I think sketching out relationships between players will be more helpful than a strict town to scum read hierarchy. Or rather it's practically a requirement for that, at this point in such a large game. It's also an excuse to try something new.
Maybe a certain graph maker can do that.
Why do you think Tric is town?
Initially, it's because of his first post since it implies he's not mafia if he's telling the truth unless Web is being a weirdo. If you don't want to accept that as an argument then fine that's understandable. Having looked at his play in the game so far I've observed the following: He selfishly wants to gobble hats and is goading the mafia to try to kill him which is extremely in-character for him as town or third-party, he's done this numerous times (like the previous BYOR15 even). I really don't believe he's mafia here. It's a bad vote.
What if I told you he forgot mine too?
(I caught him before he left and he sent it before my first post. I didn't think it was worthy of mention at the time.)
Let's say I believe you, I don't think this changes my opinion of Tric.
ToonyMan - inconsistent.
Says the guy who votes Max a player they townread.
I think my thought process has been well-explained and not inconsistent in the least.
I like it more when you roleplay and use colored text so maybe do more of that.
I don't like this vote. If Tric isn't town, it's more likely that he's a TP with the wincon of collect all the hats than scum. While I'd like to get him out if that's the case, I still think that D1 it'll be more productive to look at someone else who is more likely to be mafia than to look at Tric
I agree.
Max
Maximum Spin
Hmmmm
I prooobably like Max here.
Not really feeling Juicebox, Lenglon, or Max as good votes.
