing with a standard 2-3 player mafia team?

If there are scum teams I really think NQT is a bad vote. They do not give me the impression they are with anyone.