Bay 12 Games Forum

This is how I'm going to die, arguing with someone on the internet.

zemaj

It's zemaj and FoU isn't it and I'm just incredibly untrustful of Max and Irony.

I liked FoU saying they got town for once though.

And I like zemaj actually giving their feelings on who they suspect, even with having group pairings of players.

Fluffe feels bad.

Quote from: ToonyMan on March 31, 2023, 03:30:47 am

YOU DIDN'T NEED TO CLAIM THAT

Ahem:

Quote from: notquitethere on March 30, 2023, 05:32:24 pm

Vote Count
- a1s - [3] Toony, Zemaj, FallacyofUrist
~24 hours remaining

I am so under the hammer (even though there are no hammers) you'd think I was an anvil.

WHO CARES ABOUT THE VOTES

Sigh do we have any counterclaims? Anyone else who claims to be the doctor?

This isn't even a question. If someone counter claims I shit gold and sell it on eBay.

I don't see a1s with anyone.

Jim is the only person I could see, but I find it less convincing than Jim with FoU or zemaj.

zemaj/FoU seems more likely than zemaj/Jim to me, if I had to pick between the two right now.

Now let me continue dying in the corner.

@Irony:
I don't think Jim is mafia with Max, Fluffe, you, or zemaj. Mafia!Jim backing up my support of a town!FoU or town!a1s when he could stick with his initial impression of always suspecting FoU or getting a free vote on a1s makes less sense to me. I think a mafia!Jim only agrees with me on these two if he's partners with them. A mafia!Jim could be appealing to my nature and just dismissing their partner to try to win that way I guess. We won't be able to reassess anything which hurts, so I need to be decisive here.

I don't really think zemaj is mafia. I originally also had Max as my next choice regardless of whether you're town or mafia, but decided to give Max a buffer if you're mafia, since he could be reading the game better than me, hence zemaj first since Max suspects zemaj and considers you a possible partner.

This may be an expression of my avoidance to OMGUS Max, but I actually have no problem with a scumteam entirely from group1, outside of the problem of both scum being in the lurker camp, which seems improbable.

It's possible but I don't think it's likely they win in this case.

I don't think anybody could convince me to vote zemaj at this point, the only thing they could do more would have been to color code their reads. I'm worried this is like Magma Mater in Matrix6 or Nakeen in FBYOR5 where I get tricked by scum, but if they're deciding to put in the effort and thought I just don't see them faking their suspicions here.

If zemaj is scum I want to say it's most likely with FoU, but I've been supportive of FoU for once. It actually annoys me that other players have shown the same trustworthiness of FoU in this game when normally the opposite is true. Are players seeing the same thing I'm seeing, or is always scum FoU getting a lucky chance? I still believe in the former.

I'm not really happy about how Fluffe or a1s are playing today, but I'm more convinced of a1s being town here based on my previous game experience. I also have a harder time putting a1s with someone compared to Fluffe.

My list right now would be something like:

Irony
Max
Fluffe
FoU
zemaj
Jim
a1s

However, that's without the knowledge of any player's alignment.

I'm not completely unconvinced of FoU/zemaj or FoU/Jim being a thing, due to me questioning liking FoU for once.

Am I rating a1s too highly? I think it makes Jim look better, unless they're with FoU.

If neither Max or Irony are mafia I'm very lost. It's also possible they're both mafia, but I don't find that too likely because of their distancing. If Irony is mafia I'm having a hard time seeing a convincing partner honestly. Maybe there's a better first vote.

Do we submit lists after the D1 flip happens? I assume so.

Max, I want to hear your opinion about Jim.

Look, Jamez iz all over the place here. Loud but insubstantial with a forzed *~*HILARIOUS*~* pretenze that makes it eazy to keep making noize without saying anything that might incriminate.

In fact, I understand why Fallacy thinks he's town because he's acting like scum Fallacy acts when he's trying to act like he thinks town would act.

If he gets it together and starts being useful, then I'll recalibrate, but right now it looks more like he's trying to audition for a one-man show on basic cable.

I don't really agree. If zemaj is acting like a one-man show it's working: they don't look like scum to me. I think your accusation feels more like a personal grudge against their playstyle than actually suspecting them of being scum.