Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 49 50 [51] 52 53 ... 1978
751
My too-busy-to-read-well reads:
I like Tric & Max
Therefore, I don't like Fallacy, since he seems to be pushing shitty reasons.
I agree.

EJ good job on completely ignoring me pointing out the flaws in your gameplan.
...
Give me one good reason why we shouldn’t get rid of you when your only inclination appears to be Jim or Toony’s sock-puppet.
Hey hey, Jack has had this "busy with work" attitude lately in a lot of games. It does make it harder for me to read him, but I agree with his cursory reads and it's probably okay if he sheep votes me or Jim. I think the fact he's trying to determine between the two of us to sheep shows some level of effort/scrutiny.

I don't really like your pursuit on Jack.

words
Nice first post Egan! A lot of effort shown here.

One comment: I have not shitpost in this game. I'm taking it quite seriously so I find this a little insulting.

Toonyman: Who do you think is likely to have chosen Town as their preferred alignment? I ask you because Spin hates answering such questions D1. (Dang it, hector asked you before I did. Oh well.)
Yeah this has been already answered: NQT.

Cause I'm 100% Not MafiaToonyMan/Approved!
Do you want me to mail you a stamp?

sort of first post
A-another good post? I'm going to cry.

This is how you do it Fluffe, follow Egan and Juicebox's example.

I feel like only one out of Maximum Spin or FoU is scum. I highly doubt that both of them are scum with immunity to alignment inspects. Between the two of them though, I'm leaning more toward Maximum Spin being scum. I don't think that looking at what alignment everyone is likely to choose will be that helpful, and shouldn't really be a focus.
That's a good point. I have a hard time trusting Max, but I do like his logic about the fourth question thing (which FoU doesn't seem to like, interesting...).

752
I also think Jim would submit town to have less responsibility so he can play more Noita.
This is true. I could make a joke about a three word role but I won't.

753
@Max:
Oh Max, your sacred breadcrumbing is far too obvious this time. I also think it's hilarious you would say -sama.

I said nothing about discussion getting bogged down Tric, don't try to stuff words in my mouth. I said that asking about Hats is rolefishing. If people want to claim their hats then that's on them, but generally people shouldn't roleclaim day 1 without a good reason. You're actively pushing and fishing for the hat part of people's roles without justification. I do think we will want to have a good long hat discussion, but said discussion will probably be best to have on day 2.
It's not Tric.

@Hector:
I'm not sure about most players. I think NQT would absolutely submit town though because he's attested multiple times to enjoying town more and has also been mafia far too many times recently. I thought FoU would also submit town for multiple reasons, but they've claimed cult so. Don't have strong reasoning for anyone else.

For me personally I said the turtles would pick town, but I myself don't care.

@Tric:
Fluffe has never been mafia yet.

754
:o

Is this supposed to help your case?
Lenglon mentioned third-party in their first post so maybe it happened again like that game they were a mutant pixie and Max was satan.

Knightwing seems town.

755
My role mentions a hat belonging to Tric, also it seems pretty op, is everyone else the same?
It's quite possible.

These seem like very silly questions for "No Fun Allowed" Lenglon to make.
I walk up to Toonyman and lean into his personal space, looking up to him while only just barely not touching him, my hands holding each other behind my back as I sway back and forth.
"Toony-kun Toony-kun Toonykun, there's nothing wrong with having a little fun early in the day now is there?"
my left hand drifts out from behind me and slowly traces its way up his right arm
"I might be serious when it comes time to make a proper lynch case later on, but later. is. not. now."
my hand drifts from Toony's shoulder up to before his mouth
"shhhhhhhhh. Let me have my fun."
I pull my hand back behind me and hop backwards one step as my hands re-clasp each other.
"Besides, there might be a method to my madness, you know?"
I spin around and walk away, eyes tracking certain other individuals in the room.
Errrgh, my one weakness...roleplaying.

756
Looking at the posts that Curious Cat linked between FoU and Lenglon I also agree with them about the two. Which also lines up with my initial first post impressions of both players! I find this very convincing.

Good stuff Toony, but probably Fallacy and Lenglon aren't both on the same team. Also am I wrong about end of day?
Fair point, I don't see it being likely either.

I hate last minute vote switching. I swear it happens to me because people force ties I have to break or large misunderstandings happening. I'm not purposely seeking out stress when I don't believe last minute switches are more likely to hit scum in the first place.

757
Cat, of course its too early to tell, but attempting to tell tells me about your tells. So make a guess

I’m kinda suspicious of Fallacy and Lenglon (primarily due to what happened starting here).



Also, can anyone tell me what blue text means?  I know red is used when voting to lynch, but I’m not sure about the blue.
Oooooof sooo tooown.

