Bay 12 Games Forum

Heeeey got a Game Over in Kara no Shoujo.  That only took FOREVER

A lot of things are apparent now...

Well that's not the case at all but whatever.  It's not a no-lynch for science either.  It's a no-lynch to more likely win the game.  You are all in entirely the wrong mind-set.

No that's stupid.  I doubt the scum have to reach the ship.  They have to be lying about their role.

Also since I should probably share this if my lynch goes through (which seems likely), I'm a Tough Dopp and pretty much the same thing as TolyK.  He could protect while it seems I'm just passively tough.  There's probably a few other serum dopps out there but they can't possibly mean any harm.  I didn't get any other information besides to get on the ship.  I can't see a way out of this so this looks like a lost for me.  Oh well I feel bad about this game.

And no, there's no possibility I would cause harm anybody.  If everybody wants to follow Meph's logic to the fucking T then he said himself that I'm perfectly fine.

The blood explosion mix on the OST is even more ridiculous.

TIME TO RANDOMLY PLAY A VISUAL NOVEL TIME

Played a couple hours of Kara no Shoujo last night.  It was actually kind of fun and left good first impressions.
I'm totally playing more tonight.  Murder mysteries are the best.  I hear this game has multiple routes too.

I have two complaints though.
1.  Non-voiced MCs make me sad.
2.  Two of the early CGs were kind of lame.

If people aren't following my logic Dariush (judging by the votes I'm getting from it) then yours is even more radical.  There's no way we can win this bastard with such closed minds, uuugh.

Well whatever, I'm not changing my point of view.  no lynch sounds good.

Answer this: is there scum or isn't there? If you think there is, who do you think is it? And why wouldn't you lynch them instead of someone who you don't think is scum?

I think there are scum, the run phase targets being the largest evidence.  What I'm saying is for now we can get more time because scum will slip up more as the game goes along.  We can also figure the game out more.  I want it to be less 'wait-and-see' and more 'active-aggressive'.  Which it clearly would be.  My proposal is only going to help town unless they act useless.

ToonyMan (addendum):
You also contradict yourself here:

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 02:12:56 pm

we should vote someone who's goal is to only see somebody else survive, because then we can save ourselves more time and most importantly gather clues.  I really want to see Meph's flavor for the third guy that stays behind too.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 03:07:16 pm

Quote from: Toaster on March 09, 2012, 02:45:21 pm

Toony:  While the theory behind your proposal is sound, aren't we then just voting someone based on a flavor difference and not because they're actually scummy?

That's a secondary reason.  The main reason is to buy time so that more things can happen.

So, is flavour "most importantly", or "a secondary reason"? What "clues" would you expect to gather, and, once again, what exactly would you learn from the lynch if the flavour says "sigh" instead of "oh noes!" or viceversa?

Heh, I meant gather clues as in finding scum and the flavor.  Finding scum takes priority obviously.  I should have made this more clear.

Toony:

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 02:12:56 pm

I really want to see Meph's flavor for the third guy that stays behind too.

Why do you want to see this for Bookthras more than anyone else? How do you feel a third lynch flavor will help us do better tomorrow, and why is it worth intentionally mislynching today?

There are two possible outcomes in flavor, a third result would absolutely confirm how Meph phrases the lynchee's composure.  The flavor isn't the main thing.  The main result is that we can safely vote somebody and also get twice as much time to find scum slippage.  It's simple really.  It's pretty much safe lynch > random lynch.  Unless there is only a single scum and we lynch them today the last claimed pilot (I think?) is going to die anyway unless we have a protector which would be good.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 02:12:56 pm

because then we can save ourselves more time and most importantly gather clues.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 03:07:16 pm

The main reason is to buy time so that more things can happen.

Such as?

More people with the 'escape to the ship' will survive.  Bookthras needs to be lynched or die at some point or else one of us is going to lose.  Unless we are able to lynch all threats 100% perfectly, hehe.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 09, 2012, 03:26:40 pm

It's basically the same thing as TolyK's case with him claiming dopp and I still side that he didn't mean any harm.

But you were opposed to TolyK's lynch. What changed?

I didn't figured out what to do exactly until now. 


We can play normally and I fully support that as well.  Since Bookthras is the only option this really does put a damper on things anyway.  I'll consider this a viable side option for some point in the future to take into consideration.  We definitely want as many winners as possible after all.

You missed me. I claimed Escape on the ship D1.

Yeah I just looked at at recently when Toaster asks everybody.