Bay 12 Games Forum

Toony: Where'd you claim your delay at? Or did you ever explicitly claim it?

I was going to get lynched Round 2, the only reason I think I survived is because Tiruin voted themsleves.  So I role-claimed to try to avoid the lynch, it didn't really work and I regret doing it.

Also yes, I'm a Delayer still.

N0: Delay Toaster
N1: Delay Toaster
N2: Delay Urist Imik
N3: Delay Okami no Rei
N4: Delay Captain Ford
N5: Delay The Soldier

So if N4 Toony delayed Ford and Ford blocked me, N5 I was blocked, and Hapah just confessed to not having an alibi, is there any reason to not lynch Hapah today?

If we're wrong I will definitely be delaying you though.  Even randomly guessing will give us a 50% of victory, but that's worst-case scenario.  It still doesn't make any sense if Hapah isn't King Mafia though.  I should have delayed him instead ugh.

PFP

Were you blocked Toaster?

I don't think I should announce who I delay anymore until after I do it.

I'm not sure, as scum it'd be better if you could wait until a townie votes a townie and then hammer to win instantly.

Is 4-player lylo 3 to hammer?

Plus behaviorally mafia is one day from winning.  The after-hammer thing would only happen in cases like BYOR11 where townies think they have concrete proof (but really it's the MOD being lame).

EDIT:
I don't see why a townie would ever put someone to L-1 in lylo with one mafia unless they were played or fooled.  Which is exactly why a quick first vote is a likely scum read.

And what if the first vote is on you, the scum?  You'd cut your win chances unless you started your attack, which you should have done in the first place.  Or cross-vote with the guy and LEAVE IT UP TO THE REMAINING TOWNIE

I'll in once Minecraft Mafia finishes.

Hmmm, Hapah's explanation seem to make sense if his ability explains his behavior on Captain Ford (the same way he targeted Toaster the first Round I believe) and I'm torn whether to switch to Deathsword or not.

You know, I think I will switch to Deathsword since Hapah said he'll reveal everything about Ford if he dies which doesn't sound like something King Mafia would do, at all.  And Deathsword hasn't convinced me at all.

If Deathsword is King Mafia the round will end and I'll be happy.
If Deathsword isn't King Mafia I'll be delaying The Soldier tonight.  If I'm right in not choosing Hapah that would leave Toaster and Captain Ford, Toaster needs to get blocked and if he is blocked than Ford is telling the truth about his block at least.

Toony:

Quote from: ToonyMan on April 01, 2013, 04:13:13 pm

Toaster

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 31, 2013, 04:45:14 pm

Quote from: Toaster on March 30, 2013, 01:04:58 pm

Ford:  I'll just have to take your claim at face value, because I took no action last night.  I did not receive any night PM.
This feels like rolefishing, but I'm not really sure.

What does that mean?  Are they role-fishing or not?

I do want an answer!

Whoops, missed that one.
I don't know.  I guess you could say it looks like a duck but it doesn't quack like a duck, so I'm not sure if it's a duck or not.  I suppose it isn't if he legitimately didn't know that I wouldn't know if I was blocked if I had taken no action.

Hmmm okay.

Day ends in about eight hours so I'll give a read of everyone (from most to least scummy):

Toaster, I don't like his subtle suspicion throwing on Captain Ford, and he had been very quick to try to lynch Deathsword for the exact same reasons as last time.

The Soldier:  Until he convinces me otherwise (or someone overtakes him like last round), it's a lynch vote.  He got away with it last round, but enough is enough.

I do agree that it's possible Deathsword is King Mafia, but aren't you just completely gambling here?  You managed to lynch NQT correctly because you had a good "actively-scummy" read on him.

---

Hapah hasn't been the most active person, and his case on Captain Ford boils down to "why didn't you use your one-shot earlier??" even though them using their one-shot would mean they couldn't kill anybody.  Although I find Toaster's agreement more suspicious.

---

Deathsword hasn't be very helpful at all and I'd reeeaally like if he posted today since his activity has been really bad.  This was true last round so it's a painfully nulltell.

---

The Solider put Deathsword at L-1 pretty quick but I've already stated that is not something you should lynch over, I haven't caught anything bad he's said otherwise.

---

Captain Ford didn't kill Okami if my night-action worked.  He also feels genuine in my gut, but maybe I've been with him too long now.  Toaster and Hapah have both thrown suspicion on him, but my biggest scum reads are on Toaster and Hapah.

Yeah that's a bit much especially since he was getting almost lynched last round for similar reasons.