Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 47 48 [49] 50 51 ... 1978
721
Everybody makes fun of me for wanting to play Noita,

but I haven't played any goddamn Noita since starting this game. :(
I've never played Noita!


unvote.
It's a goddamn miracle.

722
Toony, NQT, and Fluffe: What are your arguments against Jack?
He's not here. I know him and NQT have given reasons for being less around but I want to see fresh faces and thoughts that don't drain the soul from my body.

723
Okay, after running through all the players in my head I was able to remember everyone eventually, but it took me the longest to remember notquitethere, so let's vote him out to make it easier on me.
Jack should vote him.

724
Who's more trustworthy - Jim Groovester or hector13?
hector13 no contest simply through avoiding most of the Tric argument and not making bizzare semi contradictory or confusing posts like Jim has done
I disagree. I don't think Jim bothers if he doesn't care. I'm seeing real frustration from him. Hector's distant approach makes him less trustworthy.

725
Thank you Mamobo.

Toony, still hold reason to vote Toaster?
No, I'm going to Unvote.

Can mafia-allies be in this game? *checks* Looks like they can, okay.

FoU is a mafia-ally. They're behaving like Webadict in FBYOR5. I'm done trying to reason with them at this point and it's a waste of time. They're wasting everyone's time and making everyone upset to cause trouble and help mafia. Maybe they are just mafia, but I think drawing this much attention to themselves is suicide and I don't really want to think about it anymore today. They probably realize Tric is very likely not to be mafia and that's why they specifically want to vote Tric out, because it's a merit to his team. I think this explains their shift in focus over the course of Day 1.

This also makes me feel better about Jim.

Did you know that I've been thinking a lot of players have been skating by because of this Fou/Tric thing sucking up all the air in the room, and included in that list of people was EuchreJack, but that I haven't had a chance to express these thoughts yet?
Sounds good to me.

Jack, which players do you think are dodging attention maliciously?

726
If Jim hadn’t been so ridiculously active in your defense and support I never would have cottoned onto you. Thanks, Jim. You’re next.
How do you feel about Lenglon?

727
Whether you're town or mafia FoU you're being incredibly stubborn. Do you want the satisfaction of being right about Tric that badly? I am extremely confident Tric isn't mafia, like 99.9% sure. It's probably a 50/50 chance he's third-party but that doesn't matter. If you really believe I'm being genuine here then voting Tric is not helpful, at all.

By being a stubborn idiot you're allowing quieter players like Knightwing/Fluffe/Egan/Juicebox/etc to not get as much attention as this turns into the FoU/Tric battle of the century. It's also possible you're both town and this is a complete waste of effort and people's good will. I think if that's true then town players are more likely to waste effort to join this debate, because it's a lot of work for a pay off that doesn't exist (which we wouldn't know for sure). Meanwhile mafia get to chill and watch town be morons.

Is it bad that I understand it, then?
Well, you live in another dimension so...

728
@FoU:
I can find the inspection quote when I'm at a computer, unless you said it as a joke? Why are you even questioning me about this? I'm pretty sure I'm not wrong about that.
I am wrong.

It was this post:
Jim is voting me just because I don’t agree with him on Tric?

This is especially aggravating because he simultaneously implies I’m competent enough to easily figure out Tric’s alignment but too incompetent to hide my scum strategies when I’m mafia.

That’s not a reasonable stance to take. I’m doing my first investigation on Tric, to try and validate my read or prove it wrong, but Jim Groovester gets my vote for that garbage.
I thought you were implying you were going to vote Jim today since you have an inspect for Tric, but that clearly isn't what you meant now that I re-read it.

I can’t believe anyone is able to follow Tric’s arguments in the slightest.
Being able to actually follow Tric's arguments is a mafiatell of his.

I have no idea what he's saying either.

Under this measurement, Jim is less genuine and Fluffe and Toony are more genuine.
Then vote Jim for being disingenuous.

Why is Tric mafia because Jim has a dishonest opinion about Tric? It's POSSIBLE Tric is mafia if Jim is being dishonest. But if you truly believe Jim is faking his feelings and that assumption is correct then HE'S MAFIA. Jim is literally using the same logic to vote you by claiming your own motivations are fake. This feels like a clown show.

729
@FoU:
I don't read Knightwing as 100% town, no.

Tric will be much harder to execute than a veteran, it's not happening. Information lynch bad.

I can find the inspection quote when I'm at a computer, unless you said it as a joke? Why are you even questioning me about this? I'm pretty sure I'm not wrong about that.

730
@FoU:
Jim is more dangerous than Tric as a player, why vote Tric first? The best way you can convince me that Tric is mafia is if Jim actually is mafia too. You said earlier you were going to inspect at night, why showboat an inspection like that?

731
I think I'm willing to believe any player could be mafia, besides Tric and Curious Cat. I'm most willing to vote FoU, Toaster, or Hector right now. I'm a bit mixed about Toaster at this point.

I don't really like NQT voting Jack. I'm confused why Juicebox voted Toaster (which I liked) but then became convinced by FoU and voted Tric??

732
Like FoU, if you voted Jim and told me he's a big faker I could be convinced by that. It's why when you voted Jim before I didn't run to his defense like I will for Tric.

733
PFP lunch break

@NQT:
I'm not really okay with a Jack lynch. I think it's unlikely he's mafia with Jim and I haven't seen anything from them that alerts my alarm bells. Last time I felt this way they were town.

@FoU:
Voting someone because of the people around them is not going to find success. Voting Tric because how other people are reacting to him is a bad vote. I remember NQT complaining about this in Roguelike mafia where we lynched a town player on D1 because of their behavior around another player we found more scummy instead of just voting the player we found more scummy (I think it was NQT who was also town but regardless).

734
ffs. okay, apparently I'm not remembering things straight. I somehow had it in my head that Jim was saying Tric was obvtown and that you wanted FoU lynched for voting obvtown.

Instead you want FoU lynched because...?
I find FoU suspicious because their opener was lukewarm "I'm pretty sure I'm town" and then claimed uninspectable. I read them successfully as town during the start of the previous game where they sounded more genuine and resolute "I felt tears of joy seeing my role was town" or something. In addition their attack of Tric doesn't make sense to me and it looks like they're trying to vote someone for faulty reasons.

I'm tempted to take Max's offer to vote FoU, but there are thoughts I'm having:
1. I don't fully trust Max. I like Max, but it's not a guarantee. FoU and Max feel like two sides of the same coin. Both claim being a kind of miller. One attacks Tric, the other defends Tric. It's possible that FoU is correct, leading to...
2. I want to see FoU pressure Tric supporters which I think are more likely to be mafia than Tric himself. I don't think it's productive to pressure Tric.

735
Toony: also, You say that Jim did a better job than you at explaining why you don't like FoU. I didn't understand Jim's reasoning in any meaningful way. It seemed like Jim was just saying that Tric was townie because Tric was townie, despite Tric to my eyes almost outright claiming to be 3p. So please tell me what Jim's reasoning was, then what yours is.
I think before Jim posted all I had said about Tric was that I was extremely (100%) confident they weren't mafia. Jim posted this before I had elaborated to Toaster when they questioned me about it.

Pages: 1 ... 47 48 [49] 50 51 ... 1978