Don't like Toaster chasting Curious Cat, but it could be from a place of good faith.

758
How do I feel about each player's first posts? I think that's a good angle to parkour from.

Let's dig in dudes.



first post
I don't like this post.
Verdict: 65% mafia

first...post?
Curious Cat doesn't even seem to be acknowledging the game here. I kind of like that, but I can't tell if they've even read their role from Web yet here. If we assume they have then...
Verdict: 70% town

first
Nothing stands out to me, could go either way for veteran Toaster.
Verdict: 50% town TBD

first, many words
So many words. Me like many words and effort.
Verdict: 60% town

first post
These seem like very silly questions for "No Fun Allowed" Lenglon to make.
Verdict: 60% mafia

Jim buttering me up
I want to say they're town here. I'm pretty good at soulreading Jim 90% of the time.
Verdict: 75.4% town

Side note: I kind of like Hector and Jim both just voting Lenglon over FoU's omega-god-awesome day inspect. I think it shows no fear at least.

first post
Helpful, I get a good impression at least.
Verdict: 66.6% town TBD

hats
So town it hurts, or at least, not mafia.
Verdict: 100% not mafia

Everybody else hasn't posted yet!



Moving on...

I'm pretty sure I'm town.
This is a pretty lukewarm reaction compared to the previous game you were town where I pegged you correctly as town (initially).

Toaster and Jim and ToonyMan: who are the players we should be trying to clear first? I was going to ask this to the more experienced players but there are quite a few of you so I guess those three seem to be a decent cross-section for this one…
Me, Toaster, you, Max.

Jim is probably okay. Don't really find anyone else dangerous.

Most likely is 10 town, 3 to 4 mafia, and 1 third party.

Aside from that, there could be multiple scumteams, a complete absence of mafia (and a lot of hostile third parties), three cult leaders...

Webadict is not afraid at all to mix things up.

The conventional pattern would suggest 10 town, 3-4 mafia, and 1-2 third parties.

Personally I'd bet web has mixed it up this time around, though, since the last few games have been more reasonable.
This does all sound reasonable, but I suspect your confidence in it.

I can't tell if you're confident in your read of Web as a moderator or know more than you should.

That means nothing. Whoever is in the lead early D1 rarely is eliminated. There'll be loads more wagons before the end of day, and (I see Toony is in this game so) probably a frantic mass switch around of votes in the last fifteen minutes. Someone like hector13 is more likely  to get eliminated. Guess again.
Rude.

PPE:
That's all you've got?  Is this TownieMan?
I'm trying man. I wanted to say something quickly before making an actual post.

759
HATS!

In answer to why. But for whatever reason, I never received my PM. What's up with that web?

Well, not like being amnesiac would be bad. Or whatever this is.

Trix the Magic - 100% not mafia

760
Mafia / Re: BYOR 16: Now In Signups - [8 Players Loaded]
« on: April 05, 2023, 06:13:18 pm »
Wait, seriously? I submitted Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as my role for Knightwing's BYOR. I don't care about revealing that because the game isn't happening.

761
Mafia / Re: Bring 3: Chaos Incarnate (Day 2 Repeating) 8/8
« on: April 04, 2023, 10:46:54 pm »
I'm not a stump until I die then I'll lose my vote. I just haven't voted today.

762
Mafia / Re: Bring 3: Chaos Incarnate (Day 2 Repeating) 8/8
« on: April 04, 2023, 10:38:27 pm »
Normally I'd absolutely do my best to play in good faith.

I think I agree with web, though. This game was broken from the start.

I don't think any path to victory existed for the scum (us), thanks to the nigh-nonexistent claim space.
Yeah, I did the math and it was nearly mathematically impossible for scum to win, regardless of all other conditions.
I'm something of a scientist myself.

763
Mafia / Re: Bring 3: Chaos Incarnate (Day 2 Repeating) 8/8
« on: April 04, 2023, 10:36:34 pm »
Which reminds me, uhhh, Toony, pass me a meme
Smee? Smee smee. Smee smee smee.

764
Mafia / Re: Bring 3: Chaos Incarnate (Day 2 Repeating) 8/8
« on: April 04, 2023, 10:33:15 pm »
Aye, the King may die but the age of the pirates will never end!!

765
Mafia / Re: Bring 3: Chaos Incarnate (Day 2 Repeating) 8/8
« on: April 04, 2023, 04:53:23 pm »
I have no night action.

For you see.

I'm made of wood, how did that happen? Yohoho, took a bite of Tree-Tree.

Pages: 1 ... 49 50 [51] 52 53 ... 1978